Bombay High CourtCSP/359/2016scheme sanctioned company

Aurangabad Electricals Ltd. v. -

2016-11-25Hon'Ble Shri Justice S.C. Gupte12 pages

!"#$"%"&'()*!+)"',+-+*(& ....(*+*+/#(!0(-(!$(&/-1"#2

"$'"'()*!+)"',"#&'()*!/#+),!+3"*(+-+*(& ...(*+*+/#(!0 (, '*+#$/-1"#2

"$'"#& ,*!+(,!+3"*(+-+*(& ...(*+*+/#(!0 (, '*+#$/-1"#2 # *4( -"**(! /5 *4( /-1"#+(, )*6 7 /5

8 # *4( -"**(! /5 ()*+/#, */ 9 !("& :+*4 ()*+/#,

/5*4(/-1"#+(,)*6 "#& /*4(! "11'+)"%'( 1!/3+,+/#, /5 *4( /-1"#+(, )*6

; # *4( -"**(! /5 )4(-( /5 !!"#$(-(#* %(*:((#

7<(-(!$(& /-1"#2=8 #& 7< (, '*+#$ /-1"#2 =8 #& 7< (, '*+#$ /-1"#2=8"#&*4(+!!(,1()*+3(,4"!(4/'&(!,"#& )!(&+*/!,

, '1"#" 4/#( "0: ! ">(,4 4"4 +0% ">(,4 4"4 ? /6 &3/)"*( 5/! *4( (*+*+/#(!, !#"#& +#$46+0%!#,"!+5/! ($+/#"'+!()*/! @ 6 @*4

("!& *4( '("!#(& / #,(' 5/! *4( (*+*+/#(! /-1"#+(, / /%>()*/! 4", )/-( %(5/!( *4( )/ !* */ /11/,( *4( )4(-( "#& #/! "#2 1"!*2 4", )/#*!/3(!*(&"#2"3(!-(#*-"&(+#*4((*+*+/#, 4( ,"#)*+/# /5 *4( / !* +, ,/ $4* #&(! ()*+/#, */ 9 !("& :+*4 ()*+/#,

/5*4(/-1"#+(,)*6 "#&/*4(!!('(3"#*1!/3+,+/#, /5 *4( /-1"#+(, )*6

6 */ *4( )4(-( /5 !!"#$(-(#* %(*:((#

6 (-(!$(& /-1"#2 "#& 6

(, '*+#$ /-1"#2 "#& 6

(, '*+#$/-1"#2"#&*4(+! (,1()*+3(,4"!(4/'&(!,"#&)!(&+*/!,

4('("!#(&/ #,('5/!*4((*+*+/#(!,*"*(,*4"**4((-(!$(&/-1"#2+, 1!+-"!+'2 (#$"$(& +# -"# 5")* !+#$ /5 " */-/%+'( "#& %!"A( ,2,*(- )/-1/#(#*,:4+)4+#)' &(," */('()*!+)"')/-1/#(#*,"#&"' -+#+ -&+(B )",*+#$ )/-1/#(#*, 4( (, '*+#$ /-1"#2 +, 2(* */ )/--(#)( "#2 % ,+#(,, 4( (, '*+#$ /-1"#2 +, (#$"$(& +# *4( -"# 5")* !+#$6 ",,(-%'+#$61!/)(,,+#$6+-1/!*+#$6(C1/!*+#$6*!"&+#$65"%!+)"*+#$"#&&("'+#$ +# 3"!+/ , A+#&, /5 ('()*!+)"'6 ('()*!/-()4"#+)"' "#& ('()*!/#+) 1"!*,6 )/-1/#(#*,6+#,*! -(#*,6"11"!"* ,6(*) 9 ("!#(& / #,(' 5/! *4( (*+*+/#(! /-1"#+(, , %-+*, *4"* *4( (-(!$(& /-1"#24",*4!((,*!"*($+)% ,+#(,, #+*,"#&*4(,($!($"*+/#/5'()*!+)"'

#&(!*"A+#$"#& ("',*"*( #&(!*"A+#$5!/-*4((-(!$(&/-1"#2+#*/ &+55(!(#*(#*+*+(,+,*/(#"%'(% ,+#(,,*/$!/:"#&")4+(3(+*,5 ''1/*(#*+"' 4( % ,+#(,, #+*, #((& )/#)(#*!"*(& (55/!*, "#& 5/) , "#& 4(#)( *4( "#"$(-(#* /5 (-(!$(& /-1"#2 *4/ $4* +* 5+* */ ,($!($"*( *4( *4!(( % ,+#(,, #+*, /5 (-(!$(& /-1"#2 +#*/ ,(1"!"*( )/-1"#+(,6 3+D6

