Smt.A. Bhagya Lakshmi v. Apsrtc
ÐÏࡱá>þÿ SUþÿÿÿRÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ð¿SbjbjqPqP v>::ö$8ÿÿÿÿÿÿ¤bbbr‚‚‚$¦®®®PþLJ<¦É-|''" ́ ́ ́ûûûH-J-J-J-J-J-J-$E/h1Tn-‚ûûûûûn-‚‚ ́ ́Gƒ-___ûî‚ ́‚ ́H-_ûH-__:#t‚‚Ð# ́†Ð'> ̃Юé¦t# Ì,|TM-0É-~#R2r2Ð#Ð#82‚$Äûû_ûûûûûn-n-^ûûûÉ-ûûûû¦¦¦¤Jd¦¦¦J¦¦¦‚‚‚‚‚‚ÿÿÿÿHONOURABLE Dr. JUSTICE B.SIVA SANKARA RAO C.M.A.No.803 OF 2004 JUDGMENT: The injured claimant preferred the appeal impugning the quantum of compensation, awarded by the II Additional chief Judge, City Civil Courts, Hyderabad (for short, 'Tribunal') passed on 19.12.2003 in O.P. NO.1431 of 2000, of Rs.2,25,000/- with interest at 9% per annum against the claim of Rs.
15,00,000/- in the claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 (for short, 'the Act'), is utterly low and requires enhancement, 2. Heard learned counsel for appellant and learned Standing Counsel for respondents. Perused the material on record. The parties hereinafter are referred to as arrayed before the Tribunal for the sake of convenience in the appeal. 3. Whereas it is the contention of the standing counsel for APSRTC that the drivers of the two buses collided with each other, from which, the bus in which the petitioner was traveling as passenger turned turtle and he further stated that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is just but for to reduce the rate of interest awarded at 9% per annum is excessive and there is nothing to interfere, hence to dismiss the appeal. 4.
Now the points that arise for consideration in the appeal are: Whether there is any dispute on the manner of accident and out come of negligence of one of the drivers to the two buses belongs to Respondents 1 and 2, if so what is the just compensation? To what result? POINT-1: 5. Now coming to the injuries sustained by the petitioner and disability is concerned, the evidence on record more particularly from that of PW.2-Dr.K.Madhukar Reddy of L.V.Prasad Eye Hospital clearly proves with reference to Ex.A2-wound certificate and Ex.A3-medical report that she lost the vision of both eyes and she had optic atrophy and she is irreversibly blind in both the eyes and no chance of getting back her vision even by any eye surgery. He further stated that the claimant had no perception and light in both the eyes, pupils of both the eyes of PW.
1 have no motion because their nerves supply is found cut from the brain. Thus, as per W.C Act, Schedule - I, Item Nos.25 and 26 where there is loss of vision of one eye without complications or disfigurement of eye ball, and other being normal it is 30%. Having regard to the above, it is just to take 70% permanent disability for loss of vision of both eyes, though it is the contention of the claimant to take 100% disability not to take so, for nothing to say from loss of vision it is impaired any avocation fully as she is only a house wife and what is proved from Ex.A6-pahanies and the evidence of PW.3, her husband got some property. 6.
Coming to the earnings, there is no proof of her earnings, as per Latha Wadhwa vs State of Bihar, which expression delivered in December, 2000, in the absence of proof of earnings even domestic contribution of a house woman can be assessed at Rs.3,000/- per month, as the accident is occurred more than 3 1⁄2 year prior to the said expression, even taken at Rs.2,000/- per month as domestic contribution, the multiplier applicable is '18' from which the TC certificate shows that she studied 10th class with date of birth 1976, thereby it comes to Rs.4,32,000/- (Rs.2,000/- X 12 X 18). If the disability is taken at 70% it comes to Rs.3,02,400/-. With regard to the medical expenses, the Tribunal since granted Rs.16,000/- same is retained and for the injuries which are two lacerated including one over right frontal region Rs.
