← Library
Bombay High CourtCSP/428/2016scheme sanctioned company

Sellcraft Softech Pvt. Ltd. v. -

2016-10-06Hon'Ble Shri Justice A. K. Menon11 pages

 



            

 

   

 !"  

#

       $! !" %%&'((&)'*+(*,*(-.

(*(*/'0(),'-,1/2    

 

    3!" !"  

#

       345 !" %%&'( %6%%7(*/8'*+( *,*(-.

(*(*/'0()87%(*/,1/2  / () ,(('  () ,1/*8 &(  !53"

   / () ,(('  &(*/8 $5! ( $5 '- 9*() &(*/ !  ( ! $  () ,1/*8&(:!53"

   /(),(('()&), ''/,/(6(9/; %%&'((&)'*+(*,*(-   %%&'( %6%%7(*/8'*+(*,*(-    ()*'81&(*+)')%-'8    

 '

<8)))*06<8)))=:-+&('()(*(*/' */6()()(*(*/  '

)',8)8)**06)'* /><?1''*/%*'&('*/ 6()()(*(*/8  ; ?

  : 

;"()  : !" 

;

'- %'/- &7/8% ' 1'(*8  / 11'8 6' () 7'((118()&),/-/'/21'(2)8&/('+'(-/2 +',/(8,-*/()(*(*/ 

)8/&(*/()7'(*887)(7/-'&(*/8$5!($5 '- 9*() &(*/ !  ( ! $  () ,1/*8 &(: !53": (  &),  ''/,/( 6(9/ %%&'( (&) '*+( *,*(- /- %%&'( %6% %7(*/8 '*+( *,*(- /- ()*' '81&(*+ 8)')%-'8 ' -,''  /19' '+*&8 /- (*/ '+*&8/-'-7&(*/8)'&1*(%%%&'( %6%%7(*/8 '*+(*,*(-  $

)'/-7/8%'()(*(*/',1/*88((8()( () ,'- ,1/2 *8 1'8/(%2 &''2*/ / 678*/88  /19' '+*&8: (*/ '+*&8 /- 8*/  '1'(2 /- ()87%(*/,1/2*8',-'&/(%2((>+'()678*/88  /19' '+*&8 /- (*/ '+*&8  %%&'( (&) '*+(*,*(- (*82((&,,/&*(8678*/881'(*/8 

)'/-7/8%7'()'8((8()(()'-*'&('  () (*(*/' ,1/*8 )+ 11'+- () 8*- &),  ''/,/(62188*/()'-8%7(*/9)*&)'//@-( ()'81&(*+,1/2&),(*(*/8  

) '/- 7/8% ' () (*(*/' */ ,1/2 &), (*(*/ 3!" !"8((8()(&),*/&%7-8'-7&(*//- &/&%%(*/  )' 1*(%  () 87%(*/ ,1/2 /- () 8, 8)%% 6 &(- 8 */('% 1'(  ()&), 8 () 8, -8 /( */+%+ *()' -*,*/7(*/  %*6*%*(2 */ '81&(  7/1*- 8)' &1*(% ' 12,/( ( /2 8)')%-'8 /- () 1'&-7' 1'8&'*6- 7/-' &(*/ ! !A B  () ,1/*8 &(: !53" 98 -*81/8-9*()81''-'-(-()7%2:

!"188-*/    345 !"

"

) '/- 7/8% ' () (*(*/'8 7'()' 8((8 ()(: (*(*/',1/*8)8&,1%*-9*()%%()-*'&(*/8188-*/ () '81&(*+ ,1/2 7,,/8 ' *'&(*/8 /- ()( () '81&(*+,1/2&),(*(*/8)+6/*%-*/&/8//& 9*() () '-'8 188- */ '81&(*+ ,1/2 7,,/8 ' *'&(*/

