Prabin Kumar v. The State Of Bihar
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.9208 of 2019 ====================================================== 1.
Prabin Kumar Son of Sri Satrudhan Prasad Singh, resident of Village and PO Nauhatta District Saharsa.
2.
Prasun Ranjan Singh Sri Gajendra Nr. Singh At/PO- Maina Gram, PS - Mahishi,Dist.- Saharsa.
3.
Ranbir Kumar Singh Son of Sri Chandrika Pd. Singh Resident of Village and PO - P.S.- Nauhatta, Dist.- Saharsa.
4.
Shambhu Prasad Yadav Son of Sri Kamleshwari Pd. Yadav Resident of Village and PO- Maina, PS- Sonbarsa, Dist.- Saharsa. 5.
Sanjeev Kumar Singh Son of Sri Yugal Kishor Singh Resident of Village and PO - Dhabouli, PS - Sour Bazar, Dist.- Saharsa. 6.
Arun Kumar Jha son of late Parmannand Jha Resident of Village and PO - Bairail, PS and Dist.- Supaul.
7.
Raghunanth Jha son of Late Chhedi Jha resident of At/PO - Baliya, Via - Mangwar, Dist.- Saharsa.
8.
Ashok Paswan Son of Late Banbari Paswan resident At/PO- Sisie, PS/Dist.- Saharsa, 9.
Raj Nandan Singh, Son of Late Kamakhiya Pd. Singh resident At - Behta, PO - Dehad, PS- Sonbarsa, Dist.- Saharsa.
10.
Manoj Kumar Singh Son of not known Resident at- Behat, PO-Dehad,PSSonbarsa, Dist.- Saharsa. 11.
Sudhir Kumar Singh Son of Ramballav Pd. Singh, Resident At - bachandhi, PO - Sahsoul, PS - Sonbarsa, Dist.- Saharsa.
12.
Chandeshwari Kumar son of Laxmi Mandal Resident At - Raghunathpur,PO- Mahua Bazar, PS - Sonbarsa, Dist.- Saharsa. 13.
Anil Kumar Paswan Son of Ramotar Paswan Resident At/PO- Khajuri, PSSour Bazar, Distt. Saharsa 14.
Amrendra Viswash son of Late Kusheshwar Vishwash Resident At - PO - PS- Sonbarsa, Dist.- Saharsa.
15.
Shatrughan Sah son of Khub Lal Sah Resident At - Manori, PO - PS - Sonbarsha, Dist.- Saharsa.
16.
Rajiv Kumar Verma Son of Late Anirudh Prasad Resident At - Brahman Toli, PO - PS - Nauhatta, Dist.- Saharsa.
17.
Anil Kumar Saha Son of not known Resident At - PO - PS- Salkhua, Dist. - Saharsa 18.
Shambhu Vishwash Son of Late Uday Narayan Vishwash Resident of At - PO- PS -Sonbarsha,Dist. - Saharsa 19.
Anwari Khatun Wife of Md Ishrayel resident At - Majhaul, PO - Sahpur Majhaul, PS0- Nauhatta, Dist. - Saharsa.
20.
Amrendra Kumar Jha son of Late Kamla Kant Jha resident at - PO- Kahra, PS - Dist.- Saharsa.
2/9 21.
Balkrishna Kamti Son of Late Shiva Nand Kamti Resident of Village at - PO - Bara, PS -Bihra, Dist. - Saharsa.
22.
Naresh Kumar Paswan Son of Lakshmi Paswan Resident of Ward No. 24, Nagar Parisad, PS and District - Saharsa.
23.
Naresh Kumar Sharma Son of Late Shiva Nand Kamti resident of At - PO - Bara, PS - Bihra, Dist. - Saharsa.
24.
Indra Mohan Jha Son of Late Shyamdeo Jha resident of At - PO - Chandrayan, PS - Nauhatta, Dist. - Saharsa.
25.
Ashim Kumar Bhagat Son of Bamdev Pd. Bhagat resident of At - PO - Khesar, PS - Belhar, Dist. - Banka 26.
Manoj Kumar Son of Vindeshwari Pd. Yadav resident At - PO - Utesra, PS - Salkhua, Dist. Saharsa.
