Birendra Kumar And ORS v. Ratnesh Mishra And ORS

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA

Civil Review No.3 of 2018 In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.17446 of 2015 ======================================================

1. Birendra Kumar, Son of Ganga Rai, resident of Village- Mahua Singh Rai, P.O. Mahua, P.S.- Mahua, District- Vaishali (Bihar).

2. Kamal Nath Yadav, Son of Siya Lal Yadav, resident of VillageCharak Para, P.O. Runki, P.S.- Rauta, District- Purnea (Bihar).

3. Md. Zeyauddin, Son of Md. Mokhtar Ahmad, Resident of Village- Mausoorpur, P.O.- Mausoorpur, District- Vaishali (Bihar).

4. Md. Salahuddin, Son of Md. Mokhtar Ahmad, Resident of Village- Mausoorpur, P.O.- Mausoorpur, District- Vaishali (Bihar).

5. Md. Tajuddin, Son of Md. Wakil, resident of VillageMasoorpur, P.O.- Mausoorpur, District- Vaishali (Bihar).

6. Abdur Rahman, Son of Samiruddin, Resident of Village- Kolha, P.O. - Runki, P.S.- Routa, District- Purnea (Bihar).

7. Md. Athar Parwez, Son of Md. Ishaque, Resident of VillageLine Bazar, New Shiv Mandir, P.O. Line Bazaar, P.S. Khazanahi Haat, District- Purnea (Bihar).

8. Dipa Kumari, Daughter of Jag Narayan Prasad Gupta, Resident of Village- Suryaganj, P.O.- Gamharia, P.S. Gamharia, DistrictMadhepura (Bihar).

9. Gita Kumari, Daughter of Deep Narayan Prasad Gupta, Resident of Village- Rajhat (Banmankhi), P.O. Banmankhi, P.S. Banmankhi, District- Purnea (Bihar).

10. Mahmood Alam, Son of Md. Suleman Ahmad, Resident of Village- Gurhi, P.O. Gurhi, P.S.- Kasba, District- Purnea (Bihar). 11.Md. Parwez Alam, Son of Abdur Razzaque, Resident of Village- Islam Nagar, P.O. K. Haat, P.S. SK Haat, DistrictPurnea (Bihar).

12. Abdul Wadood, Son of Md. Shariful Hassan, Resident of Village- Dimia, P.O. Gaira, P.S. Jalalgarh, District- Purnea (Bihar)

13. Md Isha Ansari, Son of Md. Asghar Ali, Resident of VillageBalwa Usri Tola, P.O. Sikkat, P.S. Barari, District- Katihar (Bihar).

14. Shivshankar Rai, Son of Late Ram Das Rai, Resident of Village- Maricha, P.O. Sarai, P.S. Sarai, District- Vaishali (Bihar).

15. Ratnesh Kumar, Son of Hakdeo Prasad Verma, Resident of Village- Majholi, Mohammadpur, Bujurg, P.O. Sarai, P.S. Sarai, District- Vaishali (Bihar).

16. Ganesh Prasad, Son of Bishundeo Rai, resident of VillageMajholi, Mohammadpur, Bujurg, P.O. Sarai, P.S. Sarai, DistrictVaishali (Bihar).

17. Nathuni Prasad Yadav, Son of U.P. Yadav, resident of VillageMaricha Garh, P.O. Sarai, P.S. Sarai, District- Vaishali (Bihar).

18. Amrendra Kumar, Son of Late Arjun Singh, Resident of Village- Anjani, P.O. Sarai, P.S. Sarai, District- Vaishali (Bihar).

2/4

19. Harinath Prasad Yadav, Son of Late Ram Shobhit Rai, Resident of Village- Bhagwatpur, Patedha, P.O. Sarai, P.S. Sarai, DistrictVaishali (Bihar).

20. Chandeshwar Ray, Son of Ramashish Ray, resident of VillageChakpitambar, P.O.- Mansoorpur, P.S.- Vaishali, DistrictVaishali (Bihar). ... ... Petitioner/s

Versus

1. Ratnesh Mishra Son of Kishori Mishra Resident of At-Shahdullhpur, Police Station-Lalganj, District-Vaishali.

2. Bangeswar Ojha, Son of Ramchandra Ojha, Resident of At-Damodar Chapra, P.S.-Saraiya, District-Muzaffarpur.

3. Rajeev Kumar, Son of Sri Ram Thakur, Resident of At-Pojhiyan, P.S.-Lalganj, District-Vaishali.

4. Rajani Kumari, Daughter of Bhuwneshwar Jha, Resident of Narayan City Apartment, E-Block, 304, Brahmsthan, P.S.-Shastry nagar, District-Patna-14.

5. Vijendra Kumar Jaiswal, Son of Ganga Prasad Jaiswal Resident of At-Shanti Nagar, Chunapur road, P.O.-Madhubani Bazar, P.S. K.-Hat, District-Purnea.

6. Rakesh Kumar, Son of Ramdhani Ray, Resident of At-Bhagwanpur Ratti, P.O.-Baluka Ram P.S.-Vaishali, District-Vaishali.

7. Dheraj Kumar, Son of Sushil Kumar Sinha, Resident of At-Nandlalpur, P.O. Nadlapur, P.S.-Vaishali, District-Vaishali.

8. Jitendra Kumar Sah, Son of Ram Ayodhya Prasad Sah, Resident of At-Simra, P.O.-Mansurpur, P.S.-Vaishali, District-Vaishali.

