Ram Pravesh Sharma And ORS v. The State Of Bihar And ORS

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA

Letters Patent Appeal No.1454 of 2013 IN Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 19120 of 2010

1. Ram Pravesh Sharma Son Of Late Firangi Singh Resident Of Village Baghi, Police Station Tekari, District - Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under

2. Ram Lakhan Manjhi Son Of Late Karu Manjhi Resident Of Village Barsona, P.O. Wazirganj, Police Station Tankupa, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv

3. Manoj Kumar Gupta Son Of Sri Prasad Saw Resident Of Village Piyar, Police Station Atri Sadar, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

4. Mohan Ram Son Of Late Ragho Ram Resident Of Mohalla Murali Hilla Telbigha, Police Station Kotwali, Gaya, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv

5. Raju Das Son Of Sri Ramshrup Das Resident Of Village Rajendra Asharam, Police Station Civil Line, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under

6. Anand Kumar Singh Son Of Late Gopal Singh Resident Of Mohalla Piparpatti, Police Station Kotwali, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under

7. Vinod Kumar Pal Son Of Sri Rambriksh Pd. Pal Resident Of Village Gore Moffacil, Manpur, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

8. Sarita Kumari D/O Amendra Kumar Verma Resident Of Village + P.O. Panari,

9. Lakshmi Rajak Son Of Sri Jagdish Rajak Resident Of Village Khizar Sarai, Police Station Nimchak Bathani, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees

10. Anita Kumari Sinha D/O Sri Bhupendra Pd. Resident Of Village Andar, P.O. Bairagi, Police Station Kotwali, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees

11. Ambika Kumar Gupta Son Of Sri Laxman Pd. Gupta Resident Of Mohalla Kairibari, Civil Line, Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

12. Md. Isteyak Son Of Md. Akram Resident Of Village Bara, Police Station Chandauti, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

13. Dilip Sao Son Of Sri Ram Balak Sao Resident Of Village Risounda, Police Station Belaganj, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

14. Chitra Kumari Sinha D/O Sri Paras Nath Sinha Resident Of Village Upardih, Police Station Civil Line, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under

2/5

15. Rajesh Kumar Son Of Late Dwarika Prasad Resident Of Village Rikabganj, Police Station Durga Asthan, Tekari, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv

16. Pradeep Kumar Son Of Sri Gopal Prasad Resident Of Village Rikavganj, Police Station Tekari, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

17. Madhuri Kumari D/O Sri Rang Vijay Singh Resident Of Village Chanpur,

18. Kumari Vibha D/O Sri Yugal Kishore Prasad Resident Of Village Ghughari Tand, Police Station Civil Line, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees

19. Ramashish Chaudhari Son Of Sri Badi Chaudhari Resident Of Village Nepa, Police Station Tekari, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

20. Kanchan Devi W/O Late Raj Kumar Gupta Resident Of Village Gol Bagicha Adda, Police Station Kotwali, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees

21. Shyam Nandan Chaudhary Son Of Sri Laldeep Chaudhary Resident Of Village Manjhouli, Police Station Wazirganj, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv

22. Raj Kishore Prasad Son Of Late Achhiya Pd. Resident Of Village Mobarakpur, Police Station Pairaiya, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under

23. Kiran Kumari Sinha D/O Sri Jagnarain Pd. Singh Resident Of Village Mohalla Upardih, Civil Line, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

24. Anita Kumari D/O Ganesh Prasad Resident Of Village Ranbahadur Road, Police Station Piparpati, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under

25. Rajeshwar Ravidas Son Of Sri Basant Ravidas Resident Of Village Dariyapur, Police Station Sherghati, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under

26. Rukmini Kumari D/O Kapildev Thakur Resident Of Village Punal, Police Station Gurua, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

27. Khelawan Manjhi Son Of Sri Balkishun Manjhi Resident Of Village Pravpur,

28. Kapil Das Son Of Rameshwar Das Resident Of Village Shankarpur, Police Station Belaganj, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The .... .... Appellants

