Gopinath And Another v. Bhavsingh And Others

NAFR HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH, BILASPUR SA No. 119 of 2006

1. Gopinath, aged about 78 years, Son of Shri Dayanidhi Tiwari.

2. Munna Prasad, aged about 59 years, Son of Shri Gaurinath Tiwari. Both are R/o Village Ghat, Lohanga, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, M.P. (Now Chhattisgarh).

---- Appellants

Versus

1. Bhav Singh, Son of Late Shri Banmali.

2. Badan, son of Shri Banmali.

Both are Resident of Village Dongarigudapara, Guchagudapara, Tahsil Jagdalpur, Bastar, Chhattisgarh.

3. Devi Singh, aged about 50 years, Dhakad Son of Shri Thun.

4. Tara, aged about 25 years, Son of Shri Ajab Dhakad.

5. Dhano, aged about 25 years, Son of Shri Hari Bhatara.

6. Dengur, aged about 25 years, Son of Shri Gagaru.

7. Chumman, aged about 45 years, Son of Shri Bondagu Bhatara.

8. Shobhnath, aged about 40 years, Son of Shri Bodangu Bhatara.

9. Budhram, aged about 30 years, Son of Shri Bodaku Bhatara. 10.

Roopdhar, son of Shri Bodangu Bhatar, aged about 28 years.

11.Sukhnath, aged about 25 years, Son of Shri Bodangu Bhatara. 12.

Dhukhu, aged about 50 years, Son of Shri Jai Singh Bhatara.

13.

Neelamber, aged about 50 years, son of Shri Tadaru Dhakad.

14.

Tangaru, aged about 50 years, Son of Shri Jai Singh Dhakkad.

15.

Mannu, aged about 23 years, Son of Shri Veer Singh. 16.

Ram Sai, aged about 27 years, Son of Shri Loknath Dhakad. 17.

Siroram, aged about 25 years, Son of Shri Govardhan Dhakad.

18.

Ganesh Singh, aged about 50 years, son of Shri Tagaru

Dhakad.

19.

Lokinath, aged about 45 years, Son of Shri Tagaru Dhakad. 20.

Mangal Sai, aged about 25 years, Son of Shri Thadama Dhakad.

21.

State of Madhya Pradesh (Now C.G.) through Distt. Collector, Bastar, Jagdalpur, Chhattisgarh.

22.

Sub Divisional Officer (Rev.), Jagdalpur, Distt. Bastar, Chhattisgarh.

23.

Tahsildar, Jagdalpur, Distt. Bastar, Chhattisgarh. 24.

Taraprasad Sharma, aged about 50 years, Son of Shri Ramnath.

25.

Teparu, aged about 35 years, son of Shri Ram Singh Dhakad.

26.

Sondhan, son of Shri Sukhdeo Dhakad, Kudalgaon. 27.

Sondhan, son of Shri Sukhdeo Dhakad, Kudalgaon. 28.

Sudarshan, aged about 30 years, Son of Shri Son Singh, Sarpach, Village Kudalgaon.

29.

Sukaldhar, Kotwar, Village Kudalgaon.

30.

Dharamu, Son of Shri Dasharu Mahra, Village Kami Aasna. 31.

Chetan, Son of Shri Aayatu Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 32.

Boga, Son of Shri Chakro Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 33.

Gaurang, Son of Shri Seebo Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 34.

Somaru, son of Shri Padoyee Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 35.

Bondaka, son of Shri Ramchandra Dhakad, Village 36.

Dharamana, son of Shri Somnath Dhakad, Village Kudalgaon.

37.

Mosum, Son of Shri Shankar, Caste Dhakad, Dongariguda. 38.

Sahadeo, son of shri Ramchandra, Village Dongariguda. 39.

Shivram, son of shri Futram, Village Kudalgaon. 40.

Kapeelnath, Son of Shri Duge, Resident of Village Kudalgaon.

41.

Dhanur, son of Shri Dhati Bhatara, Village Dongariguda.

42.

Deochand, Son of Shri Kanwal Mawalipadar (Kudalgaon ka Para).

43.

Mahadeo, son of Shri Digga Mahara, Village Dongariguda. 44.

Budhram, son of Shri Bhagat Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 45.