(, '*+#$ /-1"#2 "#& (, '*+#$ /-1"#2 4+, :+'' 4('1 *4( +( ",*+#$ ,+#(,,&+3+,+/#/5(-(!$(&/-1"#2*/$!/:+#&(1(#&(#*'2:+*4 %(**(!5/) ,"#&5/) ,(&/1(!"*+/#, 4((*+*+/#(! /-1"#+(,"11!/3(& *4( ,"+& )4(-(%2 1",,+#$ *4( /"!&

(,/' *+/# +# *4(+! !(,1()*+3( -((*+#$, "#& :4+)4 "!( "##(C(& */ *4( !(,1()*+3(/-1"#2)4(-((*+*+/#,

4('("!#(&)/ #,('5/!*4((*+*+/#(!,,*"*(,*4"**4((*+*+/#(!/-1"#+(, 4"3( )/-1'+(& :+*4 "'' &+!()*+/#, 1",,(& +# /-1"#2 --/#, 5/!

+!()*+/#,"#&*4"**4()4(-(4",%((#5+'(&+#)/#,/#"#)(:+*4*4(/!&(!, 1",,(&+#!(,1()*+3(/-1"#2 --/#,5/!+!()*+/#, E / #,(' "11("!+#$ /# %(4"'5 /5 *4( (*+*+/#(!, 4", ,*"*(& *4"* *4(2 4"3( )/-1'+(&:+*4"''!(F +!(-(#*,",1(!&+!()*+/#,/5*4+,/ !*"#&*4(24"3( 5+'(&#()(,,"!255+&"3+*,/5)/-1'+"#)(+#*4(/ !*/!(/3(!6(*+*+/#(! /-1"#+(, #&(!*"A( */ )/-1'2 :+*4 "'' ,*"* */!2 !(F +!(-(#*,6 +5 "#26 ", !(F +!(& #&(!*4(/-1"#+(,)*6 "#&/-1"#+(,)*6

"#&*4(

'(, -"&( *4(!( #&(!6 ", -"2 %( "11'+)"%'( 4( ,"+& #&(!*"A+#$ +, "))(1*(& G 4( ($+/#"' +!()*/! 4", 5+'(& "# 55+&"3+* /# *4 )*/%(!6

+# *4( "%/3((*+*+/#,*"*+#$*4(!(+#*4"*,"3("#&(C)(1*",,*"*(&+#1"!"$!"14 7"8 */7'8/5*4(,"+&55+&"3+*6+*"11("!,*4"**4(,)4(-(+,#/*1!(> &+)+"'*/*4( +#*(!(,* /5 ,4"!(4/'&(!, "#& 1 %'+) # 1"!"$!"14, 7"8 */ 7'8 /5 *4( ,"+& 55+&"3+*6*4( ($+/#"'+!()*/!4",,*"*(&*4"*@B

! "

#$%&'%(&$)

(&$*$) +

$##

!(&$# - .

! (&$*% ,

, !

0($

!$1)0!

*)&

%(&$#%

2 % ,

6 5 "

2 72

% ! 8 #$%&'%(&$)

, %5 "

0($

!$1)0!

*)&

% (&$#% .

.9""

%4 ,-

, $#$&(&$0

#$$((&$0% .

.9"

- ! ,

!4 ,-

, $#$&(&$0!"

.9"

%! 3

% 4 ,-

, $#$&(&$0!2

, %5 -,!"

;9" <

.9"

, 3 =

4 >, -

&/%$&%(&$*

! (&$#

4 % 8 !"

, >, "

+%%! =

4 >, -%% %&1%$$%(&$)%4 "

% ?

- &'%$$%(&$)@

, >, -%% &1%$$%(&$)%

, - "

- > "

! 93 ,

444 +

+9 A

, . = % ,

, 9! ,

444+=+#(!+#/ +*1!

*+$+

! (&$#-

!(&$#%

! 8

, ,

% .

.9"

93 ,

444 +

% "

!,7+$

= (

= #.

= % 4

. =

>=.

. = ,

% "

444+=+)@+/! - ? !>

(&$$$( (&$*$)

+94

. = "

- 3

, . = %5 -,!=

4 >,% %!

3, 9%

3, -

- - 3 .

.9"

= %4 ,-

, "

, , ,

#$&#(&$0

$#$&(&$0 % 5 -,! 3

!.9",

%$'&+$+

!(&$#%

: .

.9"

: %4 ,-

$#$&(&$0!"

