Shri. Gavhane Ashish Nanabhau And ANR. v. The State Of Maharashtra Through Secretary And ORS.

vai

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION NO.3530 OF 2018 SHRI. NAGHOTAKAR RAVINDRA SURESH...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.3543 OF 2018 TUWAR PANDURANG RAGNATH & ORS....PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.2642 OF 2018 SMT. KASHID PRAMILA BANSI ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2644 OF 2018 SHRI. BHAGADE SHITAL BHAUSAHEB & ANR IA (ST) 14425 OF 2021 ...........

SMT. SONALI ANIL SHINDE ...APPLICANT 1/15

THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA & ORS...RESPONDENTS WRIT PETITION NO.11923 OF 2017 SHRI. KAKADE SAMBHAJI MURLIDHAR...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.12425 OF 2017 SMT. SALVE PRAVIN RAMESH ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.11924 OF 2017 SHRI. GAVHANE ASHISH NANABHAU & ANR WRIT PETITION NO.2551 OF 2018 MRS. NAVGHANE JYOTI UMESH & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.1554 OF 2018 SHRI. BARSE SANDEEP KASHINATH ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.1553 OF 2018 2/15

SMT. TAMBE ALKA PARMESHWAR...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.11925 OF 2017 SHRI. NARODE PANKAJ DATTATRAYA...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.12427 OF 2017 SMT. BABAR POURNIMA PRATAPRAO & ANR WRIT PETITION (STAMP) NO.27429 OF 2017 MS. GAIKWAD RAJESHRI SURESH...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2314 OF 2018 SHRI. SONAWANE SUNIL PRAKASH & ORS WRIT PETITION (STAMP) NO.27626 OF 2017 SMT. SONAWANE NIRMALA ASHOK & ORS.

3/15

WRIT PETITION NO.2549 OF 2018 VIJAYKUMAR BHAGWAN PAWAR & ORS WRIT PETITION NO.2554 OF 2018 MS. THETE BHAGYASHRI CHANDRAKANT & ORS.

WRIT PETITION NO.2555 OF 2018 SHRI. ZURALE DEEPAK KISAN & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.2557 OF 2018 GURAV GOPAL BHAGAVAT & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.12424 OF 2017 SHRI. BANKAR ANIL ASHOK & ANR...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.3002 OF 2018 4/15

SHRI. PANGREKAR SUBHASH LAXMAN ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.12426 OF 2017 SHRI. BALPATRE SURAJ SHRIKRISHNA ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION (STAMP) NO.28859 OF 2017 SMT. TURKANE KIRAN VISHNU & ORS WRIT PETITION NO.3003 OF 2018 SHRI. CHITALE ARJUN BHIMA & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION (ST) NO.30171 OF 2017 (RC NO.1820 OF 2018) SHRI. SURYAWANSHI MAHESH BAPURAO & ORS.

WRIT PETITION NO.13121 OF 2017 5/15

MALI GANESH TRIMBAK ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.11582 OF 2018 SMT. DESHMUKH ASHWINI LAXMAN & ORS.

WRIT PETITION (STAMP) NO.33677 OF 2017 SHRI. SHELKE RAJENDRA RAMCHANDRA & ORS WRIT PETITION NO.2570 OF 2018 LONDHE GANESH HANUMANT & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.707 OF 2018 WABLE GANESH VASANT ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.841 OF 2018 SMT. KHATAL MAEE PRABHAKAR ...PETITIONER 6/15

WRIT PETITION NO.2575 OF 2018 NEHUL SANDIP SARANGDHAR & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.2572 OF 2018 BHALEKAR JANARDHAN SURYABHAN & ORS WRIT PETITION NO.843 OF 2018 SHRI. JADHAV RAHUL ANNASAHEB...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.331 OF 2018 SHRI. KAMBALE AMAR SURYAKANT...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.708 OF 2018 SMT. NIGHUTE YOGITA TULSHIRAM & ANR WRIT PETITION NO.2567 OF 2018 SHRI. BHAGWAT NILESH PRAKASH...PETITIONER 7/15

WRIT PETITION NO.2506 OF 2018 SMT. UPADHYE MANISHA SUDAM ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.313 OF 2018 KARLE VISHNU MACHINDRA & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.14287 OF 2017 SMT. AHIRE SAPANA VIJAY & ANR...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.366 OF 2018 SHRI. DHANWATE KAILAS MACHINDRA & ORS WRIT PETITION NO.842 OF 2018 SHRI. KHAIRE MAHESH DATTATRAY & ORS 8/15

