Bombay High CourtCSD/191/2015disposed off

Famy Care Limited v. -

2015-03-13Hon'Ble Shri Justice S.J. Kathawalla5 pages

!"

#$%$!&"

+"

$!&"

*- !"

#$% ) (- $-.# ", /'

)

.

$!&"

' ( ) * +* ( ) "

( )

$% *-

!"

#

) ! $%

"!2"# '!'

,3 ! #0 ,$!&"

24 ,

"'"#!"'!'

24 , '## (& ) , $#(

"!2 "# '!'

,* )$!&"

)$#&$#"

,5 , # &#$7'('$ ($% $!&"

' ( ) +* "7'

# 0'( # , $%%') ('

5"

#",2 $5( * -#, 6$$#* 8.* # "#'!"

$",* $# *5!1"'9. ::&&6')"

#('(;"!"

'818(#"/%$#,"26 2<$*,7$)"

%$#&&6')"

$!&"

2 = ;>* =- *

2 "1$7 "! , 12 " * #('(;"!"

#5)

128(#"/%$#,"26 2<$*,7$)"

(%$#

2*

%%',"7'

,"

,.

,"2$% 1#5"#2* $%#$&"6 ",,"* 5 $#'( , '0 $#2 $%

2* '

(5&&$# ( %$# '# ) * "

?'1'

# '

# % ## , $*

@= )$ 0"

,$6,'

0$% !

0$% A5'

2"# $6, #(

2%$# &5#&$( $%)$ (', #'

0"

,*'% $50 %'

"&&#$7'

0 /'

$# /'

$5 !$,'%')"

3(4* &#$&$( , ) ! $%

1 "!2 "# '!'

, 3 ! #0 , $!&"

24 "

"' "#!"'!'

24"

'## (& ) $#(* '( ,'(& ( , /'

7' / $% )$

0'7 12 "66

A5'

2 "# $6, #( $%

2* /') "# "

? , "( ?'1'

(B@C $B@C %%',"7'

5&&$# $%$!&"

25!!$ %$#'# ) )$ 0"

,$6,'

!

0$% )5# ,# ,'

$#($%

2*%$# &5#&$( $%)$ (', #'

0*"

,'% $50 %'

"&&#$7'

0* /'

$# /'

$5 !$,'%')"

3(4* ) ! $% ##"

"!2"# '!'

,3 ! #0 ,$!&"

24"

"'"#!"'!'

0 $!&"

24 "

'# # (& ) '7 "# $6, #( "

, # ,'

$#(* '( ,'(& 7' /$%"7 #!

&"#"0#"&($% %%',"7'

5&&$# $% 5!!$ ( %$# '# ) ( * '

# "6'"* ( )5# , $#($%

2"# "%% ) ,"("% #, ! #0 #

"(( ( $%

$!&"!2 '( %$ !$# ( 6'"1'6'

' ( "

, &&6')"

2 5 , # "D $ $1 "'

$@ 1E ) # '%')"

( %$# &#$&$( , ) ! $% ##"

%#$! '

( )5# , # ,'

$#( 1 %$# %'6'

0 $% & * %"'6'

0 /')

2 5 , # "D ( '((5 '

,'7',5"6 ') $% ,"

$% "#'

0$% 12 0'( # , $( 5&$ ( )5# ,# ,'

$#("

,"6($ $&516'( ') $% "#'

6$)"6 /(&"& #(* 7'F B # # (( $5# "6C '

06'( "

05"0 "

#"

(6"

# $%'

B"7("D 'C'

"#"

'"

05"0 *1$ "7'

0)'#)56"

5!1"' ("',5 , # "D'

0'(")) & , - )$ 0"

,$6,'

!

0$%

( )5# ,# ,'

$#(

2*%$# &5#&$( $%)$ (', #'

0*"

,'% $50 %'

"&&#$7'

0* /'

$# /'

$5 !$,'%')"

3(4* &#$&$( , ) ! $%

1 "!2 "# '!'

, 3 ! #0 , $!&"

24 "

"' "#!"'!'

24"

'## (& ) $#(*'(,'(& 7' /$%"7 #!

&"#"0#"&-$%

%%',"7'

5&&$# $%5!!$ (*'

#"6'"*( #!( $% ) ! $% ##"

/'66 "D $7 # "66 , 1 (* 6'"1'6'

' (*,5 ' ("

,$16'0"

("(/ 66"(1 7 ( ,/'

"66 "(( ("

&#$& # ' ($% ! #0 ,$!&"

2% ###"

"6"(( ($%

! #0 , $!&"

2 /$56, 1 !$# (5%%')'

$ ,'()"#0 6'"1'6'

' ( $% ! #0 , $!&"

2 "

, # "D ( $'((5 '

,'7',5"6 ') $% ,"

$% "#'

0$%

12 0'( # ,$( 5&$

( )5# ,# ,'

$#("

,"6($ $&516'(

') $% "#'

0 $% 6$)"6 /(&"& #(* 7'F B # # ((

$5# "6C '

06'( "

05"0 "

#"

(6"

# $% '

B"7("D 'C '

"#"

' "

05"0 * 1$ "7'

0 )'#)56"

5!1"' ("', , # "D'

0'(")) & . "( & # )6"5( 3G4 $% () ! * ,'%% # ) ( 1 7"65 $%"(( ("

,7"65 $%6'"1'6'

' ( #"

(% ## ,&5#(5"

) ! * '% &$('

'7 * ("66 1 ",E5( , %'#( "0"'

)"&'

"6 # , !& # ( #7 "))$5

?

"7"'6"16 *( )$ ( )5#'

' (&# !'5!"))$5

?

"7"'6"16 * '#, 0 #"6# ( #7 ?

"7"'6"16 , # !"'

0 1"6"

) "0"'

&#$%'

< 6$(( "))$5

1"6"

) "

, '%

0"

'7 * ("66 1 )# ,'

$ )"&'

"6 # ( #7 "))$5

&#$&$( , '6'("

8 # ,5) "&'

"6 , !& ( #7 "

, ( )5#'

' ( &# !'5!"))$5

$%

2("661 "%% ) ,"("

0#"6 &"# $% ) ! "

,'

7' /$% "7 #!

&"#"0#"&.$%

%%',"7'

5&&$# $% $!&"

2 5!!$ ( %$# '# ) * '

# "6'"* # ,5) $% "&'

"6 , !& ( #7 "

, ( )5#'

' ( &# !'5!"))$5

,$ ( 7$67 '

#,'!'

$%6'"1'6'

2'

# (& ) $% &"',("# )"&'

"6$#&"2!

$"

2("# $6, #$%"

2&"',@5&("# )"&'

"6 &&6')"

2"(&"(("& )'"6 ($65 &5#(5"

&#$7'('$ ($% ) $% +'

?

#" #,'

"#2 #"6 0$%'

(A5'

2"# $6, #(%$## ,5) $%"# "&'

"6$%

2"

,("! '("

? ,"(?'1'

7' /$%"1$7 * &#$) ,5# &# ()#'1 ,5 , # ( ) 34$% +'(,'(& 3 ;"

"/"66"* 4