Awadhesh Kumar And ORS v. The State Of Bihar And ORS
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.22064 of 2013 ======================================================
1. Awadhesh Kumar Son Of Sri Mahendra Choudhary Resident Of Village, Po Saha Dullahpur Ps Ganga Bridge, Hajpur Vaishali Presently Working As Assistnat Teacher Upgraded Girls Middle School, Chandpura Bidupur Block (Vaishali)
2. Prabhat Kumar Choudhary Son Of Late Ram Prasad Choudhary Resident Of Bagdulhan (Ram Prasad Chowk), Hajipur (Vashali) Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School, Basra Rajapakar Block (Vaishali)
3. Vidya Sagar Rai, Son Of Sri Ram Pravesh Rai Resident Of Village Chajainan Po Chak Sikandar, Ps Bidupur Distt Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School, Chak Sikandarpur Bdupur Block (Vaishali)
4. Sanjay Kumar Vdyarthi Son Of Sri Laldeo Paswan Resident Of Vill Pindauta Khurd Po & Ps Tisiaut, Distt Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School Andharwara, Hajipur (East) Block (Vaishali)
5. Anil Kumar Singh Son Of Sri Ramdayal Singh Resident Of Village Sultanpur Po And Ps Industrial Area Hajipur Vaishali, Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Girls Middle School, Chandpura, Bidupur Block Vaishali
6. Virendra Prasad Singh Keshari Son Of Munnilal Singh Resident Of Villaged Po And Ps Desari Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Chakjamal Sahadei Bujurg Vaishali
7. Deen Dayal Paswan Son Of Late Sant Lal Paswan Resident Of Village Dayalpur Ps Rajapakar Distt Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School, Bathadasi Rajapakar Block Vaishali
8. Ashutosh Kumar Son Of Yadunandan Ram Resident Of Village Chaksaid Po And Ps Rajapakar Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School Dharmpur Raja Pakar Block Vaishali
9. Akabar Ali Son Of Md Ajij Mian Resident Of Village Daudnagar Po Chakgadho Daudnagar, Distt Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School, Lakhani Bidupur Block Vaishali;
10. Harimohan Kumar Son Of Sri Bindeshwar Rai Resident Of Village Rohua Ps Jandaha Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School, Bhojpatti Rajapakar 11.Ashok Kumar Son Of Sheo Prasad Singh Resident Of Village Po And Ps Jandaha Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Loma Tada Jandaha Block Vaishali
12. Ravindra Kumar Thakur Son Of Sri Ganesh Thakur Resident Of Village Po Kharika Desari Distt Vashali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School , Chamarupur Jandaha Block Vaishali
13. Nasim Akhatar Raja Son Of Ali Raja Resident Of Vilage Sonpur Adam Ward No 8 Po And Ps Sonpur Saran Presently
2/8 Working As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Chak Salaha Hajipur Block Vaishali
14. Sunil Kumar Thkaur Son Of Yougal Kishore Thakur Resident Of Mohalla Pokhara Subhash Chowk Hajipur Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, New Primary School Gadai Sarai Hajipur Block Vaishali
15. Umesh Kumar Yadav Son Of Rajdeo Prasad Yadav Resident Of Village Khajbatta Sultanpur Po Chaksikandar Ps Bidupur Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School Sultanpur Hajipur Block Vaishali
16. Satyendra Kumar Son Of Surya Shekhar Rai Resident Of Village Gauspur Po Mahisaur Ps Jandaha Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Muiddle School, Ahmadpur Lakhani Hajipur Block Vaishali.
