← Library
Bombay High CourtCSP/116/2016absolute

Geecee Logistics And Distributions Pvt.Ltd. v. -

2016-07-01Hon'Ble Shri Justice B.P. Colabawalla7 pages



 

 

  

             

              !"##!$!$%&#'%()*&+  

 

 

  

     ,        

    -  

    !"##!$!$%&#'%()*&+     

   !"# $  %& &    

'( )* 

   )! )!+ 

 !"# $  %& &  

'( )* 

        %   ,   -  . ,  

    /0 

      

/  *..#/0%'"#*'$&1 ' *2#3""*"$45 *2#3""*" %6/7%8*!#0%'!"##!$!$%&#'3 '3"9$&$$&1"$45'*&:*2;*)%%'0%' #1$%&*.$'#8!%'  <%.*5*9*..*6   <3! =.+6 <  #*'/#*'&#/%=&3#.0%'!"#)*'!$#3%%52#8!%'"*38%(#5#0%'#!"# 8%='! !% %))%3# !"# 8"#(# *&/ &%' *&+ )*'!+ "*3 8%&!'%7#'!#/ *&+ *7#'(#&!3(*/#$&!"##!$!$%&3  "# 3*&8!$%& %0 !"# %='! $3 3%=1"! !% *    %    ,   -  . ,  

   

  / 0 

       

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

 $ %$  /    $     % 1  $  02%$ 1 $&2   1   &  $    1

   % /  /   %3  $  1 

1$  2   $ 2       % 02%$  2%  $2  %$12 

   /$

  //$%% %$ $/ 0%%11$1/ 2%%.2 

$&%1%/

%$%   / 0    / 0%% %  &$  2/  %&

1$

 $12%$  1%12 

0    %%/ 

 0%% 1% % 2%4  5   2   $ &$  2/2%%/%& 

 1% 5 5 $  2 2  1   $  $ / 0%% %  &

2 2$ 62$ % %$  &$$ 

$ %0%% 2%   & 1  / %4 7   /$  2  0  5 $ 2% 1%/    & $ 1%/%&%  %$ / > "##*'&#/%=&3#.0%'!"##!$!$%&#'0='!"#'3!*!#3!"*!!"#%*'/%0 $'#8!%'3%0!"##!$!$%&#'%()*&+"*7#*))'%7#/!"#3*$/8"#(#%0 (*.1*(*!$%& *&/ 5+)*33$&1%*'/ #3%.=!$%&39"$8"*'#*&&#?#/ !%!"#'#3)#8!$7#%()*&+8"#(##!$!$%&3  "# #*'&#/ %=&3#. 0%' !"# #!$!$%&#' 0='!"#' 3!*!#3 !"*!6 #!$!$%&#' %()*&+"*7#8%().$#/9$!"*..!"#/$'#8!$%&3)*33#/$&!"#'#3)#8!$7# %()*&+ =((%&3 0%' $'#8!$%&3 *&/ !"*! !"# '#3)#8!$7# %()*&+ 8"#(##!$!$%&3"*7#5##&0$.#/$&8%&3%&*&8#9$!"!"

#%'/#'3)*33#/ $&'#3)#8!$7#%()*&+=((%&30%'$'#8!$%&3  "##*'&#/%=&3#.*))#*'$&1%&5#"*.0%0!"##!$!$%&#'"*7#3!*!#/ !"*!!"##!$!$%&#'%()*&+"*7#8%().$#/9$!"*..'#A=$'#(#&!3*3)#' /$'#8!$%&3 %0 !"$3 %='! *&/ !"#+ "*7# 0$.#/ &#8#33*'+ *00$/*7$! %0 8%().$*&8#$&!"#%='!%'#%7#'6!"##!$!$%&#'%()*&+=&/#'!

