The State Of Maharashtra v. Dehubai Ramchandra Keni
RAMESHWAR LAXMAN DILWALE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION FIRST APPEAL NO. 2123 OF 2005 by RAMESHWAR LAXMAN DILWALE Date: 2024.01.23 10:18:12 +0530 Mr. Kanchan Chintaman Oze Special Land Acquisition Officer (I)Raigad Alibag.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 154 OF 2009 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.3866 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.154 OF 2009 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4710 OF 2011 FIRST APPEAL NO.154 OF 2009 Babu Masanya Keni D/hVimal Jan Chimane and Anr. FIRST APPEAL NO. 293 OF 2009 Bama Goma Patil D/h- Pandarinath Bama Thakur and Anr.
..Respondents CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4734 OF 2011 FIRST APPEAL NO.293 OF 2009 1/23
City Industrial and Development Corporation (Cidco) Bama Goma Patil D/h- Pandarinath Bama Thakur and Anr.
..Respondents CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.17060 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.293 OF 2009 Bama Goma Patil D/h- Pandarinath Bama Thakur and Anr.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 155 OF 2006 Dehubai Ramchandra Keni The State of Maharashtra CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1327 OF 2014 FIRST APPEAL NO.155 OF 2006 Dehubai Ramchandra Keni Thr. Her Constituted Power of Attorney Holder Mr. Ankush Ramchandra Ken The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Metro Centre No.3 FIRST APPEAL NO. 156 OF 2006 Dehubai Ramchandra Keni 2/23
The State of Maharashtra CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1334 OF 2014 FIRST APPEAL NO.156 OF 2006 Dehubai Ramchandra Keni Thr. Her Constituted Power of Attorney Holder Mr. Ankush Ramchandra Ken The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Metro Centre No.3 FIRST APPEAL NO. 157 OF 2006 Dehubai Ramchandra Keni CIVIL APPLICATION NO.1335 OF 2014 FIRST APPEAL NO.157 OF 2006 Dehubai Ramchandra Keni Thr. Her Constituted Power of Attorney Holder Mr. Ankush Ramchandra Ken The Special Land Acquisition Officer, Metro Centre No.3 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1120 OF 1996 Kamlabai C. Gulbani 3/23
The Secretary, Union Of India FIRST APPEAL NO. 378 OF 2001 Versu Dharmabai Balkrishna Gondhali and Ors FIRST APPEAL NO. 699 OF 2008 Jayawant Namdeo Gawand and Ors.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1649 OF 2009 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4263 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.1649 OF 2009 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.29115 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.1649 OF 2009 Shri. Prabhakar Krishna Gawad and Ors.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1735 OF 2009 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.30908 OF 2009 4/23
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1735 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1987 OF 2008 Dnyanoba Pandurang Gaikwad D/hHarishchandra Dnyanoba Gaikwad and Ors. FIRST APPEAL NO. 171 OF 2009 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.3865 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO. 171 OF 2009 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4715 OF 2011 FIRST APPEAL NO.171 OF 2009 Babu Masnya Keni D/hVimal Jana Chimane and Anr. FIRST APPEAL NO. 173 OF 2009 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.3867 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.173 OF 2009 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4714 OF 2011 FIRST APPEAL NO.173 OF 2009 5/23
Dnyanoba Pandurang Gaikwad D/hHarishchandra Dnyanoba Gaikwad FIRST APPEAL NO. 400 OF 2001 Shri Kanchan Chintaman Oze.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 146 OF 2009 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.3174 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.146 OF 2009 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.47117 OF 2011 FIRST APPEAL NO.146 OF 2009 Babu Masnya Keni D/h- Vimal Jana Chimane and Anr FIRST APPEAL NO. 741 OF 2005 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3674 OF 2015 FIRST APPEAL NO. 741 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 742 OF 2005 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3675 OF 2015 FIRST APPEAL NO.742 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 743 OF 2005 6/23
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3676 OF 2015 FIRST APPEAL NO.743 OF 2015 FIRST APPEAL NO. 744 OF 2005 Kana Dhaya Keni D/h Ramdas Kana @kanha Keni and Ors.
...Appellants FIRST APPEAL NO. 2372 OF 2008 Anant Shankar Keni FIRST APPEAL NO. 396 OF 2010 Jayawant Namdeo Gawand and Ors.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 878 OF 2009 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4082 OF 2013 FIRST APPEAL NO.878 OF 2009 Hanuman Vilas Keni D.h. Anjana Hanuman Keni and Ors. ...Appellants 7/23
FIRST APPEAL NO. 878 OF 2008 Shri Rajesh Ramkrishana Kambli The Maharashtra Housing and Area Development Authority FIRST APPEAL NO. 5 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO. 6 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO. 7 OF 2006 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4704 OF 2011 FIRST APPEAL NO.7 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO.8 OF 2006 Anant Babu Pardeshi and Ors.
