← Library
Bombay High CourtWP/13819/2017disposed off

Shri. Aba Shankar Jadhav And ORS. v. The Secretary , Planning Department And ORS.

2023-03-30Hon'Ble The Acting Chief Justice,Hon'Ble Shri Justice Sandeep V. Marne6 pages

1/6

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO. 13819 OF 2017 ALONGWITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 3497 OF 2022 ALONGWITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 3498 OF 2022 ALONGWITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 2726 OF 2021 Shri. Aba Shankar Jadhav and Ors.

.....Petitioners V/s.

The Secretary, Planning Department and Ors.

.....Respondents ----- Mr. Kiran Bapat, Senior Advocate i/by. Mr. Y.B. Lengare, Mrs. Suman Y. Lengare and Ms. Snehal Avhad Advocate for the petitioner. Mr. Pankaj Deokar, Advocate for respondent no.4 in WP(St.) No. 104602019 and for respondents no.10 & 11 in W.P.-12167-2019. Mr. Vishwasrao Deokar a/w. Ms. Vishaka Patel , Advocate for respondents no.7 & 12, 14.

Mr. Nitin Deshpande, Special Counsel a/w. Mrs. R.A. Salunkhe, AGP for State.

CORAM : S.V. GANGAPURWALA, ACTING CJ & SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.

DATE :

th MARCH, 2023.

2/6 P.C. :

1.

Petitioners seek directions to extend benefits of Government Resolution dated 1 st December, 1995 and 21 st April, 1999.

2.

It is not disputed that petitioners in the present writ petition, were Muster Assistant. Petitioners were dismissed from service. They filed dispute with the Industrial Court. The Industrial Court allowed the dispute and granted reinstatement but did not grant permanency. The details of petitioners and the respective dates are detailed as under : Sr.

No.

Name of Petitioner Date of Appointme nt Terminati Reference IDA No./Complaint/Re vision & Decision Writ Petition Reinstateme nt

Present

Status

1. Aba Shankar Jadhav, through Lrs.

21.09.1982 30.06.1987 84/1992 03.02.1998 Partly allowed.

Revision 18/1998 Dismissed for default 12.12.1994 18.04.1998 15.09.2021

2. Shivaji Gajendra Hembade 21.07.1986 30.03.1988 130/1992 Complaint allowed 01.04.1999 Revision Dismissed 14.01.2000 5806/2000 filed by CEO remanded 23.01.2001 05.02.2000

3. Dilip Ramchandra Chaure 07.04.1986 30.11.1989 34.1993 Allowed on 15.06.1999 653/2000 Disposed of remanded 08.02.2000 31.05.2022 IDA No.34/1993 filed by CEO dismissed 26.04.2001

4. Sajjan Hinduraon Mane 01.07.1984 01.05.1987 38/1993 allowed 17.10.1996 30.12.1996 Retired 31.05.2019

5. Dattatraya Kalyranrao Patil 21.10.1982 06.06.1987 359/1992 allowed 06.05.1997 10.07.1997 31.05.2021

6. Kumar Uddhav Jadhav 05.08.1988 23.12.1989 74/1992 allowed 02.03.1998 08.07.1998 31.12.2020

7. Shivaji Ishwar Maske 01.07.1985 15.11.1988 88/1992 partly allowed 07.02.1998 23.07.1998

3/6 30.04.2020 Rev. No.25/1998 disposed of on 04.08.1998

8. Tanaji Baburao Anbhule 14.08.1985 01.01.1989 82/1992 allowed on 27.07.1998 27.01.1999 31.10.2018

9. Balanath Mahadeo Pathade 22.11.1982 01.08.1987 22/1993 allowed on 24.12.1997 5416/1998 Remanded 02.09.1998 31.05.2021 22/1993 allowed on 10.04.2001

10. Namdeo Kisan Kale 24.11.1987 01.01.1989 22/1992 allowed on 06.03.1998 5004/2002 23.10.2002 04.07.1998 22/1992 allowed on 20.04.2001

11. Balasaheb Ramchandra Ragade 24.03.1986 28.11.1987 100/93 allowed on 05.05.1999.

654/2000 WP No.

