Anuj Kumar And ORS v. The State Of Bihar And ORS

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA

Letters Patent Appeal No.350 of 2018 In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.15321 of 2016 ======================================================

1. Anuj Kumar son of Dayanand Singh resident of Village/Mohalla - Chadhua, P.O. - Chadhua, P.S. - Kurhani, Prakhand - Kurhani (Turki), District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

2. Vivekanand Son of Ram Ashish Sharma resident of village / Mohallah - Mahanth Maniyari, P.O. Mahanth Maniyari, P.S. Maniyari, Prakhand - Kurhani, District Muzaffarpur ( Bihar )

3. Punam Kumari Wife of Ainil Ram resident of village / Mohalla - Baghi Ekdara, P.O. Baghi Ekdara, P.S. Samastipur, Prakhand - Tajpur, District - Samastipur ( Bihar )

4. Mamta Kumari wife of Tinku Kumar resident of Village/Mohalla - Lakshmipur, P.O. - Turki, P.S. Kurhani, Prakhand - Kurhani (Turki), District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

5. Subhas Kumar Son of Shambhu Ray resident of village / Mohallah - Molha, P.O. Arvindnagar, P.S. Dariyapur, Prakhand - Dariyapur, District - Saran

6. Jaykant Kumar son of Shatrudhan Sah resident of Village/Mohalla - Turhi, P.O. - Turki, P.S. - Kurhani, Prakhand - Kurhani (Turki), District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

7. Rakesh Kumar son of Avadesh Ray resident of Village/Mohalla - Turhi, P.O. - Turki, P.S. - Kurhani, Prakhand - Kurhani (Turki), District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

8. Mukesh Kumar Son of Uma Dayal Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Dewan, P.O. Dewan, P.S. Kadirganj, Prakhand - Dhanarua, District - Patna

9. Chandan Bihari son of Umesh Chandra resident of Village/Mohalla - Turhi, P.O. - Turki, P.S. - Kurhani, Prakhand - Kurhani (Turki), District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

10. Prem Kumar son of Biku Ray resident of Village/Mohalla - Turhi, P.O. - Turki, P.S. - Kurhani, Prakhand - Kurhani (Turki), District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

... ... Appellant/s

Versus

1. The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary, Department of Planning AND Development, Government of Bihar, Patna

2. The Principal Secretary, Department of Planning AND Development, Government of Bihar, Patna

3. The Director, Department of Planning AND Development, Government of Bihar, Patna

4. The Joint Director - Cum - office Head, Department of Planning AND Development, Government of Bihar, Patna

5. The District Statistical Officer, Patna, District Patna ( Bihar )

6. The District Statistical Officer, Gaya, District - Gaya ( Bihar )

7. The District Statistical Officer, Bhojpur, District - Bhojpur ( Bihar )

8. The District Statistical Officer, Rohtas, District - Rohtas ( Bihar )

9. The District Statistical Officer, Kaimur, District - Kaimur ( Bihar )

10. The District Statistical Officer, Khagaria, District Khagaria ( Bihar )

2/13

11. The District Statistical Officer, Purnea, District Purnea ( Bihar )

12. The District Statistical Officer, Supaul, District - Supaul ( Bihar )

13. The District Statistical Officer, Madhepura, District - Madhepura ( Bihar )

14. The District Statistical Officer, Vaishali, District - Vaishali ( Bihar )

15. The District Statistical Officer, Muzaffarpur, District - Muzaffarpur ( Bihar )

16. The District Statistical Officer, Sheohar, District Sheohar ( Bihar )

17. The District Statistical Officer, Begusarai, District - Begusarai ( Bihar )

18. The District Statistical Officer, Sheikhpura, District Sheikhpura ( Bihar )

19. The District Statistical Officer, Saran, District Saran, ( Bihar )

20. The District Statistical Officer, Madhubani, District Madhubani ( Bihar )

21. The District Statistical Officer, Buxar, District - Buxar ( Bihar )

22. The District Statistical Officer, Nawada, District Nawada ( Bihar )

23. The District Statistical Officer, Nalanda, District Nalanda ( Bihar )

24. The District Statistical Officer, Darbhanga, District Darbhanga ( Bihar )

25. The District Statistical Officer, Araria, District - Araria ( Bihar )

26. Manish Kumar son of Nagendra Singh resident of Village/Mohalla - Bishunpur Patti, P.O. - Bishunpur Patti, P.S. - Sahebganj, Prakhand - Sahebganj, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

27. Ravish Kumar Nigam son of Nagendra Panjiyar resident of Village/Mohalla - Pathan Tola, Damodarpur, P.O. - Damodarpur, P.S. - Kanti, Prakhand - Kanti, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

28. Manish Kumar Nigam son of Nagendra Panjiyar resident of Village/Mohalla - Pathan Tola, Damodarpur, P.O. - Damodarpur, P.S. - Kanti, Prakhand - Kanti, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

29. Sushil Kumar son of Birendra Prasad resident of Village/Mohalla - Gardh Karnal, P.O. - Gardh Karnal, P.S. - Sahebganj, Prakhand - Sahebganj, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

30. Shashi Kant son of Suresh Kumar Tiwari resident of Village/Mohalla - Chanakyapuri, Road No. 03,P.O.- M.I.T. Muzaffarpur, Prakhand - Kanti, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

31. Suman Kumar son of Chandeshwar Thakur resident of Village/Mohalla - Patahi Roop, P.O.- Patahi, P.S. - Muzaffarpur (Sadar), Prakhand - Mushahari, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

32. Prabhakar Bharti son of Sri Ram Niwas Sharma resident of Village/Mohalla - Punas Chaturi, P.O. Muzaffarpur, P.S. - Ahiyapur, Prakhand - Mushahari, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