...Appellants FIRST APPEAL NO. 1310 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1311 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21963 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1311 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1312 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21965 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1312 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1314 OF 2005 8/23
CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21969 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1314 OF 2015 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1315 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21971 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1315 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1316 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21973 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1316 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1317 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21975 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1317 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1318 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21977 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1318 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1319 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21979 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1319 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1320 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21981 OF 2007 9/23
FIRST APPEAL NO.1320 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1321 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21983 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1321 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1322 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21985 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1322 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1323 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21987 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1323 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1324 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21989 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1324 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1325 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1326 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21993 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1326 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1328 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21997 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1328 OF 2005 10/23
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1329 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.21999 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1329 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1330 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.22001 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1330 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1331 OF 2005 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.22003 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.1331 OF 2005 State Of Maharashtra Shankar Vitthal Gulave D/h Sangram S.Gulave and Anr. FIRST APPEAL NO. 483 OF 2008 Parvatibai Shankar Keni FIRST APPEAL NO. 2099 OF 2008 Gramdevi Kalbhirav Sansthaan -Annat Shankar Keni and Ors. ...Respondents FIRST APPEAL NO. 2396 OF 2008 11/23
Savlaram Shankar Keni FIRST APPEAL NO. 2389 OF 2008 Dhaya Sitaram Keni and Ors.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1199 OF 1996 Shri Vasant Laxman Vani and Ors ...Appellants Spl.Land Acqn. Officer and Anr FIRST APPEAL NO. 721 OF 2004 Hari Kachar Waskar and Anr FIRST APPEAL NO. 719 OF 2004 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.103 OF 2004 FIRST APPEAL NO.719 OF 2004 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.29055 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.719 OF 2004 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4529 OF 2008 12/23
FIRST APPEAL NO.719 OF 2004 Smt .Dharmabai Balkrishna Gondhali and Others FIRST APPEAL NO. 718 OF 2004 Smt. Chhindhibai G. Thakur FIRST APPEAL NO. 720 OF 2004 Hari Kacher Waskar and Anr.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 867 OF 1997 Ashok L.Wani Spl.Land Acquisition Officer, and Anr.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2620 OF 2005 Kana Dhaya Keni D/h Ramdas K.keni and Ors.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2621 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2622 OF 2005 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2623 OF 2005 13/23
Kana Dhaya Keni D/h Ramdas Kana @kanha Keni and Ors. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1636 OF 2009 Ibrahim Kazimiya Kazi D/h- Begam Bibi Ibrahim Kazi & Ors. ...Respondents FIRST APPEAL NO. 2052 OF 2007 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.5826 OF 2008 FIRST APPEAL NO.2052 OF 2007 Shri Atmaram Panga Joshi and Ors FIRST APPEAL NO. 2060 OF 2007 CIVIL APPLICATION (ST) NO.928 OF 1998 FIRST APPEAL NO.2060 OF 2007 Shri Sanjay Dattatraya Wani FIRST APPEAL NO. 403 OF 2008 ...Appellants Smt. Anyabai B. Bhoir and Ors.
14/23
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2056 OF 2007 CIVIL APPLICATION (ST) NO.914 OF 1998 FIRST APPEAL NO.2056 OF 2007 Atmaram P. Joshi and Ors.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2054 OF 2007 CIVIL APPLICATION (ST) NO.937 OF 1998 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2054 OF 2007 Shri Sanjay D. Wani and Ors.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 402 OF 2008 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.3783 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.402 OF 2008 Songya B. Bhoir FIRST APPEAL NO. 986 OF 2010 RPF (ST) NO.19962 OF 2023 15/23
FIRST APPEAL NO.986 OF 2010 State Of Maharashtra Anandibai Rama Pawar FIRST APPEAL NO. 1578 OF 2009 State Of Maharashtra Anant Lahu Patil FIRST APPEAL NO. 112 OF 2009 RPF (ST) NO.29043 OF 2023 FIRST APPEAL NO.112 OF 2009 Nakul Govind Patil and Anr FIRST APPEAL NO. 271 OF 2009 Anant Lahu Patil and Anr FIRST APPEAL NO. 52 OF 2009 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.3869 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.52 OF 2009 16/23
Ambu Dharama Pardeshi and Others FIRST APPEAL NO. 123 OF 2014 The State Of Maharashtra (through The Special Land Acquisition Officer) Smt. Anabai Bhaskar Patil FIRST APPEAL NO. 48 OF 2010 Hanuman Vilas Keni D.h. Anjana Hanuman Keni and Others FIRST APPEAL NO. 1301 OF 2008 Dattatray Shankar Keni -Lrs- Ramubai Dattatray Keni and Others FIRST APPEAL NO. 1136 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1137 OF 2006 Bhau Kana Patil and Ors.