Hastu, son of Shri Budharu Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 46.

Siro, son of Shri Mundi Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 47.

Burandu, son of Shri Bhagat Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 48.

Mangal, son of Shri Antu Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 49.

Lakhamu, son of Shri Budharu Bhatara, Village 50.

Umashankar, son of Shri Ganpat Bhatara, Village Donariguda.

51.

Ramsai, son of Shri Prem Dhakad, Village Kudalgaon. 52.

Khito, son of Shri Thadaga Dhakad, Village Muwagadapara. 53.

Sundar, son of Shri Thaduga Dhakad, Village Dongariguda. 54.

Jagbandhu, son of Shri Jairan Dhakad Village Dongaiguda. 55.

Puran, son of Shri Jairam Dhakad, Village Guwagunda. 56.

Sakaru, son of Shri Kamlochan Dhakad, Village Guwagunda.

57.

Nawaru, son of Shri Govardhan Dhakad, Village Guwagunda.

58.

Gadadhar, Son of Shri Bor Singh Dhakad, Village Guwagunda.

59.

Khemeshwar, son of Shri Boga Dhakad, Village Guwagunda. 60.

Damaru, son of Shri Jairam Dhakad, Village Guwagunda. 61.

N.R. Thakur, son of Shri Khitoram Dhakad, Village Guwagunda.

62.

Sukhram, son of Shri Sukhdeo Bhatara, Village 63.

Tulasiram, son of Shri Hastu Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 64.

Annat Ram, son of Shri Tayee Bhatara, Village Dongarugada.

65.

Siro, son of Shri Mahadeo Bhatara, Village Dongariguda.

66.

Ram Deo, son of Shri Mahadeo Bhatara, Village Dongariduga.

67.

Bheema, son of shri Bolo Bhatara, Village Metawada ( Near Kudalgaon).

68.

Dabari, son of Shri Budaru Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 69.

Deonath, son of Shri Buti Dhakad, Village Kudalgaon. 70.

Batiram, son of Shri Naani Dhakad, Village Ektagudapara. 71.

Ramdhar, son of Shri Dantu Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 72.

Udainath, son of Shri Saganu Bhatara, Village Mawalipadar. 73.

Banshidhar, son of Shri Roopdhar Mahara, Village 74.

Koyakaram, son of shri Ramdhar Village Dongariguda. 75.

Bholo, son of shri Jaldhar Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 76.

Peela Sigh, son of Shri Sonsai Dhakad, Village 77.

Saganu, son of Shri Sukaru Dhakad, Village Dongariguda. 78.

Hariram, son of Shri Bondka Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 79.

Ganga Ram, son of Shri Sukhdeo Bhatara, Village 80.

Dalar, son of Shri Jayeet Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 81.

Deenbandhu, son of Shri Toli Mahara, Village Dongariguda. 82.

Rajadhar, son of Shri Digga Mahara, Village Dongariguda. 83.

Dhano, son of shri Sammat Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 84.

Mangal Ram, son of Shri Gandhu Bhatara, Village 85.

Sukhabai, widow of Late Sonsai Bhatara, Village 86.

Dalo, son of Shri Kapeelnath Dhakad, Village Kudalgaon. 87.

Trilochan, son of Shri Khuja Dhakad, Village Kudalgoan. 88.

Nilaam, son of Shri Naino Dhakad, Village Kudalgaon. 89.

Dayashankar, son of Shri Chingade, Village Kudalgaon. 90.

Kanwalsai, son of Shri Raghuram Bhatara, Village Kudalgaon.

91.

Somaru, son of shri Madan Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 92.

Dharam Singh, son of Shri Astu Bhatara, Village 93.

Jhitaru, son of Shri Nahru Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 94.

Chain Sai, son of Shri Duwaru Bhatara, Village 95.

Damaru, son of Shri Lakhamu Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 96.

Chandan, son of Shri Budharoo Bhatara, Village 97.

Sureej, son of Shri Budharoo Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 98.

Shivram, son of Shri Sar Singh Bhatar, Village Dongariguda. 99.

Goncharam, son of Shri Jhitaru Bhatara, Village 100.

Astu, son of Shri Naani Kumhar Bhatara, Village 101.

