← Library
Bombay High CourtCSP/340/2015absolute

Ubiquitous Trading Pvt. Ltd. v. -

2015-08-14Hon'Ble Shri Justice S.C. Gupte8 pages

 



            

 

   

 !"

 

#

       !$" !"





   

%&%&'()&(*% ('*((+,'-          

 

   

! !"

 

#

       !$. !"

      

%&%&'()/'0 ('*((+,'-          

 

   

 !"

 

#

       !$1 !"

     



   

%&%&'() ('*((+,'-   

       

 

   

 !"

 

#

       !$3 !"

 





%&%&'() ('*(+,'- '%2+%%(%2+,'&*/%4!!$". '0%2((56'%,(6&*&'*%2+,'&* /%4 !

7   ' %2 +%%(  /%&'* $! % $   %2 +,'&* /%4 !$". '0 %2( (56'% ,(6&*&'*%2+,'&*/%4 !

7   ' %2 +%%(  /2+  +5+%&'  8    

 

4 9%2 &(*% ('*(( +,'-: '0

  



49%2/'0

('*(( +,'-: '0 #

;   

      



4 9%2 ('*(( +,'-: <&%2  



49%2 

('*(+,'-: 

    

     550(2(&' ( =*222&)>=*222? 406/%(%2%&%&'(*&'55%&%&'* (* 02@>5;=5&)>(   '*(&(&'5&(/%(&'>%2%2%&%&'* (  +A'%24&/&5&B@&0%(4,(*'%&' 

%

 !"

C  @,%4 

C!

%2@@*%4 !" C

(0('0@'*5(%2,(%&*  >=/%(2*/+>(%2/@(% %,,*%2/2+'0'('-,(%-2*/'%(6(%0'-6(+'%*+0&'%2 %&%&'*

2 *'/%&'  %2 @(% &* *@2% %  /2+  +5+%&'  8   



4%2&(*% ('*((+,'-'0

 



4%2/'0 ('*((+,'-'0 #

;  

    



4%2

('*(( +,'- <&%2    

 

4 %2

('*(+,'-4@'0(/%&'* $!% $ %2+,'&*/%4!$".

2 ('0 @'*5 ( %2 %&%&'(* *%%* %2% %2 &(*% ('*(( +,'-&*'0&'%2/%&6&%&* (0&'&'/++0&%&*'0'6*%+'%*? 

(0&'&'2(*?/@(&%&*'0%2/'0 ('*((+,'-&*'0&'

(0&' '0 '6*%+'% /%&6&%&* '0 ('*(( +,'- &* '0 &' '6*%+'% /%&6&%&* '0 ('*( +,'- &* '0 &' %2 /%&6&%&* 

(0&'&'/++0&%&*'0'6*%+'%*? (0&'&'2(*?

('*((+,'&*'0%2 ('*(+,'-

('0@'*5(%2%&%&'(*@(%2(*%%*%2%%2(0&(/%(* %2 %&%&'( +,'&* 26 ,,(60 %2 *&0 /2+  +5+%&' >- 

,**&' (0 *5@%&'* <2&/2 ( ''D0 % %2 (*,/%&6 +,'- /2+ %&%&'* "

2 ('0 @'*5 ( %2 %&%&'(* @(%2( *%%* %2%4 %&%&'( +,'&*26/+,5&0<&%255%20&(/%&'*,**0&'%2(*,/%&6+,'- @++'*(&(/%&'*'0%2%%2(*,/%&6+,'-/2+%&%&'*26>' &50 &' /'*''/ <&%2 %2 (0(* ,**0 &' (*,/%&6 +,'- @++'* ( &(/%&'* .

2('0@'*5,,(&''>25%2%&%&'(*26*%%0%2%%2 %&%&'(+,'&*26 /+,5&0 <&%2 55(B@&(+'%** ,(0&(/%&'*  %2&* @(%'0%2-26&50'/**(-&06&%/+,5&'/&'%2@(% (6(4 %2%&%&'(+,'&*@'0(%A%/+,5-<&%255*%%@%(-(B@&(+'%*&'-4 *(B@&(0@'0(%2+,'&*/%4!$".)  '0 (@5* +0 %2( @'0( <2&/26(&*,,5&/>5 2*&0@'0(%A&'&*//,%0

2 &/&5 &B@&0%( 2* &50 2&* (,(% ' !%2 0-  @@*%4 !" &' +,'- /2+ %&%&' *

 %

  !" *%%&' %2% %2 &(*  %2

('*(( +,'&* 26 >' /'0@/%0 &'  ,(,( +''( '0 %2% %2

('*((+,'-+->(0(0%>0&**560

2&'5&(/%(2*&50'&06&%' (00-@5-4 !"*%%&' %2(&'4*6'0D/,%**%%0&',((,2.4&%,,(*%2%%2/2+&*'% 

,(=@0&/&5 % %2 &'%(*%  *2(250(* '0 ,@>5&/  ' ,((,2 .  %2 *&0 &06&%4%2&'5&(/%(2**%%0%2%CF  

   9:         

    

              !