33. Ajitesh Kumar son of Dr. Manik Lal Pandey resident of Village/Mohalla - Phuladh, P.O. - Phuladh, P.S. - Paroo, Prakhand - Paroo, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar)

34. Diwakar Bharti son of Ram Niwas Sharma resident of Village/Mohalla - Chaturi Punas, P.O. - Head Post Office, Muzaffarpur, P.S. - Ahiyarpur, Prakhand - Mushahari, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar)

35. Satya Prakash son of Arun Kumar Thakur resident of Village/Mohalla - Patahi Hari, P.O.- Patahi, P.S. - Muzaffarpur (Sadar), Prakhand - Mushahari, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

36. Maneeish Kumar son of Sri Jaichandra Thakur resident of Village/Mohalla - Panapur Akhtiyarpur, P.O. - Panapur Akhtiyarpur, Via - Jaitpur (Estate), P.S. - Karanja, Prakhand - Marwan, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

37. Mahesh Kumar Gupta son of Kishandeo Prasad resident of Village/Mohalla - Piprahi, P.O. - Piprahi, P.S. - Piprahi, Prakhand - Piprahi, District - Sheohar (Bihar).

3/13

38. Dharmendra Kumar son of Late Krishna Lal Srivastava resident of Village/Mohalla - Teacher's Colony, Charitravan, P.O. - Charitravan, P.S. - Buxar, Prakhand - Buxar, District - Buxar (Bihar).

39. Bijay Kumar Dubey son of Rameshwar Nath Dubey resident of Village/Mohalla - Airport Road, Buxar, P.O. - Central Jail Bazar, P.S. - Buxar, Prakhand - Buxar, District - Buxar (Bihar).

40. Jitendra Kumar son of Ramdhani Singh resident of Village/Mohalla - Maniyara, P.O. - Sikariya, P.S. - Tiyar, Prakhand - Bihiya, District - Bhojpur (Bihar).

41. Dhananjay Kumar son of Lalan Choudhary resident of Village/Mohalla - Belhar, P.O. - Budhan Road Bhadokhra, P.S. - Darigon, Prakhand - Sasaram, District - Rohtas (Bihar).

42. Satyajit Kumar son of Mahesh Prasad resident of Village/Mohalla - Saksohra, P.O. - Saksohra, P.S. - Saksohra, Prakhand - Belchi, District - Patna (Bihar).

43. Ashok Kumar Yadav son of Kisto Prasad Yadav resident of Village/Mohalla - Jhouramani, P.O. - Runki, P.S. - Rauta, Prakhand - Baisa, District - Purnea (Bihar).

44. Satish Kumar son o Shree Ram Yatan Das resident of Village/Mohalla - Rajuan Sisauni, P.O. - Bardaha, Kamtaul, Jale, P.S. - Jale, Prakhand - Jale, District - Darbhanga (Bihar).

45. Binay Kumar Singh son of Gajendra Prasad Singh resident of Village/Mohalla - Jogiara, P.O. - Jogiara, P.S. - Jale, Prakhand - Jale, District - Darbhanga (Bihar).

46. Shashi Shekhar Prasad Yadav son of Chandra Shekhar Prasad resident of Village/Mohalla - Amaei Kukroon, P.O. - Kukroon (East), P.S. - Dhamdaha, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea (Bihar).

47. Sunil Kumar Singh Son of Kameshwar Prasad Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Chandrahi, P.O. Chandrahi, P.S. Dhamdaha, Prakhand Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar )

48. Bindi Kumari Wife of Sunil Kumar Gupta resident of village / Mohalla - Nawadih, P.O. Amjhore, P.S. Rohtas, Prakhand - Rohtas, District - Rohtas

49. Raj Kishore Yadav Son of Sri Kamleshwari Prasad Yadav resident of village / Mohalla - Mogaliya Purdaha, P.O. Mogaliya Purdaha, P.S. Dhamdaha, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar )

50. Rajeev Ranjan Son of Chandra Shekhar Prasad Sah resident of village / Mohalla - Rangpura Milki, P.O. Rangpura, P.S. Mirganj, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar )

51. Sudhanshu Kumar Son of Chandra Shekhar Prasad Sah resident of village / Mohallah - Rangpura Milki, P.O. Rangpura, P.S. Mirganj, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar )

52. Vinay Kumar Son of Chandra Shekhar Prasad Sah resident of village / Mohalla - Rangpura Milki, P.O. Rangpura, P.S. Mirganj, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar )

53. Mahadev Prasad Singh Son of Bir Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Ardania, P.O. Angar Hat, P.S. Angar Hat, Prakhand - Baisa, District - Purnea ( Bihar )

54. Mukesh Kumar Son of Bhuneshwar Prasad Yadav resident of village / Mohalla - Mahua Tola Lakshmipur, P.O. Khadgi Tirasi, P.S. Khagaria, Prakhand - Khagaria, District - Khagaria ( Bihar )

55. Md. Izhar Son of Md. Liyas resident of village / Mohallah - Raun, P.O. Raun, P.S. Alauli, Prakhand Alauli, District - Khagaria ( Bihar )

4/13

56. Dheeraj Kumar Son of Kishundeo Sah resident of village / Mohallah - Khutaha, P.O. Khutaha, P.S. Alauli, Prakhand Alauli, District - Khagaria

57. Arvind Kumar Son of Chaturbhuj Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Haujpura, P.O. Haujpura, P.S. Vaishali, Prakhand - Vaishali, District - Vaishali

58. Sharad Kumar Son of Late Sudama Prasad resident of village / Mohalla - Mathiya, P.O. Mathiya, P.S. Lauriya, Prakhand - Lauriya, District - West Champaran ( Bihar )