15,000/- is to be awarded besides Rs.10,000/- towards attendant charges and transport charges, which comes to Rs.3,43,400/- is just compensation. However, to reduce the rate of interest from 9% per annum to 7.5% per annum vide TN Transport vs Raja Priya and Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh. Accordingly, point No.1 is answered. POINT No.2: 7. In the result, the appeal allowed in part by enhancing the compensation from Rs.2,25,000/- to Rs.3,43,400/- (Rupees three lakhs forty three thousand four hundred only); however by reducing the rate of interest from 9% per annum to 7.5% per annum from the date of claim petition till the date of realization. Rest of the terms of the award of the Tribunal holds good. There is no order as to costs. 8. Miscellaneous petitions, if any pending in this appeal, shall stand closed. _______________________ Dr. B.
SIVA SANKARA RAO, J Date:02-04-2015 knlHONOURABLE Dr. JUSTICE B.SIVA SANKARA RAO C.M.A.No.803 OF 2004 Date:02.04.2015 knl 2005 (6) SCC 236 2013 ACJ 1403 PAGE PAGE 5 *367<=>?@AIJKLMQlwåæüý+ 1 ïÝË1ݧ˕ݕÝï݇vhZhZvFvZh&hT‰hÙ96CJOJQJ]^JaJh΋CJOJQJ^JaJh3⁄4B6CJOJQJ^JaJ hT‰hÙ9CJOJQJ^JaJhÙ9CJOJQJ^JaJ#h3⁄4B65>*CJOJQJ\^JaJ#h]\Ã5>*CJOJQJ\^JaJ#hÌb05>*CJOJQJ\^JaJ#h΋5>*CJOJQJ\^JaJ#h+Xé5 h+Xé5CJOJQJ\^JaJ*@AK õ £æ¤ ́ μ ¿ òåÛÑÄÄ·a ̃†yy$dà¤xa$gdSmÅ$ &Fdà¤ð¤a$gdSmÅ$ &Fdð¤ð¤a$gd?zƒ$dà¤xa$gd?
zƒ$dà¤xa$gd&x$dà¤xa$gdÙ9 dà¤gdDA† dð¤gd3⁄4B6$dð¤a$gd3⁄4B6$dà¤a$gdDA†öRýýý1 2 3 6 7 N O R Z s u w • Æ Ü Þ ß ] a ‚ õ ö ù \dòäÖòäÖäÖäòÖäÈ·£'·Ö·ÖsÈeÈÖWh"4gCJOJQJ^JaJhÌb0CJOJQJ^JaJhCJOJQJ^JaJ h}phÙ9CJOJQJ^JaJ h΋6CJOJQJ]^JaJ&hT‰hÙ96CJOJQJ]^JaJ hT‰hÙ9CJOJQJ^JaJhÙ9CJOJQJ^JaJh΋CJOJQJ^JaJh3⁄4B6CJOJQJ^JaJhúëCJOJQJ^JaJdev€Ê棤¥§æî ¤ 3 ́ μ òäÖÈÖÈÖo¬ž~l~ZF4#hÓ æ5>*CJOJQJ\^JaJ&hÓ æhSmÅ6CJOJQJ]^JaJ#hÓ æhSmÅ6CJOJQJ^JaJ#hÓ æh6CJOJQJ^JaJ#hÓ æh? zƒ6CJOJQJ^JaJhSmÅCJOJQJ^JaJhSmÅCJOJQJ^JaJh?
zƒCJOJQJ^JaJhCJOJQJ^JaJhJMCJOJQJ^JaJh΋CJOJQJ^JaJhœ`íCJOJQJ^JaJh¥-ŽCJOJQJ^JaJμ ¿ À  swîó$*§ó÷>_£3¿ËÓÙéýXYwz}¿ÝíßÑÃμÃμÃμ§μTM‹}‹}‹}‹}TM}‹}‹}‹o}X},hÞh^É56CJOJQJ\]^JaJhÓ æCJOJQJ^JaJh^ÉCJOJQJ^JaJh[F3⁄4CJOJQJ^JaJh‰CJOJQJ^JaJhœ`íCJOJQJ^JaJhJMCJOJQJ^JaJhCJOJQJ^JaJhSmÅCJOJQJ^JaJh?zƒCJOJQJ^JaJ#hSmÅ5>*CJOJQJ\^JaJ¿ y ï/?CmnopqrîîáîÎ1⁄2°¦œ‚‚‚‚‚$dð¤a$gd{$dà¤a$gd{ dð¤gd » dð¤gdŒe$dð¤a$gdSmÅ$„Ðdð¤`„Ða$gdSmÅ$„Ðdà¤ð¤x`„Ða$gd€1 ̃$dà¤xa$gd‚$„Ðdà¤x`„Ða$gdSmÅ16L]„... ̃¢μÑÔÞáTUV[ik¢)*+8>RÝéñ -.
