Sandeep Balbir Singh v. The State Of Maharashtra And ANR




  


  





 WRIT PETITION NO. 5764 OF 2019 

 !!!"

$!

% $&$  ""#'  $ "

(#"  !

!!

$#"$!

 !)$ *)& +,#-"'# "

!

 !% ,)%!.

$ +,#-"'# $#"!

$!!! "

+'# $#"/""!

 0 !% ( !! .+

!

 Date : April 22, 2022.

!!0 1!

  $""

$2&  -334#'"  #$"

"&"

##'
  5 " $-"

#673#'" ##'

 #-& + 9:;<$) "#=&$ " 

$"
'# 8"

# "> ? 



8#!

3@9#'3@97 $" 5 " & # -""

#+ $"!$ )#"  ##'-#88 $$ ##'#A-$& $  & $-"

#$6:7>?+6@4 B@6 5 " <6#'" 
 #+974@! $

$" ""  $"-#' $#"#!3!

C!

 8

 "5" "

 $#"#!3 "##)-#9< " -8 +3@9B$ "  &

"$

"&$!

#5, +" 8

" $-# $## &" "5" -#&5 - "# " 2 #',

#&$ $ *"  $ $"- #"  -& SACHIN RAMCHANDRA PATIL Date: 2022.05.07 10:38:01 +0530 1 / 5 SACHIN RAMCHANDRA PATIL

, $5$-

"  $" $##'" 8!

D!

 -#&$

'# "  $-"

, $ $& """ "5 " "   " ,"

##''

$+ * $#$ " '8 *5/5 $  $+"  $ ,$""" 

 $&"$8 - *  ,- "# "" 

5*$! -#&$$& ""$& "" --# *"  $""

$2'# =&$ 8"#'$& E-" * -#$"#' $#"#!3+"5 #$ $"-" $  $ 2!

F!

'# "

$#& "+ $#"#!3 $2G, "" 3@ " 

+3@33+5  $  $$""" "$  $#" " $" -#"

& 5 " " -

 #$-&"

##'" "

" $& E-" !

  $'& "  $"" " G, "" "$  $#

,- $""  "

$ #$#"5 $ "#& $&* $ $""  "

!  $$#8*G 8" "$  $5 "  5 "  #$8 $"" "

" $ " "$  $# # E-"

#'# =&$ "  #! H!

$#"#!3 $ $#* $" "

$#& "

#& "! $- 2-=& *8 *&$+$  $& """ "$  $8 " $ G, "#  #5'

5 +5 " #&""  * $$& #

&& I&-!  $'& "  -#2 8" "$  $## E-"

#'#

=&$ "  $"

"&""  $"- $"" "

'# " #A-$& $  & $-"

#$6:7>?+6@4+B@6+ 5 " <6#'

" 
 #+974@!

2 / 5

J!

 K#& !! #$ ,$!""#' * # " L
3@@<9<74M $ " " " ,"#'$""8"#'8"

8#  $&"+"  & -"

#6:7- =&$ +," #& " $ #A- $#"-#8#&  " 8$#'-"

#<3@#'"  !!! 

,"# $ ,"

#$#'" K#& " -#"   $969B -   #&-   #50 N1F!   $##& "" "" # E-"#' "

#&-  "

OO/-#" -"

#6:7 " 
 #5$"#  ,"" "# "& "#5#8 *   &$ # * "

,$#'

 &$ !-"

#6:75$5 " , 5"#&  &$  $ "

,$5 #  $$# "# "& " 5 '"#-# - #   "

,$"#$"

$'*&5'&8$#'#5 *!  * /"-  -, 55#& -#&"  #&-"

,5#&-"

 $" " $"$#'5#8 $"" # E-"'# 5 - "

 #, #5$!  $, * ) ##" "#/K $ #'   "#5 "#=&$ "  $"#8"" $#'

E&$"

-5#& ,"5#8'

#8$""   ! " $#""  # E-"#' " OO#'
 #!

1H!

, 5#'"  #, $-&$$ #+5 #" "" 

#& K $#' "$   "#5 $-=&$ -

  $# # -#8 "-"

#<3@#'" ##$ #" "# A-"" #5 $& -"

#673#'" #!P   , 5 $ ") *"  &- #'"

$#&  $  ,#8,$!""#'  $ "

L3@@7>B? !#'"64M! Q!

"-+" &$+ $" "" 8""  $ 8 - *$""

"5"  $!

#8"  &$#'-#8 "+ ""

$

$" ""  #$ "#"* $# "& !  $#8"#'&  -5

,#, " -

8! #A--#" $ "# ,* 8-"

#" $#- "*!

3 / 5

R!

 &$+ " $" ""  $ ,$""" 8"" +$ " * ,- "#)  8#* "5" 8"# " 8"# , " -#,! -#8 #8 $ -# $" "" * ,# &  $"- #"  " -#8 " $$- 2-* " "$  $ ## E-"

'"  $=&$ ! & "  + #" "  $ , & ")#""# & * "

# $"- #"  5 "  5 " -#8 "$  "5"  $ '# " -#& "!$" *# #" ""# #-5 " *-

-$ $"- #"  +#" " $ " $& $$ ##'" "

$ $" "" -#"

&-#'" -

  $ " '# $ 5  '&"

K $8 5$"#'

 - #&$"

8#'" -#& "$5$ ,$"

"

- $!

S!

" $-

-&8$"-$+$- *+ , 5#'" 5 #5 *" K#& " -$#' # 

#",$!""#'

&E +L>3@@7?6B73M+52" "#& #$5#& $ , * ) " $& E-"  ,!T #'" , 5" " "  -) ##'"  '# $""'-"/$ "&"

#+" -#"

&"

##' #$-&"

##' " '# 8#'

"  $""-$5 8#&""#"  &$#' #-$$#'#& " "  '# $ " 2"$$#'"

$"#=&$ " $& E-" #  "# $-& " $#'E&$"

-!T  8"5 " " $& $$ ##'"   #&$

'# "  $-"

, $" "-#"

&"

##'

 $ " '# 8#' "  $""-$5  K $

'&"

 "*E&$"

- " -$8$" ""  $&" "5"   $ $&""#- $ $"# !

1U!

"   "#'" 

- $ #5 *" K#& "  4 / 5

'# $ - #$5$ " -$#'

   ,$!""#'&E

L3@96
T3@4BM 5 #'" -#$  , 5" ""  $#

8 8" =&$ "  #!--# *+5

""

#5 " 8$#' * -&$>?!##  $"#-#$"$!

[S. M. Modak, J.] [Prasanna B. Varale, J.] 5 / 5