Jadavjibhai Lalji Shah And ORS v. The State Of Maharashtra And ANR




  


  





  WRIT PETITION NO. 1632 OF 2021

     !

!!!"##$%" !

&" '

 "##"$(  # %$# "!

!!

" )$%"%# !

!* $! %+,#-$.#"($"##$%"!

 !!! #"-($ " )$%"%#/##"!

!* $ %0 12 3"-$.#"($ " )$%"%#$!4!

 5 !& 

!! *-

!

 Date : April 22, 2022.

!!5 6!

 "%$.#$%$("7#/$%8' .#$%$(#  $'# '%"#.

"449$(# "$% ##'#$%$(
% ,"

 '%" ".#$%:;4$( "$"$(3% $."'"-<=;>  $'2 #($8# ")"##$%" #$ ?'  #
%($3#$% ")$#"2 #""2% ## "3#'

'%$ ."

##$%-"%23"$!4@@$(4A4A$%# "

"2#$%$(.$33 $%$( $B"%.")'%  "'%" ".#$%:4A",# >:$(# "
%%"% $"

% ".#$%:$(# "  # ,%"

)$(

# .#C "2'

#$%$(# $3$#$%$($% #'.#$%- "-%2"3"%#%% ("D.#-<=9>!

E!

%%'#

-# ". "%# 2% ## ""##$%"  # ' %$(# ".

% / #"".

%'

  $$+"."#%F# %# $' %2)$".#$()"##$%" -% ) ."#%3$'%##$, # ")'.

 "$(# $ "F# - $,""-# ")"##$%"

1 / 4 SACHIN RAMCHANDRA PATIL SACHIN RAMCHANDRA PATIL Date: 2022.05.04 12:27:21 +0530

" )#"".")#$(.$% "#$%($3# #"".

%'

 $" #$"8# "$ 2#$% %#$2")$ " $%$(# "2""F# !

%2("

#"('"## % $()"##$%" -#  $'2 $,"$(##$%"8$ "! "% - " )$%"%#$!4 ""%G " " '".#  #
%($3#$% ")$#C D2% ## ")"##$%" !

H!

"%".$'% "

))"%2$%"

($(" )".#")#"

'3##"# ")"##$%" % " )$%"%#%$!4 "%$, "## "# "  )'#" %"%#""%#$.$% "%##"3 -  '. " )$%"%#$!4%$3$"

,%# #$)$ ".'#"# ")"##$%" %# " '".# ! ".$'% "

('# '3##"# #%",$( '.

 "## "3"%#"#"#,""%# ")#" -# )" "%#)"##$% G "($?' %2# " '".# 8.$% "%#$(

" )$%"%#$!4!

I!

")" "%#)"##$%-$2% .$3) %%#-%3"

8- #   ,"

  " )$%"%#$!4J "% "G "# " ")#"K# 2%2%$$".#$% #"<; '

8-4A4A, , ""%# "8

"%'

8 ##"# #%# #$(.$% "%##"3 "%#""%#$# )#" -# "8 "%$$".#$%($?' %2# " '".# 2% ## )"##$%" !

L!

" )$%"%#$!4J "%  )" $%

8)" "%# "($"# "$'#! % )".G.?'"83"8' - " '3##"# # 3"# " K#$%  $,%("",

-,# $'## """%2%8)" '"

$'%'"%F'"%."!"  ('# ".$%G3"# #  %$$".#$%($ ?' %2# %?'" #$%% ##'#"#  % #%."2% ## ")"##$%"

2 / 4

($# "$B"%.")'%  "'%" ".#$%:4A",# >:$(# "
%%"%

$"% ".#$%:$(# "  # ,%"

)$(

# .#C "2'

#$%$( "$3$#$%$($% #'.#$%- "-%2"3"%#%% ("D.#-<=9>!

M!

))"%# 8-# " )'#" )'"

8$(. %#'"%#.%-"

("

8 # "3##"  ""%3. 8 "## ""#,""%# ")#" !

$3# ")"'  $(.$3) %#-##% )" # "

"2#$% "#$#

)" $% %%#'"! "" %$"

"3"%#$()' . ,%$ "%# ".3"!

 "$B"%."

"2".%%$#" #$ "%83).#$%# " $."#8! )#"  " "## "# "3##"-8"%#"%2%#$.$% "%##"3 , .

"

#"%""%# " )$.""%2 ! ".$3)$3 "".$ # "8 "%$ 2'2"2% #".

$# "%# ".$3) %%#   )".G.

82""#

 %$$".#$%(# %?'" #$% ?' "! # "$2%

.$3) %%#% " )$%"%#$!4$%$#%#"%#$)$."",# )$ ".'#$%$()"##$%" -$%# #  # " '3 $%$(# ")"##$%"  ".$%#%'%."$()$ ".'#$%%# "($"  ,

"('# "7". "%3"", #2"$()".$' #3"$(# "$'# ,"

 %" #2#%22"%." !

N!

#$($"(.# / #'#$%%" )".

8%",$( , $,%8# ")"7$'#%# ". "$( %$ %$# !

##"$('%-OC4AA;D:P;4Q-,"G%# #%$)')$ ",$'

" "" 8+"")%2#  "-"7.")#'

#3#"

8'"%%2# "3% $'# , .

" "8$"'"%"!1""$(# "",# #%# ".+$)$( "($" ##"(.#/ #'#$%-# ".$%#%'#$%$()$ ".'#$%$(# )"##$%" %# "% #%#. "0 ,

3$'%##$# "' "$()$." $( 3 / 4

$'#%# ""($"# %# "G#%" $(# %2 #$?' " '".# % $"#$ ".'"# ""% $(' #."!1""%#$# 2""3"%#,# '3 $%$( "%"$'% "

))"%2($# "" )".#")#" # .$%#%'#$%$()$ ".'#$%0 %# "% #%#. ",

"%"7". "% ('# #8%' #."%# ". ""3% # " )'#""#,""%# ")#"

 )'##$%"%%)"." " #$"!

R!

#$()%.) "  $,%8# ")"7$'#%# ($" ". $% ,"

 %# ". "$(%"%2  !##"$('% O4A<:
14A9PQ ,""$(# ".$% """,# "" %$ 3)"3"%#%?' %2# %?'" #$%!..$%2 8-,#)"##$%

$,"%#"3 $()8".

' "CD!$,""-,"G%#,$'

"%# G#%" $(# %2 #$  "# ""##$%" ,# ".$ #$( !@P-AAA0/".

- , .

")#$STata Memorial Hospital, MumbaiT%% ##'#$% ##+" ."$(# "%."%#"3%

8

.%.")#"%# !

U!

$# "?' 3"%##$#+""B".#-# ")"##$%" 

)8# .$ # %)$'."# "".")# # ""$($%# "G "$(#  $'#,# %# )"$$(G",""+ ($3#$8!  %2#$)8.$ # %)$'."".")# ,# %# " #)'

#"#3"-# ")"##$%

 #% 3 "'#$3#.

,# $'#('# ""(""%."#$# "$'#%# "$"?' %2)$.""%2 0

"#"#" %$%/" #!

[S. M. Modak, J.] [Prasanna B. Varale, J.] 4 / 4