The Union Of India And ORS v. Manoj Kumar And ORS
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Review No.191 of 2017 1.
The Union of India through the Chairman, Railway Board, Ministry of Railway, Rail Bhawan, New Delhi 2.
The Secretary, Railway Board, Ministry of Railway, Rail Bhawan, New Delhi 3.
The Financal Commissioner, Railway Board, Ministry of Railway, Rail Bhawan, New Delhi 4.
The General Manager, East Central Railway, Hajipur 5.
The General Manager ( Personnel ), East Central Railway, Hajipur 6.
The Financial Advisor & Chief Accounts officer, East Central ... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1.
Manoj Kumar Son of Sri Kamal Kishore Prasad, Son of Sri Kamal Kishore Prasad, PS - II, under Chief Engineer ( Con ), South, East Central Railway, Mahendrughat, Patna 800001 and others 2.
Aman Kumar Son of Late Akhauri Suresh Prasad PS - II, Deputy Chief Engineer ( Con ), South, East Central Railway, Mahendrughat, Patna 4 3.
Ravi Ranjan Son of Nareshwar Prasad PS - II, under Chief Engineer ( Con ), South, East Central Railway, Mahendrughat, Patna 4 4.
Rajiv Ranjan Triyar Son of K.K. Triyar P.S. II under COS, East Central 5.
Harendra Kumar Son of late Basudeo Roy P.S. II, Under SR DFM, East Central Railway, Sonpur 6.
Biresh Kumar Singh Son of Sri Vishnudeo Singh PS II, under FA & CAO, East Central Railway, Hajipur 7.
Srish Son of Sri. R.K. Prasad Gupta PS II, under FA & CAO, East Central 8.
Dhananjay Kumar Son of Sri Yogendra Sharma PS II, under FA & CAO, East 9.
Uday Shankar Sah Son of Sri Shiv Narayan Sah PS II, under FA & CAO, East Central Railway, Jahipur
10. Ajay Kumar Pandey Son of Bharat Pandey PS II, under FA & SDMG, East
11. Ajay Kumar Singh Son of late Ram Jiwan Singh PS II, under COS, East
12. Sanjay Kumar Son of late Baleswhar Singh PS II, under CEE, East Central
13. Niranjan Kumar Son of T.N. Prasad Singh PS II, under CCM, East Central
14. Harendra Harijan Son of Ramyatan Harijan PS II, under CCM, East Central
15. Abdhesh Thakur Son of late Phuldeo Thakur PS II, under CSTE, East Central
16. Sanjit Kumar Singh Son of late C.D. Singh PS II, under Secy. To GM, East
17. Uttam Kumar Son of Ganauri Lal PS II, under Secy. To G.M., East Central
2/4
18. Binoy Kumar Son of late Nepali Sah PS II, under Secy. To G.M., East Central
19. Chandan Kumar Son of Tulsi Ram PS II, under Secy ( Confidential ), East
20. Radhey Shyam Prasad Son of late Chandeshwar Prasad PS - II, under COM, East Central Railway, Hajipur
21. Firoz Ansari Son of Karim Ansari PS - II, under CPO, East Central Railway, Hajipur
22. Jeetendra Kumar Ram Son of Muneshwar Ram PS - II, under CPO, East
23. Anoop Prasad Gupta Son of late Ramesh Chandra PS - II, under CSC, East
24. Manoj Ram Son of late Fakira Ram PS - II, under CSTE, East Central
25. Subhash Kumar Son of Suri N. Kumar PS - II, under CSTE, East Central
26. Ramanuj Das Son of Sitaram Ravidas PS - II, under PCE, East Central
27. Dilip Kumar Son of late Shivnath Noniya PS - II, under CCM, East Central
28. Sidheshwar Choudhary Son of Baiju Choudhary PS - II, under COM, East
29. Pramod Kumar Son of late B. Mahto PS - II, under CMD, East Central
30. Yogeshwar Mahli Son of M. Mahli PS - II, under SDGM, East Central
31. Navin Kumar Son of N.K.P. Gupta PS - II, under PCE, East Central Railway, Hajipur
32. Rajesh Prasad Son of N.K. Prasad PS - II, under CEE, East Central Railway, Hajipur
33. Raj Kumar ,J Das Son of late Jageshwar Das PS - II, under CME, East
34. Sanjay Shankar Lal Son of Hakim Ram PS - II, under CSO, East Central Railway, Hajipu
35. Shiv Shankar Lal Son of late U.N. Lal Das PS - II, under Sr. DCM, East