27.
Indu Prakash Son of Jawahar Prasad resident of At - PO - PS - Salkhua, Dist. - Saharsa.
28.
Arvind Kumar Karn Son of Jagdish Narayan Das Resident of At - PO - Maina, PS - Sonbarsha, Dist. - Saharsa.
29.
Ratneshwar Lal Das Son of Kusheshwar Lal Das Resident of At - PO -PS - Bihra, Dist. - Saharsa.
30.
Kameshwar Sing Azad Son of Jiwachh Pd. Yadav Resident of At - PO - Bakur, PS - Dist. - Supaul.
31.
Pawan Kumar Jha Son of Late Krishna Kant Jha Resident of At - PO - Barail, PS - Dist. - Supaul.
32.
Pradeep Kumar Jha Son of Late Jagdish Jha Resident of At - PO - Sarouni, PS -Mahishi, Dist. - Saharsa.
33.
Manju Kumari Son of Late Siya Ram Yadav Resident of At - PO - Jemhara, PS -Sour Bazar, Dist. - Saharsa.
34.
Rajiv Ranjan Son of Brahmdeo Kumar Yadav Resident of At - Matha, PO - PS - Salkhua,Dist. - Saharsa.
35.
Ranjit Kumar Son of Basudeo Singh Resident of At - PO -Harinsari, PS - Salkhua,Dist. - Saharsa.
36.
Bhagwat Mandal Son of Pritam Mandal Resident of At -Kathuar,, PO - Hati,Via - Sukhpur, Dist. - Saharsa.
37.
Amrendra Kumar Yadav Son of Nageshwar Pd. Yadav Resident of At -Galfariya, PO -Rampur, Dist. - Saharsa.
38.
Jatashankar Keshri Son of Late Dev Narayan Keshri Resident of At - PO -Bariyahi Bazar, PS - Bangaon,Dist. - Saharsa. 39.
Upendra Rajak Son of Rajendra Rajak Resident of At - PO -Bariyahi Bazar, PS - Bangaon,Dist. - Saharsa.
40.
Md. Nasimul Haque Son of late Md. Aafaque Resident of Meer Tola, Ward No - 30, Dist. - Saharsa.
41.
MD. Wasimool Haque Son of Md. Aafaque Resident of Meer Tola, Ward No - 30, Dist. - Saharsa.
42.
Sunil Kumar Son of Narayan Prasad Resident of Kaystha Tola, Ward No -
3/9 30, Dist. - Saharsa.
43.
Indeshwari Roy Son of Dev Roy Resident of Patel Nagar, Ward No - 31, Dist. - Saharsa.
44.
Chandra Mohan Thakur Son of Ram Narayan Thakur Resident of Batraha,, Ward No - 23, Dist. - Saharsa.
45.
Sharat Chandra Mishra Son of Ratish Chandra Mishra Resident of At -PO - Sihoul, PS - Bihra, Dist. - Saharsa.
46.
Jay Prakash Verma Son of Lekh Narayan Lal Das Resident of At -Kandaha, PO - PS -Mahishi, Dist. - Saharsa.
47.
Shashi Shekhar Lal Das Son of Mahidhar Lal Das resident at - Sukhasan, PO - Sukhasan, Dist. - Madhepura.
48.
Viveka Nand Jha Son of Late Madhav Jha Resident At - PO - Bargaon, Dist. - Saharsa.
49.
MD. Kurshid Alam Son of Md. Kyamuddin Resident At -Lagma, PO - Tariyama, Via - Simri Bakhtiyarpur, Dist. - Saharsa. 50.
Pradeep Kumar Choudhary Son of Late Radha Raman Choudhary resident of Naya Bazar Saharsa, Ward No. - 9. PS and District Saharsa. 51.
Jitendra Yadav Son of Tanuk Lal Yadav Resident At - Mahpura, Po - Maina Gram, Via - Mahishi, Distt.- Saharsa.
52.
Dhirendra Jha Son of Late Amol Jha Resident At and Po and Ps - Mahishi, Dist- Saharsa.
53.
