Pravin Maruti Patil And ORS. v. State Of Maharashtra And ANR.




  


  





 WRIT PETITION NO. 1240 OF 2022     !

"! #! $! !"%$$  $!

 #!( !)'"* !%" $!!

"!  +( ,-"()'"* !%" " .

 / #  !)%" 0  1  # 

   /)

 Date : April 22, 2022.

  1 $&!

"3 !''! * !..4"% $!" ""%
'5!

!* "67."% $!"'!"%8 "*!'!)9:;<!!(-

$!&"*!!'-"%8 !>!-  " 9?6<@,@.?97 &!'-" !"%!

"&"

-  !)A?

$" )#($"

)8> $!'&"*!!'-$!%"8  
%"8 " !&" B >!-8!" <<"%.?97!- !!'5 $ -"

*! ") 8>- "!" $!

""%*"88""%"D!*!

&$> !'!!* "6:7BC)6?4)<.<'A?6!'5 $<6"%
' ! "'! $!' !- !!' *!"% " .

!

"!" 9' " .-"

8!'"..

'

& ).?94&!' !'* "8  "!! by SACHIN RAMCHANDRA PATIL Date: 2022.05.04 16:10:13 +0530 1 / 5 SACHIN RAMCHANDRA PATIL

!

!"%!

"!" 9  %"  +) $!8 !'"!"

!

%" "-'-!! "8

& !&"*!!'-)* 5!

*8 '

$!&!! &"*!!'-"!"% $!8 !!'*"!

&&!-%" $!!&!* !& !

>8

&!'-  $!>"!&"*!!'- !$!)5 $

$!$!

&' !! ""%!

'! +&!" $!%8 +'5!

5$! 8*> +!

$!'& !'!' !

)'!5"%

!' ) $!&!! &!

"3 !'%"=$-"% $!>G!*

*8 &"*!!'-5 $!*"! " .) 5$"! *!

55& "8"

"  *! $!*"!

% $! >8

!$! !'+&&"*$!' 8 +" >+ -&!

"%"'"*!>+8  *"! )>!-!

""  @..64@.?..

5$*$&!'- 8 +"  ')8>
 $" ) " .$3 !'I' ' !'..

'

& ).?..)5$!!$!$ $!"

!!

!'*" - 5 &"!* ""% "! $!>G!* *8 *!

$!$% $! $!+$!'!*'!' "& $!5+'

$!!%"!5$ "& !' "

$!'& !&!'->!

$!8 $!

$"

!8 +I8!' $!5 $'5-

$!

"8'!

- "! $!' @*8 &"*!!'-' $!$ "">G!* "%"=$- @*8 *!>!-" " 9?6<@,@ .?97&!'-" !"%!

"&"

-  !)A?

$" )#($"

) 8> 2 / 5

J

" .&!"

+&!! >!%"! $!"   &!*3*=!+8'!>+)$!>8

$!$8'! $!'I'

"$!"5%!!5

)5 $" $!!>!-+&!!"'!K!*!

$!$% $!*"38!' $!$"">G!* "%"=$- @ *8 &"*!!'-=!

" !' $! *!- !

"!%" $!"D!*!&$> !'!!* "6:7BC)6?4)<.<'

A?6!'5 $<6"%
'! "'!)974?

L $!&!M"    "$  !"%+!&" !'

N
.??<9<74O$$!

'  $!!! "%!

"%8 8"

'& !) '!!* "6:7*>!=$!')!! $"-$ $!'

"D!*!"

*"8&"'> ! !8"%!* "<.?"% $!   $!

!

! ">! ""% $!&!M" !*" !'96'9A 5$*$!!&"'*!'$!!>!

"51 P2H $!!"'"> $!">G!* "% "'*- $& !QQ0*" -!* "6:7 $!
'!

"'!5 "&!! " ! "5"8>+$!$>'

">+!

!"%$!$>' !* "6:75''!'

5 $!5 "&$-$>''$!

!5$"

$" " ! $!5%! "*"!*!$!"$!!

! "

%+ 5% '!8'"%'"5+ $!$+&!0 !*$*

!55" '>!*" !&"'* !'5" '* -

 !!

"%5"8!'- $!">G!* %"5$*$ $ &""5''!' $!!!!+ (!

$""' "0 !M!*!"%$!! &"5! $!&"*!!'- "

8!!

$!!'"%G *!5" '&!! 5"8!%"8!

- ! ! $ "

$!">G!* "%$& !QQ"%
'!

"'!

3 / 5

2J
!5"% $!>"!'*")5!$"

' $!-$ " !M!*!"% $!! &"5!*=$*8

&"*!!'-" "*"8&  '!* "<.?"% "'!'"!"

8 "D!* $!&"5!'!!* "67.

"% $!"'! R 8 !5$>!! (!>+

!*$"% $" >$!>'"8!  !"%$$ N.??7BAC "% 64O  S *) $)>!!! $!8

!$>!!8*> +!

!'

>!

!  "8 $!&! "%*"8&  ) &!

"! "

+&!"  ! $!!"!

"%&> * 5 "

!' $!*8! $!"D!*!

!-!'*"

>!' "$!+8&*

" $!"*!

+ T $!& !$!!

$!8

!) $!+$!'!*'!' "

(!!&$8"+>!

$!8 "!> ! $!8 " !5 $&!*!' "!

$!*"8&"8!!*"' $!+$!"-'-!- !*$"

$!'

$!*"8&  $&!*3*

+-!!' $!$"">G!* "% =!

"=$!'   $!)>"

!$!'! (!"

"

' -!+ - "- !*$"

$!'5 $'5

$!*"8& 

&!'->!

!>!%"! $!*"  $!+'""

!' "

&"*!!'5 $+*8 *!- !*$"

$!)" > >8""% "! $!*" *!"%

&"*!!'- $!%"!'*!5

>!% !!M!*!'8!!5 -!

"%&!*" 8!"% $!*" 5!

!

- --!*!

4 / 5

U
 $!!**8 *!)'!&!*

+)!5"% 5 '

'"5>+ $!&!M"  $!*!"% '"$>>"

  !"% G>)NB.??7C6A7.O)5!3' "&&"!5" '>!!!'>+ (!!&- &"*!!'-&!'-!M*!& 

8 +>'!- 8 " 5$*$! !'+"!>'!!' ,!!"% $!!5

$!>*('"&"% $!%"!

!'%* 0  ") $!*"  ""% &"!* ""%&!

"!  *!5

8" ">!"% &"*!"%" ' $!!%"!  !"% $- >G!* *8 &"*!!'-"'! "!*! $!!'"%G *! ,!! -!!8! 5 $!>8""% !!'"!

&&!-%" !&!* !& ! *"  ""%*8 &"*!!'- 

*!5

>!!M!*!% +'G *! $!*!'!8' '& !>!

!& "!''&!*!!

"!'

2V
 -$ $!&*& ! ''"5>+ $!&!M"  %"!''!*"5!

 $!*!"%'!-$  !"%G> N.?96
,.?4AO 5!!"% $!*"'!!'!5 $!!"

8&!'8! =$- &"*!!'-=!

" **"'- +) 5 &!

"

"5!' !8"%&+!* !BC ""'! "*"

[S. M. Modak, J.] [Prasanna B. Varale, J.] 5 / 5