17. Yogendra Choudhary Son Of Asharfi Choudhary Resident Of Village Repura Po - Ps - Lalganj Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School, Etwarpur Sirnaula Lalganj Block Vaishali
18. Surendra Kumar Choudhary Son Of Late Paltu Chaudhary Resident Of Village And Po Aabbakarpur Kowahi Ps Patepur Vaishali Presently Working As Assistnat Teacher Upgraded Middle School Saidpur Dumra, Patepur Block Vaishali
19. Virendra Prasad Son Of Lagte Ram Briksha Sah Resident Of Village And Po Simarwara Ps Patepur Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Maudha Bujurg Part Ii Patepur Block Vaishali
20. Laldeo Pandit Son Of Sri Jaimurat Pandit Resident Of Village Nirpur Po Dhan Kaul Via Patepur Ps Patepur Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Midle School Patepur Patepur Block Vaishali
21. Chandeshwar Ram Swon Of Sri Lakhan Ram Resident Of Village Chaknasib Po- Sukki Ps- Patepur Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, New Primary School, Mikki Chakasia Mahua Block Vaishali
22. Vinod Paswan Son Of Late Lalchand Paswan Resident Of Village Pop Aabbakarpur Kwashi Ps Patepur Vaishali Presently Working As Assisntat Teacher, Govt Primary School, Neerpur Sc Tola Patepur Block Vaishali
23. Naresh Ram Son Of Sri Dhna Ram Resident Of Village And Po Simarwara Via Ps - Patepur Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, New Primary School, Sahbajpur Patepur
24. Chandeshwar Rajak Son Of Sri Kishundeo Rajak Resident Of Vilalge And Po Simarwara Via Ps Patepur Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher New Primary School Sahbajpur Patepur Block Vaishali
25. Upendra Pandit Son Of Ram Prasad Pandit Resident Of Village And Po Madhopur Nijma Ps Mahua Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Kusahar Khas Mahua Block Vaishali.
26. Shastri Lal Sahani Son Of Late Ram Prasad Sahani Resident Of Village Kushahar H=Khas Po Mahdopur Nijma Via Ps Mahua
3/8 Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School Kusahar Khas Mahua Block Vaishali.
27. Abhay Kumar Son Of Sri Kharamanath Singh Resident Of Village Po Uchidih Ps Bidupur Rs Vaishali Presently Working As Assistant Teacher, Govedrnment Primary School Baranti Hajipur
28. Vijay Kumar Son Of Krishana Lal Singh Resident Of Village Govindpur Jhakharaha Po Chaksikandar Ps Rajapakar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School Gauspur Rajapakar Block Vaishali
29. Umanath Das Son Of Late Lacchu Das Resident Of Village Nayagaon Po Nayaganj Ps Desari Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School, Bajitpur Tole Chakwa Sahadei Bujurg Block Vaishali
30. Rajesh Kumar Son Of Late Sakaldeo Rai Resident Of Village Rohua Ps Jandaha Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Chak Faridabad Jandaha Block Vaishali
31. Rabind Kumar Son Of Sri Vijay Prasad Singh Resident Of Village Po And Ps Jajapakar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle Girls School Rajapakar Vaishali.
32. Prakash Chandra Son Of Satyanarayan Sharma Resident Of Mo-Lodipur Po And Ps- Hajipur Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School, Rahimapur Pethia Bidupur Block Vaishali
33. Amarendra Kumar Arya Son Of Late Yogendra Bhakata R Resident Of Village Gadai Sarai Ps Hajipur Sadar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Thengadih Lalaganj Block Vaishali
34. Ashok Kumar Bhagat Son Of Late Gatar Bhagat Resident Of Mo-Pokhara Hajipur Vaishali Presently Posted Asz Newly Created Primary School, Rasulpur Musahari Harijan Lalganj
35. Isteyak Ahmad Sonof Md Abbas Ansari Resident Of MoKadirganj Po- Balhouri, Ps Dulhin Bajar Patna Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Sapahan Hajpur (East) Block Vaishali
36. Surendra Das Son Of Sri Isri Das Resident Of Vilage Jadhua Chisti Po Jadhua Ps Ganga Overbridge Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Pakari Bidupurblock Vaishali
37. Sanjay Kumar Choudhary Son Of Guru Shankar Choudhary Resident Of Village Hathsarganj Po And Ps Hajipur Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School Raudi Pokhar Lalganj Block Vaishali
38. Pramod Kumar Ratan Son Of Krishan Mohan Ram Resident Of Mo Chak Dhanauti Industrial Ara Hajipur Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School, Pachai Mubarak, Rajapakar Block Vaishali
39. Narayan Jha Son Of Late Bihari Jha Resident Of Vill And Po Ladaur Ps Gaighat Distt Muzaffarpur Presently Posted As
4/8 Assistant Teacher Np. School Samudaik Bhawan Patepur Chandi, Hajipur Block Vaishali.