12 oòäÖäÖäòäòäòäòäÖäÈäòä¶ä ̈š ̈È ̈šÖšÖšŒ ̈Œ ̈Œ ̈È ̈È ̈È ̈{ hÓ æ5CJOJQJ\^JaJhßcâCJOJQJ^JaJhÓ æCJOJQJ^JaJh=*2CJOJQJ^JaJ#h^Éh^ÉCJH*OJQJ^JaJhœ`íCJOJQJ^JaJh[F3⁄4CJOJQJ^JaJh^ÉCJOJQJ^JaJhÞCJOJQJ^JaJ- o»1⁄4Á×ØÙ èÔà ̄-‡xjYE6'hÙ9CJOJQJ\^JaJhÓ æCJOJQJ\^JaJ&h‚h‚5>*CJOJQJ^JaJ h‚5>*CJOJQJ^JaJhvZCJOJQJ^JaJh=*2CJOJQJ\^JaJhìb¦CJOJQJ\^JaJ1jhìb¦hìb¦0J@ˆ(CJOJQJU^JaJ&hìb¦hìb¦5CJOJQJ\^JaJ hÓ æ5CJOJQJ\^JaJ&hìb¦hÓ æ5CJOJQJ\^JaJ-jhÓ æ0J5CJOJQJU\^JaJ*:=GK`·EŸ ¡ïñó/4ðáÒáÃáÒÃá ́£•‡vhvYG7hÔ8àhŒe5OJQJ\aJ"h•¶hSmÅ5CJOJQJ\aJh•¶hSmÅCJOJQJaJhSmÅCJOJQJ^JaJ h•¶hSmÅCJOJQJ^JaJhSmÅCJOJQJ^JaJhÓ æCJOJQJ^JaJ hO=Ghã'ÑCJOJQJ^JaJh(uñCJOJQJ\^JaJh[F3⁄4CJOJQJ\^JaJh=*2CJOJQJ\^JaJhŠ, ±CJOJQJ\^JaJhã'ÑCJOJQJ\^JaJ46789=>?
@BCm ̃TMžÐÑõö÷ óãÖÉãÉã1¬ŸŽ|oŸbRŸB84h"4gjh"4g0JUh »h{CJOJQJ\aJh{h{CJOJQJ\aJh{CJOJQJ\aJhY_?CJOJQJ\aJ#h{5>*CJOJQJ\^JaJ h{5CJOJQJ\^JaJh{CJOJQJ\aJhE]ñCJOJQJ\aJh•Nh†>óCJOJQJ\aJhÓ æ5OJQJ\aJhšm|5OJQJ\aJhÔ8àhŒe5OJQJ\aJhœ`í5OJQJ\aJrstuvwxyz{|}~€‚ ̃TMš›œžŸ ¡¢òòòòòòòòòòòòòòòòòèèèèèèèèèè dð¤gd »$dð¤a$gd{¢£¤¥¦§ ̈©a«¬® ̄°±23 ́μ¶ÆÊËÌÍõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõèÞõõõ dð¤gd{$dð¤a$gd{ dð¤gd »ÍÎÏÐÑÒÓÔÕÖרÙÚÛÜÝÞßàáâãäåæçèéõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõõ dð¤gd »éêëìíîïðñòóôõö "#%&/õõõõõõõõõõõõõóóñçñçñçñçñÛ„øÿ„&`#$gdJ¡ dð¤gd+Xé dð¤gd » !#$&'-.