Md. Arfin Son of Wajul Haque Resident At and Po - Mahichanda, Block - Forvisganj, Dist- Araria.
54.
Akhilesh Kumar Thakur Son of Kalika Nand Thakur Residentat and Po - Panchgachhiya, Ps - Bihra, Distt.- Saharsa.
55.
Sunil Kumar Rajak Son of Ramotar Rajak Resident At - Parwiniya, Po - Diwari, Ps and Distt.- Saharsa.
56.
Madan Kumar Varma Son of Chakradhar Lal Das Resident At and Po - Sukhasan (Chakla), Distt.- Madhepura.
57.
Anant Pandit, Son of Late Shaini Pandit Resident At - Shahpur, Po - Murlibasantpur, Ps and Distt.- Saharsa.
58.
Hari Narayan Ram, Son of Jagmohan Ram Resident of At and Po - Samda, P.S. - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa.
59.
Hareram Paswan of Khushi Lal Paswan Resident At and Po - Nauhata, P.S. - Nauhatta, Distt.- Saharsa.
60.
Uma Kant Ry S/o Late Shyam Sundar Ray Resident at Matihani,P.O. Khajuri Matihani,P.S. Simri Bakhtiyarpur,Dist.-Saharsa 61.
Chandra Bhushan Jha, Son of Late Ganesh Narayan Jha Resident At - Dhanga, Po and Ps - Nauhatta, Distt.- Saharsa. 62.
Dhirendra Kumar Varma, Son of Late Harivallav Lal Das Resident At - Brahman Toli, Po and Ps - Nauhatta, Distt.- Saharsa. 63.
Gunjan Kumari, Wife of Sri Sadhu Prasad Yadav Resident At and Po - Khajuri, Ps - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa.
4/9 64.
Lalita Kumari, Wife of Kamaldev Sah Resident At and Po - Salkhua Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa.
65.
Santosh Kumar Mishra, Son of Late Bhuvneshwar Mishra Resident At - Po - Bhawanpura, Ps - Kharik, Distt.- Bhagalpur.
66.
Chandan Kumar, Son of Brahmdeo Prasad Resident At Saharsa Basti, Ward - 24, Ps and Saharsa.
67.
Aamoda Nand Amar, Son of Pramanand Bhagat Resident At and Po - Golma, Ps - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa.
68.
Shashi Bhushan Singh, Son of Late Guneshwar Pd. Singh Resident At and Po - Telhar, Ps - Mahishi, Distt.- Saharsa.
69.
Sandeep Kumar Suman Son of Late Badri Nath Jha Resident At and Po - Tiri, Ps - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa.
70.
Kumari Sabnam Wife of Late Nawal Kishor Singh Resident At and Po - Madrouni, Distt.- Bhagalpur.
71.
Rajesh Kumar Jha, Son of Amrendra Narayan Jha Resident At and Po - Bara, Via - Panchgachhiya, Distt.- Saharsa.
72.
Hemant Kumar Jha, Son of Maheshwar Jha Resident At and Po - Khauraha, Ps - Sonbarsa, District Saharsa.
73.
Ashok Kumar Rajak, Son of Late Chhathu Pd. Rajak Resident of Bhartiya Nagar, Ward No.6 Ps and District - Saharsa.
74.
Sanjay Kumar, Son of Chandra Kishor Yadav Resident At and Po - Nandlali, Ps - Bihra, Distt.- Saharsa 75.
Kumari Nirmala, Wife of Satyadeo Prasad Yadav Resident At and Po - Nandlali, Ps - Bihra, Distt.- Saharsa.
76.
Nand Kishor Choudhary Son of Late Ganga Pd. Choudhary Resident At and Po - Rakiya, Ps - Bihra, Distt.- Saharsa.
77.
Sanjit Kumar Singh, Son of Late Nawal Kishor Singh Resident At and Po - Dhabouli, Ps - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa.
78.
Rajiv Kumar Singh Son of Late Kishori Pd. Singh Resident At and Po - Dhabouli, Ps - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa.
79.
Vimal Kumar, Son of Late Raghunandan Mandal Resident At-Dumma, PoBihra, Ps-Bihra, Distt.- Saharsa. 80.
