← Library
High Court for State of TelanganaCRLP/2158/2015dismissed

Songa Yesu, v. State Of Andhra Pradesh,

2015-04-24C.Praveen Kumar2 pages

ÐÏ​ࡱ​á>​þÿ ​H​J​þÿÿÿGÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ​ð​¿​,​bjbjqPqP ​;:​:​:​Ô​2%ÿÿ​ÿÿ​ÿÿ​¤​&​&​&​:​b​b​b​8š​Læ​$:​#​è​"8​8​8​8​8​8​¢​¤​¤​¤​¤​¤​¤​$​h​s​~È​&​8​8​È​&​&​8​8​Ý​C​C​C​&​8​&​8​¢​C​¢​C​C​n​&​&​o​8 ​@ÏêÓI ̃Ð​b​9​ʆ​†​ó​0#​Ž​,ñ​âñ​o​ñ​&​o​Ì​8​"Z​C​r​†​•8​8​8​È​È​å​^8​8​8​#​:​:​:​D​~​ä:​:​:​~​:​:​:​&​&​&​&​&​&​ÿÿÿÿ​THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE C. PRAVEEN KUMAR CRIMINAL PETITION No.2158 of 2015 ORDER : This petition is filed under Section 439(2) r/w 482 Cr.P.C. by the de facto complainant seeking cancellation of bail granted by this Court to the respondent Nos.2 to 4 herein, who are accused Nos.1 to 3 in Crime No.9 of 2015 of Darmajigudem Police Station. The said crime came to be registered against the respondent Nos.2 to 4 herein/accused Nos.

1 to 3 for the offences punishable under Sections 447, 427 r/w 34 I.P.C. and Section 3(1)(x) of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (for short, 'the Act'). By an order dated 09.02.2015, this Court granted anticipatory bail to the accused with certain conditions which is as follows: "Accordingly, the Criminal Petition is allowed and the petitioners are directed to surrender themselves before the Station House Officer, Dharmajigudem Police Station, West Godavari District, within a period of ten days from today and on such appearance, the petitioners shall be released on bail on their executing personal bonds for Rs.

10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand only) each with two sureties for a like sum each to the satisfaction of the same Station House Officer and on a further condition that they shall report before the said Station House Officer, once in a week for a period of six weeks." The present petition is filed seeking cancellation of the anticipatory bail granted to the respondent Nos.2 to 4 herein/accused Nos.1 to 3 on the ground that in view of the bar under Section 18 of the Act, the Court ought not to have entertained the petition under Section 438 Cr.P.C. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent Nos.2 to 4/accused Nos.1 to 3 submits that the accused have not violated any of the conditions imposed while granting bail to them and as such the question of cancelling the bail already granted would not arise.

A perusal of the averments in the First Information Report would show that on the date of incident, i.e., on 06.01.2015, while the son of the informant and one Sudershan were watering their lands, the respondent Nos.2 to 4 herein, who are accused Nos.1 to 3, are alleged to have gone there, abused them by touching their caste and also threatened them to spoil the land by spraying weeds removal pesticide sand on the land. The First Information Report would further show that all the accused in one voice and at one time are alleged to have abused the informant by using same words. While interpreting the provisions of Section 3(1)(x) of the Act vis-à-vis the object of the Act, a learned single Judge of Delhi High Court in Mukesh Kumar Saini and others v.

State (Delhi Administration)​ observed as under: "The basic ingredients of the offence under clause (x) of Sub-section (1) of Section 3 of the SC/ST Act are: a) that there must be an "intentional insult" or "intimidation" with "intend" to humiliate SC/ST member by a non-SC/ST member; (b) and that insult must have been done in any place within the "public view". The use of expression "intentional insult or intimidation" with "intention" to humiliate, makes it abundantly clear that the means read is an essential ingredient of the offence and it must also be established that the accused had the knowledge that the victim is the SC/ST and that the offence was committed for that reason. Merely calling a person by caste would not attract the provisions of this Act. There must be a specific accusation alleged against each of the accused.

Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code cannot be pressed into service. Omnibus statement that all the accused persons uttered allegedly humiliating word may not be enough. This being a penal provision has to be given a strict interpretation. If any of the ingredient is found lacking, it would not constitute the offence...." From the judgment referred to above, it is clear that abusing the informant in chorus without any specific role would not attract the provisions of Section 3(1)(x) of the Act. Similarly, this Court in S.Venkata Lakshmamma Vs.