59. Prakash Kumar Son of Bijay Prasad resident of village / Mohalla - Bikram, P.O. Bikram, P.S. Bikram, Prakhand - Bikram, District - Patna ( Bihar )

60. Srikant Thakur Son of Hiralal Thakur resident of village / Mohalla - Chinhuta, P.O. Benibigha, P.S. Rani Talab Kanpa, Prakhand - Bikram, District - Patna

61. Sanjay Kumar Son of Dineshwar Thakur resident of village / Mohalla - Bikram, P.O. Bikram, P.S. Bikram, Prakhand - Bikram, District - Patna

62. Brajesh Kumar Son of Satyadeo Thakur resident of village / Mohalla - Bikram, P.O. Bikram, P.S. Bikram, Prakhand - Bikram, District - Patna

63. Arunjay Kumar Vidyarthi Son of Rajendra Prasad resident of village / Mohallah - Bela, P.O. Dariyapur, P.S. Dariyapur, Prakhand - Dariyapur, District - Saran ( Bihar )

64. Navin Sharma Son of Ganesh Prasad Sharma resident of village / Mohallah - Bela, P.O. Bela, via - Sitapur, P.S. Dariyapur, Prakhand - Dariapur, District - Saran ( Bihar )

65. Rakesh Kumar Sah Son of Ram Briksha Sah resident of village / Mohalla - Rarhi, P.O. Rarhi, P.S. Jale, Prakhand - Jale, District - Darbhanga ( Bihar )

66. Shobha Kumari Wife of Vijay Kumar resident of village / Mohalla - Kachua, P.O. Kachua, P.S. Jale, Prakhand - Jale, District - Darbhanga ( Bihar )

67. Krishna Kumar Raut Son of Raju Raut resident of village / Mohalla - Kachua, P.O. Kachua, P.S. Jale, Prakhand - Jale, District - Darbhanga ( Bihar )

68. Chandra Shekhar Prasad Son of Jagdish Prasad resident of village / Mohalla - Reodha, P.O. Reodha, P.S. Jale, Prakhand - Jale, District - Darbhanga ( Bihar )

69. Naresh Mistry Son of Ram Prasad Mistry resident of village / Mohalla - Kaswa Pachrukhi, P.O. Rajhat, P.S. Akbarpur, Prakhand - Akbarpur, District - Nawada ( Bihar )

70. Niranjan Kumar Son of Dani Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Dihi, P.O. Fatehpur More, P.S. Akbarpur, Prakhand - Akbarpur, District - Nawada

71. Raushan Kumar Son of Naresh Prasad Sinha resident of village / Mohalla - Pachrukhi, P.O. Rajhat, P.S. Akbarpur, Prakhand - Akbarpur, District - Nawada ( Bihar )

72. Abhinay Prasad Son of Tulsi Prasad resident of village / Mohalla - Pachrukhi, P.O. Rajhat, P.S. Akbarpur, Prakhand - Akbarpur, District - Nawada ( Bihar )

73. Amardeep Kumar Son of Jawahar Lal resident of village / Mohalla - Pachrukhi Kothi, P.O. Rajhat, P.S. Akbarpur, Prakhand - Akbarpur, District - Nawada ( Bihar )

74. Arvind Kumar Son of Kapil Deo Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Pachrukhi Kothi, P.O. Rajhat, P.S. Akbarpur, Prakhand - Akbarpur, District - Nawada ( Bihar )

5/13

75. Anil Kumar Son of Nawal Kishore Prasad resident of village / Mohalla - Fatehpur, P.O. Fatehpur, P.S. Akbarpur, Prakhand - Akbarpur, District - Nawada ( Bihar )

76. Amit Kumar Son of Surya Narayan Vishwakarma resident of village / Mohalla - Pachrukhi, P.O. Rajhat, P.S. Akbarpur, Prakhand - Akbarpur, District - Nawada ( Bihar )

77. Sunil Kumar Son of Suraj Mistri resident of village / Mohalla - Pachrukhi Kothi, P.O. Rajhat, P.S. Akbarpur, Prakhand - Akbarpur, District - Nawada

78. Rajesh Kumar Son of Ram Darash Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Pipra, P.O. Pipra, P.S. Kudra, Prakhand - Kudra, District - Kaimur ( Bihar )

79. Pappu Kumar Son of Rajendra Prasad Yadav resident of village / Mohalla - Parmanpur, P.O. Bhatrandha, P.S. Ghailarh, Prakhand - Ghailarh, District - Madhepura ( Bihar )

80. Barun Kumar Son of Rajendra Prasad Yadav resident of village / Mohalla - Parmanpur, P.O. Bhatrandha, P.S. Ghailarh, Prakhand - Ghailarh, District - Madhepura ( Bihar )

81. Arun Kumar Son of Rajendra Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Bara, P.O. Panditganj, P.S. Kadirganj, Prakhand - Masaurhi, District Patna ( Bihar )

82. Jai Prakash Narayan Son of Lakshmi Narayan Sinha resident of village / Mohalla - Tandwa, P.O. Pabhera, P.S. Dhanarua, Prakhand - Dhanarua, District - Patna ( Bihar )

83. Akshay Kumar Son of Sri Devendra Prasad Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Bara, P.O. Panditganj, P.S. Kadirganj, Prakhand - Dhanarua, District Patna ( Bihar )

84. Harendra Kumar Ganesh Son of Sharan Lal Ganesh resident of village / Mohalla - Talbari, P.O. Badampur, P.S. Dighal Bank, Prakhand - Dighal Bank, District - Kishanganj ( Bihar )

85. Dipak Kumar Son of Rajendra Prasad resident of village / Mohallah - Bela, P.O. Bela, P.S. Dariyapur, Prakhand - Dariyapur, District - Saran ( Bihar )

