Horilal Sinha And ORS. v. State Of Chhattisgarh And ORS.

NAFR HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR Writ Petition (S) No.454 of 2009

1. Horilal Sinha, aged 51 years, son of Shri L.R.Sinha,

2. Smt. Sobhana Sagdeo aged 58 years w/o Shri M.A. Sagdeo,

3. Jeevanlal Chandraker aged 56 years son of Shri M.L.Chandraker,

4. Harish Nandanwar aged 52 years, son of Shri K.G.Nandanwar,

5. Mahendra Kumar Sharma aged 51 years, son of Shri M.P.Sharma,

6. Smt. Mamta Sing, aged 52 years, w/o Shri M.M.Singh

7. Smt. Ashma Begum Hasmi, aged 58 years, w/o Shri S. Moinuddin

8. Govind Lal Dewangan, aged 47 years, son of Shri P. Dwangan,

9. Girdhar Lal Dewangan, aged 51 years, son of Shri M.L.Dewangan 10.Kawal Singh Gautam aged 43 years son of Shri S.L.Gautam 11.Umrao Singh Rajak aged 43 years son of Shri M.R.Rajak 12.Ramkumar Dewangan aged 46 years son of Shri S.L.Dewangan 13.Tarachand Nandanwar aged 48 years son of Shri K.G. Nandanwar 14.Yashwant Yadava aged 47 years son of Shri B.R. Yadava 15.Pokhanlal Sinha aged 44 years son of Shri C.R. Sinha 16.Deepak Shrivastava aged 50 years son of late Shri R.S. Shrivastava 17.Ku. Amita Meshram aged 45 years wife of Shri A. Meshram 18.Prakash Prasad Sharma aged 48 years son of Shri B.P.Sharma 19.Vidyabhushan Soni aged 42 years son of Shri C. Soni 20.Laxminarayan Swarnkar aged 48 years son of Shri J.L.Soni 21.Jainarayan Sahu aged 50 years son of Shri S.R. Sahu 22.Shri Sailesh Shrivastava aged 45 years, son of Shri U.C.

Shrivastava 23.Niranjan Namdeo aged 48 years son of Shri S.K.Namdeo 24.D.P. Ramteke aged 47 years son of Shri P.L. Ramteke 25.Shailesh Khobragadhe, aged 40 years, son of Shri S. Khobragadhe 26.Dilip Soni aged 46 years son of Shri M. Soni 27.Uma Deshmukh aged 46 years son of Shri S. Deshmukh 28.Anil Mahobe 45 years son of Shri B.L.Mahobe 29.Smt. Premlata Gajbhiye aged 52 years, wife of Shri N.K.Gajbhiye 30.Ku. Chandrabhaga Borker, aged 54 years daughter of Shri S. Boreker 31.Puneshwar Kumar Lilhare aged years, son of Shri L.C. Lilhare 32.K.L. Sahu aged 52 years son of Shri P.S. Sahu 33.Manohar Patila aged 41 years son of Shri G.

34.Rajesh Khaparde aged 44 years son of Shri M.L.Khaparde 35.Rajendra Ramteke aged 42 years son of Shri B.L. Ramteke 36.Smt. Amrika Yadava aged 40 years wife of Shri I. Yadava 37.Dumeshwarkumar Lilhare, aged 40 years son of Shri L.C.Lilhare 38.Ashwani Sahu aged 41 years son of Shri N.P. Sahu 39.Ganeshwardas Vaishnava aged 45 years son of Shri G.D. Vaishnava 40.Vinod Yadava aged 45 years son of Shri J.R. Yadava 41.Kamlesh Hedau aged 37 years son of Shri B.L.Hedau 42.Jitendra Thakur aged 32 years son of Srhi M.L. Thakur 43.Moreshwar Gosai aged 43 years son of Shri B.L.Gosai 44.Maehs Baghmare aged 40 years son of Shri S.L.Baghmare 45.Prakash Dhomne aged 48 years on of Shri V.R. Dhomne 46.Lilar Singh Sahu aged 51 years sonof Shri Lilar 47.Smt. Maya Gajbhiye aged 48 years wife of Shri S. Gajbhiye 48.Sanjay Kukade aged 47 years son of Shri R.C.