9. Shiv Shanker Kumar, Son of Sri Dewari Ram, Resident of At-Bhagwanpur Ratti, P.S.-Vaishali, District-Vaishali.

10. Rajendra Kumar, Son of Haricharan Ram, Resident of At-Daudnagar, P.S.- Vaishali, District-Vaishali.

11. Rajeev Kumar, Son of Jagarnath Prasad @ Jagranath Sah, Resident of AtMansoorpur, P.S.-Vaishali, District-Vaishali,.

12. Shahbhu Kumar, Son of Parshuram Sah, Resident of At-Daudnagar, P.S.- Vaishali, District-Vaishali.

13. Md. Ainul Haque, Son of Md. Usman, Resident of At-Makrandpur, P.S.-Gaya Ghat, District-Muzaffarpur.

14. Pankaj Kumar, Son of Rajendra Sah, Resident of At-Daudnagar, P.S.-Vaishali, District-Vaishali.

15. Madhuri Kumar, Daughter of Yogendra Bhagat, Resident of At-Gosai Chhapara, P.S.-Saraiyan, District-Muzaffarpur.

16. Bhuneshwar Prasad Sah, Son of Bhagwanji Sah Resident of At-Daudnagar, P.S.-Vaishali, District-Vaishali.

17. Sanjeev Kumar, Son of Radha Kant Sinah, Resident of Village + P.O.- Tarajiwar, P.S.-Hathauri, District-Muzaffarpur.

18. Rajnish Kumar, Son of Mukunand Narayan Thakur, Resident of Village-Rajia, P.S.-Benipatti, District-Madhubani.

19. Sangita Rani Daughter of Mukund Narayan Thakur, Wife of Anil Kumar, Resident of Village + P.O.-Tarajiwar, P.S.-Hathauri, District-Muzaffarpur.

20. Rubbi Kumari Daughter of Shiv Shankar Sharma, Wife of Navin kumar Resident of Village-Pakri P.S.-Sitamarhi, District-Sitamarhi.

21. Kiran Kumari, Daughter of Radha Kant Sinha, Wife of Dhananjay Kumar, Resiednt of Village+P.O.- Tarajiwar, P.S.- Hathauri, District- Muzaffarpur.

3/4

22. Prakash Kumar, Son of Gyan Chandra Sahni, Resident of Village- Pahshara, P.S.- Pahshara, Babhan Gayw, District- Purnea.

23. Vijay, Son of Gyan Chandra Sahni, Resident of Village- Pahshara, P.S.- Pahshara, Dabtian Gayw, District- Purnea.

24. Latika Kumari, Daughter of Surindar Prasad Yadav, Resident of VillageNipariya, P.S.- B. Kothi, District- Purnea.

25. Indu Kumari, Daughter of Sri Naryani Yadav, Resident of Village- Amari, P.S.- Dhamdaha, District- Purnea.

26. Anil Kumar, Son of Arbind Prasad Sah, Resident of Village- Choudhary Tola, P.O.- Kahalgaon, P.S.- Kahalgaon, District- Bhagalpur.

27. Md. Nesar Alam, Son of Md. Idris, Resident of at+P.O.- Chakalhadad, P.S. +District- Vaishali.

28. Harendra Prasad Sah, Son of Domen Sah, Resident of At+P.O.- Daudnagar, P.S.+District- Vaishali.

29. Lakshmi Narayan Singh, S/o Satya Narayan Singh, Resident of Village- Kash Pata Dha, P.O.- Sarai, District- Vaishali.

30. Sanjay Kumar, Son of Satyanarayan Singh, Resident of Village- Kash Pata Dha, P.O.- Sarai, District- Vaishali.

31. Ram Nath Sharma, Son of Jamira Sharma, Resident of Village+P.O.- Karthan, P.S.- Lalganj, District- Vaishali.

32. Ravi Shankar Kumar Ravi, Son of Baswan Singh, Resident of VillageKartahan, P.O.- Kartahan, P.S.- Lalganj, District- Vaishali.

33. Radhika Kumari, Daughter of Bateshwar Ray, Resident of Village- Afjalpur Dhobghatti, P.S.- Hajipur Sadar, District- Vaishali.

34. Sanjay Kumar Sah, Son of Bishwanath Sah, Resident of VillageShambhupur, P.O.- Sarai, District- Vaishali.

35. Suresh Kumar, Son of Suraj Paswan, Resident of Village+P.O.- Pratap Tand, P.S.- Bhagwanpur, District- Vaishali.

36. Vishanu Prakash Prabhakar, Son of Rama Sankar Prasad, Resident of VillageBharamsthan, P.S.- Hilsa, District- Nalanda.

37. The State of Bihar through Principal Secretary, Department of Education, Government of Bihar, Vikas Bhawan, Patna.

38. The Director, Parimary Education, Government of Bihar, Vikas Bhawan, Patna.

39. The Bihar School Examination Board through its Secretary, Patna. ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance :

For the Petitioner/s :

Mr. Subodh Kumar Barnwal For the Respondent/s :

Mr. LALIT KISHORE ( AG ) ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE and HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR UPADHYAY ORAL JUDGMENT (Per: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE) Date : 07-03-2018 Office objection stands ignored.

4/4 We have gone through the records and we find that this application has been filed for review of the order passed on 1.11.2017 in C.W.J.C. No.17446 of 2015.

Taking note of the ground raised in the review application and keeping in view the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Sasi (Dead) Through Legal Representatives Vs. Aravindakshan Nair And Ors., (2017) 4 SCC 692, we find no error apparent on the face of the record on the basis of which the review of the order is permissible. The application is dismissed.

(Rajendra Menon, CJ) ( Anil Kumar Upadhyay, J) K.C.Jha/- AFR/NAFR NAFR CAV DATE N/A Uploading Date 12.03.2018 Transmission Date