Jaideo, son of Shri Mahadeo, Village Dongariguda. 102.

Budh Singh, son of Shri Sahadeo, Village Dongariguda. 103.

Sonu, son of Shri Danamu, Village Dongariguda. 104.

Bhataru Nath, son of Shri Devi singh, Village Dongariguda. 105.

Sahadeo, Bhatara, village Dongariguda.

106.

Harbandhu, son of Shri Son Sai Mahara, Village 107.

Yen Singh alias Gan Singh, son of Shri Rupdhan Mahara, Village Dongariguda.

108.

Balram, son of Shri Chanturam, Village Dongariguda. 109.

Roopsai, Son of Shri Naani Dhakad, Village Ektaguda. 110.

Ramesh Kumar, Son of Shri Dhan Singh Dhakad, Village Ektaguda.

111.

Naani, son of Shri Puran Dhakad, Village Ektaguda. 112.

Kenuram, son of Shri Keshav Dhakad, Village Ektaguda. 113.

Roop Singh, son of Shri Naani Dhakad, Village Ektaguda. 114.

Sofar Singh, son of Shri Lachhu Dhakad, Village Ektaguda. 115.

Baldeo, son of Shri Sukhram Dhakad, Village Ektaguda.

116.

Balam, son of Shri Kawalsai Dhakad, Village Mawalipadar. 117.

Mangal Singh, son of Shri Sukhram, Village Dongariguda. 118.

Badan, son of Shri Sukhram, Village Dongariguda. 119.

Sukuram, son of Shri Budhram Dhakad, Village Kudalgaon. 120.

Inder nath, Son of Shri Gunju Dhakad, Village Kudalgaon. 121.

Sajman, son of Shri Aayatu Dhakad, Village Dongariguda. 122.

Bheemasan, son of Shri Nar Singh, Dhakad.

123.

Kamal Ram, Son of Shri Budhram Bhatara, Village 124.

Hanumant, son of Shri Antu Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 125.

Laxmi Nath, son of Shri Pitanar Singh Bhatara, Village 126.

Narayan Singh, son of Son Sai Dhakad, Village 127.

Meghnath, son of Shri Motakoo, Village Dongariguda. 128.

Son Singh, Son of Shri Aatu Dhakad, Village Dongariguda. 129.

Bandhulal, Son of Not Known, Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 130.

Sukhdeo, son of Shri Kartik Dhakad, Village Dongariguda. 131.

Nadgu, son of Shri Kadi Bhatara, Village Guwaguda. 132.

Banshi, son of Shri Nar Singh Dhakad, Village Ghat Lohanga.

133.

Balram, son of Shri Arjun Bhatara, Village Mawalipadar. 134.

Ramdhar, son of Shri Rainu Bhatar, Vilage Dongariguda. 135.

Madhu, son of Shri Son Singh Bhatara, Village Dongariguda. 136.

Madho Ram, son of Shri Ramchandra, Village Kudalgaon. Except Respondents No. 20, 21 & 22, all are residents of village panchayat Kudalgaon, Tahsil Jagdalpur, Distt. Bastar. Through - Sarpanch, Distt. Bastar, Tahsil Jagdalpur, Chhattisgarh. 137.

Ramnath Tiwari, aged about 85 years, son of Shri Dayanidhi Tiwari.

138.

Lokeshwar Prasad Tiwari, aged about 65 years, Son of Shri Gaurinath Tiwari.

139.

Pitamber Prasad Tiwari, aged about 45 years, Son of Shri Gaurinath Tiwari.

140.

Smt. Jaimati Tiwari, widow of Late Manishankar Tiwari, aged about 72 years.

All residents of Village Ghat, Lohanga, Tahsil Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Madhya Pradesh (Now Chhattisgarh).

--- Respondents For Petitioners :

Mr. C.D. Sharma, Advocate For State : Mr. Ravi Bhagat, Dy. G.A. Hon'ble Shri Justice Sanjay K. Agrawal Order On Board 18.07.2019

1. Learned counsel for the petitioners seeks permission of this Court to withdraw this second appeal.

2. Accordingly, the second appeal is dismissed as withdrawn. Sd/- (Sanjay K. Agrawal) Judge Harneet