Lila Ram v. Estate Officer -Ii Dda & ANR
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI % Judgment delivered on: 31.01.2018 LPA 481/2013 & CM Nos. 10532/2013, 10533/2013 DHARAMBIR SINGH SAINI AND ANR LPA 482/2013 & CM Nos. 10535/2013, 10536/2013 JAI CHAND AND ANR LPA 483/2013 & CM Nos. 10538/2013, 10539/2013 PRITAM SINGH SAINI AND ANR LPA 484/2013 & CM Nos. 10541/2013, 10542/2013 HARI CHAND SAINI & ANR LPA 485/2013 & CM Nos. 10544/2013, 10545/2013 RAKESH KUMAR SAINI AND ANR LPA 488/2013 & CM Nos. 10557/2013, 10558/2013 RAJINDER SAINI AND ANR
LPA 489/2013 & CM Nos. 10560/2013, 10561/2013, 10562/2013 MOOL CHAND AND ANR LPA 490/2013 & CM Nos. 10563/2013, 10564/2013 JYOTI SAINI AND ANR LPA 491/2013 & CM Nos. 10566/2013, 10567/2013 HARI CHAND SAINI & ANR LPA 492/2013 & CM Nos. 10569/2013, 10570/2013 KRISHAN KUMAR SHARMA & ANR LPA 555/2013 & CM No. 11893/2013 RAM PRATAP & ANR.
LPA 558/2013 & CM Nos. 11897/2013, 11898/2013 RAMU & ANR.
LPA 559/2013 & CM Nos. 11919/2013, 11920/2013 RAJESH KUMAR & ANR LPA 560/2013 & CM Nos. 11921/2013, 11922/2013 OM PRAKASH & ANR ..... Appellant LPA 561/2013 & CM No. 11923/2013 SANJAY AGGARWAL & ANR.
LPA 132/2016 & CM Nos. 7344/2016, 7345/2016 FAQIR CHAND (SINCE DECEASED) THR HIS LEGAL HEIR MUKESH KUMAR & ANR LPA 200/2015 LILA RAM ..... Appellant ESTATE OFFICER -II DDA & ANR ..... Respondents LPA 75/2017 & CM Nos. 3683/2017, 3684/2017
RAMESH CHAND SAINI & ANR LPA 668/2016 & CM Nos. 44900/2016, 44902/2016 NATHU SINGH & ANR LPA 4/2017 & CM Nos. 56/2017, 57/2017, 58/2017 DINESH KUMAR & ANR LPA 669/2016 & CM Nos. 44910/2016, 44912/2016 MAHESH KUMAR & ANR W.P.(C) 5041/2014 & CM Nos. 10061/2014, 10062/2014, 10063/2014 RAJESH KUMAR & ANR ..... Petitioners W.P.(C) 5790/2016 CHHOTE LAL ..... Petitioner THE DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY & ORS...Respondents
W.P.(C) 5805/2016 TARA CHAND ..... Petitioner THE DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY & ORS ..... Respondents W.P.(C) 5806/2016 NATHU RAM ..... Petitioner THE DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY & ORS. Respondents W.P.(C) 5808/2016 KISHAN LAL ..... Petitioner THE DELHI DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY & ORS. Respondents LPA 2/2017 & CM Nos. 35/2017, 36/2017, 37/2017 RAJ PAL ..... Appellant DDA LPA 3/2017 & CM Nos. 53/2017, 54/2017, 55/2017 BUDH RAM ..... Appellant LPA 5/2017 & CM Nos. 62/2017, 63/2017, 64/2017 GIAS RAM & ORS
