← Library
Bombay High CourtCSP/103/2015disposed off

Premier Nutricare Private Limited v. 0

2015-04-30Hon'Ble Shri Justice S.J. Kathawalla6 pages



 

 

  

             

   

         ! !"#$%$&#'($"$")*&#+             

   

         ! !"#$%$&#'($")*&#+ # ,)& $"( ,")*&#!'- . "( / 0 &#1 " ,$ $23&#  *$"3!'!"# "( ,")*&#!'- .4  # ,)& $"(- !"#'/ "/ "( , ")*&#!' - . / 0 &#1 " ,$ $23&#  *$"3!'!"# "( , ")*&#!' - .4  # ,)& $"(-,)"()&25&)& !"#"(         . 6, $&#'($"$ ")*&#+7 8! ,      .6, $&#'($")*&#+7  &221("$,&$!#5 

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

#''"(1&2!#5!#&22 +*' 1'-$!* !"#'. '*-!(!-& !"#'. ' $#5 ,' &#1 &**2!-& !"#' "( *,&$)&-> !-&2. #> $&-> !-&2 &#1 -,)!-&2 *$"1>- ' , *$"*"'1 '-,) "( )&25&)& !"# 8!22 ,&3 , :#(!  ,&  :" , ,")*&#!'&$>#1$ '&)&#&5)# &#1! 8">21:&13&# &5">' "-"):!# ,&- !3! ' &#1 "*$& !"#' !# & '!#52 ")*&#+ , &)&25&)& !"# 8!22 #&:2 , $&#'($")*&#+ "-"#'"2!1&  ,:>'!#'''&#12&1 "'+#$5!'!

"*$& !"#&#1-$& &' $"#5$(!#&#-!&2:&'&#1! 8">21:&13&# &5">' " -"):!# , &- !3! !' &#1 "*$& !"#' "( :" , -")*&#!' !# " & '!#52 ")*&#+("$'+#$5!' !-2!#<&5'&':" , ,")*&#!'&$#5&51!# , '&) +*"(:>'!#''&- !3! !'&#1 ,>' ,$8!22::#(! "(-"):!#1 (!#&#-!&2$'">$-'

 &$#1 ">#'2 ("$ ,  ! !"#$' (>$ ,$ ' & ' ,&  , "&$1 "( !$- "$' "( ,  ! !"#$ ")*&#!' ,&3 &**$"31 , '&!1 -,) "( )&25&)& !"# :+ *&''!#5 "&$1 '"2> !"#' 8,!-, &$ &##A1 " , $'*- !3")*&#+-,) ! !"#'

 ,&$#1">#'2("$ , ! !"#$'(>$ ,$' & ' ,& . ! !"#$ ")*&#!' ,&3 -")*2!1 8! , &22 , 1!$- !"#' *&''1 !# , $'*- !3 ")*&#+>))"#'("$!$- !"#'&#1 ,&  ,$'*- !3")*&#+-,)  ! !"#',&3:#(!21!#-"#'"#&#-8! , ,"$1$'*&''1!#$'*- !3 ")*&#+>))"#'("$!$- !"#' 0 , &$#1 ">#'2 &**&$!#5 "# :,&2( "( ,  ! !"#$' ,&3 ' & 1 ,&  , ! !"#$")*&#!',&3-")*2!18! ,&22$=>!$)# '&' *$ 1!$- !"#' "( ,!' ">$  &#1 ,+ ,&3 (!21 #-''&$+ &((!1&3!  "( -")*2!&#-!# ,">$ "$"3$. , ! !"#$")*&#!'>#1$ &< " -")*2+ 8! , &22 ' & > "$+ $=>!$)# ' !( &#+. &' $=>!$1 >#1$ , ")*&#!'- ./ 0% &#1 $>2' )&1 ,$ >#1$ 8,!-,3$ !' &**2!-&:2,'&!1>#1$ &<!#5!'&--* 1 

B , ((!-!&2!=>!1& "$,&'(!21,!'$*"$ "#' 1&+"(*$!2. !# ")*&#+ -,)  ! !"# "  "(   ' & !#5 ,&  , &((&!$' "( , $&#'($"$")*&#+,&3:#-"#1>- 1!#&*$"*$)&##$&#1 ,&  , $&#'($"$")*&#+)&+:"$1$1 ":1!''"231 C , 5!"#&2!$- "$,&'(!21&#((!1&3! "#/ ,1&+"(*$!2. ' & !#5 ,$!#. '&3 &#1 A-* &' ' & 1 !# *&$&5$&*, 0. !  &**&$' ,&  ,-,)!'#" *$9>1!-!&2 " ,!# $' "(',&$,"21$'&#1*>:2!-# *&$&5$&*,0"( ,'&!1((!1&3! . , 5!"#&2!$- "$,&'' & 1 ,& ?D  

         

      

 !