Versus

1. The State Of Bihar

2. The Principal Secretary, Personal and Administrative Reforms Department, Government of Bihar, Patna

3. The Selection Committee of the Class IV Employees of Gram District through the District Magistrate, Gaya

4. The District Magistrate, Gaya

5. The Deputy Collector (Nazarat) Of Collectorate, Gaya, District Gaya

6. Md. Mokhtar Alam Son of Rafique Alam Resident of Village Ajmatganj, Police

3/5 Station Tekari, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class IV Employees under the Collectorate of Gaya District

7. Sunil Kumar Son of Rajendra Nishad Resident of Village Malahchak, P.O. Jehanabad, District Jehanabad, Empanelled As Class IV Employees under the Collectorate of Gaya District

8. Md. Alauddin Ansari Son of Md. Ramjan Miyan Resident of Village Chhavni, Tekari, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class IV Employees Under The Collectorate Of Gaya District

9. Rajeev Kumar Son Of Sri Arun Kumar Sharma Resident Of Village Solra, P.O. Paraiya, Police Station Tekari, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees

10. Ram Chandar Mochi Son Of Late Revat Mochi Resident Of Village Budhi Palmar, Police Station Muffasil Manpur, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv

11. Birij Kumar Das Son Of Late Devsharan Das Resident Of Village Kandi, Police Station Chandauti, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

12. Raj Kumar Son Of Late Chutar Ravidas Resident Of Village Ghughari Tand, Police Station Chandauti, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under

13. Ram Ishwar Bhagat Son Of Sri Moshafir Bhagat Resident Of Village Gire, Police Station Muffasil Manpur, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees

14. Surendra Kr. Pal Son Of Sri Rameshwar Prasad Pal Resident Of Village Gere, Police Station Muffasil Manpur, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees

15. Birendra Kumar Pal Son Of Sri Bindeshwari Bhagat Resident Of Village Gera, Police Station Muffasil, Manpur, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees

16. Chandrika Prasad Son Of Late Ramratan Pal Resident Of Village Powari Belaganj, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

17. Ganesh Prasad Son Of Late Dwarika Prasad Resident Of Village Sighoul,

18. Aruna Kumari Singh S/O Late Ganesh Prasad Singh Resident Of Village Housing Board Colony, Rampur, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees

19. Raj Kumari Sinha D/O Late Hari Lal Resident Of Village Tel Bigha, Police Station Rang Bahadur Road, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees

20. Sulendra Prasad Son Of Sri Chandra Mahto Resident Of Village Rasalpur, Police Station Chandauti, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under

21. Arjun Prasad Son Of Sri Iswari Prasad Resident Of Village + Mohalla Janta Colony, Bragi, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees Under The

22. Ganauri Paswan Son Of Late Munshi Paswan Resident Of Village Bhusunda, Police Station Moffasil, Gaya, District Gaya, Empanelled As Class Iv Employees .... .... Respondents

4/5 Appearance :

For the Appellants : Mr. Jitendra Prasad Singh, Advocate For the Respondents : Mr.

CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR TRIPATHI and HONOURABLE JUSTICE SMT. NILU AGRAWAL ORAL JUDGMENT (Per: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY KUMAR TRIPATHI) Date: 23-02-2017 Heard counsel for the appellants. Perused the order of the learned single Judge dated 10.07.2013, which is impugned in this appeal.

The learned single Judge, keeping in view the previous directions issued in C.W.J.C. No. 2964 of 2009, disposed off on 18.01.2010, as also the principle of law that whenever a panel is required to be prepared, it has to be prepared afresh and old panel cannot be revalidated again and again since it looses its validity after one year, set aside the panel prepared by the district authorities and directed them to issue a fresh advertisement by ignoring all previous panel and draw-up a fresh panel.

Since learned single Judge has committed no error of law in the given facts, the grievances of the appellants that the said order is causing prejudice to them is of no avail. Since the order of the learned single Judge does not suffer from any infirmity either in fact or law, the same is not required to be rectified in appeal.

5/5 Appeal has no merit. It is dismissed.

(Ajay Kumar Tripathi, J) (Nilu Agrawal, J) Pawan/- AFR/NAFR NAFR CAV DATE N/A Uploading Date 23.02.2017 Transmission Date N/A