!%8%().+9$!"*..3!*!=!%'+'#A=$'#(#&!3$0*&+6*3'#A=$'#/=&/#'!"# %()*&$#38!6 4-*&/'=.#3(*/#!"#'#=&/#'9"$8"#7#'$3 *)).$8*5.#"#3*$/=&/#'!*:$&1$3*88#)!#/ , "# 00$8$*.$A=$/*!%'"*30$.#/"$3'#)%'!%&3!/*+%0 =&#6$& %()*&+ 8"#(# #!$!$%& %  %0  3!*!$&1 !"*! !"# *00*$'3 %0 !"#'*&30#'%'%()*&+"*35##&8%&/=8!#/$&*)'%)#'(*&&#'*&/ !"*!!"#'*&30#'%'%()*&+(*+5#%'/#'#/!%5#/$33%.7#/

 "# #1$%&*.$'#8!%'"*30$.#/*&00$/*7$!%&-!"/*+%0 =&#6 3!*!$&1 !"#'#$&6 3*7# *&/ #?8#)! *3 3!*!#/ $& )*'*1'*)" 6 $! *))#*'3 !"*!!"#8"#(#$3&%!)'#2=/$8$*.!%!"#$&!#'#3!%03"*'#"%./#'3*&/ )=5.$8&)*'*1'*)"%0!"#3*$/00$/*7$!6!"# #1$%&*.$'#8!%'"*3 3!*!#/!"*!<B  

     

               

 

   

 



     

!  "

 



  

      #       $ 

         

  



 

    

 

 $ 

"

   

 % 0*' *3 !"# %53#'7*!$%& $& )*'*1'*)"  %0 !"# 00$/*7$! %0 #1$%&*. $'#8!%' $3 8%&8#'&#/6 !"# #*'&#/ %=&3#. 0%' !"# #!$!$%&#' %()*&$#33=5($!!"*!!"##!$!$%&#'%()*&$#3*'#5%=&/!%8%().+ 9$!" *.. *)).$8*5.# )'%7$3$%&3 %0 &8%(# *? 8! *&/ *.. !*? $33=#3 

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

$%& % , %0 $3(*/#*53%.=!#$&!#'(3%0)'*+#'8.*=3#3C*D!%C8D - "##!$!$%&#'%()*&$#3!%0$.#*8%)+%0!"$3%'/#'*&/!"#8"#(# /=.+ *=!"#&!$8*!#/ 5+ !"# %()*&+ #1$3!'*'6 $1" %='! C D6 %(5*+69$!"!"#8%&8#'&#/=)#'$&!#&/#&!%0!*()360%'!"#)=')%3# %0*/2=/$8*!$%&%03!*()/=!+)*+*5.#6 $0*&+6 %&!"#3*(#9$!"$& /*+30'%(!"#/*!#%0!"# '/#' > "##!$!$%&#'%()*&$#3*'#/$'#8!#/!%0$.#*8%)+%0%'/#'*.%&19$!" *8%)+%0!"#8"#(#%0(*.1*(*!$%&9$!"!"#8%&8#'&#/ #1$3!'

%()*&$#36 #.#8!'%&$8*..+6 *.%&1 9$!"  %'( B   $& *//$!$%& !% )"+3$8*. 8%)+ *3 )#' !"# '#.#7*&! )'%7$3$%&3 %0 !"# %()*&$#3 8!6  4-9"$8"#7#'$3*)).$8*5.#   /    8 ((((9: %  ; 21$ /  8 +' '( #/    8 ((((9:, %62$< 2.1/8

 1$0203 $,$  $.$&1*&/$33=*&8#%0!"#/'*9&=)%'/#'$3/$3)#&3#/9$!" , ..8%&8#'&#/'#1=.*!%'+*=!"%'$!$#3!%*8!%&*8%)+%0!"$3%'/#'*.%&1 9$!"8"#(#/=.+*=!"#&!$8*!#/5+!"#%()*&+ #1$3!'*'6$1"%='! C D6%(5*+ C%.*5*9*..*6 D    8#'!$0+!"*!!"$3 '/#'=).%*/#/$3*!'=#*&/8%''#8!8%)+%0%'$1$&*. 3$1&#/%'/#'

).%*/#/5+<"*&:*'*9/#6!#&%1'*)"#'