Ram Balak Singh And ORS v. Trisul Singh And ORS
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.6866 of 2013 ======================================================
1. RAM BALAK SINGH SON OF LATE RAM NADAN SINGH RESIDENT OF
2. GANGA SAGAR SINGH SON OF LATE MAHENDRA SINGH RESIDENT OF
3. SITA RAM SINGH SON OF LATE MAHENDRA SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
4. NAND KISHORE SINGH SON OF LATE MAHENDRA SINGH RESIDENT OF
5. RAJESH KUMAR SINGH SON OF LATE MAHENDRA SINGH RESIDENT OF
6. RAKESH KUMAR SINGH SON OF LATE MAHENDRA SINGH RESIDENT OF
7. LEELA DEVI WIFE OF LATE NAWAL SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
8. CHANDAN SINGH MINOR SON OF LATE NAWAL SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS MOTHER LEELA DEVI RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
9. KUNTI DEVI WIFE OF NAWAL KISHORE RAI RESIDENT OF VILLAGE NATHHU DWAR P.S. KHANPUR DISTRICT SAMASTIPUR
10. PARVATI DEVI WIFE OF UMA SHANKAR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BIHAT TOLA JAGIR P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
11. LEELAVATI DEVI W/O RAMANAND SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SIHMA P.S. MATIHANI DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
12. CHITRANJAN DEVI W/O ASHOK KUMAR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE BIHAT TOLA IBRAHIMPUR P.S. BARAUNI DISTRICT BEGUSARAI .... .... PETITIONER/S
VERSUS
1. TRISUL SINGH S/O LATE RAMAUTAR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
2. AJAY KUMAR SINGH SON OF SRI TRISUL SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
3. ASHOK KUMAR SINGH SON OF SRI TRISUL SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
4. RANJIT KUMAR SINGH SON OF SRI TRISUL SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
5. MOHAR SINGH MINOR SON OF TRISUL SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS FATHER RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
6. BALVEER SINGH MINOR SON OF RANJIT KUMAR SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS FATHER RANJIT KUMAR SINGH RESIDENT OF
7. RAM SAGAR SINGH S/O RADHE SINGH @ RADHA SINGH RESIDENT OF
8. SACHIN SAURABH @ DIPAK MINOR SON OF SRI RAM SAGAR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
9. ABHINAV GAURAV @ KANHAIYA MINOR SON OF SRI RAM SAGAR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
10. ANUPAM BAIBHAV @ BALRAM MINOR SON OF SRI RAM SAGAR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
11. MOST. GIRIJA DEVI @ DROPADI DEVI WIFE OF LATE DEV NARSIN SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
12. PUJARI SINGH S/O AMBIKA SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S.
13. SHIVA LOCHAN SINGH S/O LATE DEV NARAIN SINGH RESIDENT OF
14. SHASHI KUMAR SINGH S/O SHIVA LOCHAN SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
15. SHAMI KUMAR SINGH MINOR SON OF SHIVA LOCHAN SINGH UNDER THE
16. RISHI KUMAR SINGH MINOR SON OF SHIVA LOCHAN SINGH UNDER THE
17. RABINDRA KUMAR SINGH SON OF LATE BASHISTH SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS MOTHER 17 (A) SURENDRA KUMAR SINGH, SON OF LATE BASHISTH SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS MOTHER, 17 (B) JITENDRA KUMAR SINGH, SON OF LATE BASHISTH KUMAR SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS MOTHER. RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S.
