Pankaj S/O Devidas Chute And ORS v. The State Of Maharashtra And ANR
WRIT PETITION NO. 1248 OF 2022
! ! "
# ###!
# %"
!!$& " !"'$! "# ## !
# # )!% * $ +&$"! !
# "#,#%# !-&$"! !.!!# "# )+# "+)"&$" !$#/# 0 #% '
## ,-
# Date : May 2, 2022.
##0 1# ! ("2
! !! " *2 3*+ !!+2!$&
( ! *!)! ("!
-! (" !)"
!(!
4+ *5! (!
$ 6! "
3!
$$&!
$ "! ""!
3+//7$&! $ ! !
$$&
)++ 3!
$89/$&! $ $&"
"$3 "-:;<=- 6!$> ! 4"
&$"2!
$"($"!*"
6 $# :/8$&/?:9"6
!" ! + $+ 3!!
$- )++ ! 3$ > !
+3"
6-2+5-
"
+ $#9?=$& /?:9(
6$! 4+$&
6- #
* "6
!" !! !3$& !$#/ " $! ++6!
3$22
$$&$@3 (
*+ " 3!
=?<-8;9-=/=-A?8
A?7" ! =8$&!
-:97?# B# $"$#: !$#/"!
by SACHIN RAMCHANDRA PATIL Date: 2022.06.06 13:05:15 +0530 1 / 6 SACHIN RAMCHANDRA PATIL
) &# !$&! (!
"! "+!
$&!
$"$#: .+)
$& !$#/# 2"
!+*+
$! " &$"+$6*!) $"$#: !$#/-) 3 + !$! 4+ 6$&"
*5! ("!
6 !3 $! " ! (" !
$$& ! 2# C# " $ +(("
6&$"! " (3!
("!
!! "
6! $6$ 6!"
+$&*$3"
6- 2+5-
$#9?=$&/?:9-) ! ! +( !"!
&2 +522*"
-&"
)++.)
"
-! ("!
2 3*+5
! "
@"3 *5)5$&2 ! + !!+2! ( "
!!$! "
!
6""
!*!)! 2-! !!(!
4+ &$"
>
6! *$ 3"
-*53$ !$&$"
3$2(+ !. !$#/ " # D#
!$#/ 4+ E ! :< ! ("
+/?// *&$"!
$ "!-) " !!
$! !" ! 3$!
6) ! ! 3"
+("$ 3 !
$$&! !
! *3!
3"
+3 # !!
3++!
( ! *2 3*+5
! 2""
6*!)!
$"$#: "
+& *
$+ *5! 3"$&
$"3*52 ! +3$ !- $!)
!$ ("$ 3 !! !
! *3!
3 #
& "! " !! ! "&$" $$*3!
&!
)"
!(!
++$) ! !$> *3!
3 # F#
!$#/
("
$++5(" !*&$"! $ "!# 2 / 6
(3 43> "52 *5 - !! 2 !
E $ "$)&") ++-) ! $ !! "* 65("
"$" G 3# & "! "3$4"2 $$*3!
$&$">
6!
3"
> ! ! ! " !36 !! ! # H# (I$ "! ##
#!!$&"5"($"!
J /??=:=97K + ! !$& !!+2!$&2!"
2$ +
( !-! "3!
$8;93*> -! $ 6 !
$@3
$!3$2($ *+ !"2 $&3!
$=/?$&! "### "+!$* "!
$&! (I$ "!"3$! " :8 :A ) 3 ""("$ 3 " *+$)0 L1D# "
$ $ *!! !! $*3!$& !"$ 6 (!"
MM.3$! 63!
$8;9 !
) !$ ("!! !$"! "!$)$2*5 " $"*5"+!
$& " #3!
$8;9)
! )!$ (
6
"+!
) $ "
$"!$"! " ! ) &!$3$"3 "$" ""+!
!$ !
&5 +)& +
2
$& $)"5# 5(".!3 3+ ))$ + * 3$ !"("$ 3!
)$ + 3!6 !" $&)$2 6 !! $*3!&$") 3 !
("$
$)
# "
"5+ + $$ ! !$.I"3
$& "!($)"
!$> ! ("$3
!$2!!