) '/- 7/8% 11'*/ / 6)%  () (*(*/'8 )+ 8((- ()( () (*(*/' ,1/*8 )8 &,1%*- 9*() %% 'C7*',/(8 8 1' -*'&(*/8  ()*8 7'( /- ()2 )+ *%- /&88'2 *-+*(  &,1%*/& */ () 7'(  '+': () (*(*/' ,1/*8 7/-'(> ( &,1%2 9*() %% 8((7('2 'C7*',/(8: * /2: 8 'C7*'- 7/-' () ,1/*8 &(: 

!53"0 !$/-'7%8,-()'7/-'9)*&)+'*811%*&6% ) 8*-7/-'(>*/*8&&1(- 

)*/%*'&(')8*%-)*8*-+*(/ 4()1(,6': : !"8((*/()'*/:8+/-@&1(88((-*/1''1)8"AB (AB*(11'8&&'-*/(*/%*'&('()(()&),*8 /( 1'<7-*&*% ( () */('8(  8)')%-'8 /- 176%*&  / 1''1)8"()8*-*-+*(:()*/%*'&(')88((- ()(; D"

)(()1//(7'()'876,*(8()(;E B     

                                          

 

        

    

     

    

  !                    ! " #   $                  %      #    !      



    

   &   %   

    ! "      !''              ( 



           

           

   $  $



    

    

     

  

                 $(   (     )      #    ! "      !'*                           

 $   

      &  

       ( $       

    +

     

 

    !       



           

    +

     



   ! "       ',                     



            #            - .   /  .     0-   1.    .

  02  (   (    

   (

         $ 3*'4!

( $     

  !       

 5

                    (         $3*'4 (  

  ! 8 ' 8 () 6<&(*/  () */% *'&(': #8('/ */:7,6**/1''1)"AB)*8*-+*(*8&/&'/-:() (*(*/' ,1/2 876,*( ()( () (*(*/' *8 67/- ( &,1%2 9*()%%11%*&6%1'+*8*/8() /&, @&(/-%%()' &(8  ' 8 () 6<&(*/  () */% *'&(': #8('/ */: 7,6*: 8 8((- */ 1''1) "A6B  )*8 *-+*( *8 &/&'/-:()%'/-&7/8%876,*(8()((,%,(9*() /()'&,1/2*819'(),1/2/-/(/6<&( () &,1/2 ) %'/- &7/8% 7'()' 876,*(8 ()( 9)/ 

()' *8 8((7('2 1'+*8*/ -%*/ 9*() ,%,(*/  &,1/*8: / 81&*% 19'8 */ 6<&( &%78  () ,,'/-7,88&*(*/()&,1/2*8/&88'2'*(8 ,%,(*/ 9*() ()' &,1/*8

9+' () (*(*/' ,1/*8 ()'7) *(8 %'/- &7/8% 7/-'(>8 ()( () 87%(*/,1/28)%%&,1%29*()1'+*8*/8&(*/!$ () ,1/*8 &(: !$ */ '81&(  ,/-,/( */ ,'/-7,88&(*/()87%(*/,1/2/-(*% / ,/-- &12  () ,'/-7,  88&*(*/ %/9*() () '%+/(',89*()()&/&'/-*8('',1/*8 !!

  ' 8 () 6<&(*/  () */% *'&(': #8('/ */: 7,6*: 8 8((- */ 1''1) "A&B  )*8 *-+*( *8 &/&'/-:()(*(*/',1/*8()'7)*(8%'/-&7/8% 7/-'(>8()((),'-,1/2)8/(7(*%*8-/'*(8)%% 7(*%*8()1'*(8'*/&,:*/2:'()17'18-&%'*/' 12*/ -*+*-/- ' ' /2 ()' 17'18 */ '81&(  () 1'*- %%*/ / /- (' () 11*/(- -(:9*()7( () 1'*' 9'*((/ &/8/(()'--*'&('8()87%(*/,1/2

  ' 8 () 6<&(*/  () */% *'&(': #8('/ */: 7,6*: 8 8((- */ 1''1) "A-B  )*8 *-+*( *8 &/&'/-:()(*(*/',1/*8()'7)*(8%'/-&7/8% 7/-'(>8 ()( () (*(*/' ,1/*8 8)%% ,> /&88'2 -*8&%87'811%*&6%&&7/(*/8(/-'-80&&7/(*/1%*&*8 