/1289:;<OPQRSèÚÉÅ1⁄2Å1⁄2Å1⁄2Å1⁄2Å33©33ž3©"©Åƒh »h{CJOJQJ\aJh}ph"4gCJaJh[F3⁄40JmHnHuh"4g h"4g0Jjh"4g0JUjhA?mUhA?m hÓ æh"4gCJOJQJ^JaJh"4gCJOJQJ^JaJ-jh£`h"4g0JCJOJQJU^JaJ/01<=>?PQRSöôèÜ××ÏÇô1⁄2 dð¤gd »$a$gd΋$a$gd}p$a$$„h] „ha$gd΋„øÿ„&`#$gdJ¡„h]„hgd΋ 9 0&P1h:p΋°Ð/ °ÀN!°p"°p#p$p%°°Ð°ÐÐ9 0&P1h:p΋°Ð/ °ÀN!
°p"°p#p$p%°°Ð°ÐІœ ̃žžžžžžžž666666666vvvvvvvvv666666>666666666666666666666666666 ̈6666666666 ̧666666666666hH sH tH n@nÿb Heading 1 $$„Ðdð¤@&`„Ða$"5CJOJQJ\_HaJmH sH DA@òÿ¡D Default Paragraph FontRióÿ3R0Table Normalö4Ö l4Öaö(kôÿÁ( 0No List\@ò\ +Xé0 Footnote Textdð¤CJOJPJQJ^J_HaJJþ¢J+Xé0 Char Char2CJOJPJQJ^J_HaJ@&@¢@ +Xé0Footnote ReferenceH*>@">}p0Headerdð¤ÆH$.þO¢1.}p0 Char Char1> B> }p0Footerdð¤ÆH$,þ¢Q,}p0 Char CharJþ¢aJé}û Char Char5CJOJPJQJ^J_HaJ.)@¢q.΋Page Numbero×S#&CS>ÿÿÿÿ;>ÿÿÿÿ*@AK õ£æ¤ ́μ¿y ï/?
Cmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~€‚ ̃TMš›œžŸ ¡¢£¤¥¦§ ̈©a«¬® ̄°±23 ́μ¶ÆÊËÌÍÎÏÐÑÒÓÔÕÖרÙÚÛÜÝÞßàáâãäåæçèéêëìíîïðñòóôõö "#%&/01<=>?PQT ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃ 0€€ ̃ 0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€ 77777777777:1 dμ o4 S¿ r¢Íé/SR :!•!ÿ•€ð¤ðp4 #ð†AÅA@ñÿÿÿ€€€÷ð'ðð0ð( ð ððB ðSð¿Ëÿ ?ðQ^hr7 ? ¿ Ä Å Ë Ì Î ̄μoËÑŠ?BÆÉö "#%&QTa€ù 36?BoÅÆÉö "#%&QT333333\ceó÷> _ £ 3 ¿ Ë é ý X Y o o w z 16L]Þá8 > R Ý é é GK·2Ðõö "#%&.
1;<OOPPTö "#%&QT3⁄4'@Gsÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿß$2^îˆlÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ„8„ ̃þÆ8^„8`„ ̃þ.„ „ ̃þÆ ^„ `„ ̃þ.„p„ ̃þÆp^„p`„ ̃þ.„@„ ̃þÆ@^„@`„ ̃þ.„„ ̃þÆ^„`„ ̃þ.„à„ ̃þÆà^„à`„ ̃þ. „°„ ̃þư^„°`„ ̃þ.„€„ ̃þÆ€^„€`„ ̃þ.„P„ ̃þÆP^„P`„ ̃þ.„„ÈûÆ^„`„Èûo(.€ „„ ̃þÆ^„`„ ̃þ‡hˆH.‚ „Ø „LÿÆØ ^„Ø `„Lÿ‡hˆH.€ „ ̈„ ̃þÆ ̈^„ ̈`„ ̃þ‡hˆH.€ „x„ ̃þÆx^„x`„ ̃þ‡hˆH.‚ „H„LÿÆH^„H`„Lÿ‡hˆH.€ „„ ̃þÆ^„`„ ̃þ‡hˆH.€ „è„ ̃þÆè^„è`„ ̃þ‡hˆH.‚ „ ̧„LÿÆ ̧^„ ̧`„Lÿ‡hˆH.3⁄4'üÜ` ß$2^ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿbrš ,Ö @ @ @ @ @ @ @ @/M_)nCsh=Q+åÒ ̄UeˆR9Y¥z{‰vÐqÇ=HÇV§ohx‚Ù9NH ËY ˆ} ? V Ì` e} μ.
