Shatrughan Thakur v. Uma Shankar

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA

Letters Patent Appeal No.14 of 2020 In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.8908 of 2011 ====================================================== 1.

Shatrughan Thakur son of late Mukhtar Thakur resident of VillageDumaria, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 2.

Ram Narayan Ram son of Shri Nageshwar Ram resident of Village- Alta Hat, PO- Alta Hat, Police Station- Kechadhawan, District- Kishanganj. 3.

Shailendra Kumar Singh son of Shri Lawindra Prasad Singh resident of Village- Bagalbari, PO- Alta Hat, Police Station- Kechadhawan, District4. Md. Kasim son of Md. Imam Ali resident of Village- Phulbari, POTerhagachh, Police Station- Terhagachh, District- Kishanganj. 5.

Shambhu Kamti son of Bishwanath Kamti resident of Village- Dumaria, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 6.

Kumari Meera Karn wife of Shri Ravindra Lal Karn resident of VillageBetauna, Police Station- Benipatti, District- Madhubani. 7.

Shivchandra Ram son of late Visheshwar Ram resident of Village- Alta Hat, Police Station- Kochadhaman, District- Kishanganj. 8.

Ganesh Prasad Sah son of Shri Dhanlal Sah resident of Village- Teli Basti Road, Police Station and District- Kishanganj. 9.

Md. Tarique Hussain son of Md. Hamid Hussain resident of MohallaDharamganj, Police Station and District- Kishanganj. 10.

Shrawan Kumar Bantar son of Shri Pulkit Bantar PO- Dhusmal Hat, Police Station- Angarh, Via and District- Kishanganj. 11.

Mahfooz Alam son of Alimuddin resident of Mohalla- Line Police Station12. Devendra Chauhan son of Balo Chauhan resident of Mohalla- Dumaria, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 13.

Deo Narayan Ram son of Shri Jageshwar Ram resident of Village and POAlta Hat, Police Station- Kochadhaman, District- Kishanganj. 14.

Shreelal Baitha son of Shath Lal Baitha resident of Village- Rupanihat, PORupanihat, District- Kishanganj. 15.

Lakshman Kumar Ray son of Asharul Ray resident of Village- Manzabari, PO- Patkoi Hat, District- Kishanganj.

16.

Rasik Lal Marandi son of Shri Charan Marandi resident of Village- Hugur Nagar, PO- Moletola, Police Station- Peerpainti, District- Bhagalpur. 17.

Gopi Das son of Late Mahabir Prasad Das resident of Village- Khagara Bahadurganj, PO and Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 18.

Sunil Kumar son of Late Satya Narain Roy Vill- Ranuchak, Police StationNathnagar, District- Bhagalpur. 19.

Kumari Kaushalya Daughter of Shri Mahendra Mandal resident of VillageBenugarh, PO- Matiyari, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj.

2/5 20.

Ramesh Kumar Ram son of Shri Birendra Bahadur resident of VillageKajlamari Road, Ward No. 2, Police Station- Kishanganj, District21. Shatrughan Thakur son of Shri Deo Narayan Thakur resident of VillageDinazpur Road, Ward No. 21, Police Station- Kishanganj, District22. Kumari Sushila daughter of Shri Mahdra Mandal resident of VillageDahibhat, PO and Police Station- Terhagarh, District- Kishanganj. 23.

Rajesh Prasad Paswan son of Shri Brij Lal Paswan resident of VillageRailway Colony, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 24.

Jyoti Kumari wife of Rajiv Kumar Ranjan c/o Uma Kant Jha, MohallaKalitalla Ruidhasa, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 25.

Chhabi Das wife of Birendra Kumar Das resident of Village- Maltola, POBangama, Police Station- Bahadurganj, District- Kishanganj. 26.

Prem Kumar Singh son of Bhumeshwar Prasad Singh resident of VillageDengapar, PO- Singhia, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 27.

Mina Devi wife of Hazari Prasad resident of Mohalla- Dumaria, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj.

28.

Barnabas Marandi son of Mohan Marandi resident of At- Naya Simldangi, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj.

29.

Ranvijay Kumar son of Ram Pravesh Singh resident of At- Kochhansa, P.O.- Karpi, P.S.- Karpi, District- Jahanabad.

30.

Sunil Kumar Hembrum son of Late Mohan Lal Hembrum resident of AtKushmarahi, P.O. and P.S.- Kushmarahi, District- Purnia. 31.

Parvin Kumar Thakur son of Shri Jagarnath Thakur resident of Loharpatti Road, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 32.

Umresh Prasad Saha son of Ganga Prasad Saha resident of MohallaDharamganj, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 33.

Dilip Kumar Goswami son of Late Andharulal Goswami resident of Village and PO- Piyari, Police Station- Rounta, District- Purnia. 34.

Ramesh Prasad Rai son of Shri Bachchalal Rai resident of Village- Parlabari, PO- Raipur, Police Station- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 35.

Saroj Kumar Yadav son of Kamal Prasad Yadav resident of VillageMajgama Angarh Hat, Sontha Kochadhaman, P.S.- Kochdhaman, District36. Md. Alam son of Lal Mohammad Ward No. 23, Ruidhasa Khanka Road, Rampur, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 37.

Mahesh Prasad Thakur son of Ram Pravesh Singh Adarsh Nagar, New Etwarpur, Kurthaul, P.S.- Jakkanpur, District- Patna. 38.

Pankaj Kumar Ram son of Bijendra Bahadur resident of Ward No. 2, Kajlamani, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 39.

Raj Kishore Thakur Son of Jageswar Thakur resident of Khagra Ward no. 32, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj.