17/23
FIRST APPEAL NO. 722 OF 2008 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5720 OF 2007 FIRST APPEAL NO.722 OF 2008 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.3709 OF 2018 FIRST APPEAL NO.722 OF 2008 Dashrath Pandu Patil FIRST APPEAL NO. 153 OF 2006 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.5431 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO.153 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO.152 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO.154 OF 2006 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.5433 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO.154 OF 2006 Govindji Walji Kumbhar D/h Devidas Govindji Kumbhar @jethva and Ors.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1713 OF 2008 RPF (ST) NO.30980 OF 2023 18/23
FIRST APPEAL NO.1713 OF 2008 Laxman Namdeo Patil and Others FIRST APPEAL NO. 1266 OF 2009 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.24048 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1266 OF 2009 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4727 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.1266 OF 2009 Janardan Vittal Keni D.h. Renubai Janardan Keni and Others FIRST APPEAL NO. 375 OF 2009 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO.9661 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.375 OF 2009 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5998 OF 2008 FIRST APPEAL NO.375 OF 2009 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4709 OF 2011 FIRST APPEAL NO.375 OF 2009 Shri. Janardan Vitthal Keni (deceased) Through Lrs. Kum. Shashikant Janardan Keni and Others 19/23
FIRST APPEAL NO. 115 OF 2009 Janardan Mahadu Mundkar (deceased Through His Legal Heirs) Chandrabhaga J. Mundkar and Ors. FIRST APPEAL NO. 1277 OF 2009 INTERIM APPLICATION NO.2224 OF 2020 FIRST APPEAL NO.1277 OF 2009 INTERIM APPLICATION NO.2229 OF 2020 FIRST APPEAL NO.1277 OF 2009 INTERIM APPLICATION NO.2227 OF 2020 FIRST APPEAL NO.1277 OF 2009 INTERIM APPLICATION NO.2225 OF 2020 FIRST APPEAL NO.1277 OF 2009 INTERIM APPLICATION NO.2232 OF 2020 FIRST APPEAL NO.1277 OF 2009 CROSS OBJECTION (ST) NO. 23789 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.1277 OF 2009 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.4728 OF 2009 FIRST APPEAL NO.1277 OF 2009 20/23
CIVIL APPLICATION NO.5885 OF 2008 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1277 OF 2009 Maya Changa Mundkar D.h. Dhaya Maya Mundkar and Others FIRST APPEAL NO. 75 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO.76 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO.77 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO.78 OF 2006 Anant Babu Perdeshi and Ors.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 700 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO. 702 OF 2006 FIRST APPEAL NO. 701 OF 2006 Dehubai Ramchandra Keni FIRST APPEAL NO. 1613 OF 2010 Ganesh Uttam Bathe 21/23
Ravindra Namdeo Bathe FIRST APPEAL NO. 1510 OF 2006 Shri Harishchandra Sitaram Bhoir FIRST APPEAL NO. 1511 OF 2006 Shri Anant Kathor Bhoir FIRST APPEAL NO. 1512 OF 2006 Smt. Babibai Babu Patil FIRST APPEAL NO. 1513 OF 2006 Shri Dadu Balaram Patil ...
Mr. Samir A. Vaidya a/w Adv. Kaivalya R., Mr. Prathamesh Sarang, Mr. Aditya Tiwari, Adv. Sayni Nambia for Appellants in FA/2123/2005. Mr. A. R. Patil, Addl. GP for Respondent-State. Mr. Shriram S Kulkarni for Respoondents in FA Nos. 1310/2005, 1311/2005, 1312/2005, 1314/2005, 1315/2005, 1316/2005, 1317/2005, 1318/2005, 1319/2005, 1320/2005, 1321/2005, 1322/2005, 1323/2005, 1324/2005, 1325/2005, 1328/2005, 1329/2005, 1330/2005, 1331/2005, 1636/2005, 1636/2005, 986/2010, 1878/2009, 112/2009, 271/2009 and for the 22/23
Appellant in FA/1199/1996.
Mr. Sachin S. Pande for Respondents in FA Nos. 293/2009, 378/2001, 699/2008, 1649/2009, 1735/2009, 1987/2008, 171/2009, 173/2009, 146/2009, 2732/2008, 483/2008, 2099/2008, 2396/2008, 2389/2008, 719/2004, 718/2004, 22/2009, 123/2004, 48/2010, 1301/2008, 1136/2006, 1137/2006, 722/2008, 1266/2009, 375/2009, 115/2009, 1277/2009 and for Appellant in FA/878/2009.
...
CORAM : A.S. CHANDURKAR & JITENDRA JAIN, JJ DATE : 19th JANUARY, 2024.
PC:- 1.
On 11/01/2024, Mr. A.R. Patil, learned Additional Government Pleader had furnished a list of about 88 First Appeals stating therein that these appeals be also heard with First Appeal No.2123 of 2005. As per the list of the aforesaid appeals prepared by the office, it is indicated that the said appeals pertain to the jurisdiction of learned Single Judge. In that view of the matter, we would proceed only with consideration of First Appeal No.2123 of 2005 alongwith First Appeal No.400 of 2011.
2.
Put up for further consideration on 02/02/2024. [ JITENDRA JAIN, J. ] [ A.S. CHANDURKAR, J. ] 23/23