Nilam Kumari, Wife of Ramchandra Sah Resident At - Sapaha, Po - Gamhariya, Distt.- Saharsa.
81.
Manoj Kumar Thakur, Son of Krishna Kant Thakurat and Po - Chainpur, Ps - Bangaon, Distt.- Saharsa.
82.
Murli Kumar Singh Son of Gopal Pd. Singh Resident At - Jamuniya, Po - Sardiha, Ps - Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa.
83.
Mahesh Kumar Singh Son of Ramawatar Singh Resident At and Po - Dhanupra, Ps - Simri Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa. 84.
Md. Sawir Husain, Son of Md. Rafiqueuddin Resident At - Puraini, Po - Ghordaur, Ps - S. Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa. 85.
Nirmal Kumar Raj, Son of Madhusudan Sah Resident At and Po -
5/9 Kharagpur, Via - Chapraw, Ps and Distt.- Saharsa. 86.
Manoj Kumar Bhagat Son of Bhagwan Bhagat Resident At - Gospur, Po - Goriyari, Ps - Salkhua, Distt.- Saharsa.
87.
Birendra Kumar Sah, Son of Anandi Sah Resident At - Chakhusaini, Po - Mansi, Distt.- Khagaria.
88.
Baijnath Das Son of Anandi Das Resident At - Bhoura, Po and Ps - S. Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa.
89.
Ajay Shankar Bhagat Son of Ramdev Prasad Bhaat Resident At and Po - Bedaur, Distt.- Khagariya 90.
Lalan Kumar Son of Nageshwar Pd. Yadav Residentat - Galfariya, Po - Rampur, Distt.- Saharsa.
91.
Anirudh Pandit Son of Brahmdeo Pandit Resident At and Po - Khamouti, Ps - S. Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa.
92.
Md. Khurshid Alam Son of Md. Islam Residentat - Fensaha, Po - Ghordaur, Ps - Salkhua, Distt.- Saharsa.
93.
Md. Irfan Alam Afi Son of Md. Jahuruddin Resident At - Fensaha, Po - Ghordaur, Ps - Salkhua, Distt.- Saharsa.
94.
Anil Kumar, Son of Satya Narayan Pd. Singh Resident At - Harinsari, Po - Salkhua, Ps - Salkhua, Distt.- Saharsa.
95.
Manju Devi Wife of Sita Sharan Baitha Resident of At and Po - Tariyama, Ps - S. Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa.
96.
Kumod Kumar Jha, Son of Late Biadyanath Jha Residentat - Baghwa, Po - Gopalpur, Ps - S. Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa. 97.
Gayadhar Tanti, Son of Late Laturan Tanti Resident At - Tilathi, Po - Rajanpur, Ps - S. Bakhtiyarpu, Distt.- Saharsa. 98.
Lalmohar Sharma Son of Parjit Sharma Resident At - Po - Amarpur, Ps - Sonbarsa Kachahari, Distt.- Saharsa.
99.
Sunil Kumar Rajak, Son of Jagdev Rajak Resident At - Khajuraha, Po - Hareba, Ps - Salkhua, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Ashit Kumar Son of Shashi Shekhar Pd. Sinha Resident Station Road, Begusarai, Po and Ps and Distt.- Begusarai.
.
Mahesh Kumar Son of Ganga Bhagat Resident At - Kasnagar, Parariya, Ps - Sonbarsa, Distt.- Saharsa .
Pramod Kumar, Son of Siyaram Yadav Resident of At - Sakhouri, Ghoghanpatti, Ps - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa .
Renu Kumari Wife of W/O Kula Nand Yadav Resident At - Murli, Po - Rasalpur, Ps - Sonbarsa, Distt.- - Saharsa.
.
Rajiv Kumar Singh Son of Surendra Nr. Singh Resident At and Po - Sardiha, Ps - S. Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Gupta Baitha, Son of Nirmal Baitha Resident At - Savaithwa, Po - Sugaha Bhawanipur, Distt.- Paschimi Champaran.
.
Ranjit Kumar Verma, Son of Indreshwar Lal Resident At and Po - Basauna, Ps - Bangaon, Dsit. - Saharsa
6/9 .