State of Andhra Pradesh​, while dealing with the bar under Section 18 of the Act, held as under: "Though Section 18 of the SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989 enacts a bar against granting anticipatory bail if an offence is committed under any of the provisions of SC/ST(POA) Act, in the instant case, it cannot be said that the petitioner committed the offence punishable under Section 3(i)(x) of the Act. Each and every dispute in respect of every Schedule Caste or Schedule Tribe member with non schedule caste or non schedule tribe member, cannot be brought under the ambit of Section 3(i)(x) of the Act." Except the offence punishable under Section 3(1)(x) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, all other offences are bailable.

In view of the judgments referred to above and having regard to the circumstances of the case, I see no reasons to cancel the anticipatory bail granted to respondent Nos.2 to 4 herein/accused Nos.1 to 3. Further, it is not the case of the petitioner that the respondent Nos.2 to 4/accused Nos.1 to 3 have violated conditions of bail. Accordingly, the Criminal Petition is dismissed. _________________________ JUSTICE C. PRAVEEN KUMAR 24th April, 2015 siva ​ 2001 Crl.L.J. 4587 2014(2)ALT(Crl.)224(A.P.) ​ ​ ​ ​ ​PAGE ​ ​PAGE ​3​ ​(​)​>​B​K​L​Q​U​W​à​ü​ 5 f ï×Ê1⁄2Ê2 ï'‚sdUF7​h​i​h;J¿OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h​'ìOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h​Y​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hH​îOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h!"êOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hQ​†OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hÙ0​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​"​h​i​hÙ0​5 ​nH ​sH ​tH ​h​i​hÙ0​5​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​)​K​L​T​| } ý X Y w​x​ˆ​‰​Ó​Ô​1​÷íèãÛÓÛÀÛÛ ̧Û°Û ̈​ ​$​dà​a$​gd]​Ê​$​a$​gd]​Ê​$​a$​gd8?

​$​a$​gdj​â​$​„Ð​„Ð​dh​] „Ð​^„Ð​a$​gd​ø​$​a$​gd8bÒ​$​dà​a$​dà​gd¡P​ ​dð​¤ðgd¿2O​$​dà​a$​Ô​+​ýýý​f ˆ ¥ ¬ · ã c z { | } ~ ​ š § ̄ è ô ü ý ñâÓâÓÄμ¦- ˆ¦yjâ[L=L¦​h​i​hH"ðOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h​(?

OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hï9​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hHNÛOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hÞ​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h8bÒOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hQ​†OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h`@"OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hÂOoOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h​aäO þ (​P​V W o ​ ​?​D​v​w​x​y​€​1⁄2​Ø​ñâÓÄñμ¦- ˆyjμ[L[=.​h​i​hgQ​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h‡2æOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hâU​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hj​âOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h*0​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hR​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h"vDOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hçhMOJ​PJ​Q ́​IOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h​(?

OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hÈkÊOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h​m÷OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h2"]OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h​zHOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​Ø​â​5​‡​ˆ​‰​Š​¬​Å​Õ​&​N​ ​%​(​0​3​ñâÓÄμ¦μμˆyj[L[L[=​h​i​h '​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​ht/​h​i​hh]0OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​hvBmOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​hîGoOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​hgxsOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​hX​{OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​hQA OJ​QJ​\​]​h"NûCJ​OJ​QJ​\​]​aJ​háVlCJ​OJ​QJ​\​]​aJ​h6U3CJ​OJ​QJ​\​]​aJ​hÎA1CJ​OJ​QJ​\​]​aJ​h​f€CJ​OJ​QJ​\​]​aJ​h¬):CJ​OJ​QJ​\​]​aJ​h`vÉCJ​OJ​QJ​\​]​aJ​h0%ÁCJ​OJ​QJ​\​] /†CJ​OJ​QJ​\​]​aJ​1​Ê​]​R​T​U​ý​þ​M​€​›​ ́​Æ​Ç​êÙÙÑÉ1⁄2 ́1⁄2 ́¦ "​‰„​gd K​ Æ​j​$​a$​$​ Æ​P​dð​a$​„μ​`„μ ​„@​dà​¤ð`„@​gd​i​„@​dà​`„@​„@​dð​`„@​gd=;+​$​a$​gdC?o​dh​gd​{:​$​„Ð​dà​¤ð`„Ð​a$​gdh]0​$​„Ð​„Ð​dh​¤ð] „Ð​^„Ð​a$​gdƒ"​ã​)​-​]​3​À​Å​Ò​Ù​R​T​U​ü​ý​þ​Ê​ëÐÁμÁ ̈ž ̈ž ̈" ̈...

