Bombay High CourtCSP/429/2016scheme sanctioned company

Clientis Soft Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. -

2016-09-22Hon'Ble Shri Justice A. K. Menon8 pages

$% !"

'('()*+',-./'()01)2

" #$ %&'' ()* ('+*( ,-.*& '/*& 0 "

'& * ()* *& ('(4& ,-.*& '/*&0-5"

* 3-,,,(+43-,,,56789'*','('()* 01)2

))7(),(+4,*( ):3;1**()/(*9'*()', '('() < ;

)71'04*6 !" <

*7 /*)7 9.)-/ * 1*'(- ) 11*- 4* ', .*''11-',9,0)7)*)21*'2,-9)'*8*'7)2 8*0)'-07()','('()

,-)9'()',.*'(--.,'.)7*9'()-=!'= ',01)(-9'6!%"6'9,0**)0)'4'>)

?', 0*7 01)2@)7

?',-./'()01)2@ =

, *)7 .)-/ * ', '('()* 01)2 -''- ',' ', 0*7 01)2 ,- 4) 9**2() 4.-()-- - 0).9'.**-6 '*7*-6 --04/*- )7 ', *)-* 01)2 ,- 4) )7 () 4.-()-- - -'>* 78/1*-6 -'>* *-//*-

,*)7.)-/*','('()*-''-','',*7 (*9'*','('()*01)2,-11*87',-(79,0 **)0)'421--()',*7-/.'()>,(9,(-))A7' ',01)29,0'('()

, *)7 .)-/ * ', '('()* -''- ','6 ', '('()*01)2,-901/(7>(',//',7(*9'()-1--7 () ', 01)2 .00)- * (*9'() )7 ',' ', 01)2 9,0'('(),84)(/7()9)-))9>(',',*7*- 1--7()01)2.00)-*(*9'() "

,*)7.)-/11*())4,/','('()*,8 -''7 ',' ', '('()* 01)2 ,- 901/(7 >(', // *B.(*0)'- - 1* 7(*9'()- ',(- .*' )7 ',2 ,8 (/7 )9--*2 (78(' 901/()9 () ', .*' *8*6 ', '('()* 01)2 .)7*': ' 901/2 >(', // -''.'*2 *B.(*0)'-6 ( )26 - *B.(*7 .)7* ', 01)(- 9'6 !%"+ !=)7*./-07',*.)7*>,(9,8*(-11/(94/ , -(7.)7*':()(-991'7

,()/(*9'*,-(/7,(-(78(') ',1'04*6

!"-''()',*()6-8)7A91'--''7()1**1,-"?@' ?7@('11*-99*7()'()/(*9'*','',9,0(-)' 1*3.7(9(/'',()'*-'-,*,/7*-)71.4/(9 )1**1,- "',-(7(78('6',()/(*9'*,--''7','< D"

,'',1))'.*',*-.40('-','<E

" #$ % &'#$

(

! ) "

* +

,- , +% ( +

+% ."

/ 01*% ! $ - * - ', 439'() ', ()/ (*9'*6 #-'*) ()6 .04( () 1**1, "?@ ,(- (78(' (- 9)9*)76

, /*)7 9.)-/ -.40('- ',' () ', 9,06 ', *()() (8(-() ', 0*7 01)2 (- () ' 0* () ', -./'()01)2)7)()',*.,',0()439'', -./'() 01)26 (' (- 4-*87 ',' 439'- *()() (8(-() ,8 )' 4) (8) () ('- 0() 439'- ,** ', /*)79.)-/*','('()*-.40('-','',01)2>(// /'* ('- 0() 439'- '* 901/2() >(', ', 1*8(-()- 9'() != ', 01)(- 9'6 != )7 ./- 07 ',*.)7*

- * - ', 439'() ', ()/ (*9'*6 #-'*) ()6 .04( () 1**1, "?4@ (- 9)9*)7 ', '('()* 01)2 ',*., ('- /*)7 9.)-/ .)7*':- ',' ', .',*(F7 -,* 91('/ (- .)7 ()-.(9()' ' (--. B.('2 -,*- ' ', -,*,/7*- ', 0*7 01)2 ,

901)2 >(// ()9*- ('- -,* 91('/ ' )4/ ('-/ ' (--. -,*- 42 (/() *B.(-(' E*0- )7 - >(', ', (-'** 01)(-6.04( - * - ', 439'() ', ()/ (*9'*6 #-'*) ()6.04(()1**1,"?9@,(-(78('(-9)9*)76 ', '('()* 01)2 -.40(' ',' ', '('()* (- 4.)7 ' 901/2>(',//11/(94/1*8(-()-',)90 A9')7 //',*9'- !!

- * - ', 439'() ', ()/ (*9'*6 #-'*) ()6.04(()1**1,"?7@,(-(78('(-9)9*)76 ','('()*01)2-.40('',')>-,*-'4(--.742 ', -./'() 01)2 ' ', *() )'('2 - ',2 * 03* -,*,/7* ', 0*7 01)26 ', '('()* 01)2 >(//':11*8/.)7* 6(*B.(*7

,*)7.)-/*()/(*9'*)()-'*.9'()- * ;0/ *3)( 1.'2 (*9'*6 () ', (9 ', ()/(*9'*6()(-'*2*1*'(*-6#-'*)()6 .04(6-''-','',2*-'(-(7>(',',-.40(--()-)7 .)7*':()-(8)42','('()* ,48.)7*':()-* 991'7

!= *0 ', 0'*(/ ) *9*76 ', 9,0 11*- ' 4 (* )7*-)4/)7(-)'8(/'(8)21*8(-()-/>)7(- )'9)'**2'1.4/(91/(92

()9//',*B.(-('-''.'*2901/()9-,84)./(//76 ',01)29,0'('()

!"(/742',-./'() 01)2 (- 07 4-/.' () '*0- 1*2* 9/.- ?@ ' ?9@ -.439' ' -)9'()() ', 9,0 **)0)' 42 042

(, .*'6 )9, () *-19' 01)2 '('() (/7 42

6 ', 0*7 01)2 !% , '('()* 01)2 '/7 912 ',(- *7*)7 ', 9,07./2.',)'(9'742',01)2(-'**6 (,.*'6 0426 >(', ', 9)9*)7 .1*()')7)' '01-6 * ', 1.*1-73.7(9'()-'017.'2124/6()26)',-0 >(',()" 72-*0',7'',(-*7* !"

,'('()**7(*9'7'(/+/7912',(-*7* /) >(', 912 ', 9,0 **)0)' >(', ', 9)9*)7 (-'** 01)(-6 /9'*)(9//26 /) >(', *0 E $6 () 77('() ' 1,2-(9/ 9126 - 1* ', */8)' 1*8(-()- ', 01)(- 9' !%"+ !=6 >,(9,8* (- 11/(94/

!C ,'('()*01)2'129-'-- ! 6 +E'',()/ (*9'*6 #-'*) ()6 .04( -'- ' 4 1(7 >(',() .* >:- *0',7'',*7* !$ (/())7(--.)9',7*>).1*7*(-7(-1)-7>(', // 9)9*)7 *./'*2 .',*('(- ' 9' ) 912 ',(- *7* /) >(', 9,0 7./2 .',)'(9'7 42 ', 01)2 (-'**6 (,.*'? @6042

9*'(2','',(-*7*.1/77(-'*.)79**9'912 *(()/-()7*7* 1/7742<,):* >76')*1,*