40.

Lovely Das D/o Late Rasrajan Das resident of Dumaria Ward no. 30, P.S.-

3/5 41.

Binod Kumar Kamti son of Lallu Kamti resident of Mohalla- Roll Bag Khagra, Ward no. 30, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 42.

Jagriti Sinha Daughter of Gour Chandra Sinha resident of Village- Chandpur Gethuara, Kadwa, P.S.- Katihar, District- Katihar. 43.

Ramcharitra Ram son of Late Bal Gobind Ram resident of Village- Belwa Halamala, P.O.- Belwa Kasipur, P.S.- Dighalbank, District- Kishanganj. 44.

Babita Kumari wife of Kamlesh Kuamr resident of At- Sardar Gopal Singh School, Dharamganj, Ward No. 11, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 45.

Santosh Kumar Thakur son of Nirsan Thakur Khagra Halim Chowk, Rampur, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 46.

Satyendra Kumar Singh son of Dina Nath Singh resident of At- Ward No. 30, Dumaria, Near Kali Mandir, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 47.

Laxmi Devi wife of Ashok Kumar resident of Ward No. 30 Roll Bagh, P.S.- 48.

Habiba Khatoon wife of Nayar Alam resident of Panasi hat, P.S. Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj.

49.

Kumari Kiran Kerketta wife of Girwar Minj resident of Village- Jamauti Kanjia, Garhwa, P.S.- Garhwa, District- Garhwa, Jharkhand. 50.

Dharmendra Kumar son of Pramod Kumar Mandal resident of Village- ward no. 23 House no. 40, New Mission road (Ratan Goswami ke pichhe), P.S.- 51.

Lobindra Prasad Thakur Son of Rattelal Thakur resident of at Phulbari, Alta Hat, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj.

52.

Lallu Raut son of Late Bangar Raut resident of Singhasani, Post Singhansai, P.S.- Singhsani, District- East Champaran.

53.

Vedanand Tudu son of Lakhan Tudu resident of Jamal Tola Bansipurandaha, District- Purnia.

54.

Bhonu Das son of Dhaneshwar Das resident of ward no. 30, Dumaria, P.S.- ... ... Appellant/s

Versus

1.

Uma Shankar son of Ram Chandra Ram resident of Village- Lohrpatti Road, Ward No. 4, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 2.

The State of Bihar Bihar 3.

The Secretary, Personnel and Administrative Reforms Department (renamed as General Administration Department), Govt. of Bihar, Patna. 4.

The Commissioner, Purnia Division, Purnia.

5.

The District Magistrate, Kishanganj.

6.

The Deputy Development Commissioner, Kishanganj, Bihar. 7.

The Establishment Deputy Collector, Kishanganj. 8.

The District Welfare Officer, Kishanganj.

4/5 9.

Additional Collector, Kishanganj, Bihar.

10.

The Director General, Vigilance Investigation Bureau, Patna. 11.

The Principal Secretary, Vigilance Department, Government of Bihar, Patna. 12.

Sadanand Sharma, S/o Basudeo Sharma, the then Head Clerk, Establishment, Kishanganj.

13.

Ashok Paswan (2259) S/o Sitaram Paswan, resident of Railway Colony, Kishanganj, presently posted at Collectorate Kishanganj. 14.

Chanchal Sharma (4628) S/o Late Ashok Karh, resident of Kalyanpur Basti, District- Samastipur, now posted at Collectorate Kishanganj. 15.

Shyamal Kumar Sinha (4622) S/o Amulya Rath Sinha, resident of Millar Patti Kishanganj, now posted at Collectorate Kishanganj. 16.

Mr. Zaved Akhtar (4439) S/o Md Kayum resident of Mazid Manzil Mohiudpur Kishanganj, posted at Collectorate Kishanganj. 17.

Prabhunath Singh (4623) S/o Lila Singh, resident of Amnabad, P.O.- Katesar, District- Patna, posted at Collectorate Kishanganj, District18. Parwati Kumari, D/o Sheetal Prasad Yadav, resident of Phulwari, P.S.- Chakia, District- Kishanganj.

19.

Ram Raj Paswan, S/o Bachna Paswan, resident of Dhaksara, P.O.- Teusa, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj.

20.

Pratima Kumari, D/o Saryug Das, resident of Mohangachi, P.O.- Mokama, District- Patna.

21.

Hopan Murmu, S/o Chetan Murmu, resident of Hazur Nagar, P.O.- Bhola Toli, P.S.- Bhagalpur, District- Bhagalpur.

22.

Ganesh Mandal, S/o Mahendra Mandal, resident of Dabibhat, P.O.- Terhangachh, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. 23.

Rekha Kumari, D/o Mahadeo Das, Dharamganj, Ward No. 20, P.S.- 24.

Ajay Paswan, S/o Anand Paswan, resident of Subhash Patti, P.S.- 25.

Sukumar Jayadar, S/o Santosh Kumar, resident of Subhash Patti, P.S.- 26.

Sushila Kumari Mochi, D/o Ram Khalawan Ram, resident of Motibagh, Karbala, P.S.- Kishanganj, District- Kishanganj. ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance :

For the Appellant/s :

Mr.Alok Kumar, Advocate For the Respondent/s :

Mr.Arvind Kumar, Advocate For the Vigilance :

Mr. Rana Vikram Singh, Special P.P.

====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE and HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV ROY

5/5 ORAL ORDER (Per: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE) 13-10-2023 The present Letters Patent Appeal stands dismissed as withdrawn on the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the matter has become infructuous. (K. Vinod Chandran, CJ) (Rajiv Roy, J) aditya/- U