Central Bureau Of Investigation v. Manoj Hanumant Kharat And ANR.
1/3 25 APPLN 676-2018..doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 676 OF 2018 Central Bureau of Investigation .. Applicant
Versus
Manoj Hanumant Kharat and Anr.
.. Respondents ...
Mr. Hiten S. Venegavkar for the applicant.
Mr. Dheer Sampat i/b Mr. T.J. Pandian for Respondent No.1 in APPLN 676/2018 Ms. Anamika Malhotra, APP for Respondent No.2/State. CORAM: BHARATI DANGRE, J.
DATED : 16th MARCH, 2023 P.C:- The application is filed by the Central Bureau of Investigation, under Section 439(2) of Cr.P.C seeking cancellation of bail granted in favour of the respondent by the Special Judge CBI on 12/06/2018, on the ground of wrongful exercise of power to grant bail.
The application came to be filed in the year 2018 and when listed before me in the year 2023, my attention is invited to an order passed by the learned Single Judge (Justice. A.S. Gadkari) of this Court on 8/07/2022 in Criminal Application No. 669 of 2018, a similar application filed by CBI seeking cancellation of bail of one of the accused in CBI Special Case No. 37 of 2018.
2/3 25 APPLN 676-2018..doc After recording the finding, that the trial court has passed a reasoned order to the effect that there is no direct material indicating that the applicant was directly involved in preparation of the alleged LOU's and LOC's. Apart this, the Court was also impressed by another facet of the matter, the pendency of the application for last 4 years. On taking cognizance of the fact that the CBI did not take any steps to circulate the application, it was recorded as under:
"There is another facet to the present Application. The impugned Order was passed on 4th August, 2018. Present Application under Section 439(2) impugning the said Order was filed on 3rd December 2018 and till 14th January, 2021, the Applicant-CBI did not take any steps to even circulate the present Application before any Bench. That, on 14th January, 2021 for the first time at the instance of learned Advocate for the Respondent No.1, who had also filed a Bail Application No. 1243 of 2018, present Application was circulated before the co-ordinate Bench and the same was thereafter adjourned to 28th January, 2021. The Applicant-CBI thereafter also did not take any steps to get the present Application listed before the concerned Bench and on 8th June, 2022, this Court listed old Applications pertaining to the year 2018 for hearing. It therefore indicates that, the Applicant was not seriously interested in pursuing the present Application".
I have heard Mr. Venegavkar, the learned counsel for CBI and the counsel for the respondent.
I have perused the impugned order, under which the Applicant/Respondent herein is released on bail.
3/3 25 APPLN 676-2018..doc As far as the present respondent is concerned he was arrested on 17/02/2018 he has been released on bail by the Special Court on 12/06/2018.
He was accused of dishonestly issuing the SWIFT message by using his ID and authorized by Gokulnath Shetty for issuing letter to various banks having branches at foreign countries for extending Buyer's credit to Diamond R US, Solar Exports and Stellar Diamond for making payment to the foreign supplier without entering into the CBS system. The Special Court while allowing his application has recorded that his role in the entire accusations is very minor and he cannot be compared with other accused persons and the Court even observed that there was no need for his arrest in the present case.
I do not see any legal infirmity in the said order and, particularly, when the observations in para 8 of the order 8/07/2022 are equally applicable to the present case, as the prosecution has not bothered to move the application and it is more than 5 years that the application has been filed. It would not therefore be in the interest of justice, without any apparent illegality being attributed in the impugned order, to cancel the bail, after a period of more than 4 years. Hence the application is rejected.
( SMT. BHARATI DANGRE, J.)