86. Samlendra Kumar Suman Son of Shatrughan Paswan resident of village / Mohallah - Jamharoo, P.O. Jamharoo Imamganj, P.S. Paliganj, Prakhand - Paliganj, District - Patna ( Bihar )

87. Brijmohan Kumar Son of Chandrika Chaudhary resident of village / Mohalla - Kharati Kutwi, P.O. Oyama Lakhanpur, P.S. Sigori, Prakhand - Paliganj, District - Patna ( Bihar )

88. Bijay Kumar Son of Late Shiv Narayan Prasad resident of village / Mohallah - Mahuri Tola, C/o Hanuman Jee Mills, Saheli Daizy Beauty Parlour, P.O. Sheikhpur, Prakhand Sheikhpura, District - Sheikhpura ( Bihar )

89. Atiqur Rahman Son of Hussam Hyder resident of village / Mohalla - Yehyapur, P.O. Sheikhpura, District - Sheikhpura ( Bihar )

90. Md. Jawed Ashik Son of Md. Ashique Hussain Ansari resident of village / Mohalla - Sakunat Ward No. 13, P.O. Sheikhpura, P.S. Sheikhpura, Prakhand - Sheikhpura, District - Sheikhpura ( Bihar )

91. Gautam Kumar Son of Sri Butan Sah resident of village / Mohallah - Baghi, Ward No. 25, P.O. Suhidra Nagar, P.S. Begusarai ( Town ), Prakhand - Begusarai, District - Begusarai ( Bihar )

92. Neeshant Kumar Son of Ram Badan Roy resident of village / Mohalla - Dadupur Tola Samsipur, P.O. Rupaswaj, P.S. Begusarai ( Town ), Prakhand - Bachhwara, District - Begusarai ( Bihar )

6/13

93. Md. Sajjad Ali Son of Md. Gul Mohamad resident of village / Mohallah - Forsahi Ward No. 11, P.O. Mahmuda, P.S. Alamnagar, Prakhand - Alamnagar, District - Madhepura ( Bihar )

94. Rajiv Kumar Son of Sudhir Mandal resident of village / Mohallah - Chakla, P.O. Basanbara, P.S. Alamnagar, Prakhand - Alamnagar, District - Madhepura

95. Mohan Singh Son of Madho Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Premchan Path Gaurakshani Sasaram, P.O. Sasaram, P.S. Sasaram, Prakhand - Sasaram, District - Rohtas ( Bihar )

96. Sunil Kumar Gupta Son of Ram Chandra Prasad resident of village - Nawadih, P.O. Rohtas, P.S. Rohtas, District - Rohtas ( Bihar )

97. Devendra Kumar Son of Kapil Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Gangarhi, P.O. Saisarh, P.S. Dinara, Prakhand - Dinara, District - Rohtas ( Bihar )

98. Anshu Kumari daughter of Madan Prasad Gupta resident of village / Mohalla - Dinara, P.O. Dinara, P.S. Dinara, Prakhand - Dinara, District - Rohtas

99. Suman Kumar Singh son of Sachchidanand Singh resident of Village/Mohalla - Kataru, P.O. - Chhap, P.S. - Paroo, Prakhand - Paroo, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar) 100.

Awadhesh Kumar son of Lal Chand Prasad resident of Village/Mohalla - Khemaipatti, P.O. - Khemaipatti, P.S. - Minapur, Prakhand - Minapur, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

101.

Rajesh Kumar Thakur son of Shaukhi Lal Thakur resident of Village/Mohalla - Dhobi Ghat Gali No. 8, Chartitravan, P.O. - Chartitravan, P.S. - Buxar, Prakhand - Buxar, District - Buxar (Bihar). 102.

Bharat Kumar son of Dashrath Prasad Singh resident of Village/Mohalla - Raksha Nagar, P.O. - Raghunathpur, P.S. - Brahampur, Prakhand - Brahampur, District - Buxar (Bihar). 103.

Daya Shankar Singh son of Umeshwar Kumar resident of Village/Mohalla - Hulaspatti, P.O. - Jageshwar Asthan, P.S. - Phulparas, Prakhand - Ghoghardiha, District - Madhubani (Bihar). 104.

Ravi Shankar Singh son of Kamaleshwar Singh resident of Village/Mohalla - Sri Nagar Matihan, P.O. - Dighwara, P.S. - Dariyapur, Prakhand - Dariyapur, District - Saran (Bihar). 105.

Manjee Kumar Shah son of Gupteshwar Shah resident of Village/Mohalla - Sohara, P.O. - Sohara, P.S. - Krishnagarh, Prakhand - Barhara, District - Bhojpur (Bihar).

106.

Ajay Kumar Singh son of Ram Kishore Singh resident of Village/Mohalla - Lauhar Shripal, P.O. - Farna, P.S. - Barhara, Prakhand - Barhara, District - Bhojpur (Bihar).

107.

Binod Kumar son of Late Siddheshwar Thakur resident of Village/Mohalla - Bidauli, P.O. - Bidauli, P.S. - Masaurhi, Prakhand - Masaurhi, District - Patna (Bihar).

108.

Ajay Mehra son of Awadhesh Prasad resident of Village/Mohalla - Biduali, P.O. - Bidauli, P.S. - Masaurhi, Prakhand - Masaurhi, District - Patna (Bihar).

109.

Bhupendra Kumar son of Sri Anirudh Prasad Singh resident of Village/Mohalla - Dhanwa, P.O. - Nadama Tola (Barh), P.S.- Barh, Prakhand - Barh, District - Patna (Bihar).

110.

Birbal Kumar Choupal son of Duni Lal Choupal resident of Village/Mohalla - Mirpure, P.O. - Mirpure, P.S. - Rauta, Prakhand - Baisa, District - Purnea (Bihar).