Jawahar Choudhary Son of Gujo Choudhari Resident At - Kusmi, Po - Sarvela, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Ramchandra Ram Son of Soman Ram Resident At and Po and Ps - Mahishi, Dist- Saharsa .
Md. Nigar Alam Son of Md. Bobinuddin Resident At - Puraini, Po - Ghordaur, Ps - Simri Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa .
Binod Kumar Poddar, Son of Janardan Poddar At and Po and Ps - Simari Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa.
111. Pankaj Kumar Jha Son of Krishna Ballav Jha Resident At and Po - Muradpur, Ps - Nauhatta, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Birendra Kumar Vimal Son of Ragho Pd. Mandal Resident of At - Duhbi, Po - Sahuriya Pruvi, Via - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa .
Sushil Kant Pathak Son of Mahakant Pathak Resident At - Goari, Po - Nanauti, Ps - Sonbarsa, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Md. Almin Son of Abdul Gafur Kamal Residentat and Po - Saharsa Basti, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Indra Narayan Yadav Son of Late Ramsevak Yadav at - Purushottampur, Po - Dharampur, Ps - Nauhatta, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Sudha Rani Wife of Prabhu Lal Choudhary Resident of Seva Sadan, Naya Bazar, Ward No. - 03, Saharsa.
.
Anil Kumar Son of Surendra Pd. Choudhary Resident Naya Bazar, Ward No. - 3, Saharsa.
.
Rajiv Kumar Son of Prabhu Nr. Poddar Resident naya Bazar, Ward No. - 3, Saharsa.
.
Alok Kumar Singh Son of Hira Prasad Singh Resident At and Po - Mahinath Nagar, Ps - Beldoul, Distt.- Khagaria.
.
Kapil Kumar, Son of Sri Kaml Sah Resident At - Rampur, Po - Gamhariya, Ps - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Dilip Kumar, Son of Late Bechan Prasad Vimal Resident of At - Makrai, Po - Maheshpur, Ps -Pipra, District. - Supaul.
.
Harimohan Sinha, Son of Sachchidanand Pd. Sinha Resident Meer Tola, Ward No. - 22, Bangaon Raod, Saharsa.
.
Ranjit Kumar, Son of Kuldeep Yadav Resident At and Po - Kopariya, Ps - Salkhua, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Chandan Kumar Mishra, Son of Siwanand Mishra Resident At and Po - Nonaiti, Ps - Sonbarsa, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Dilip Kumar, Son of Upendra Yadav Resident At - Menha, Po - Khadipur, Ps - Bihra, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Pawan Kumar, Son of Bhagwan Bhagat Resident At - Gospur, Po - Goriyari, Ps - Salkhua, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Vidya Nand Paswan, S/o Ramchandra Paswan Residentat - Bhatpura, Post - Paharpur - Ps - S. Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa. 128 Sanjay Kumar Verma, Son of Birendra Kumar Verma Resident Ward No. -
7/9 .
23, Krshna Nagar, Batraha, Ps and District Saharsa. .
Ashok Kumar Singh, Son of Surendra Nr. Singh Resident of At - Po - Sardiha, Ps - S. Bakhtiyarpur, Distt.- Saharsa. .
Dineshwar Thakur, Son of Parmeshwar Thakur Resident At and Po - Kahra, Via - Dhabouli, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Dharmendra Kumar, Son of Late Kari Lal Pd. Yadav Resident At and Po - Kopariya, Ps - Salkhua, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Bhajuman Yadav, Son of Late Nathan Yadav Resident At - Arshi, Po - Maina Ghat, Ps - Sonbarsa, Dsit. - Saharsa.
.
Ajay Kumar, Son of Late Parmanand Singh Resident At - Raj Nagar, Po - Line Bazar, Distt.- Purnina.
.
Rajesh Kumar Jha, Son of Late Nirbhay Chandra Jha Resident of At and Po and Ps - Mahishi, Dist- Saharsa.
.
Vishnu Dev Kumar, Son of Rameshwar Yadav Resident At and Po - Nandlali, Ps - Bihra, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Prabhash Kumar, Son of Late Bindeshwari Pd. Yadav Resident At - Indarwa, Po - Routa, Ps - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa. .