18. KHANUA DEVI WIFE OF BASHISHTA SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
19. BISHUNDEO SINGH S/O GENDALAL SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
20. PRASIDH SINGH S/O GENDALAL SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI
21. JAI NARAIN SINGH S/O LATE GAJO SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
22. BALMIKI SINGH S/O LATE MADAN SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
23. NAVIN KUMAR SINGH SON OF LATE MADAN SINGH RESIDENT OF
24. BACHCHA SINGH MINOR SON OF JAI NARAIN SINGH UNDER THE
25. BIPIN SINGH S/O LATE SATTO SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S.
26. NIRANJAN NARAIN SINGH MINOR S/O BIPIN SINGH UNDER THE
27. RAJ KISHORE SINGH SON OF BISHUNDEO SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
28. SIYA RAM SINGH SON OF BISHUNDEO SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
29. RAJ NEESH KUMAR SINGH MINOR SON OF RAJ KISHOR SINGH UNDER THE
30. AVNEESH KUMAR SINGH MINOR SON OF RAJ KISHOR SINGH UNDER THE
31. SIKANDAR SINGH MINOR SON OF SIYARAM SINGH UNDER THE
32. NAND KISHORE SINGH SON OF BISHUNDEO SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
33. BRAJ KISHORE SINGH SON OF BISHUNDEO SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
34. RAJO SINGH SON OF BISHUNDEO SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI
35. RAM KISHORE SINGH MINOR SON OF NAND KISHORE SINGH UNDER THE 36.
CHANDAN SINGH MINOR SON OF RAJO SINGH UNDER THE
37. MOST. SAVITRI DEVI @ PAKO DEVI WIFE OF LATE RAM BILAS SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
38. RAJIV SINGH S/O LATE RAM BILAS SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
39. SANJEEV SINGH MINOR SON OF LATE RAM BILAS SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS MOTHER SAVITRI DEVI @ PAKO DEVI RESIDENT OF
40. SACHIDA NAND SINGH MINOR SON OF LATE RAM BILAS SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS MOTHER SAVITRI DEVI @ PAKO DEVI RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
41. RAJA SINGH MINOR SON OF LATE RAM BILAS SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS MOTHER SAVITRI DEVI @ PAKO DEVI RESIDENT OF
42. SUSHIL KUMAR SINGH SON OF LATE RAM PRASH SINGH RESIDENT OF
43. JAI KISHORE SINGH SON OF LATE RAM PRASH SINGH RESIDENT OF
44. KAMAL DEO SINGH MINOR SON OF SUSHIL KUMAR SINGH UNDER THE
45. BIMAL DEO SINGH MINOR SON OF SUSHIL KUMAR SINGH UNDER THE
46. SMT. MASA DEVI W/O SHAMBHU SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE AND P.S. MATIHANI DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
47. RAGHUVAR SHARAN SINGH S/O LATE DUND BAHADUR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
48. LAL BAHADUR SINGH S/O LATE DUND BAHADUR SINGH RESIDENT OF
49. VINAY KUMAR SINGH SON OF RAGHVAR SHARAN SINGH RESIDENT OF
50. VIJAY KUMAR SINGH SON OF RAGHVAR SHARAN SINGH RESIDENT OF
51. MANOJ KUMAR SINGH SON OF RAGHVAR SHARAN SINGH RESIDENT OF
52. AJIT KUMAR SINGH MINOR SON OF VIJAY KR. SINGH UNDER THE
53. RUBAL MINOR SON OF SRI VIJOY KR. SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS FATHER RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
54. TUBUL MINOR SON OF SRI VIJOY KR. SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS FATHER RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
55. PRINCE KUMAR MINOR SON OF SRI VIJOY KR. SINGH UNDER THE
56. GAUTAM SINGH MINOR SON OF MANOJ KR. SINGH UNDER THE
57. RAM NARAIN SINGH S/O LATE BANARSI SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
58. MOST. ANUCHIT KUMARI W/O LATE MATHURA SINGH RESIDENT OF
59. RAJU PRASAD SINGH SON OF RAM NARAIN SINGH UNDER THE
60. SANDIP KUMAR SINGH SON OF RAM NARAIN SINGH UNDER THE
61. GIRIJA DEVI W/O RAM CHARITRA SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI
62. GANGA SINGH S/O LATE KARI SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI
63. RAM KALYAN SINGH S/O LATE GAGADHAR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
64. GORELAL SINGH S/O LATE RAM CHARITRA SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
65. KANHAIYA SINGH MINOR SON OF KALAYAN SINGH UNDER THE
66. KRISHNA SINGH MINOR SON OF GORELAL SINGH UNDER THE
67. MOST. DUAVATI DEVI WIFE OF SONELAL SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
68. JOG MAYA DEVI W/O PRASIDH NARAIN SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SAFAPUR P.S. BEGUSARAI (GRAMIN) DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
69. MOST. KRISHNA DEVI W/O LATE CHANDRA BHUSHAN SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
70. PANDAVA DEVI W/O RAM NARAIN PANDEY RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
71. RAM PADARATH SINGH S/O KAILU SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
72. DIGVIJAY SINGH MINOR SON OF SRI RAM PADARATH SINGH UNDER THE
73. MAN MOHAN SINGH MINOR SON OF SRI RAM PADARATH SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS FATHER RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S.
