← Library
Bombay High CourtCSD/341/2016absolute

Suranjan Holding And Estate Developers Pvt Ltd v. -

2016-04-29Hon'Ble Shri Justice S.C. Gupte4 pages



 

 

  

     

         !"#!$%& !%"'# (!)*%& +, -.     ! "#!$ %& !*(% ) + % + %&  !%"'# (!)*/+, .   "#!$ %& * !"! %& "#01#"#(% 1 5 )#! !6!0%'!$) $(6#! ("(!4 78 ! $# )&!$%$%"'# 9:- ; <!9)% !#0%$) $(6#! ("(!4 78 ! $# 9:-   !($$!)'!*(6! #$! %04!$)  

  

  

  /# *%"'# 9 *%$'%$#!4 4!$ (!)*/+,  #6( 1()$!1()!$!4 %&&(*! # = / #$#3/  %#4 *(% / ;!)!$ >'$!))(1 ?#9/ 4 !$(7#)-/ 2"@#(A

+ - - - - - - -B''0(*# 9 

  !"    # $ #3!)  # (C@C) #3!)  # 5%/&%$ !''0(*# 9  %$#"D  #!D+ %&'$(0     

   ! #''0(*#(%  %&  ! ''0(*# 9 #@%6! #"!4 @9 # 2""%       $ #3!)   #  )$2*!4 @9 C) #3!)   #  5 %/ 46%*#! &%$  ! ''0(*# 

9/    !&&(4#6(4#!4+ #$* /  %& $ %3!)   #E%$/ 2 %$(F!4 (1 #%$9/ %&  ! ''0(*# 9/ ( )2''%$%& !2""% )&%$($!*(% # 4 !> (@( !$!( $!&!$$!4%/   DG   !*% 6!

1# 4 %04( 1 !"!!( 1%& !H2(9 #$! %04!$)%&  !''0(*# 9/&%$ !'2$'%)!%&*% )(4!$( 1# 4/(& %21  &(/ #''$%6( 1/ ?(  %$ ?( %2 "%4(&(*#(% 7)-/  ! * !"! %& "#01#"#(% 1 5 )#! !6!0%'!$) $(6#! ("(!4 ?(  <!9)% !#0%$) $(6#! ("(!4 # 4  !($ $!)'!*(6!  #$! %04!$)/()4()'!

)!4?( ( 6(!?%&*% )!

1(6!

@9@%  ! H2(9 #$! %04!$)%& !''0(*# 9/? (* #$!#

!>!4#) $% & "

'()*%'(+*% !&&(4#6(( )2''%$%& !2""% )&%$ ($!*(%    !*% 6!

1# 4 %04( 1 !"!!( 1%& !)%0!!*2$!4$!4(%$ %&  ! ''0(*# 9/ &%$  ! '2$'%)! %& *% )(4!$( 1 # 4/ (&  %21  &(/ #''$%6( 1/?( %$?( %2 "%4(&(*#(% 7)-/ ! '$%'%)!4 * !"! %& "#01#"#(% 1 5 )#! !6!0%'!$) $(6#! ("(!4 ?(  <!9)% !#0%$) $(6#! ("(!4 # 4  !($ $!)'!*(6! #$! %04!$)()4()'!

)!4?( ( 6(!?%&#6!$"!

)"#4! '#$#1$#'  %& !&&(4#6(( )2''%$%&%"'# 92""% )&%$ ($!*(% 4  #  ! ''0(*# 9 2 4!$#E!) % ())2! 4(6(42#0 %(*!%& !4#!%& !#$( 1%& !!((% @9 % ())%0!!*2$!4$!4(%$# 4#0)%%'2@0()  !)#"!( ?%0%*#0 

!?)'#'!$) 6(F I $!! $!)) %2$ #0J/ (   10()  0# 12#1! # 4 $# )0#(%   !$!%& (  I#6) #E(J/ (  #$# ( 0# 12#1!/ @%  #6( 1 *($*20#(% ( 2"@#( !)#(42 4!$#E( 1()#**!'!4   !*% 6!

1# 4 %04( 1 !"!!( 1%& !

)!*2$!4$!4(%$)%&  !''0(*# 9/&%$ !'2$'%)!%&*% )(4!$( 1# 4/(& %21  &(/#''$%6( 1/?( %$?( %2"%4(&(*#(% 7)-/ !'$%'%)!4* !"! %& "#01#"#(% 1 5 )#! !6!0%'!$) $(6#! ("(!4 ?(  <!9)% !#0%$) $(6#! ("(!4 # 4  !($ $!)'!*(6!  #$! %04!$) () 4()'!

)!4 ?(  (  6(!? %& #6!$"!

) "#4! ( '#$#1$#'  = %&  ! &&(4#6( (  )2''%$ %& %"'# 9 2""% ) &%$ ($!*(% 4  #  ! ''0(*# 9 2 4!$#E!) % ())2! 4(6(42#0 %(*!)%& !4#!%& !#$( 1%& !!((% @9 % #00()

)!*2$!4$!4(%$)# 4#0)%%'2@0()  !)#"!( ?%0%*#0

!?)'#'!$) 6(F I $!! $!)) %2$ #0J/ (   10()  0# 12#1! # 4 $# )0#(%   !$!%& (  I#6) #E(J/ (  #$# ( 0# 12#1!/ @%  #6( 1 *($*20#(% ( 2"@#( !)#(42 4!$#E( 1()#**!'!4   ! ''0(*# 9 () # ? %009 %?

!4 )2@)(4(#$9 %&  ! $# 9# 4 !$!() %$!G%$1# (F#(% %&) #$!*#'(#0%&  !$# 9# 4 % !?) #$!)#$!$!H2($!4%@!())2!4 @9  ! $# )&!$!! %"'# 9 # 4 $(1 ) %& *$!4(%$) %& $# )&!$!! 9#$! %#&&!*!4#)"!

(% !4( '#$#1$#' )K%%& ! &&(4#6( (  )2''%$ %& %"'# 9 2""% 4 

%@)!$6#(% )"#4!@9 ()*%2$( # ##"@# 6!)"!

46!$)!) ("(!47

- ,%*#)!)'#1!K%/ !&(0( 1%&)!'#$#! 9 2""% 4 %"'# 9 * !"! !((% 4!$!*(% +# 4+%& !%"'# (!)*/+, @9<!9)%

!#0%$)$(6#!("(!4/ !$# 9()4()'!

)!4?(   7 / -   ,  *!$(&9 #  () $4!$2'0%#4!4 () #$2! # 4 *%$$!**%'9 %&  !%$(1( #0 )(1 !4%$4!$

'0%#4!49D # E#$#?4!/!

%1$#' !$