"›+fYKõlÌ/ÑmRYZ ̈D^ðyîad~a/)Kó‡Ké~Øw'v0+RÙ g Ñ!{]!{7#Ý$$"$M4$&!S&·'](ïT( ^(Ñ~(¡))LB)Æ;*Õi*%7,ÊG,mb.†=."c.1m.š/êO/<0\Y0Ìb0Ak0ò1-2=*2.C3ÚD31⁄2S3Ú]3Å>4RG4xI596ß063⁄4B6%27" 9»G9æg9`:";»c;Ín;Ez;Z.<3</=á=9!=eL=Ý> ̄[>p`> <@?Y_?ux??A"zA›yD€)EŽF§GÙ4GO=GHûHÿHˆKHrH/{H. I? WI~YIÿJ(JW,Je_JoJFKnK`pK»|KM0M,M)MM•N0N:pN†MPtPP0DRETò"T1KT ̄UÔGUÙVD;V©~VéWËpXvZ[i=[qJ[Óc[ÿz[âF\oe\&]§u]Î^Q^ o^å*a%kaêoarpa€bmb/bÜ9bTMXbˆcÅ#cËmc©dŒ(dAdŸPdŒe0eveì1eÐ;e¡Ne©rae4«šM›`‰®L@®†G®3k®E4 ̄YB°·j°4{°s ±Š,±¦k±... G2r$3;3Y ́}` ́!j ́•¶we¶o¶ ̃q¶Õ}¶7·AS·ÇS·1M1L1÷U1lFoIfo » » »#<»<1⁄2"3⁄4Õ43⁄4[F3⁄4ß¿Tm¿È>ÀOsÁTQÃ]\ÃÄŽ`ÄMmĈ|ÄÅ1ÅSmÅ| ÆA*ÇÀ7ÇÒ>Ç"È6 Éí@É^ÉC)Ê@Ê1⁄4aÊ×yÊ?ˆGË1⁄4bËÌ›;ÌÔhÌ8Í ̧ÍÉwÍÓÍ1!Îá>ÏwÏ¿gÐo!Ñã'ÑöJÑJOÑ€}ÑéÒ ÒÊnÒ›[Ô0kÕ¥wÕÐI×Þ^×Xg×ùtØ?
ÙBTÚ bÚ¡uÚÍÛ æxmæqçoçpoç3èJ é3Oé+Xéç{éÒéñêúëf8ëŸEëwì5^íœ`íeîuaî7ïONïzqï#rïöñ7;ñE]ñ(uñò)uòó†>óFô/Uõ,|õÛ=ö>Wö cöç÷6_÷nu÷ | ÷|EøH}ø ̃+ùÇ;ùòiúNBûYEûé}ûä7ü=ný¶xÿKM õú¢£¤æ ́ ̃öTY0Y0aTaTY0Y0Y0Y0}¬Y0Y0ÿ@€;zS@@ÿÿUnknownÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿGï:àAxÀ ÿTimes New Roman5€Symbol3&ÿ:àCxÀ ÿArialA&‡ŸTrebuchet MS7&ï { @ŸCalibriK,‡ŸBookman Old Style"1ˆðÐh‰[#GÂÚ5g+5G.4®H 3f qðppn ́‚4í>ƒQðüýHX ðÿ$Päÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ+Xé2ÿÿ HONOURABLE DruserESTTþÿà...ŸòùOh«'+'3Ù0t ̃°1⁄4ÌØè ø $0< HT\dläHONOURABLE DruserNormalESTT46Microsoft Office Word@86ÊN@ú€g‡Ð@jVY=Ï@ÈGt> ̃ЮHþÿÕÍÕœ."-+,ù®0hpˆ ̃ ̈° ̧À ÈâäWipro Limited íæHONOURABLE DrTitle þÿÿÿ!"#$%&'þÿÿÿ)*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?
@AþÿÿÿCDEFGHIþÿÿÿKLMNOPQþÿÿÿýÿÿÿTþÿÿÿþÿÿÿþÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ Entryÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÀFÀ['> ̃ÐV€Data ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ 1Tableÿÿÿÿ(2WordDocumentÿÿÿÿv>SummaryInformation(ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿBDocumentSummaryInformation8ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿJCompObjÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ ÀFMicrosoft Office Word Document MSWordDocWord.Document.