Prof. Gyandeo Prasad Tiwary v. The State Of Bihar
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.427 of 2022 ====================================================== 1.
Prof. Gyandeo Prasad Tiwary S/o-Late Sarbdeo Tiwary, R/o-Muhalla-Brindavan Colony, P.O.-Chapra, P.S.-Bhagwan Bazar, District-Saran, Pin841301. 2.
Dr. Gajendra Prasad Singh Son of Late Ramcharitra Singh Residing atH.No. 683,(Behind SBI Training Center), P.O.-Deoghar, P.S.-Deoghar, District-Deoghare, Jharkhand. 3.
Dr. Abdul Malik, Son of Late Hafir Md. Salim, R/o-Muhalla- Nayee Bazar, P.O.-Chapra, P.S.-Bhagwan Bazar, District-Saran. 4.
Dr. Sunil Kumar Verma Son of Late Krishna Mohan Prasad Verma R/oMuhalla-Prabhu Nath Nagar, P.O.-Tadi, P.S.-Chapra, Muffasil, DistrictSaran. 5.
Dr. Om Prakash Singh Son of Late Thakur Prasad Singh, R/o-Vill-Pakridih, P.O.-Pakri Mohammad, P.S.-Amnour, District-Saran Pin-841218. 6.
Dr. Ram Narayan Roy, Son of Late Giriwar Roy, R/o-Vill-Mishraulia, P.O.- Magaidih, 841316.
7.
Dr. Ram Prasad Yadav S/o-Late Ram Dayal Rawat, R/o-Muhalla-Masoomganj, (Ward no.4), P.O. and P.S.-Bhagwan Bazar, District-Saran. 8.
Geeta Singh W/o-Late Dr. Binod Kumar Singh Residing at-Flat no. 204, 2nd Floor, Ashwani Enclave-II South of AIIMS, P.O. and P.S.-Phulwari Sharif, District-Patna, Pin-801505.
9.
Dr. Tapaswi Prasad Singh S/oLate Ganga Prasad Singh Residing at-Sona Sadan, Dahiyawan, P.O.-Tari P.S.-Muffasil, District-Chapra. 10.
Dr. Kapildeo Singh S/o-Girdhari Prasad Singh R/o-Vill-Narayan Nagar, P.O.-Gurukul Mehiya, P.S.-Muffasil Chapra, District-Saran Pin-841302. 11.
Dr. Vijay Kumar S/o-Late Kaushailendra Sharma, Residing at H. NO. 30, IINd Floor Katab Bhawan Lane Krishna Apartment North S.K. Puri Boring Road, District-Patna, Pin-800013.
12.
Dr. Gopal Prasad Arya, S/o-Late Kanhaiya Lal Arya, R/o-Muhalla- Chitragupt Nagar East, (Behind Lakshmi Apartment), P.O.-Sampatchak, P.S.- Chitragupt Nagar, District-Patna.
13.
Dr. Ram Ayodhya Singh S/o-Late Ramdeo Singh Residing at Home no.3, Road No. 24, Adarsh Bihar Colony, Rajiv Nagar, (Eeshari Nagar), P.O. and P.S.-Rajiv Nagar, District-Patna Pin-800024.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1.
The State of Bihar Bihar 2.
The Secretary High Education, Govt. of Bihar, Patna. 3.
The Director Higher Education, Bihar, Patna.
4.
The J.P. University, Chapra through its Registrar. 5.
The Vice Chancellor, J.P. University, Chapra, Saran.
2/5 6.
The Finance Officer, J.P. University, Chapra, Saran. 7.
The Finance Advisor, J.P. University, Chapra, Saran. 8.
Dr. A.K. Jha S/o-Late H.M. Jha, R/o-not Known to the Present Petitioners, Associate Professor, PG, Department Botany, J.P. University, Chapra. 9.
Dr. Raj Kumar Son of Late Mahabir Roy, Resident of Village-Mirchaiye, Tola, P.O.-Bhagwan Bazar, P.S.-Bhagawan, Bazar, District-Saran-841301 rerited as Associate Professor (Zoology) from the Rajendra College, Chapra. 10.
Dr. S.K. Singh S/o-Fulema Singh At and P.O.-Reotith, District-Gopalganj, retired as Associate Professro, PG, Department Math, J.P. University, Chapra.