7/13 111.Saroj Kumar son of Tej Bahadur resident of Village/Mohalla - Purnea College Campurs, near Purnea Railway Dhala, P.O. - Purnea , P.S. K. Hat, Purnea, Prakhand - Purnea East, District - Purnea (Bihar). 112.

Santosh Kumar son of Virendra Ray resident of Village/Mohalla - Bhagwanpur, P.O. - Fatehpur, P.S. - Akbarpur, Prakhand - Dariyapur, District - Saran (Bihar).

113.

Akhilesh Kumar son of Triveni Mahto resident of Village/Mohalla - Maheshpur, P.O. - Maheshpur, P.S. Alamganj Chauk, Prakhand - Patna Sadar, District - Patna (Bihar).

114.

Ganesh Kumar Yadav son of Ramanand Yadav resident of Village/Mohalla - Faurashi, P.O. Mahmuda, Via - Alam Nagar, P.S. - Alam Nagar, Prakhand - Alam Nagar, District - Madhepura (Bihar). 115.

Chaitanya Kumar son of Sri Bishwanath Yadav resident of Village/Mohalla - Faurashi, P.O. Mahmuda, Via - Alam Nagar, P.S. - Alam Nagar, Prakhand - Alam Nagar, District - Madhepura (Bihar). 116.

Maya Shankar Thakur son of Baleshwar Thakur resident of Village/Mohalla - Bishanpur, P.O. - Lodiyagi, Via - Bachawara, P.S. - Bachwara, Prakhand - Bachwara, District - Begusarai (Bihar). 117.

Rajesh Kumar son of Daroga Pandey resident of Village/Mohalla - Umarpur, P.O. - Paiga, Via - Bheldi, P.S. - Bheldi, Prakhand - Amnour, District - Saran (Bihar).

118.

Sunil Rajak son of Paramhansh Rajak resident of Village/Mohalla - Bishanpur, P.O. - Lodiyagi, Via - Bachawara, P.S. - Bachwara, Prakhand - Bachwara, District - Begusarai (Bihar).

119.

Dhananjay Kumar son of Din Dayal Prasad resident of Village/Mohalla - Bakarpur Jagat, P.O. - Bakarpur Jagat, Via - Kalyanpur, P.S. - Kalyanpur, Prakhand - Kalyanpur, District - East Champaran (Bihar). 120.

Dindayal Kumar son of Ramchandra Prasad Gupta resident of Village/Mohalla - Basantpur, P.O. - Birpur, P.S. - Basantpur, Prakhand - Basantpur, District - Supaul (Bihar).

121.

Md. Salahuddin Siddiqi son of Md. Shoyab resident of Village/Mohalla - Masjid Road, Ward No. 08, Birpur, P.O. - Birpur, P.S. - Basantpur, Prakhand - Basantpur, District - Supaul (Bihar). 122.

Ritesh Kumar son of Nageshwar Prasad Gupta resident of Village/Mohalla - Masjid Road, Ward No. 08, Birpur, P.O. - Birpur, P.S. - Basantpur, Prakhand - Basantpur, District - Supaul (Bihar). 123.

Nawal Kishore son of Mangal Rai resident of Village/Mohalla - Shahpur Maricha, P.O. - Shahpur Maricha, Via - Baghi, P.S. - Maniyari, Prakhand - Kurhani, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar). 124.

Chandan Kumar son of Kailash Ray resident of Village/Mohalla - Shahpur Maricha, P.O. - Shahpur Maricha, Via - Baghi, P.S. - Maniyari, Prakhand - Kurhani, District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar). 125.

Manoj Kumar son of Jitendra Paswan resident of Village/Mohalla - Turhi, P.O. - Turki, P.S. - Kurhani, Prakhand - Kurhani (Turki), District - Muzaffarpur (Bihar).

126.

Kanchan Kumari daughter of Mahendra Prasad Sah resident of Village/Mohalla - Forbesganj, P.O. - Forbesganj, P.S. - Forbesganj, Prakhand - Forbesganj, District - Araria (Bihar).

127.

Dharmendra Kumar Sah son of Mahendra Prasad Sah resident of Village/Mohalla - Bhargama, P.O. - Bhargama, P.S. - Bhargama, Prakhand - Bhargama, District - Araria (Bihar).

8/13 128.

Naveen Kumar son of Dinesh Prasad Sah resident of Village/Mohalla - Dhamdaha, P.O. - Dhamdaha, P.S. - Dhamdaha, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea (Bihar).

129.

Lalan Paswan Son of Umesh Paswan resident of village / Mohalla - Amari Kukroun, P.O. Amari Kukroun, P.S. Dhamdaha, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 130.

Md. Gulzar Alam Son of Abdul Sattar resident of village / Mohalla - Amari Kukroun, P.O. Amari Kukroun, P.S. Dhamdaha, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 131.

Bipul Kumar Son of Rajendra Prasad Sah resident of village / Mohallah - Dhamdaha Middle, P.O. Dhamdaha Middle, P.S. Dhamdaha, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 132.

Navin Kumar Son of Vishwanath Mandal resident of village / Mohallah - Nehru Chouk Dhamdaha, P.O. Dhamdaha, P.S. Dhamdaha, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District Purnea ( Bihar ) 133.

Pawan Kumar Choudhary Son of Late Ramanand Choudhary resident of village / Mohalla - Khagadha Mirganj, P.O. Khagadha Mirganj, P.S. Dhamdaha, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 134.

Neeraj Kumar Son of Yogendra Prasad Sah resident of village / Mohalla - Kukuron Amari, P.O. Kukuron Amari, P.S. Dhamdaha, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 135.

Anandi Mahto Son of Late Balram Mahto resident of village / Mohalla - Bardewa, P.O. Dhamdaha, P.S. Dhamdaha, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 136.