$& 3)$ +
("!)$2&"$2 !!+ 6"+ "# !
$!! $*3!$& (!"MM$&
# 1F# )$&! *$
$-) $+ ! !! $ "! I"3
$& "!($)"
3> 3"
$" $"3$2(+ ! 3!
$=/?$&! $
$!+ !$"@3!! ($)"
"3!
$89/$&! $ #N 3 / 6
+" ) *!*5! ++3 $&!
$ "! * * $2 #!!$& " !"J/??9OAP #$&!87K# Q# $&" $3!
$$& 3!
$=?<$&!
- :97?
3$3" -) 3
"
$@3-++6!
+++ *5
!$#/- $ " ) $$! (++$ !5 6"
!
$&!
3!
$#
$$&! (I$ "! "
" 6 #!!$& * J/?:8 R/?7AK-2 !3+"! !! $ "!3$! 3+ !$>
! 2"+5*3 ! 3$"($"! ("!
3 +"("$
$) 3
"
$@3$"$@36 !! $3 !5# $ "! !$ $ "
!$4 $ !) ! "!
3+$ 6"
!
$& 3 $@3
! !! $ "!333(!! !!+2! > S "6.
! & ! $ "!
$&! $( $! ! 3 $@3
3
"
+5 3$"($"!
! 3 "6.
!#! !!3 -! "+ ! !! $2(+ !
T !$#/ 2"+5++6 ! !!
$"$#:*! "*54
3 #$+ $-! ("
+$&2
3+3"!
43!+ $ $!"+! !
!$#/ @" 52$" "5#! ! )$&! 2!!"- $ " )-! 3$"($"!
$$& 3!
$=?<$&!
-:97? ! $!2! (" !3 "
$@3 3 # U# !3-!
-* ! !! 2!!" *2 3*+5
*!)! ("!
# "$2! ("
+$&3$2(+ !- !!" ( " ! !! ++6!
"!$!++5("
$+ ! "# "
$+2!$&( *+ 3+)
$+ ! 3"
2# $@3++6 3$!*
!$ 5 2(3!
$! $3 !5# 4 / 6
V# !
!
3+"! !("!
! 2!!"- ! 5
!$( "2$5*!)! 2!$*+! 2!$+ ) (3 +$# 3$2("$2
"3$"
! !! 5 $6"
66 3 $! " ! 3$2(+ ! (3 43++56" $ $*3!
&! >
> # "! "-*$! ! ("!
"!$!!$ +6 5+ 6!
$6 !3 $! " ") ++! 3$2(+ !
(
6*!)! ("!
*&$"! 3$ "!#
!$#/ "
+& !! ! !$)! 5 ("! )5 ! 5 $*!
$"3*52 ! +3$ ! "$2$" &# 1W## ! 3 "3 2 !3 - (3 ++5- )$&! +)+
$)*5! (I$ "! ! 3 $& $ **$! #!!$& *-JO/??9P8A9/K-)4 ! !$( "($ )$ + * " *5 ( 6! 3"
(
6I3(!* "
6! "
$ "!
3 "+" 5$"* "
#R"$&! )! ! ! *3 "$($&! &$" !! &3!.
! !
$-! 3$!
!
$$&("$ 3 !
! !
! !!3 ) ++2$ !!$* $&! ("$3
$& $ "! ! "&$"
! 4!
$&!
!$> *3!3"
3 -* 6
$#9?=$&/?:9 $"
"!$ 3 "!
$& 3#R" 6"2!) ! !
$$&! +" $ + (("
6&$"! " (3!
("!
! !3$!
!
$$&3"
! !!3 ) ++*I"3
& !
+ !5 3 ! 3 2
! !!
( !*!)! ("!
( !!$
(3
" !$" # 5 / 6
11# ! + 6 !$&! ("
3 (+ +
$)*5! (I$ "! ! &$"
$ )++ ! 3 $&"
" 6 #!!$& * J/?:8 R/?7AK )"$&! 3$
" )! !! "
$
2(
2! >
6! *3!
3 #33$"
6+5-(!
2 * $+ ! !"2 $&("5"3+ O*P# [S. M. Modak, J.] [Prasanna B. Varale, J.] 6 / 6