-1(- ' &&7/(*/ ('(,/( */ () 7-*(- *//&*% 8((,/(8  !$   ' 8 () 6<&(*/  () */% *'&(': #8('/ */: 7,6*: 8 8((- */ 1''1) "AB  )*8 *-+*( *8 &/&'/-:()(*(*/',1/*8()'7)*(8%'/-&7/8% 7/-'(>8 ( &,1%2 9*() () 1'+*8*/8  &(*/ !$  () ,1/*8 &(: !$ */ '81&(  *%*/ /&88'2 ',8 9*() () &/&'/-*8('',1/*8'&)//,

  ) '/- 7/8% ' */% *'&(' / */8('7&(*/8  8   )%: */( *'&(': */ () *&  () */% *'&(':*/*8('2'1'(*'8:#8('/*/:7,6*: 8((8 ()( ()2 ' 8(*8*- 9*() () 876,*88*/8 /- 7/-'(>*/8 *+/ 62 () (*(*/'8 ) 6+ 7/-'(>*/8 '&&1(-  !3  ', () ,('*% / '&'-: () &), 11'8 ( 6 *' /-'8/6%/-*8/(+*%(*+/21'+*8*/8%9/-*8 /(&/(''2(176%*&1%*&2  !"

 */&%%()'C7*8*(8((7('2&,1%*/&8)+6/7%*%%-: (),1/2&),(*(*/ 

 !"*%-62(),'- ,1/2',-68%7(*/(',81'2'&%78AB=A6B/- ,1/2 &), (*(*/  3!" !" *%- 62 () 87%(*/ ,1/2',-68%7(*/(',81'2'&%78AB(AB 

!4 )(*(*/',1/*8(%-&12()*8'-'/-() &),-7%27()/(*&(-62(),1/2*8('': *)7'(: ,62: 9*() () &/&'/- 71'*/(/-/(  (,18: ' () 17'18-<7-*&(*/8(,1-7(2126%:*/2:/()8, 9*()*/" -28',()-(()*8'-'

 )(*(*/'8'-*'&(-(*%0%-&12()*8'-' %/ 9*()  &12  () &),  ''/,/( 9*() () &/&'/- *8(''  ,1/*8: %&('/*&%%2: %/ 9*() ',  E : */ --*(*/ ( 1)28*&% &12: 8 1' () '%+/( 1'+*8*/8  () ,1/*8 &( !53"0 !$: 9)*&)+' *8 11%*&6%  !5 )(*(*/'8,1/*8(12&8(88 ! : 0E&)( () */% *'&(': #8('/ */: 7,6*  8(8 ( 6 1*- 9*()*/7'9>8',()-(()'-'

 (*(*/' */ ,1/2 &), (*(*/   3!"  !" ( 176%*8)  /(*&  '*8('(*/  '-' /- ',  ,*/7(8  '-7&(*/  &1*(% //@- 8 @)*6*( FG ( ,1/2 &), (*(*/  3!" !"62*8('',1/*8/&&)*/() (9 %&% /9811': +*H: D ) &/,*& *,8I */ /%*8) /7 /- ('/8%(*/ ()' */ D)'8)(' *,8I */ '()*/7:6())+*/&*'&7%(*/*/7//-%8*/() )'8)(' +'/,/( H((9*()*/!

-28'*8('(*/  

 *%*//-*887/&()-'9/71'-'*8-*81/8-9*() 

 %% &/&'/- '7%('2 7()'*(*8 ( &( /  &12  ()*8 '-' %/ 9*() () &), /- ',  */7(8 //@- 8

@)*6*( DI ( () ,1/2 &), (*(*/  3!"  !" -7%2 7()/(*&(- 62 () ,1/2 *8('': *) 7'( A  B: ,62                    

 !    

&'(*2()(()*8'-'71%--*8('7/-&''&(&12 '**/%8*/-'-'

 1%--62;)/>' 9-:(/'1)'