11.
Dr. Om Prakash S/o-Shiv Shaukan Singh At-Prof. Colony Near R.N. College, District-Vaishali-844101, retired as Associate Professorfromthe, Y.N. College, Dighwara.
12.
Dr. B.K. Singh S/o-Late Chanceshwar Singh R/o-At and P.O.-Ram Chaura, P.S.-Isuapur, District-Saran-84103, retired as Associate Professor, Y.N. College, Dighwara, at Present Mohalla-Shakri Nagar, P.O.-Tari, P.S.-Mufassil, Chapra, District-Saran.
... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s :
Mr.Sanjay Kumar For the Respondent/s :
Smt. Binita Singh (Sc28) ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA ORAL ORDER 08-03-2022 The case is being taken up from the defect side. Learned counsel for the petitioner is directed to submit the original petition along with attested affidavits and also remove the defects pointed out by the Registry within two weeks from today.
In view of the judgment passed in the case of Suresh Ram Vrs. The State of Bihar & Ors. (C.W.J.C. No. 5489 of 2020) and connected petitions where this Court has held as under:
3/5 "13. Having reached to the aforesaid conclusion, this Court directs that all the maters concerning teachers pending before this Court deserve to be first adjudicated on merits and on facts by the concerned relevant District Appellate Authority. If still there is any grievance left, the concerned person would be entitled to take up the matter before the State Appellate Authority and this Court need not deal with such matters at the initial stage.
14. Having stated so, the learned counsel have informed that on account of Pandemic for the last two years, the State Government has not taken any steps for forming District Appellate Authority and the District Appellate Authorities are non-functional in several districts.
15. Accordingly, it is directed that the writ petition and similarly situated other writ petitions are required disposed of in terms as aforesaid with liberty to approach the District Appellate Authority. The petitioner would be free to obtain a certified copy of the present petition and the counter affidavit if any filed by the respective State counsel to be made as part of the pleadings and file an application before the District Appellate Authority, who would be entitled to call for the records from the respective schools/establishment/college etc. and after hearing the parties pass a speaking order expeditiously.
16. Learned counsel appearing for the State shall also inform the Chief Secretary and Secretary of Education about the present order and it is directed that the Chief Secretary and the Secretary, Education Department shall take immediate steps for the respective
4/5 District Appellate Authorities to start their function. The necessary staffs and members shall be appointed as early as possible not later than a period of one month from today. Necessary directions for their functioning shall also be passed accordingly.
17. The writ petitions are accordingly, disposed of."
2. It is informed by the learned counsel for the petitioners that the State Appellate Authority is not entertaining the petition directly on the ground that it is an appellate authority. It is also informed that the State Government has not formed the District Appellate Authority in several districts and the District Appellate Authorities are non-functional. It goes without saying that the very purpose of the Rules of 2020 is to provide alternative and efficacious remedy to the teachers for quick redressal of their grievances relating to their services. In circumstances where the District Appellate Authority do not function or the same has not been formed by the State Government, the State Appellate Authority which is the extension of the adjudicating Authority powers given to the District Appellate Authority, can not wash its hands off such cases where the concerned teachers have approached directly the State Appellate Authority for redressal of his/her grievance in situations on account of the District Appellate Authority being non-functional.
3. The concerned litigants will of-course have to file
5/5 in affidavit to the effect that the District Appellate Authority is not functioning.
4. If such an affidavit is filed it is expected from the State Appellate Authority to entertain the grievance directly and adjudicate on the merits of the case.
5. In Suresh Ram's case (C.W.J.C. No. 5489 of 2020) and connected petitions this Court has also held that the District Appellate Authority must be made functional within a period of one month by the State Government. In the case of Minakshi @ Sushre Minakshi & Anr. Vrs. The State of Bihar & Ors. (C.W.J.C. No. 34 of 2022) this Court has observed that if the District Appellate Authority is not functioning, an affidavit may be filed to the said effect before the State Appellate Authority and the State Appellate Authority would be empowered to examine the grievance and pass orders accordingly directly or after giving opportunity to the parties.
6. In view of the above, this case is disposed of in aforesaid terms.
(Sanjeev Prakash Sharma, J) amit/- U