State Of Maharashtra Through Principal Secretary To The Government, Finance Dept. And ANR. v. Shri Dilip Gopal Desai
Shridhar Sutar 1 wp-3439.17+ judgment.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO. 3439 OF 2017 State of Maharashtra and another ... Petitioners
Versus
Yogita Yashwant Kharade and others ... Respondents WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 1128 OF 2016 The State of Maharashtra and others ... Petitioners
Versus
Vishvas P. Kamble ... Respondent WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 3330 OF 2016 The State of Maharashtra and others ... Petitioners
Versus
Anita Ashok Khedkar ... Respondent WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 3047 OF 2016 The State of Maharashtra and others ... Petitioners
Versus
Pratiksha P. Shriwadkar ... Respondent WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 3983 OF 2016 The State of Maharashtra and others ... Petitioners
Versus
Suman Vishwas Nawkhande ... Respondent
Shridhar Sutar 2 wp-3439.17+ judgment.doc WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 3984 OF 2016 The State of Maharashtra and others ... Petitioners
Versus
Arvind Nathuram Sankhe ... Respondent WITH WRIT PETITION STAMP NO. 33493 OF 2015 State of Maharashtra and others ... Petitioners
Versus
Jayashri Dilip Belwalkar ... Respondent WITH WRIT PETITION STAMP NO. 9692 OF 2016 The Additional Chief Secretary, General Administration Dept. and others ... Petitioners
Versus
Sulochana Tulshiram Shinde ... Respondent WITH WRIT PETITION STAMP NO. 16938 OF 2015 State of Maharashtra and another ... Petitioners
Versus
Manasi Arun Mahimkar ... Respondent WITH WRIT PETITION STAMP NO. 9788 OF 2016 State of Maharashtra and another ... Petitioners
Versus
Dilip Gopal Desai ... Respondent WITH WRIT PETITION STAMP NO. 9696 OF 2016 State of Maharashtra and others ... Petitioners
Versus
Jyoti Prakash Mumbarkar ... Respondent
Shridhar Sutar 3 wp-3439.17+ judgment.doc .....
Mr. P. G. Sawant, AGP for the Petitioner in Writ Petition No. 3439 of 2017.
Mr. Narendrakumar Rajpurohit, AGP for the Petitioners in All Writ Petitions except Writ Petition No. 3439 of 2017. Ms. Ranjana Todankar i/b Miss Swati Prabhakar Manchekar for the Respondents.
.....
CORAM : A. S. OKA AND M. S. SONAK, JJ.
RESERVED ON : 09th OCTOBER, 2018 PRONOUNCED ON : 22nd OCTOBER, 2018 P. C.:
1.
Heard Mr. P.G. Sawant, the learned AGP in Writ Petition No. 3439 of 2017 and Mr. Rajpurohit, the learned AGP for the Petitioners in all other writ petitions except Writ Petition No. 3439 of 2017.
2.
The learned AGPs agree that these petitions can be disposed of by a common order. The learned AGPs also agree that the judgments and orders made by the Maharashtra Administrative Tribunal (MAT), which have been impugned in all these petitions are almost entirely based upon the reasoning in the judgment and order dated 3rd March, 2014 made by the MAT in Original Application No. 328 of 2010 instituted by Mahadev Sitaram Gurav, which was the subject
Shridhar Sutar 4 wp-3439.17+ judgment.doc matter of challenge in connected Writ Petition No. 1795 of 2016. The learned AGPs agree that the issues of both the facts and law involved in the present petitions are the same as the issues of facts and law involved in Writ Petition No.1795 of 2016 and therefore, the decision in the said petition will govern the fate in these petitions as well. 3.
By a separate judgment and order which we have pronounced today, we have dismissed the Writ Petition No. 1795 of 2016. Therefore, for reasons recorded in the said judgment and order pronounced today, we dismiss all these petitions as well. Accordingly, all these petitions are dismissed. There shall however be no order as to costs. 4.
Pending Civil Applications, if any, do not survive and the same are disposed of.
( M. S. SONAK, J. ) ( A. S. OKA, J. ) Shridhar Marutirao Sutar Shridhar Marutirao Sutar Date: 2018.10.22 16:21:26 +0530