Parmeshwar Kumar, Son of Late Pritam Mandal Resident At - Khathuar, Po - Hati, Ps - Nauhatta, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Manju Kumari, Wife of Arvind Pd. Yadav Resident of At and Po - Bakiya, Via - Guru Bazar, Ps and Distt.- Katihar.
.
Manoj Kumar, Son of Late Bindeshwari Pd. Yadav Residentat and Po - Ajgeba, Ps - Sour Bazar, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Md. Mujahid Rabbani, Son of Md. Jainuddin Resident of At and Po - Saharsa Basti, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Md. Jafar Alam, Son of Md. Abul Hasan Resident At and Po - Saharsa Basti, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Bipin Kumar Gupta, Son of Late Lakhan Lal Gupta Resident At and Po and Ps - Sonbarsa Raj, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Prabhat Kumar Ranjan, Son of Sonelal Choudhary Resident of At and Po - Laharniya, Ps - Triveniganj, Distt.- Supaul.
.
Md. Faquerul Hoda, Son of Ainul Haque Resident At and Po - Bhelahi, Ps - Mahishi, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Vimal Kumar, Son of Kamal Sah Resident of At - Sapaha, Po - Gamhariya, Distt.- Saharsa.
.
Anil Kumar Bharti, Son of Siyaram Sharma Resident of Nayatola Bariyarpur Ps Bakhtiyarpur District Saharsa.
.
Sanjay Kumar Son of Sant Kumar Yadav Resident At Maheshpur Po Rupnagra District Saharsa .
Sangeeta Kumari Wife of Sunil Kumar Resident of Gangjala Ward No.18 Ps and District Saharsa .
Parimal Kumar S/o Ramshakal Singh Resident of Village-Danupra,Via Chapraon Kothi P.S. Simribakhtiyarpur,Dist.Saharsa
8/9 .
Anil Kumar Son of Sachhidanand Poddar Resident of Bakhtiarpur Ward No.26 Ps Bakhtiarpur District Saharsa.
.
Awadhesh Kumar, Son of Sri Suryanarayan Thakur Resident of Village Barahsher Ps and Daistrict Saharsa.
.
Dipak Kumar Singh, Son of Late Dashrath Prasad Singh Resident of Village and Po Sardiha Ps Simribakhtiarpur District Saharsa ... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1.
The State Of Bihar through the Principal Secretary Human Resources Development Department Bihar,Patna 2.
Directorl (Primary Education) Bihar, Ministry of Human Human Resources Development Department Bihar,Patna 3.
Deputy Development Commissioner cum Chairman Establishment Committee Saharsa 4.
District Education Officer, Saharsa 5.
District Programme Officer, Saharsa ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s :
Mr.Diwakar Prasad Singh For the Respondent/s :
Mr.Madanjeet Kumar (Gp20) ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MOHIT KUMAR SHAH ORAL ORDER 25-04-2019 Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and the learned counsel appearing for the State.
The present writ petition has been filed for issuing a direction to the respondents to grant senior pay scale on completion of 12 years.
The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the issue raised in the present writ petition is no more res integra. A coordinate Bench of this Court had already decided the issue vide order dated 31.03.2011 passed in CWJC No. 6139 of 2007 (Ram Ashis Tiwary & others vs. The State of Bihar
9/9 and others) and the order of the Writ Court was affirmed in L.P.A. No. 756 of 2015 dated 16.08.2017.
In above view of the matter, the present writ petition is disposed of with a direction to the respondent no.5 to examine the case of the petitioners in light of the decision of the Writ Court in C.W. J.C. No. 6139 of 2007 dated 31.03.2011 as affirmed in L.P.A. No. 756 of 2015 dated 16.08.2017 and the final decision in this regard must be taken by the respondent no.5 within a period of two months from the date of receipt/ production of a copy of this order and all consequential benefits including the monetary benefit should be extended to the petitioners within a period of one month thereafter. The writ petition stands disposed of on the aforesaid terms.
(Mohit Kumar Shah, J) Tiwary/- U