Arvind Kumar Sharma Son of Satya Narayan Sharma resident of village / Mohalla - Chandrahi, P.O. Chandrahi, P.S. Dhamdaha, Prakhand Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 137.

Shyam Kishore Singh Son of Bijendra Kumar Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Kasmara, P.O. Nirpur, Via - B. Kothi, P.S. B. Kothi, Prakhand - Dhamdaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 138.

Priyavrat Kumar Son of Late Ramadhin Pandit resident of village / Mohallah - Bhirkhi ( Garib Tola ), Ward No. 26, P.O. Madhepura, P.S. Madhepura, Prakhand - Shankarpur, District - Madhepura ( Bihar ) 139.

Sanjay Kumar Gond Son of Late Jagarnath Prasad Gond resident of village / Mohallah - Panchwati Nagar Raja Bazar Bihiya, P.O. Bihiya, P.S. Bihiya, Prakhand - Bihiya, District - Bhojpur ( Bihar ) 140.

Amarjit Kumar Son of Bijay Jha resident of village / Mohallah - Alauli, P.O. Alauli, P.S. Alauli, Prakhand - Alauli, District - Khagaria ( Bihar ) 141.

Avinav Kumar Bharti Son of Dip Narayan Mandal resident of village / Mohallah - Alauli, P.O. Alauli, P.S. Alauli, Prakhand - Alauli, District - Khagaria ( Bihar ) 142.

Sajjan Kumar Son of Suresh Sah resident of village / Mohalla - Ladahi, P.O. Gouryami, P.S. Alauli, Prakhand Alauli, District - Khagaria 143.

Pyare Sajan Son of Visheshwar Prasad resident of village / Mohalla - Benhar, P.O. Sonmanfi, Via - Koshi College, Khagaria, P.S. Alauli, Prakhand Alauli, District - Khagaria ( Bihar ) 144.

Rajesh Kumar Ranjan Son of Late Chhote Lal Rai resident of village / Mohalla - Lakhminiya, P.O. Lakhminiya, P.S. Balia, Prakhand - Balia, District - Begusarai ( Bihar ) 145.

Deo Prakash Son of Om Prakash Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Sahari, P.O. Sahari, P.S. Barh, Prakhand - Barh, District - Patna ( Bihar )

9/13 146.

Om Prakash Singh Son of Kamta Prasad Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Sahari, P.O. Sahari, P.S. Barh, Prakhand - Barh, District - Patna 147.

Madhumita Kumari daughter of Suresh Prasad Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Majhauli, P.O. Majhauli, P.S. Vaishali, Prakhand - Vaishali, District - Vaishali ( Bihar ) 148.

Rahul Kumar Son of Mahesh Prasad Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Majhauli, P.O. Majhauli, P.S. Vaishali, Prakhand - Vaishali, District - Vaishali ( Bihar ) 149.

Rambabu Kumar Son of Late Bhagwan Sah resident of village / Mohalla - Dumra, P.O. Mathiya, P.S. Lauriya, Prakhand - Lauriya, District - West Champaran ( Bihar ) 150.

Pradeep Kumar Gupta Son of Devi Prasad resident of village / Mohalla - Bankatwa, P.O. Mathiya, P.S. Lauriya, Prakhand - Lauriya, District - West Champaran ( Bihar ) 151.

Sushil Kumar Son of Shashi Bhushan Prasad Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Chakdariya, P.O. Chakdariya, P.S. Vaishali, Prakhand - Vaishali, District - Vishali ( Bihar ) 152.

Kumari Mira Wife of Mukesh Kumar resident of village / Mohalla - Husaina Raghav, P.O. Chakdariya, P.S. Vaishali, Prakhand - Vaishali, District - Vishali ( Bihar ) 153.

Mukesh Kumar Son of Ramji Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Husaina Raghav, P.O. Chakdariya, P.S. Vaishali, Prakhand - Vaishali, District - Vishali ( Bihar ) 154.

Chandan Kumar Ram Son of Ghanshyam Ram resident of village / Mohalla - Alahdadpur, P.O. Alahdadpur, P.S. Vaishali, Prakhand - Vaishali, District - Vishali ( Bihar ) 155.

Santosh Kumar Singh Son of Late Sukhnandan Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Lakhanpar, P.O. Lakhanpar, P.S. Punpun, Prakhand - Punpun, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 156.

Nitesh Kumar Singh Son of Jaleshwar Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Khanpur, P.O. Khanpur, P.S. Derni, Prakhand - Dariyapur, District - Saran ( Bihar ) 157.

Birendra Kumar Son of Kuleshwar Yadav resident of village / Mohallah - Mahabigha, P.O. Utalibara, P.S. Tankuppa, Prakhand - Tankuppa, District - Gaya ( Bihar ) 158.

Sweta Kumari daughter of Harihar Prasad resident of village - Mohalla - Naudiha, P.O. Naudiha Jhurang, P.S. Fatehpur, Prakhand - Fatehpur, District - Gaya ( Bihar ) 159.

Asha Kumari daughter of Jagdish Prasad resident of village / Mohalla - Naudiha, P.O. Naudiha Jhurang, P.S. Fatehpur, Prakhand - Fatehpur, District - Gaya ( Bihar ) 160.

Pankaj Kumar Bharti Son of Bhola Prasad Mehta resident of village / Mohallah - Sitapur Ward No. 12, P.O. Sitapur, Via - Balua Bazar, P.S. Basantpur, Prakhand - Sanantpur, District - Supaul ( Bihar ) 161.

Ajay Kumar Singh Son of Ram Narayan Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Rampur, P.O. Kudra, P.S. Kudra, Prakhand - Kudra, District - Kaimur ( Bihar ) 162.