40. Satyendra Kumar Son Of Yamuna Prasad Resident Of Village Jogiya Po And Ps Chandi Distt Nalanda Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Government Middle School Kartahan Lalganj
41. Phulchand Rai Son Of Sri Punit Rai Resident Of Village Gangajal Ps Rajapakar Vaishali Presentlyu Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Chak Sikandar Bidupur Block Vaishali
42. Madan Rajak Son Of Late Laljee Rajak Resident Of Village Chakdaulat Po Olakhanpura Bakhtiyarpur Patna Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School, Phulwari (East) Mahua Block Vaishali
43. Mahesh Prasad Yadav Son Of Late Ram Ratan Rai Resident Of Village Chapith Ps Goraul Vaishali Presently Posted As Assitant Teacher At Np School Hilalpur Hajpur East Blcok Vaishali
44. Satyendra Kumar Thakur Son Of Sri Ramjee Thakur Resident Of Village Panapur Silauthar Ps Jandaha Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Majrohi Saharia Sahadei Bujurg Block Vaishali
45. Dilip Kumar Son Of Sri Nanhaku Singh Residnet Of Village Po - Ps= Rajapakar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School Bhathadasi Rajapakar Block Vaishali.
46. Mohan Kumar Sahani Son Of Sri Ramdeyal Sahani Resident Of Vilage Harpur Bhindi, Ps Tajpur Samastipur Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Mudah Bujurg Rajapakar Block Vaishali.
47. Suresh Kumar Son Of Sri Ramchandra Rai Resident Of Village Mahua Singh Rai (North) Ps- Mahua Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Dharampur Rajapakar Block Vaishali.
48. Shashi Bhushan Son Of Alate Ram Parikshan Rai Resident Of Vilage Lawapur Ps Mahanar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Jagodih Harijan Lalganj Block Vaishali
49. Ranjan Kumar Singh Son Of Ganesh Prasad Singh Resident Of Village Singhara Ps Mahua Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Majauli Tola Bidupur
50. Rama Shankar Sah Son Of Sri Rajeshwar Sah Resident Of Village Harauli Ps Hajipur Sadar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Patepur Lalganj
51. Ajay Kumar Gupta Son Of Sri Etwari Lal Gupta Resident Of Village Chakmida Berai Ps Hajipur Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Government Middle School, Titirhaz Kansara Hajipur East Block Vaishali
52. Shashi Kant Thakur Son Of Sri Ram Ekbal Thakur Resdent Of Vilage Maniar Ps Bidupur Viashali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Government Middle School Kutubpur Bidupur Block Vaishali.
5/8
53. Shivaji Singh Son Of Sri Dhanraj Singh Residnet Of Village Surhatha Ps And Distt Viashali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Belsar Hat Paterhi Belsar
54. Sanjay Kumar Son Of Sri Ram Pyare Rai Resident Of Village Chak Jainav Po Chak Sikandar Vashali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher N.P School Rampur Baghel Harijan Tola Sahadei Bujurg Block Vaishal.
55. Ramnath Sah Son Of Sri Chhathu Sah Resident Of Village Rahim Pur Jagadish Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teach Er N.P School, Jalalpur Laganj Blcok Vaishali.
56. Lalan Das Son Of Sri Bilat Das R Resident Of Village Jadhua Bajar Ps Hajipur Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Rahimapur Pethia Bidupur Block Vaishali
57. Mantosh Kumar Son Of Sr Harendra Paswan Resident Of Village Suratpur Vudya Ps Mahua Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Tajpur Rajo Mahua
58. Bharat Choudhary Son Of Ram Lakhan Choudhary Resident Of Village Chhoti Marai Ps Hajipur Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Fatahpur Rajapakar
59. Nandesh Singh Son Of Late Dasarath Prasad Singh Resident Of Village Senduari Ps Hajipur Sadar, Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School Phulwari East, Mahua Block Vaishali.
60. Andand Kumar Son Of Late Bhushan Pandit Resident Of Village Saidpur Rajauli, Ps Hajipur Sadar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School, Jamalpur Hajipur East Block Vaishali
61. Sanjay Kumar Son Of Late Saryug Rai Resident Of Village Loma, Ps Jandaha Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher, Upgraded Middle School Sarai North Rajapakar Block Vaishali
62. Bigan Ram Son Of Sri Anandu Ram Resident Of Village Saheganj Ps Rajapakar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Aahmadpur Lakhani Hajipur East Block Vaishali
63. Chandeshwar Baitha Son Of Late Jamun Baitha Resident Of Village Khar Jamma, Ps Mahnar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Chakjamal Sahadibujurg Block Vaishali.