44@444

.9"

>,% % +.

;

%$ =

4 >,% %+.

;

% ( . $#$&(&$0

8 %5 !

" ! - ,

$&& $&#

!$1)0%B #,/5"!",/%,(!3"*+/#,-"&(+#1"!"$!"14 7"8"#&7)8/5*4(55+&"3+*/5 *4( ($+/#"'+!()*/!"!()/#)(!#(&6*4((*+*+/#(!4",(C1'"+#(&%(5/!(*4+, / !* *4"* *4(!( 4"3( %((# &+,)'/, !(, +#,/5"! ", *4( 1"!*+) '"! &(3+"*+/#, 5!/-B 9"!()/#)(!#(&:+*4+#*4(-("#+#$/5'" ,(9/5*4(4(

($+/#"'+!()*/!,*"*(,*4"*4(#/:4",#//%>()*+/#/#*4+,,)/!(

#,/5"!",/%,(!3"*+/#,-"&(+#1"!"$!"14 7%8/5*4(55+&"3+*/5 ($+/#"' +!()*/! +, )/#)(!#(&6 *4( (*+*+/#(! /-1"#2 #&(!*"A(, *4"* *"C +-1'+)"*+/#,6 +5 "#2 "!+,+#$ / * /5 *4( )4(-( ,4"'' %( , %>()* */ 5+#"' &()+,+/# /5 *4( #)/-( "C *4/!+*2 "#& "11!/3"' /5 *4( )4(-( %2 *4( +$4 / !* -"2 #/* &(*(! *4( #)/-( "C *4/!+*2 */ ,)! *+#+D( *4( *"C

!(* !#,5+'(&%2*4((*+*+/#(!/-1"#2"5*(!$+3+#$(55()**/*4()4(-(/5 !!"#$(-(#*

# ,/ 5"! ", /%,(!3"*+/#, -"&( +# 1"!"$!"14 7&8 /5 *4( 55+&"3+* /5 *4(

($+/#"' +!()*/! +, )/#)(!#(&6 *4( (*+*+/#(! /-1"#+(, *4!/ $4 *4(+! )/ #,(' #&(!*"A(*4"**4()4(-(/5!!"#$(-(#*,4"''%(-"&((55()*+3(/# /!%(5/!( 0

,5"!",/%,(!3"*+/#,-"&(+#1"!"$!"14 7(8/5*4("55+&"3+*/5*4( ($+/#"' +!()*/!"!()/#)(!#(&6)/#,+&(!+#$*4(5")**4"**4(&(-(!$(&)/-1"#24", "'!("&2 1"+& 5 '' ,*"-1 & *2 /# *4( %",+, /5 " &((-(& )/#3(2"#)( /# *4( *4!(("$!((-(#*,*/,(''6:4(!( 1/#*4("$!((-(#*,4"3(%((#!($+,*(!(&6*4( /%>()*+/#4",#/-(!+*"*"''

# ,/ 5"! ", /%,(!3"*+/#, -"&( +# 1"!"$!"14 758 /5 *4( 55+&"3+* /5 *4(

($+/#"'+!()*/!+,)/#)(!#(&6*4((-(!$(&/-1"#2*4!/ $4+*,)/ #,(' !(1!(,(#*,*4"**4(,"+&'"#&+,4('&+#>/+#*/:#(!,4+1:+*4*4(1!/-/*(!!

+,4+ H -"! "$'""#&!, "-*""$'"4(,(1!/-/*(!, 4"3( "'!("&2 )/#,(#*(&*/*4()4(-(",,4"!(4/'&(!,/5 !"#$"%"&'()*!+)"',+-+*(& "#& 5 !*4(! *4( /"!& /5 +!()*/!, /5 !"#$"%"& '()*!+)"', +-+*(& 4", "11!/3(& *4( )4(-( 4 ,6 (")4 1"!*2 4", )/#,(#*(& */ *4( ,)4(-( /5 "!!"#$(-(#*4(,"+&(C1'"#"*+/#+,5/ #&*/%(,"*+,5")*/!2

9 #,/5"!",/%,(!3"*+/#,-"&(+#1"!"$!"14 7$8"#&748/5*4(55+&"3+*/5 *4( ($+/#"' +!()*/! +, )/#)(!#(&6 *4( (, '*+#$ /-1"#2 *4!/ $4 +*, )/ #,(' #&(!*"A(,*/+#)/!1/!"*() !!(#*)'" ,(787867E8"#&798