LPA 7/2017 & CM Nos. 69/2017, 70/2017, 71/2017 LAXMI NARAYAN ..... Appellant DDA LPA 8/2017 & CM Nos. 75/2017, 76/2017, 77/2017 KAILASH CHAND ..... Appellant LPA 10/2017 & CM Nos. 81/2017, 82/2017, 83/2017 SANJEEV CHAUHAN ..... Appellant DDA LPA 11/2017 & CM Nos. 84/2017, 85/2017, 86/2017 CHHATAR SINGH ..... Appellant DDA LPA 12/2017 & CM Nos. 146/2017, 147/2017, 148/2017 RAM SINGH SAINI & ANR LPA 65/2017 & CM Nos. 3159/2017, 3161/2017, 3162/2017 RAM BHOOLI ..... Appellant
LPA 68/2017 & CM Nos. 3383/2017, 3385/2017, 3386/2017 CHIDDA RAM ..... Appellant LPA 70/2017 & CM Nos. 3389/2017, 3391/2017, 3392/2017 MOHAN LAL ..... Appellant LPA 71/2017 & CM Nos. 3393/2017, 3395/2017, 3396/2017 JAIPAL SINGH DECEASED THR LR ..... Appellant DDA LPA 72/2017 & CM Nos. 3397/2017, 3399/2017, 3400/2017 DINESH CHAND ..... Appellant LPA 73/2017 & CM Nos. 3401/2017, 3403/2017, 3404/2017 ANOOP SINGH ..... Appellant DDA
Present:
Mr. Amit Kumar with Mr. Kumar Abhishek, Advocates for Appellant in LPA Nos. 481/2013, 482/2013, 483/2013, 484/2013, 485/2013,
488/2013, 489/2013, 490/2013, 491/2013, 492/2013, 132/2016, 668/2016, 669/2016, 2/2017, 3/2017, 4/2017, 5/2017, 7/2017, 8/2017, 10/2017, 11/2017, 12/2017, 65/2017, 68/2017, 70/2017, 71/2017, 72/2017, 73/2017, 75/2017 & WPC Nos. 5041/2014. Mr S.N. Gupta, Adv. for appellants in LPA Nos. 555/2013, 558/2013, 559/2013, 560/2013 and 561/2013 Mr. A.K. Bhardwaj, Advocate along with Dheeraj Bhardwaj, Advocate for Appellant in LPA No.200/2015.
Mr. U.M. Tripathi, Advocate for Petitioner in WPC Nos. 5041/2014, 5790/2016, 5805/2016 & 5806/2016.
Ms. Shobhana Takiar, Advocate for respondent/DDA in LPA Nos.479/2013, 481/2013, 482/2013, 483/2013, 484/2013, 485/2013, 488/2013, 489/2013, 490/2013, 491/2013, 492/2013, 555/2013, 558/2013, 559/2013, 560/2013, 561/2013, 200/2015, 132/2016, 668/2016, 669/2016, 2/2017, 3/2017, 4/2017, 5/2017, 7/2017, 8/2017, 10/2017, 11/2017, 12/2017, 65/2017, 68/2017, 70/2017, 71/2017, 72/2017, 73/2017, 75/2017 & WPC Nos. 5041/2014, 5790/2016, 5805/2016, 5806/2016 & 5808/2016.
Mr. Dhanesh Relan with Ms. Isha Garg, Advocates for respondent/DDA in LPA Nos.200/2015, 132/2016., 668/2016, 669/2016, 2/2017, 4/2017, 5/2017, 7/2017, 8/2017, 68/2017, 72/2017 & 75/2017.
Mr. Sanjeev Sabharwal with Mr. Hem Kumar, Advocates for respondent/DDA in LPA No.668/2016.
Mr. Arun Birbal, Advocate for respondent/DDA in LPA Nos.2/2017, 5/2017, 7/2017, 8/2017, 10/2017, 12/2017, 65/2017 & 70/2017 Mr. Arjun Pant, Advocate for respondent/DDA in LPA Nos.4/2017 & 71/2017.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIPIN SANGHI HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE DEEPA SHARMA
J U D G M E N T
DEEPA SHARMA, J.
Dismissed.
For detailed order, see LPA No.479/2013.
DEEPA SHARMA (JUDGE) VIPIN SANGHI (JUDGE) JANUARY 31, 2018 BG