uh]TG7​h​i​h​i​CJ​OJ​QJ​aJ​o(​h=;+CJ​OJ​QJ​aJ​o(​h=;+OJ​QJ​o(​h​i​h=;+OJ​QJ​h​i​h=;+OJ​QJ​^J​h=;+​h=;+CJ​OJ​QJ​^J​o(​h​i​hˆMìOJ​PJ​QJ​^J​hfk#OJ​QJ​aJ​hÐYêO @sH @​h​9‹​j​h​9‹0J​U​h​i​hÙ0​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h K​H*​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​h K​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​i​hÙ0​5​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​#​h​i​hÙ0​5​CJ​OJ​QJ​^J​aJ​#​h​i​hÙ0​CJ​OJ​QJ​^J​aJ​o( ​h​i​hÙ0​CJ​OJ​QJ​^J​aJ​h​i​hQgÈCJ​OJ​QJ​aJ​o(​h​i​hÙ0​CJ​OJ​QJ​aJ​o(​h​i​h​i​CJ​OJ​QJ​aJ​o(​hÍ QCJ​OJ​QJ​aJ​o(​Ç​Ì​Í​Î​Ï​Ð​Ñ​Ò​Ó​Ô​é ​(​)​*​ýýýõõõõõõðëýýýýýýýýýâàýâàý​„üÿ​„​&`#$​gdh]0​gd:U×​$​dh​a$​è​é​ê​ ​ ​$​%​&​'​(​*​+​,​õëçãÛãÛãÛãÛãÑËÑËçÑËÑÀÑËçã±​h​i​hÙ0​OJ​PJ​QJ​^J​h​(Ò0J​mH​nH​u​ ​h​9‹0J​j​h​9‹0J​U​j​h›​2U​h›​2​h​9‹​j​h​9‹0J​U​h"2 ​h​9‹mH @sH @​*​+​,​ýõ​$​dh​a$​9 0​&P​1​h​:p"​N​°Ò/ °ÃN!

°p​"°p​#​p​$​p​%°​°Å​°Å​Ä​†​œ​@@ñÿ​@​Normal​CJ​_H​aJ​mH @sH @tH @V​@​V​ Heading 1​$​$​dà​@&a$​5​>*​OJ​PJ​QJ​aJ​DA@òÿ¡D​Default Paragraph FontVióÿ3V​Table Normal :V​ö​4Ö​4Ö​ ​laö​(kôÿÁ(​No List​RB@​òR​ Body Text​$​dh​a$​CJ​OJ​QJ​mH ​sH ​tH ​J​@​J​ Footnote Text​CJ​aJ​mH ​sH ​tH ​@&@¢​@​Footnote Reference​H*​4​@​"​4​Header ​ Æ​9​r ​.)@¢1​.​Page NumberJ>@​B​J​Title​$​dà​a$​5​CJ​OJ​PJ​QJ​aJ​tC@​R​t​Body Text Indent​$​„Ð​dh​`„Ð​a$​#CJ​OJ​PJ​QJ​aJ​mH ​o(​sH ​tH ​NP@​b​N​Body Text 2​$​dà​a$​OJ​PJ​QJ​aJ​nT@​r​n​ Block Text!

​$​„@​„@​7$8$H$]„@​^„@​a$​6​OJ​QJ​]​aJ​mH ​sH ​tH ​<þO¢​<​°U, Char Char​_H​mH ​sH ​tH ​¤ ​,​14,​:​ÿÿÿÿ)KLT|​}​ý​X​Y​w​x​ˆ​‰​Ó Ô 1 ​Ê​]​R​T​U​ý​þ​M​€​›​ ́​Æ​Ç​Ì​Í​Î​Ï​Ð​Ñ​Ò​Ó​Ô​é​ ​(​)​*​- ̃0€€​0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃​0€€ ̃0€€ ̃​0€€ ̃​0€€ ̃​0€€ ̃​0€€ ̃​0€€ ̃​0€€ ̃​0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€€ ̃0€ ​$$$$$'​f ý Ø​3​ë​ã​Ê​è​,​1​Ç​*​,​+​ '​!•​!​ÿ•€ÿÿ​ê¢X​¬T!​ë¢X​¬V!​ ​ -​" " -​8​*€urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags​€City€9​*€urn:schemas-microsoftcom:office:smarttags​€place€​l​‰​9​E​‡​"​a​2​o​u​*​3​g m t y ã​ì​í​÷​s​t​?​@​ó​û​Ç​Ë​Ô​Û​â​ö​ù​ ​ ​*​-​LS​ Ö​à​1​»​ø​ú​@​B​„​†​/​Ç​Ë​Ô​ ​ ​*​-​3​3​3​3​3​3​3​3​3​è​ô​v​v​5​i​o​S​T​M​s​} ́​3⁄4​Æ​Ç​È​Ë​Ó​ ​ ​'​-​Ô​ ​ ​*​-​ê!†​ÂC​Oÿ​ÿ​ÿ​ÿ​ÿ​ÿ​ÿ​ÿ​ÿ​„ ​„0ý​Æ​ ​^„ ​`„0ýo(​)​€​„​„ ̃þ​Æ​^„​`„ ̃þ​.​‚​„Ø ​„Lÿ​Æ​Ø ​^„Ø `„Lÿ​.