   "

        # 

        # $             



            %

 &       #

   %

 %'(  )* 

  +  #           

 $  + #

 



    #,

- ,  #

   $   + #  .  +   #  

   #             

   

    $   +  #

 

  

   #  $  ( * %2 >*(6%&' &' ,((,2 . 9:  %2 &06&%  &'5 &(/%(&*/'/('04%2%&%&'(+,'-%2(@2&%*/@'*5*@>+&%%0 %2% &' 00&%&' % %2 /+,5&'/  //@'%&' %'0(0 G !  %2

('*(+,'-*255,***@/2//@'%&''%(&*<2&/2('/**(- &'/''/%&'<&%2%2/2+%/+,5-<&%2%2(,,5&/>5//@'%&' %'0(0*@/2*F"%/   ( * %2 >*(6%&' &' ,((,2 .9>:  %2 &06&%  &'5 &(/%( &* /'/('04 %2 ('0 @'*5 ( %2 %&%&'( +,'&* 

*@>+&% %2% %2 %&%&'( +,'&* ( >@'0 % /+,5- <&%2 55 ,,5&/>5,(6&*&'*'/+ D/%'055%D&**@*(&*&'@%%2 /2+<&55>+%'0'*<(0&'//(0'/<&%25< !!

2 ('0 @'*5 ( &'5 &(/%( ' &'*%(@/%&'*  (   2'0'@%2@4&'%&(/%(5&'%2&/%2&'5&(/%(4&'&*%(- (,(%&(*4#*%('&'4@+>&*%%*%2%%2-(*%&*&0<&%2%2 @'0(%A&'*&6'>-%2%&%&'(* 2>6@'0(%A&'*&*//,%0 (+%2+%(&5'(/(04%2/2+,,(*%>&('0(*'>5'0 &*'%6&5%&6'-,(6&*&'*5<'0&*'%/'%((-%,@>5&/,5&/-

&'/ 55 %2 (B@&*&% *%%@%(- /+,5&'/* 26 >' @5&5504 +,'- /2+%&%&' *

%

 !"&*+0>*5@%&'%(+*,(-(*/5@* 9:49>:'090:'0

 !"&*+0>*5@%&'%(+*,(-(/5@**9:'0 9/:

2 %&%&'( +,'&* % &5  /,-  %2&* (0( '0 %2 /2+ 0@5- @%2'%&/%0 >- %2 +,'- &*%((4 &2 @(% 9 :4 +>-4 <&%2 %2 /'/('0@,(&'%'0'%%+,*4(%2,@(,*0=@0&/%&'*%+,0@%- ,->54&'-4'%2*+<&%2&'.0-*(+%20%%2(0( !"

%&%&'(*(0&(/%0%&5/(%&&0/,-(0(5'<&%2/,-%2 /2++5+%&'<&%2%2/'/('0&*%((+,'&*45/%('&/55-4  

5'<&%2 (+ F 3&'00&%&'%,2-*&/5/,-*,(%2(56'%,(6&*&'* %2+,'&*/%4!$".) !

<2&/26(&*,,5&/>5 !.

2 %&%&'( +,'&* % ,- /*%*  * !4)F /2 % %2 &'5 &(/%(4 #*%(' &'4 @+>& '0 %2 %&%&'(* &' %2 +,'- /2+ %&%&' *

 %

  !" % ,- /*%*  * !4)F /2 % %2 &/&5 &B@&0%(4 &2@(%4+>- *%*%>,&0<&%2&'@(<A*(+%20% %2(0( !1 &5&''0&**@'/%20(<'@,(0(&*0&*,'*0<&%2 !3 55/'/('0(@5%(-@%2(&%&*%/%'/,-%2&*(0(5'<&%2 /2+0@5-@%2'%&/%0>-%2+,'-&*%((4 &2@(%9  :4+>- 9  @,%4 :