36. Bhgwan Paswan Son of Sahdeo Paswan PS - II, under Sr. DSO, East Central
37. Niraj Kumar Son of Gauri Shankar Prasad Singh PS - II, under Chairman, RRB, , East Central Railway, Muzaffarpur
38. Ranjan Kumar Singh Son of late Kapil Deo Narayan PS - II, under SPO/Const., East Central Railway, Hajipur
39. Rajen Kumar Sharma Kumar Son of late S.N. Sharma S II, under Sr. DFM, East Central Railway, Hajipur
40. Rajesh Kumar Son of Krishna Prasad PS - II, under DGM/Law, East Central
41. Ajit Kumar Son of Ramji Prasad PS - II, under DGM/Law, East Central
42. Md. Faroque Rashid Son of Late Md. Saud PS - II, under CE/C/Central, East Central Railway, Patna
43. Md. Mojibur Rahman Son of Md. B. Joha PS - II, under Dy. CE/C/South, East Central Railway, Hajipur
3/4
44. Vijay Kumar Choudhary Son of late Rajendra Choudhary PS - II, under Dy. CE/Con/South, East Central Railway, Hajipur
45. Manoj Kumar Mishra Son of late G. Mishra PS - II, under CAO/Con/South, East Central Railway, Patna
46. Manish Raj Son of Sri Deo Prakash PS - II, under CE?Con/SE, East Central Railway, Patna
47. Umesh Kumar Son of Radhey Podda PS - II, under FA&CAO/Con, East Central Railway, Patna
48. Kaushal kumar Son of Nar Singh Mahto PS - II, under FA&CAO/Con, East Central Railway, Patna
49. Sanjay Kumar Son of Jagdish Ram PS - II, under FA&CAO/WP&TA, East Central Railway, Patna
50. Khurshid Anwar Son of late Md. Nasiruddin PS - II, under CAO/C/GELF, East Central Railway, Patna
51. Suman Kumar Thakur Son of late Sudist Narayan Thakur PS - II, under DRM//Danapur, East Central Railway, Danapur
52. C.K. Goshami Son of Late B.N. Goshami PS - II, under Sr. DEN/Danapur, East Central Railway, Danapur
53. B.B. Sharma Son of late D.N. Sharma PS - II, under ADRM/Danapur, East Central Railway, Danapur
54. S.N. Sinha Son of late Seo Mangal Lal PS - II, under DEN/Con/Danapur, East Central Railway, Danapur
55. Ratneshwar Prasad Karn Son of late L.D. Prasad PS - II, under MD /CH/, East Central Railway, Patna
56. Arun Jha Son of late Sidhhi Nath Jha PS - II, under Medical Director/ CH, , East Central Railway, Patna
57. Ravi Narayan Pandey Son of Janardhan Pandey PS - II, under CE/Con/DNR, East Central Railway, Danapur
58. Sanjay Kumar Sharma Son of N.N. Bhushan PS - II, under Dy. CE/Con/G, East Central Railway, Patna
59. Pramod Lakra Son of late Rajkishre Lakra PS - II, under CSTE/Con/N, , East Central Railway, Patna
60. Rajiv Kumar Son of Ashok Kumar PS - II, under Dy. CE/Con/GB - 1,, East Central Railway, Patna
61. Mauje Lal Ram Son of Late Sanful Ram PS - II, under CSC/RPF, East
62. Kalyan Kumar Dey Son of Late L. B. Dey PS - II, under CME - East Central
63. Janardhan Prasad Singh Son of late Shyam Sundar Singh PS - II, under CSTE/T&P, East Central Railway, Hajipur
64. Pravin Kumar Singh Son of late M.N. Singh PS - II, under Dy.GM ( G ), East
65. Yadunath Prasad Son of late Satya Rai PS - II, under Secy. To CAO/C/N, East Central Railway, Patna
66. Bikash Kumar Singh Son of C.D. Singh PS II, under CAO/C/N/, East Central Railway, Patna
67. Akhilesh Prasad Son of late Mathura Prasad PS - II, under CPO/Admn., East ... ... Respondent/s Appearance :
4/4 For the Petitioner/s :
Mr. Shekhar Singh For the Respondent/s :
Mr.
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR TRIPATHI and HONOURABLE JUSTICE SMT. NILU AGRAWAL ORAL ORDER (Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR TRIPATHI) 23-08-2017 Heard counsel for the Railways. Perused the impugned order.
The Court does not find any error apparent on the face of record, which is required to be rectified in the review application.
Review application, therefore, stands dismissed. (Ajay Kumar Tripathi, J) ( Nilu Agrawal, J) skm/- U