Rakesh Raushan Son of Late Sadan Ram resident of village / Mohalla - Chakiya, P.O. Kudra, P.S. Kudra, Prakhand - Kudra, District - Kaimur

10/13 163.

Rajesh Kumar Son of Ram Darash Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Pipra, P.O. Pipra, P.S. Kudra, Prakhand - Kudra, District - Kaimur ( Bihar ) 164.

Anuranjan Kr. Pandey Son of Naval Kishore Pandey resident of village / Mohalla - Dhamaul, P.O. Dhamaul, P.S. Pakribarawa, Prakhand - Pakribarawa, District Nawada ( Bihar ) 165.

Anil Kumar Yadav Son of Anandi Yadav resident of village / Mohalla - Dhamaul, P.O. Dhamaul, P.S. Pakribarawa, Prakhand - Pakribarawa, District Nawada ( Bihar ) 166.

Vikash Rath Son of Bangali Ram resident of village / Mohalla - Garra, P.O. Nuaon, P.S. Nuaon, Prakhande - Nuaon, District - Kaimur 167.

Suman Kumar Son of Vishnudeo Yadav resident of village / Mohalla - Parmanpur, P.O. Bhatrandha, P.S. Ghailarh, Prakhand - Ghailarh, District - Madhepura ( Bihar ) 168.

Mukesh Kumar Son of Deoraj Prasad Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Aurlaha, P.O. Aurlaha, P.S. Barhara Kothi, Prakhand - Orlaha, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 169.

Amit Kumar Son of Parmanand Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Parmanpur, P.O. Bhatrandha, P.S. Ghailarh, Prakhand - B. Kothi ( Purnea ), District - Madhepura ( Bihar ) 170.

Neel Kusum Chakravarty Son of Shiv Narayan Mandal resident of village / Mohalla - Durgapur Milik Tola, P.O. Durgapur, P.S. Bhawanipur ( Rajdham ), Prakhand - Bhawanipur, District Purnea ( Bihar ) 171.

Shailendra Kumar Son of Shriram Azad resident of village / Mohallah - Salimpur, P.O. Salimpur, P.S. Salimpur, Prakhand - Bakhtiyarpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 172.

Santosh Kumar Sah Son of Bhola Prasad Sah resident of village / Mohallah - Sirni Bazar Kasba Ward No. 9, P.O. Kasba, P.S. Kasba, Prakhand Kasba, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 173.

Sanjeev Kumar Mirdha Son of Nityanand Mirdha resident of village / Mohallah - Sirni Bazar Kasba Ward No. 13, P.O. Kasba, P.S. Kasba, Prakhand Kasba, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 174.

Ram Kumar Sah Son of Bhola Prasad Sah resident of village / Mohallah - Sirni Bazar Kasba Ward No. 9, P.O. Kasba, P.S. Kasba, Prakhand Kasba, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 175.

Sudhanshu Kumar Son of Anil Kumar Yadav resident of village / Mohallah - Bhatsara, P.O. Bhatsara, P.S. B. Kothi, Prakhand - B. Kothi, District - Purnea ( Bihar ) 176.

Raj Mohan Son of Krishna Prasad Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Tulsia, P.O. Tulsia, P.S. Dighal Bank, Prakhand - Dighal Bank, District Kishanganj ( Bihar ) 177.

Aditya Prasad Gupta Son of Shyam Narayan Prasad resident of village / Mohallah - Fazalganj, P.O. Sasaram, P.S. Sasaram, Prakhand - Sasaram, District - Rohtas ( Bihar ) 178.

Amit Kumar Son of Shiv Shankar Prasad resident of village / Mohallah - Fazalganj, P.O. Sasaram, P.S. Sasaram, Prakhand - Sasaram, District - Rohtas ( Bihar ) 179.

Akhlesh Kumar Son of Pasuram Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Fazalganj, P.O. Sasaram, P.S. Sasaram, Prakhand - Sasaram, District - Rohtas ( Bihar )

11/13 180.

Anita Kumari Son of Pasuram Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Fazalganj, P.O. Sasaram, P.S. Sasaram, Prakhand - Sasaram, District - Rohtas 181.

Rakesh Kumar Son of Pasuram Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Fazalganj, P.O. Sasaram, P.S. Sasaram, Prakhand - Sasaram, District - Rohtas 182.

Rama Chaudhary Son of Sukar Chaudhary resident of village / Mohalla - Dumrawa, P.O. Dumrawa, P.S. Pakribarawa, Prakhand - Pakribarawa, District - Nawada ( Bihar ) 183.

Ajay Kumar Son of Chandeshwar Prasad Verma resident of village / Mohallah - Pakribarawa, P.O. Pakribarawa, P.S. Pakribarawa, Prakhand - Pakribarawa, District - Nawada ( Bihar ) 184.

Sanjeev Kumar Son of Surendra Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Pakribarawa, P.O. Pakribarawa, P.S. Pakribarawa, Prakhand - Pakribarawa, District - Nawada ( Bihar ) 185.

Rajeev Ranjan Bharti Son of Late Ram Bihari Ram resident of village / Mohallah - Semri, P.O. Semri, P.S. Dawath, Prakhand - Dawat, District - Rohtas ( Bihar ) 186.

Deepak Kumar Son of Sachidanand Sharma resident of village / Mohallah - Bargaon, P.O. Nalanda, P.S. Silao, Prakhand - Silao, District - Nalanda ( Bihar ) 187.

Akhilesh Kumar Son of Siddheshwar Pandit resident of village / Mohallah - Silao, P.O. Silao, P.S. Silao, Prakhand - Silao, District - Nalanda 188.

Kumar Sumit Ranjan Son of Tapeshwar Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Silao, P.O. Silao, P.S. Silao, Prakhand - Silao, District - Nalanda 189.