!($"!&+#$*4()"!!2+#$/ */5 ("',*"*( ,+#(,,+#*4("+# %>()*,'" ,( +#*4((-/!"#& -/5,,/)+"*+/#7 84((C1'"#"*+/#+,5/ #&*/%( ,"*+,5")*/!2

,5"!",*4(/%>()*+/#"*(!+"' 7>8/5*4("55+&"3+*/5*4( ($+/#"'+!()*/! +,)/#)(!#(&6+*+,)/-1'(*('2-("#+#$'(,,"#&4(#)(6+$#/!(&

# ,/ 5"! ", /%,(!3"*+/#, -"&( +# 1"!"$!"14 7A8 /5 *4( 55+&"3+* /5 *4(

($+/#"' +!()*/! +, )/#)(!#(&6 *4( (*+*+/#(! /-1"#+(, *4!/ $4 *4(+! )/ #,(' #&(!*"A( */ &('(*(*4( )"''/1*+/#)'" ,()/#*"+#(& +# )4(& '( "#&/5*4()4(-(("!#(&/ #,('5/!*4((*+*+/#(!/-1"#+(,,((A, '("3(*/"-(#&*4()4(-("))/!&+#$'24(("3(+,$!"#*(&-(#&-(#* */%()"!!+(&/ *:+*4+#5/ !:((A,5!/-*4(&"*(/5*4( !&(!

E # ,/ 5"! ", /%,(!3"*+/#, -"&( +# 1"!"$!"14 7'8 /5 *4( 55+&"3+* /5 *4(

($+/#"'+!()*/!+,)/#)(!#(&6+*+,, %-+**(&*4"*%2/!&(!&"*(&

*41!+'

6 5/''/:+#$ /5 1!/)(& !( 1!(,)!+%(& #&(! ()*+/#

78 /5 *4( /-1"#+(,)*6 :",&+,1(#,(&:+*45/!*4(!(",/#,",,(*/ *+#1"!" "#& 1"!" /5 *4( 55+&"3+* +# , 11/!* /5 --/#, 5/! +!()*+/# 5/!

(, '*+#$/-1"#2 "#& (, '*+#$/-1"#24((*+*+/#(!"',/, %-+*, *4"**4(24"3()/-1'+(&:+*4"''#()(,,"!21!/3+,+/#,/5'":4((C1'"#"*+/# +,5/ #&*/%(,"*+,5")*/!2

G 4( ("!#(& / #,(' 5/! ($+/#"' +!()*/! /# +#,*! )*+/#, /5 !

"-"A"#*4" /+#*+!()*/!+#*4(/55+)(/5*4( ($+/#"'+!()*/!6+#+,*!2/5

/!1/!"*(55"+!,6(,*(!# ($+/#6 -%"+,*"*(,*4"**4(2"!(,"*+,5+(&:+*4 *4( #&(!*"A+#$0, %-+,,+/#, $+3(# %2 *4( (*+*+/#(!0 (, '*+#$ /-1"#+(, 4(,"+& #&(!*"A+#$,"#&, %-+,,+/#,"!("))(1*(&

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

&"2,5!/-*4(&"*(/5*4(/!&(! (*+*+/#(!,"!(&+!()*(&*/5+'(")/12/5*4+,/!&(!"'/#$:+*4")/12/5*4( "-(#&(&)4(-("#& /!-/5+# *(,& '2" *4(#*+)"*(&%2*4(/-1"#2

($+,*!"!6+$4/ !*6/-%"2:+*4*4()/#)(!#(& ($+,*!"!/5/-1"#+(,6 ('()*!/#+)"''26"'/#$:+*4B /!-BG+#"&&+*+/#*/142,+)"')/126",1(! *4(!('(3"#*1!/3+,+/#,/5*4('":

4((*+*+/#(!,+#"''*4(/-1"#2(*+*+/#,*/1"2)/,*,/5 ,

0B(")4 */*4( ($+/#"'+!()*/!6(,*(!# ($+/#6 -%"+/,*,*/%(1"+&:+*4+# 1(!+/&/55/ !:((A,5!/-*/&"2 9

+'+#$"#&+,, "#)(/5*4(&!":# 1/!&(!+,&+,1(#,(&:+*4 '')/#)(!#(&!($ '"*/!2" *4/!+*+(,*/")*/#")/12/5*4+,/!&(!"'/#$:+*4 "-(#&(&)4(-("#&5/!-/5-+# *(,& '2" *4(#*+)"*(&%2*4(/-1"#2

($+,*!"!6+$4/ !*6/-%"2 7 6 8 CERTIFICATE I certify that this Order uploaded is a true and correct copy of original signed order.

Uploaded by: Shankar Gawde, Stenographer