1854/2004 Rule 08.02.2000 IDA 100/93 02.05.2001 WP No.1854/2004 Rule

12. Sadhu Maruti Panage 01.04.1983 01.04.1988 18/1993 partly allowed on 22.07.1997 10.6.1998 31.05.2017

13. Veerchandra Ramchandra Salve 26.04.1986 17.11.1987 108/1993 allowed on 09.09.1998.

108/93 filed by EE dismissed 03.05.2001 2962/1999 Remanded 29.01.1999

14. Vishnu Tukaram Kharat 26.04.1986 29.04.1989 89/1992 allowed on 20.12.1996 4360/1997 Dismissed 14.02.2018 25.09.1997 30.06.2014

15. Shabir Fakruddin Shaikh 20.04.1987 01.02.1992 362/92 allowed on 14.02.1997.

10.03.1997 31.05.2014 15/1997 stayed back wages on 06.03.1997

16. Dhanaji Bhagwat Labade 23.10.1982 01.05.1988 102/93 allowed on 04.03.1999 07.02.2000 31.01.2015

17. Rajendra Sandipan Bankar 15.02.1984 Feb.1988 220/1991 allowed on 21.01.1997 06.02.1997

18. Sugriv Trimbak Yadav 01.01.1986 30.06.1987 89/1993 allowed on 10.11.1998 16.04.1999 Rev.44/99 20.09.2000

4/6

19. Dattatraya Digambar Gawali 01.12.1985 01.09.1986 80/1992 allowed on 05.06.1998 13.11.1998

20. Madekar Prabhakar Sadashiv 31.10.1982 01.02.1986 99/93 allowed on 15.07.2000 28.07.2003 31.05.2018

21. Annasaheb Trimbak Chavan 01.10.1982 01.11.1988 57/92 allowed on 16.02.1998 6024/1998 filed Dy.

Eng.

Dismissed 01.09.1998

22. Balbhim Gopinath Patil 07.10.1982 18.02.1988 79/92 allowed on 06.04.1998 5417/1998 Remanded 01.09.1998 31.05.2018 Rev. 79/92 filed by Dy. Eng. Dismissed on 24.04.2001

23. Sunil Nagnath Gulve 05.09.1986 27.10.1987 73/1992 allowed on 19.09.1998.

2977/99 Remanded 05.03.1999 31.01.2020 Rev.73/92 filed by Ex. Eng. dismissed on 23.04.2001

24. Mahadeo Bhimrao Chaure 27.02.1984 01.02.1988 46/93 allowed on 06.08.1999 20.01.2000 31.07.2019

25. Sudhir Dnyandeo Shinde 25.03.1986 14.03.1988 46/93 allowed on 12.07.1999 10.01.2000 31.07.2022

26. Pralahad Nivrutti Shinde 07.10.1982 21.02.1988 75/1992 allowed on 06.03.1998 6020/1998 01.09.1998 31.10.2016

27. Ramesh Gajanan Karanjkar 08.02.1983 01.10.1985 85/1992 allowed on 17.02.1997 6026/1998 filed by Ex.Eng.

Rejected on 12.06.1997 30.06.2019

28. Suryakant Shankarrao Mule 26.05.1983 19.02.1988 27/1993 allowed on 16.04.1999.

647/2000 05.02.2000 30.06.2019 27/1993 on 20.04.2001

29. Tukaram Janardhan Gawali 16.12.1986 01.04.1989 74/1992 allowed on 27.03.1998 01.09.1998

30. Bhagwan Hanumant 05.06.1986 31.10.1987 58/92 allowed on 21.4.2001 2956/1999 24.12.1998

5/6 Awate 14.9.1999

31. Shivaji Atmaram Dadape 06.07.1983 30.08.1987 81/92 allowed on 17.09.1998 05.03.1999 31.05.2018 81.92 filed by Dy.

Eng.

Dismissed on 24.04.2001

32. Bhaskar Raghunath Gore 07.10.1982 19.02.1988 62/1992 allowed on 24.07.1998 2958/1999 disposed on 09.08.2000 24.12.1998 31.06.2012 3.

As far as Petitioners are concerned, they have approached the Industrial Court. The Industrial Court had passed an order reinstating them but has not granted permanency. In that event, the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Shaikh Miya S/o. Shaikh Chand etc. vs. State of Maharashtra dated 7th September, 2022 in Civil Appeal No. 65316533 of 2022 will be relevant. In that judgment, it is observed that the persons who have been absorbed over a period of time post 31st March, 1997, for pensionable services, reckoning date will be 31st March, 1997 and such of the persons who have rendered pensionable services will be entitled to that benefit. In view of that, the petitioners shall be considered as permanent from 31 st March, 1997 and the pensionable benefits shall be granted to them considering their services with effect from 31st March, 1997, as expeditiously as possible.

4.

With this direction, the Writ Petition alongwith Interim Applications is disposed of.

Digitally signed by NEETA SHAILESH SAWANT Date:

2023.04.11 12:40:01 +0530 NEETA SHAILESH SAWANT (SANDEEP V. MARNE, J.) (ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE)

6/6