The Conservator Of Forests And ANR. v. Chandrabhan Vithoba Jadhav
pdp
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO.6229 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4193 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 49 OF 2018 Conservator of Forests & Anr.
.. Appellants Chandrabhan Vithoba Jadhav .. Respondent LETTERS PATENET APPEAL STAMP NO. 3685 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4190 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 50 OF 2018 Conservator of Forests & Anr.
.. Appellants Kalu Deoram Bhangare .. Respondent LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 5649 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4762 OF 2011 CIVLL APPLICATION NO. 51 OF 2018 Pravin Dasharath Pandit by Pravin Dasharath Pandit Date: 2018.07.13 15:36:06 +0530 Deputy Conservator of Forest & Anr.
.. Appellants Yashwant Laxman Basre .. Respondent
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 3113 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4308 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 52 OF 2018 Conservator of Forest & anr.
.. Appellants Sawaliram Pandurang Sapte .. Respondent LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6163 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4316 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 53 OF 2018 Conservator of Forest & anr.
.. Appellants Kisan Deoji Karwande .. Respondent LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 8646 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4166 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 54 OF 2018 .. Appellants Hari P. Warghade .. Respondent LETTERS PATENET APPEAL STAMP NO. 8751 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4249 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 55 OF 2018 .. Appellants Yewaji Ladya Pawar .. Respondent
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 8761 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4163 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 56 OF 2018 Popat Namdeo Karwande .. Respondent LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6202 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4162 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 57 OF 2018 Shrawan S. Nirgude LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 8773 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4165 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 58 OF 2018 .. Appellants Laxman M. Nirgude .. Respondent LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6170 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 3938 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 59 OF 2018 .. Appellants Damu Bala Jadhav
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6236 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4289 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 60 OF 2018 .. Appellants Annaji L. Aware .. Respondent LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 3681 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4311 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 61 OF 2018 Shivram S. Kakade LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 8572 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4170 OF 2011 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 62 OF 2018 .. Appellants Sukhdeo N. Mengal LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6137 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4171 OF 2011 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 63 OF 2018 State of Maharashtra through Dy. Conservator of Forest ..Appellant Ramdas Mohan Awad
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 3121 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4250 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 64 OF 2018 Abaji Tulshiram Gavali LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 3693 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4192 OF 2002 CIVIL APPPLICATION NO. 65 OF 2018 Janu Sajgaran Ghatal LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6243 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4185 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 66 OF 2018 Raghunath Dagadu Bhusare LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 8659 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4188 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 67 OF 2018 Hiraman Vithhal Bhoye
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6331 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4169 OF 2011 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 68 OF 2018 State of Maharashtra through Dy. Conservator of Forest ..Appellant Kisan R. Mengal LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6325 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4671 OF 2011 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 69 OF 2018 State of Maharashtra through Dy. Conservator of Forest ..Appellant Yamraj Kushaba Jadhav LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6184 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4242 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 70 OF 2018 .. Appellants Ramdas S. Rathod .. Respondent LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 4985 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4819 OF 2003 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 71 OF 2018 chandar Vithhal Pimpalake
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO.6309 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4147 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 72 OF 2018 Govind Baburao Bendkule LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 8782 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4309 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 73 OF 2018 Amruta R. Bhangare LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 4968 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4315 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 74 OF 2018 Hiraman R. Chaudhari LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6220 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 3944 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 75 OF 2018 Rambhau Suka Lande
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO.5004 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO.4248 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 76 OF 2018 Shivram N. More LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6318 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4184 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 77 OF 2018 Pandurang K. Gawande LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 8667 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4310 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 78 OF 2018 Balu R. Shingade LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6209 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4189 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 79 OF 2018 Khandu B. Kadali
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 1507 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 3662 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 80 OF 2018 Dy. Secretary, Rural Development & Water Conservation Dept. and ors.
Nashik Zilla Van Shramik Sangh LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 3675 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4142 OF 2002 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 81 OF 2018 Dy. Secretary and ors.
Nashik Zilla Van Shramik Sangh LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 6159 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4174 OF 2011 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 82 OF 2018 State of Maharashtra through Dy. Conservator of Forest ..Appellant Bhagwan G. Jadhav
LETTERS PATENT APPEAL STAMP NO. 5015 OF 2013 WRIT PETITION NO. 4698 OF 2011 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 83 OF 2018 Dy. Conservator of Forest and anr.
Yashwant Krishan Jadhav and ors.
..Respondents Mr. A. B. Vagyani, Govt. Pleader a/w Mr. P. P. More, AAGP for AppellantsState in all the matters. Mr. Hasan Patel I/by Ms. Seema Sarnaik for respondents in all the matters.
CORAM: NARESH H. PATIL & G. S. KULKARNI, JJ.
JULY 10, 2018.
P.C.
1.
We have heard the learned Govt. Pleader Mr. Vagyani, who has placed before us a copy of order dated 18/12/2017 passed by the Division Bench of this court (Coram :Smt. Vasanti A. Naik and Mr. Sarang V. Kotwal,JJ.) in Letters Patent Appeal No. 7 of 2017 along with connected matters, which is taken on record. The learned Govt. Pleader has also placed on record chart showing details of stages with remarks as to whether proposal in a case was forwarded or not, which is taken on record and
marked "X" for identification. There are 33 cases listed in the said chart. Out of these 33 cases, in 4 cases employees/workers were made permanent. In about 11 cases proposal was not forwarded. In the remaining 18 cases proposal was forwarded.
2.
We find that the facts dealt with by the Division Bench of this court in Letters Patent Appeal No. 7 of 2017 along with connected matters decided on 18/12/2017 are similar to the fact situation in the present appeals placed before us. We find that on similar lines and adopting the same reasoning, these appeals can be disposed of. 3.
We accordingly dismiss all the Letters Patent Appeals in terms of the order dated 18/12/2017 passed by the Division Bench of this Court in Letters Patent Appeal No. 7 of 2017 along with connected matters. The State Government shall undertake appropriate compliance of the order passed by the Industrial Court.
4.
All the Civil Applications do not survive and are disposed of. (G. S. KULKARNI J.) (NARESH H. PATIL,J.)