WRIT PETITION NO.308 OF 2018 SHRI. JAGDALE SUJIT BHASKAR & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.365 OF 2018 SMT. PATIL SWATI GULABRAO ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.602 OF 2018 SHRI. JOSHI VIJAY BHASKAR & ANR...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.2505 OF 2018 INAMDAR KAUSAR BANU ABDUL SHAHID & ORS WRIT PETITION NO.298 OF 2018 SMT. SALUNKE RESHMARANI NANASAHEB ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.498 OF 2018 SHRI. SABALE JANARDHAN LAXMAN...PETITIONER 9/15

WRIT PETITION NO.297 OF 2018 SMT. VARPE SWATI SHIVAJI & ORS ...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.294 OF 2018 SMT. MOHITE MEGHA BAJRANG ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2573 OF 2018 SMT. UGALE SHAILA BABASAHEB ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.499 OF 2018 SHRI. SHINDE MUKESH DATTATRAYA...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2571 OF 2018 SOU. RAUT MAINABAI HANUMANT...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2574 OF 2018 10/15

SHRI. TAD GANAPAT JALINDAR & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.3004 OF 2018 SOU. DIGHE KALPANA NANASAHEB...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.1309 OF 2018 KADAM UJWALA BALKRISHNA & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.1953 OF 2018 SHAIKH MOIN AYUB ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2643 OF 2018 GADGE CHANDRAKANT POPAT ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2763 OF 2018 SMT. YAWALE RATNAPRABHA NANDARAM...PETITIONER 11/15

WRIT PETITION NO.2648 OF 2018 SMT. GHADGE ROHINI VITTHAL ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2645 OF 2018 SHRI. JADHAV VIJAY SAHEBRAO ...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2649 OF 2018 MRS. DESHMUKH NISHA RAMLING...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.1951 OF 2018 SHRI. MORE SACHIN BHAUSAHEB...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2647 OF 2018 SHRI. SHEJWAL ARUN DHONDIRAM...PETITIONER WRIT PETITION NO.2646 OF 2018 KALE PRAVIN GORAKNATH ...PETITIONER 12/15

WRIT PETITION (STAMP) NO.36080 OF 2017 SHINDE REVJINANA SADASHIV & ANR...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.5336 OF 2021 ...... (NOT ON BOARD. TAKEN ON BOARD) DATTATRAYA VITTHAL SUTAR & ORS...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION (STAMP) NO. 36098 OF 2018 (NOT ON BOARD. TAKEN ON BOARD) SHRI. AROTE SAMBHAJI BAJIRAO & ANR...PETITIONERS WRIT PETITION NO.9117 OF 2018 SUNANDA PANDURANG CHOUDHARI...PETITIONER Mr.Narendra V. Bandiwadekar with Mr.Vinayak R. Kumbhar, Mr.Ajinkya Navale i/b Mrs.Ashwini Navjyot Bandiwadekar and Ms.Neha Narendra Bandiwadekar and Mr.Sagar A. Mane for the 13/15

Petitioners in above group.

Mr.A.V. Anturkar, Senior Counsel with Mr.D.I.S Mulla and Mr.Milind Deshmukh for the Respondent - Management in above group. Mr.A.I. Patel, Addl.G.P. with Mr.V.M. Mali, AGP with Mrs.P.J. Gavhane, AGP with Mr.N.K. Rajpurohit, AGP with Mr.A.A. Alaspurkar, AGP with Mr.N.C. Walimbe, AGP with Ms.K.N. Solunke, AGP for the State - Respondents in the above group. CORAM : R.D. DHANUKA & ABHAY AHUJA, JJ.

DATE : 13TH SEPTEMBER, 2021.

P.C. :- 1.

The parties have tendered the consent terms dated 13th September, 2021 between the petitioners and the Management duly signed by the parties and their respective advocate. The signature of the parties are identified by their respective advocates. The consent terms are taken on record and marked "X" for identification. 2.

Learned counsel for the Management states that the Management has approved the consent terms and has authorized the Honorary Secretary viz. Dr.V.S. Shivankar to sign these consent terms on behalf of the Management. Some of the parties have not signed the consent terms who are not parties to the consent terms and have left the job and have joined the services in the same management or have expired and or are not interested in pursing the matter. Statement is accepted. The undertakings contained in the consent terms are accepted. Since the State Government is not a party to these consent terms, we direct the State Government to 14/15

grant approval to the appointment of the petitioners who are parties to the consent terms within six weeks from the date of receipt of respective proposals from the Management.

3.

The above writ petitions are disposed of in terms of the consent terms.

4.

Parties to act on the authenticated copy of this order. (ABHAY AHUJA, J.) (R.D. DHANUKA, J.) 15/15