Kukade 49.G.R.Sahu aged 53 years son of Shri Govindram Sahu 50.Deepak Kumar Dewangan aged 40 years son of Shri J. Dewangan 51.Rajesh Kumar Tiwari aged 38 years son of Shri B.N. Tiwari Sr.No.1 to 51 Accountants, Education Dept. Education District Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh 52.Ramesh Kumar Dewangan aged 44 years s/o Shri Nakul Ram Dewangan 53.Arun Kumar Verma aged 46 years son of Shri Ramsewak Verma 54.R.R. Yadava aged 48 years son of Shri Kisun Yadava 55.Amar Yadava aged 46 years son of Shri Shyamlal 56.Rajendra Prasad Sahu aged 49 years son of late Shri Paltan Sahu 57.Digvijay Meshram aged 44 years son of Shri S.D. Meshram 58.Dushyant Kumar Sahu aged 52 years son of Shri Amarsingh Sahu 59.Sharad Prakash Banchhor aged 50 years son of Shri Sheonarayan Banchhor 60.Smt. Radha Sahu aged 54 years son of Shri N.S. Sahu 61.Shri S.K.

Rajput aged 45 years son of Shri Banshi Singh 62.Madan Kumar Sahu aged 42 years son of Shri Manbodh Singh Sahu 63.Hemant Dewangaon aged 41 years son of late Shri Ramadhin Dewangan 64.Ram Bilas Sahu aged 48 years son of late Shri Sambhoo Lal Sahu 65.Tilok Singh aged 46 years son of Shri Same Singh 66.Sheosingh Vistha aged 47 years son of Shri A.s.

67.Smt. Usha Chandraker aged 46 years wife of Shri Khilawan Chandraker 68.S.R. Rajhansh aged 56 years son of Shri Hirasingh Rajhansh 69.Smt. Shanta Sahare aged 48 years wife of Shri D.M.Sahare 70.Sharad Kumar Chandraker aged 45 years son of Shri K.R. Chandraker 71.G.R. Pal aged 54 years son of late Shri B.R. Pal 72.Shekhar Singh Rajput aged 44 years son of late Shri Dhansingh 73.Rajjansingh Kahar aged 47 years son of Shri H.L. Kahar 74.M.K. Tiwari aged 52 years son of Shri D.D. Tiwari Sr.No.52 to 74 Accountants, School Education Department, Durg, Chhattisgarh ---- Petitioners versus

1. State Government of Chhattisgarh, through the Secretary, School Education Department, Ministry, D.K.S. Bhawan, Raipur, Chhattisgarh

2. Secretary, Finance Department Ministry, State of Chhattisgarh, Raipur, Chhattisgarh

3. Director of Public Instruction, State of Chhattisgarh, D.K.S. Bhavan, Raipur, Chhattisgarh

4. District Education Officer, Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh

5. District Education Officer, Durg, Chhattisgarh ---- Respondents For Petitioners : Shri Ajay Shrivastava, Advocate For Respondents/State : Shri B. Gopa Kumar, Deputy Advocate General Hon'ble Shri Navin Sinha, Chief Justice Order on Board 14/12/2015 1.

Heard Learned Counsel for the Petitioners and the State. 2.

The controversy in this case relates to grant of pay-scale and anomaly with regard to the same. Paragraph 4 of the counter-affidavit states that the matter is under consideration. 3.

The writ application is disposed in the aforesaid terms that if the Respondents have taken a decision and the Petitioners are aggrieved they may pursue their remedies in accordance with law. Conversely, if the

Respondents have not taken a decision till date in accordance with the representation made in the counter-affidavit they are required to do so within a maximum period of three months from the date of receipt and/or production of a copy of this order.

4.

The writ application is disposed.

Sd/- (Navin Sinha) CHIEF JUSTICE Gopal