  " #     $         %         % &    "        

    

 

 !

  " '  (            %     

  "   $   

% 



 $       

 % $   

   !

  "'  !')*    

  +  % "

               

 &

  + ! % 



     %,

- ,"

%

    &

 +! %   .  +   %   



  % "  "    "

 



   &

  + ! %    "

   



  % / "(&$&' ,":'$3& !"#!#*&$&5$&*,06&7"( ,((!1&3! "( 5!"#&2 !$- "$ !' -"#-$#1. ,  ! !"#$ %$&#'($ ")*&#+ ,$">5, ! ' -">#'2>#1$ &<' ,&  ,$&#'($")*&#+8!22*&'''>-,&--"># !#5 # $!'8,!-,&$#-''&$+!#-"##- !"#8! , ,!'-,) "-")*2+8! , &#+" ,$--"># !#5 &#1&$1' 

"(&$&' ,":'$3& !"#!#*&$&5$&*,06:7"( ,((!1&3! "( 5!"#&2 !$- "$ !' -"#-$#1. , &$#1 ">#'2 ("$ ,  ! !"#$ ")*&#!' '>:)!  ,&  ,  ! !"#$ ")*&#!' &$ :">#1 " -")*2+ 8! , &22 &**2!-&:2*$"3!'!"#'"(#-")&A- &#1&22 &A!''>'&$!'!#5"> "( , -,)8!22:) &#1&#'8$1!#&--"$1&#-8! ,2&8  ,&$#1">#'2("$ 5!"#&2!$- "$"#!#' $>- !"#'"($ ,&#1&#&> ,>. "!# !$- "$5&2!# ,"((!-"( , 5!"#&2!$- "$. !#!' $+"("$*"$& ((&!$'. ' $# 5!"#.>):&!' & ' ,&  ,+&$ '& !'(!1 8! , , >#1$ &<!#5' 5!3# :+ ,  ! !"#$' , &:"3 >#1$ &<!#5'!'&--* 1 

$") , )& $!&2 "# $-"$1. , -,) &**&$' " : (&!$ &#1 $&'"#&:2&#1!'#" 3!"2& !3"(&#+*$"3!'!"#'"(2&8&#1!'#"  -"# $&$+ "*>:2!-*"2!-+  !#- &22 , $=>!'!  ' & > "$+ -")*2!&#-' ,&3 :# (>2(!221. ")*&#+ -,)  ! !"# "  "(   !' )&1 &:'"2>  !# $)' "( *$&+$' -2&>' 6&7 &#1 617 &#1   "(   !' )&1 &:'"2>  !# $)' "( *$&+$-2&>''6&7&#16-7 , ! !"#$")*&#!' "(!2&-"*+"( ,!'"$1$&#1 ,-,) 1>2+&> ,# !-& 1:+ ,")*&#+ 5!' $&$.!5,">$ 6 7."):&+. 8! , , -"#-$#1 >*$!# #1#  "(  &)*'. ("$ , *>$*"' "( 

&19>1!-& !"#"(' &)*1> +*&+&:2.!(&#+."# ,'&)8! ,!#01&+'($") ,1& "( , $1$  ! !"#$' &$ 1!$- 1 " (!2 & -$ !(!1 -"*+ "( "$1$ &2"#5 8! , & -"*+ "( , -,) "( )&25&)& !"# 8! , , -"#-$#1 5!' $&$ "( ")*&#!'.2- $"#!-&22+.&2"#58! , "$)DC!#&11! !"# "*,+'!-&2 -"*+ &' *$ , $23&#  *$"3!'!"#' "( , ")*&#!' - . / 0% 8,!-,3$!'&**2!-&:2 0 ,  ! !"#$ ")*&#!' " *&+ -"' ' "( '.%D &-, " ,

5!"#&2 !$- "$. ' $# 5!"#. >):&! &#1 ,  ! !"#$' !# , ")*&#+-,) ! !"#""(  "*&+-"' '"( '.%D&-, " , ((!-!&2!=>!1& "$.!5,">$ ."):&+"' ' ":*&!18! ,!#(">$ 8<'($") ,1& "( , $1$ B

!2!#5&#1!''>&#-"( ,1$&8#>*"$1$!'1!'*#'18! , C 22 -"#-$#1 $5>2& "$+ &> ,"$! !' " &-  "# & -"*+ "( ,!' "$1$ &2"#5 8! , -,) 1>2+ &> ,# !-& 1 :+ , ")*&#+ 5!' $&$. !5, ">$ 6 7."):&+ 6 @& ,&8&22&. 7