74. BHAGIRATH SINGH SON OF LATE DHANESHWAR SINGH RESIDENT OF
75. KUSHAL KISHORE SINGH SON OF LATE DHANESHWAR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S. GARHPURA DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
76. KAPILDEO SINGH SON OF LATE BILAT SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
77. SAJJAN SINGH SON OF BISHUNI SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI
78. DEVENDRA SINGH SON OF BISHUNI SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
79. LALU SINGH MINOR SON OF SRI SAJJAN SINGH UNDER THE
80. DHIRAJ SINGH MINOR SON OF SRI BHAGIRATH SINGH RESIDENT OF
81. AMIT KUMAR SINGH MINOR SON OF SRI BHAGIRATH SINGH RESIDENT OF
82. MAYA DEVI W/O LATE CHANDRA SHEKHAR SINGH RESIDENT OF
83. MANOJ SINGH S/O LATE CHANDRA SHEKHAR SINGH RESIDENT OF
84. MITHU KUMAR SINGH MINOR SON OF LATE CHANDRA SHEKHAR SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS MOTHER MAYA DEVI RESIDENT OF
85. MITHUN KUMAR SINGH MINOR SON OF LATE CHANDRA SHEKHAR SINGH UNDER THE GUARDIANSHIP OF HIS MOTHER MAYA DEVI RESIDENT OF
86. MITHILESH KUMAR S/O RAM SAGAR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
87. URMILA DEVI WIFE OF TRISULDHARI SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
88. BRAJENDRA SINGH SON OF KUSHESHWAR SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
89. SUMITRA DEVI WIFE OF DHODHAI TANTI RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
90. RAJENDRA SINGH S/O KAPILDEO SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI
91. BIPIN SINGH S/O PHULENA SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S.
92. SAHEL YADAV S/O MUSAHRU YADAV RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI
93. BISHUNDEO YADAV S/O RAMRUP YADAV RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
94. RAM NANDAN YADAV S/O RAM BAHADUR YADAV RESIDENT OF
95. RAM SAGAR YADAV S/O RAM BAHADUR YADAV RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
96. ROHIN YADAV S/O BRIHASPI YADAV RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI
97. SITARAM YADAV S/O BIDAN YADAV RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KANAUSI P.S.
98. SIOTHESHWAR YADAV S/O MISHRI YADAV RESIDENT OF VILLAGE
99. JAGDISH SINGH S/O LATE SHIVA BALAK SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE CHAK, P.S. MATIHANI DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
100. JANAK KUMARI DEVI WIFE OF ANIRUDH SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE CHAK, P.S. MATIHANI DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
101. INDRA BHUSHAN SINGH S/O ANIRUDH SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE CHAK, P.S. MATIHANI DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
102. SHASHI BHUSHAN SINGH S/O ANIRUDH SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE CHAK, P.S. MATIHANI DISTRICT BEGUSARAI
103. PHULO SINGH S/O MOUJE LAL SINGH RESIDENT OF VILLAGE DUNHI P.S. .... .... RESPONDENT/S ====================================================== Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Ram Sumiran Singh-Advocate For the Respondent/s : Mr.
====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ADITYA KUMAR TRIVEDI ORAL ORDER 29-03-2016 Heard learned counsel for the petitioners.
Gone through the order impugned.
It has been contended on behalf of learned counsel for the petitioners that defendant third party happens to be party proforma on account thereof, the order sheet could not have been admitted as an exhibit on their behalf in the background of the fact that same was filed on behalf of plaintiffs and further, regarding which (Collectorate partition), there happens to be admission at the end of petitioners/ defendant first set under Para-8 of the written statement.
Document was filed on behalf of plaintiffs and, being admitted by the adversary can be marked as an exhibit. Whether the status of defendant third party be a party proforma is irrelevant for the aforesaid purpose.
Petition lacks merit and is accordingly, rejected. (Aditya Kumar Trivedi, J) Vikash/- U