64. Surendra Prasad Singh Son Of Late Ram Sewak Sin Gh Resident Of Vilalge Aznd Ps Rajapakar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Bhathadasi Rajapakar Block Vaishali
65. Vijay Bhagat Son Of Sri Ram Chandra Bhagat Resident Of Village Barhauna Ps Vidyapati Nagar Distt Samastipur Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Basudeopur Chandel Paschim Tola Mahnar Block Vaishali./
6/8
66. Upendra Kumar Rai Son Of Sri Rajballabh Rai Resident Of Village Hasanpur Surat Po And Ps Pator Samastipur Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Basudeopur Paschim Tola Mahnar Block Vaishali
67. Shailendra Kumar Son Of Late Nawal Kishore Prasad Resident Of Villaged Rajani Babnhangama, Ps Bhariganj Distt Madhepura Presently Poste As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Bardiha Turki Sc Tola Patepur Block Vaishali
68. Ramesh Kumar Son Of Sri Hriday Roy Resident Of Village Madhopur Ps Jandaha Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Alampur Sahadei Bujurg Block Vaishali
69. Deonath Pandit Son Of Of Late Ram Surat Pandit Resident Of Vilage Mangurahi Ps Ganga Bridge Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Kiratpur Bhagwanpur
70. Abjay Kumar Singh Son Of Late Punit Singh Resident Of Village Dighi Kalal West Ps Hajipur Sadar Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher N.P. Sc Hool Tarwa Isara Hajipur West Block Vaishali.
71. Umesh Kumar Choudhary Son Of Sri Jaimangal Choudhary Resident Of Mo Rajput Nagar Hajipur Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Hasanchak Bidupur Block Vaishali.
72. Kumari Kiran Daughter Of Sri Bindeshwar Paswan Resident Of Village Chhoti Issupur Hajip Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teac Her Primary School Rajashan Bidupur Block Vaishali
73. Sunil Kumar Choudhary Son Of Sri Dahaur Choudhary Resident Of Mo - Bagmusa Ward No 4 Ps Hajipur Town Viahsli Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher N.P School Chak Bakhari Munia Tola Vaishali Block Vaishali
74. Amarnath Singh Sonof Dadhu Singh Resident Of Villa Jajia Ps Goraul Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher U.M School Dharahara Hajipur Vaishali.
75. Anil Kumar Pankaj Son Of Late Bhola Rai 4resident Of Village Kishanpura Ps Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Khajuatta Vaishali Block Vaishali.
76. Raman Kumar Son Fo Sri Ram Briksha Singh Resident Of Village Basantpur Ps- Dighwara Saran Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher Upgraded Middle School Jatkauli Vaishali
77. Braj Kishore Son Of Sri Ganga Prasad R Resident Of Village Gopalpur Koth Ps Basantpur Siwan Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher N.P,. School Piroi Raja Rai Ke Nikat Goraul
78. Shrawan Kumar Paswan Son Of Sri Shivajee Paswan Resident Of Village Bhathadasi Ps Rajapaka Vaishali Presently Posted As Assistant Teacher N.P. School Piroi Raja Rai Ke Nikat Goraul ... ... Petitioner/s
7/8
Versus
1. The State Of Bihar
2. The Principal Secretary Education Department Government Of Bihar Patna
3. The Joint Secretary Education Department Government Of Bihar Patna
4. The Director Primary Education, Government Of Bihar Patna
5. The Regional Deputy Of Director Tirhut Division Muzaffarpur
6. The District Magistrate Vaishali At Hajipur
7. The District Education Officer, Vaishali At Hajipur
8. The District Programme Officer (Establishment) Viahsli At Hajipur ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s :
Mr. Bajarangi Lal, Advocate For the Respondent/s :
Mr. Upendra Pratap Singh, AC to SC 4 ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KUMAR UPADHYAY ORAL ORDER 19-11-2018 The issue involved in the present writ petition is covered by their own policy decision of the respondents. The respondents have taken decision to extend the benefit of trained scale with effect from October, 2003 in the event the teacher has completed training and passed training examination in the very first attempt in 2004 examination, the result thereof was published in 2005.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed and disposed of with the direction to the respondents to grant the benefit of trained scale to the petitioners in the light of their own policy decision with effect from 01.10.2003 and grant all consequential benefits within a maximum period of four months from the date
8/8 of receipt/production of a copy of this order. With the aforesaid, the writ petition stands disposed of.
(Anil Kumar Upadhyay, J) mrl./- U