Sheopujan Kumar Son of Kameshwar Prasad resident of village / Mohallah - Silao, P.O. Silao, P.S. Silao, Prakhand - Silao, District - Nalanda 190.

Ranjit Ranjan Son of Rameshwar Prasad resident of village / Mohallah - Daman Khandha, P.O. Nalanda, P.S. Nalanda, Prakhand - Silao, District - Nalanda ( Bihar ) 191.

Chandan Kumar Sharma Son of Bijay Sharma resident of village / Mohallah - Silao, P.O. Silao, P.S. Silao, Prakhand - Silao, District - Nalanda 192.

Om Prakash Singh Son of Sumeshwar Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Bharua, P.O. Dinara, P.S. Dinara, Prakhand - Dinara, District - Rohtas ( Bihar ) 193.

Mukesh Kumar Singh Son of Ramayan Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Bariyarpur, P.O. Akoraha, P.S. Dinara, Prakhand - Dinara, District - Rohtas ( Bihar ) 194.

Md. Aasik Raja Son of Md. Jibrail Ansari resident of village / Mohalla - Dinara, P.O. Dinara, P.S. Dinara, Prakhand - Dinara, District - Rohtas ( Bihar ) 195.

Suresh Kumar Singh Son of Bishwanath Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Bararhi ( S.K. ), P.O. Bararhi ( S.K. ), P.S. Dinara, Prakhand - Dinara, District Rohtas ( Bihar ) 196.

Jit Narayan Gupta Son of Kundan Prasad resident of village / Mohallah - Natwar, P.O. Natwar, P.S. Dinara, Prakhand - Dinara, District - Rohtas ( Bihar )

12/13 197.

Bipin Kumar Singh Son of Sri Daroga Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Jigna, P.O. Jigna, P.S. Dinara, Prakhand - Dinara, District - Rohtas ( Bihar ) 198.

Jitendra Kumar Mehta Son of Upendra Mehta resident of village / Mohallah - Khandpar nearby Mahato Kuan, P.O. Sheikhpura, P.S. Sheikhpura, Prakhand - Sheikhpura, District - Sheikhpura ( Bihar ) 199.

Dhananjay Kumar Son of Late Harish Chandra Prasad resident of village / Mohalla - Khandpar ( Bhitthapar ), P.O. Sheikhpura, P.S. Sheikhpura, Prakhand - Sheikhpura, District - Sheikhpura ( Bihar ) 200.

Santosh Kumar Suman Son of Ganesh Poddar resident of village / Mohallah - Forsahi Ward No. 12, P.O. Mahmuda, P.S. Alamnagar, Prakhand - Alamnagar, District - Madhepura ( Bihar ) 201.

Dilip Sharma Son of Paryag Sharma resident of village / Mohallah - Forsahi, P.O. Mahmuda, P.S. Alamnagar, Prakhand - Alamnagar, District - Madhepura ( Bihar ) 202.

Sanjeet Kumar Son of Sri Sahja Nand Prasad resident of village / Mohalla - Dariyapur Tola, P.O. Dariyapur, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 203.

Arvind Kumar Son of Ramayan Yadav resident of village / Mohallah - Bhawani Chak, P.O. Amarpura, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 204.

Santosh Kumar Son of Babulal Paswan resident of village / Mohallah - Bickan Tola, P.O. Bela Thariya, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 205.

Sanjeet Kumar Son of Ajay Kumar Verma resident of village / Mohallah - Goai Karanja, P.O. Karanja, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 206.

Jitendra Kumar Son of Late Ramayan Singh resident of village / Mohalla - Bakuyan, P.O. Poawan, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 207.

Santosh Abhishek Son of Sunil Chandra Verma resident of village / Mohallah - Bari Tangraila, P.O. Sahar Rampur, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 208.

Manoj Kumar Son of Ghamandi Ray resident of village / Mohallah - Malahi Khanda, P.O. Bela Tarari Nisarpura, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 209.

Krishna Kumar Kamal Son of Raghuvir Prasad Verma resident of village / Mohallah - Goai Karanja, P.O. Karanja, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 210.

Shankar Kumar Singh Son of Sri Saryu Prasad resident of village / Mohallah - Gonwan, P.O. Sadisopur, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 211.

Pankaj Kumar Niramal Son of Narendrawar Prasad Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Akbarpur, P.O. Shorampur, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 212.

Sanjeev Kumar Son of Sri Lalan Singh resident of village / Mohallah - Chesi, P.O. Chesi, P.S. P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 213.

Sidhnath Kumar Son of Baldev Paswan resident of village / Mohallah - Sahar Rampur, P.O. Sahar Rampur, P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar )

13/13 214.

Ravi Kant Kumar Son of Ram Chandra Yadav resident of village / Mohallah - Bichkan Tola, P.O. Bela Tarhari, P P.S. Naubatpur, Prakhand - Naubatpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) 215.

Ved Prakash Son of Bachhu Sharma resident of village / Mohallah - Salimpur, P.O. Salimpur, P.S. Salimpur, Prakhand - Bakhtiyarpur, District - Patna ( Bihar ) ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance :

For the Appellant/s :

Mr.Sushant Praveer, Advocate For the Respondent/s :

Mr.

====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE and HONOURABLE JUSTICE SMT. ANJANA MISHRA ORAL JUDGMENT (Per: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE) Date : 03-01-2019 Shri Sushant Pravir, learned counsel for the appellant, informs the Court that the issue raised in this appeal has already been decided by the co-ordinate Bench in L.P.A. No.535 of 2017, decided on 17.4.2018.

This appeal also stands dismissed on similar terms. (Amreshwar Pratap Sahi, CJ) ( Anjana Mishra, J) K.C.Jha/- AFR/NAFR NAFR CAV DATE N/A Uploading Date 05.01.2019 Transmission Date N/A