​€​„ ̈​„ ̃þ​Æ​ ̈​^„ ̈​`„ ̃þ​.​€​„x​„ ̃þ​Æ​x​^„x​`„ ̃þ​.​‚​„H​„Lÿ​Æ​H​^„H​`„Lÿ​. €​„​„ ̃þ​Æ​^„​`„ ̃þ​.​€​„è​„ ̃þ​Æ​è​^„è​`„ ̃þ​.​‚​„ ̧​„Lÿ​Æ​ ̧​^„ ̧​`„Lÿ​.​ê!†​ÿÿÿÿÿÿ​ÿÿ​FCŠš​ ​ ​ ​ ​ ​ ​ ​ ​í​åì£"​Us​6​3E​mM​Cu​ð​...L​Y​QA ​¡P​Ô]​Ýl​U​*0​d​i​P​Þ​8?​:D​D​÷b​R​ï9​Är​H)​°6​}V​qm​'​ƒ"​gQ​ K​Ù0​p Hh RV":s"fk#C​%~6&ë:'​(z()Ck*=;+°U,/4.​W.h]0Ç?1›​2±475I7íb7š 8...58<_8Û 9Ï​9¬):3G:_h:​{:​y;Ë"=​?​(?•​BçjC ̃​D"vD@+E3⁄4#F​zH ́​Iæ I8{LçhM"​NÆ)N​5N¿2OŽKPÍ Q1 RQMS1⁄4zTo VècVÓpV©​X•​Z2"]​r_|​`FY`8\`ókc¡​il)jÁQÀ0%Á​{Á/[éQÄfbÄbeÅ(DÆ​bÆQgÈ+]É9qÉ`vÉ]​ÊzNÊÈkÊ[7ËR_Ï​(Ò8bÒä​ÓäkÓr​Ôà​Õu​Õh+ÖšÖ¶;×:U×^?ÙHNÛ%}ÛX​ÝÌcÝj​â8Iâ}DãÑ'äÄFä​aä‡2æ!"

êÐYê​5ë​'ì{7ìˆMìH​îw ïH"ð ̄(ñŠ ò<​ò}qòý,ó​m÷"​ø​ø-Hø"Nû​Jü°Wü>sü​'ý​ÿ​:ÿ1 ü​-​"​"​ÿ@​€​S​S​h+Ë​S​S​,​@​@ÿÿ​Unknownÿÿ​ÿÿ​ÿÿ​ÿÿÿÿ​ÿÿ​G​ï:àAxÀ ÿ​Times New Roman5​€Symbol3&​ÿ:àCxÀ ÿ​ArialA&​‡​ŸTrebuchet MSm&​†​‡​€R<Ï(​Microsoft YaHei UIMicrosoft YaHei5&​€​UtsaahK​,​‡​ŸBookman Old Style"​1​ˆ​ðÐ​h​›2‡​Û5gc›5G+​»​1​ ​%​1​ %q​ð​p​p ́ ́​4Ê​Ê​2ƒað​Ü​HP​ðÿ​?ä​ÿÿÿ​ÿÿÿ​ÿÿÿ​ÿÿÿ​ÿÿÿ​ÿÿÿ​ÿÿÿ​H)​2ÿÿ​THE HON​ BLE SRI JUSTICE C Administrator​SIVA​þÿ​à...ŸòùOh​«'​+'3Ù0ˆ​ ̃​1⁄4​È​à​ì​ü ​ 8​D​P \​h​p​x​€​ä​THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE C​Administrator​Normal​SIVA​299​Microsoft Office Word@"¤​@ž®€ 'Ð​@​1| LÐ​@î​ÅI ̃Ð​1​þÿ​ÕÍÕœ.​"-​+,ù®0​h​p​ˆ​ ̃​ ​ ̈​°​ ̧​À È​î​ä​Wipro Limited​%​ ​Ê​æ​THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE C​Title​ ​ ​þÿÿÿ​ !"#$%þÿÿÿ'()*+,- .

<=>þÿÿÿ@ABCDEFþÿÿÿýÿÿÿIþÿÿÿþÿÿÿþÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ Entry​ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ​ ​ÀF0ŠïÓI ̃Ð​K€Data ​ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ​1Table​ÿÿÿÿ&

WordDocument​ÿÿÿÿ;:​SummaryInformation(​ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ7​DocumentSummaryInformation8​ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ?​CompObj​ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿqÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ÿÿÿÿ​ ​ÀF​Microsoft Office Word Document MSWordDoc​Word.Document.8ô92q