Spice Commerce And Trade Pvt. Ltd. v. -
!"
#
$ !"
%%%%&'&'()* )(+)),-(.
/ !"
#
$ !"
%%%%&'&'()* )(+),-(. (&0,&&)&0,-('+1&2!
/"3!!
/"45 (&0,&&)1&'(+
!&
&0,-('+ 1&2!
/"5 (&0,&&)10,,6,&'( -'1,,)1(7 )7)'8&','&739-'1 ,,)1:)9 )(+)),-(.:4 ;'&0 '7 6<6 =)'8&','&739 '7 6<6: )9 )(+),-(.:4 (7
&0'))+-1&'8+0)067)+%
+% 6-( ( > )% ?+0 00 '*< ?+0 00 > %2 781& ) &0 &'&'()+'(&0&'&'(% )%0)'@(&70''*<2)%(@?A-))'(6')1&)% )%'(70),2'1'6'BC'7&)2-)+(&% D%A%((2%
D!
&01&<)2 !" !%
)7)(7C(+6)&0-)&'+% <?1&)0+1,<)&01C)&& --+&010,(7()(.-)&.0+1(&)8)&7(.8),(&+,7'( &0&'&'(%
0+(1&'(&0C)&'++C0&C(7)1&'(+
!&
(7&0))68(& -)8'+'(&0,-('+1&2!
/"2&&010,,6,&'(-'1 ,,)1(7 )7)'8&','&73E F)E )(+)),-(.F4;'&0 '7 6<6 = ','&7 3E F ) E )(+) ,-(.F4 (7 &0') )+-1&'8+0)067)+3E&010,F4%
0)(7C(+6)&0&'&'()++&&+&0&&0 )(+)),-(. '+ 1C))(&6. (7 '( &0 <C+'(++ &)7'( (7 '(8+&,(&+% 0
)(+),-(.'+6+(7'(&0<C+'(++&)7'(% 0)&'(6 ) &0 10, '+ & )7C1 ,()'6 8)6-+2 ;0'10 ) (1++)'6.
'(8687 '( )C(('( ,C6&'-6 (&'&'+2 & )7C1 7,'('+&)&'8 1+&(7& 10'8-)&'(6(7,(,(&'1'(1.%
)(7C(+6)&0&'&'()+C)&0)+&&+&0&&0)7')1&)+ &0 &'&'() ,-('+ 07 --)87 &0 +'7 10, <. -++'( )7 +6C&'(+2;0'10)((G7&&0,-(.10,&'&'(% /%
0)(7C(+6)&0&'&'()+C)&0)+&&+&0&2&'&'(),-('+ 081,-6'7;'&066&07')1&'(+-++7'(,-(.C,,(+)')1&'( (7 &0&&0 ,-(. 10, &'&'( 0+<( '67'(1(+((1 ;'&0&0 )7)-++7'(,-(.C,,(+)')1&'(% "%
0)(7C(+6--)'((<06&0&'&'()+0++&&7&0&&0 &'&'(),-('+081,-6'7;'&066)BC'),(&++-)7')1&'(+ &0'+C)&(7&0.08'67(1++).'78'&+1,-6'(1'(&0C)&% )8)2&0&'&'(),-('+C(7)&@&1,-6.;'&066&0+&&C&). )BC'),(&+'(.2+)BC')7C(7)&0,-('+1&2! /"* !
(7C6+ ,7&0)C(7);0'108))--6'1<6% 0+'7C(7)&@'('+11-&7% H%
0 '1'6 'BC'7&) 0+ '67 0'+ )-)& ( !+& 1&<)2 !" '( ,-(. 10, &'&'(2 '(&)6'2 +&&'( &0& &0 ')+ &0 )(+)) ,-(. 08<(1(7C1&7'(-)-),(()(7&0&&0 )(+)),-(.,. <)7)7&<7'++687;'&0C&;'(7'(C-% !
0 '(6 ')1&) 0+ '67 ( '78'& ( H&0 1&<)2 !"2 '(&) 6'2 +&&'(+8(7G1-&++&&7'(-))-0+"34&3142'&--)+11)7'( & '(6 ')1&)2 &0& &0 10, '+ (& -)?C7'1'6 & &0 '(&)+& +0)067)+ (7 -C<6'1% . +-)& )7) 7&7 ! &0 1&<)2 !"2 &0 <?1&'(+)'+7<.&0'(6')1&)'(-))-0+"34&31408<( 1(+'7)7%
0 )(7 C(+6 ) '(6 ')1&) ( '(+&)C1&'(+ )% % ,@(&02 '(& '(6 ')1&) '( &0 '1 &0 '(6 ')1&)2 '('+&).)-)&')+2#+&)('(2C,<'+&&+&0&&010, '+(&-)?C7'1'6&&0'(&)+&+0)067)+(7-C<6'1(70+(&)'+7(. C)&0) <?1&'(+ & &0 +C<,'++'(+ ,7 <. &0 &'&'() ,-('+% 0 +'7+C<,'++'(+(7C(7)&@'(+&0&'&'(),-('+)11-&7% ! % ),&0,&)'6()1)72&010,--)+&<')(7)+(<6(7'+ (&8'6&(.-)8'+'(+6;(7'+(&1(&)).&-C<6'1-6'1.% !!% '(166&0)BC'+'&+&&C&).1,-6'(1+08<(C6'6672&0,-(. 10,&'&'( %
!"'+,7<+6C&'(&),+-).)16C++342 314(7374(7&0,-(.10,&'&'( / !"'+,7<+6C& '(&),+-).)16C++34(7314% ! % 0 &'&'() ,-('+ & '6 1-. &0'+ )7) (7 &0 10, 7C6. C&0(&'1&7<.&0,-(.'+&))2 '0C)&3%%42,<.2;'&0&0 "
1(1)(7C-)'(&(7(&&,-+2)&0-C)-+7?C7'1&'(+&,- 7C&.-.<62'(.2(&0+,;'&0'(" 7.+),&07&&0'+)7)% !
0&'&'(),-('+)7')1&7&'61)&''71-.)7)6(;'&0 1-.&010,;'&0&01(1)(7'+&)),-('+261&)('166.2 6( ;'&0 I), I $ '( 77'&'( & -0.+'16 1-. + -) &0 )68(& -)8'+'(+&0,-('+1&2!
/"* !
;0'108)'+--6'1<6% !
0&'&'(),-(.'(<&0&0,-(.10,&'&'(+&-.1+&+ +%! 2 *I 10 & &0 '(6 ')1&)2 #+&)( '(2 C,<' (7 &0 &'&'() '( ,-(. 10, &'&'( %
!" & -. 1+&+ +%! 2 *I & &0 '1'6 'BC'7&)2 '0 C)&2 ,<.% +& & < -'7 ;'&0'(C);@+),&07&&0'+)7)% !/% '6'((7'++C(1&07);(C-)7)'+7'+-(+7;'&0% !"% 66 1(1)(7)C6&).C&0)'&'+&1& ( 1-.&0'+)7)6(;'&0 10, 7C6. C&0(&'1&7 <. &0 ,-(. '+&))2 '0 C)& 3% %42 ,<.% 3%A%((%4
!" #