← Library
Bombay High CourtCSP/428/2015absolute

Westplot Developers Private Limited v. 0

2015-09-29Hon'Ble Shri Justice S.C. Gupte8 pages

 



            

 

   

 !"

 

#

      

$  !"

#     





%&%&'()%* ('+((,-'.          

 

   

/ !"

 

#

      

$0 !"

    





%&%&'()%* ('+(,-'. '%*,%%(%*,-'&+1%2! !/"3'4%*((56'%-(6&+&'+%* ,-'&+1%2 !07   ' %* ,%%(  1%&'+ 0/! % 0/   %* ,-'&+ 1%2 !/"3 '4 %*( 

(56'% -(6&+&'+  %* ,-'&+ 1%2 !07   ' %* ,%%(  1*,  ,5,%&'  #      



2%* ('+((,-'.8&%*  

  

 

2 %* ('+( ,-'.  554(*(&' ( 9+***&):9+***; 2461%(%*%&%&'(+ (+ <('&,8+%*&&):(   '+(&(&'5&(1%( (  ,='%*2&1&5&><&4%( ?  <-%2 

? /%*-%,:(2 !" ?

(4('4<'+5(%*-(%&+  :91%(*+1,:(%*1<(% %--+%*1*,'4'('.-(%.*+1'%(6(%4'.6(,'%+,4&'%* %&%&'+

* +'1%&'  %* <(% &+ +<*% %  1*,  ,5,%&'  #     



2%* ('+((,-'.8&%* 

   



2%* ('+(,-'.2<'4(1%&'+0/! %0/ %*,-'&+1%2!/"3

* ('4 <'+5 ( %* %&%&'(+ +%%+ %*% %* ('+(( ,-'. *+ :' 1((.&' ' %* :<+&'++ % :<&542 1'+%(<1%2 1><&(2 (1%2 465-2 4&+,'%52 %<(' % 11<'%2 <('&+*2 5652 :(&1%2 ,&'%&'2 +<(6.2 -(,%2(<%24&2@16%2('6%2<'4(%='4%1%+1&6&5'&'('4%*

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

('+(,-'.'4%*%%*&+1*,,5,%&'8<54(+<5%&',(( '4 %*<+ 1'+5&4%&'  :<+&'++  %* ('+(( ,-'. '4 %* ('+( ,-'.&'''%&%.255%*+*(*54(+%*,(4'%&%.8&55::'&%4:. (+<5%  %* ,5,%&'  <+&'++ '4 6&5:&5&%.   1,,' -(%&' -5%(,'4%*%%*,5,%&'%* ('+((,-'.8&%*%* ('+( 

,-'.8&555+-(6&4'--(%<'&%.%56(1,:&'4++%+'4:<&54 +%('( +<+%&':5 :<+&'++ 8*&1* %* ,(( 8&55 ':5 -%&,5 <%&5&B%&'  @&+%&' (+<(1+ '4 -(6&4 ' --(%<'&%. % <55. 56( +%(' ++%+2 1-:&5&%&+2@-(&'12@-(%&+'4&'(+%(<1%<(:%*%*1,-'&+'4%*% %*,(4'%&%.8&555+*6+<&1&'%<'4+(><&(4(,%&'&%+5'%(, 1-&%5'4++-(6&44(&'%*+1*,'4%*%%*1*,,5,%&'8&55 (+<5%&'1+%+6&'(:%*%*1,-'&++%*.(1-&%5&B&''1*%*(A+ 1(1,-%'1.'4(+<(1+8*&1*&+@-1%4%(+<5%&'+%:&5&%.-(%&'+2 1+%+6&'+'4*&*(-(&%:&5&%.565+(%*,5,%4,-'. 

('4<'+5(%*%&%&'(+<(%*(+%%+%*%%*(4&(1%(+ %* %&%&'( ,-'&+ *6 --(64 %* +&4 1*,  ,5,%&' :. -++&' (4 +5<%&'+ 8*&1* ( ''@4 % %* (+-1%&6 ,-'. 1*, %&%&'+ "

* ('4 <'+5 ( %* %&%&'(+ <(%*( +%%+ %*%2 %&%&'( ,-'&+*61,-5&48&%*55%*4&(1%&'+-++4&'%*(+-1%&6,-'. <,,'+(&(1%&'+'4%*%%*(+-1%&6,-'.1*,%&%&'+*6:' &54 &' 1'+''1 8&%* %* (4(+ -++4 &' (+-1%&6 ,-'. <,,'+ ( &(1%&'+

*('4<'+5--(&'':*5%*%&%&'(+*6+%%4%*%%* %&%&'(,-'&+*6 1,-5&4 8&%* 55(><&(,'%++ -(4&(1%&'+  %*&+ 

<(%'4%*.*6&54'1++(.&46&%1,-5&'1&'%*<(% (6(2 %*%&%&'(,-'&+<'4(%=%1,-5.8&%*55+%%<%(.(><&(,'%+&'.2 +(><&(4<'4(%*,-'&+1%2!/"3)

!0 '4 (<5+ ,4 %*( <'4( 8*&1*6(&+--5&1:5 *+&4<'4(%=&'&+11-%4 $

*&1&5&><&4%(*+&54*&+(-(%' 0(44.-%,:(2 !"&' ,-'.1*,%&%&' +

 !"+%%&'%*%%*&(+%* ('+(( ,-'.*+:'1'4<1%4&'-(-(,''('4%*%%* ('+((,-'. ,.:(4(4%:4&++564

* &'5 &(1%( *+ &54 ' &46&% ' /%* 4.  -%,:(2 !" +%%&'%*(&'2+6'4@1-%++%%4&'-((-*32&%--(+%*%%*1*,&+ '%-(9<4&1&5%%*&'%(+%+*(*54(+'4-<:5&1 '-((-*3%*+&4 &46&%2%*&'5&(1%(*++%%4%*%?C  

   DE         

    

              !

   "

        # 

        # $             



            %

 &       #

      %

         "  

 # 



" %     #"  

     %

 %'(  

)* 

  +  #           

 $  + #

 



    #,

- ,  #

   $   + #  .  +   #  

   #             

   

    $   +  #

 

  

   #  /   ( + %* :+(6%&' &' -((-* 3 DE  %* &46&%  &'5 &(1%(&+1'1('42%*%&%&'(,-'.%*(<*&%+1<'+5+<:,&%%4 %*% &' 44&%&' % %* 1,-5&'1  11<'%&' %'4(4 F ! 2 %*

('+(,-'.+*55-+++<1*11<'%&''%(&+8*&1*('1++(. &'1''1%&'8&%*%*1*,%1,-5.8&%*%*(--5&1:511<'%&' %'4(4+<1*+C"%1    ( + %* :+(6%&' &' -((-* 3D:E  %* &46&%  &'5 &(1%( &+ 1'1('42 %* ('4 <'+5 ( %* %&%&'( ,-'&+ +<:,&% %*% %* %&%&'( ,-'&+ ( :<'4 % 1,-5. 8&%* 55 --5&1:5-(6&+&'+'1, @1%'455%@&++<+(&+&'<%%* 1*,8&55:,%'4'+8(4&'11(4'18&%*58 !!

* ('4 <'+5 ( &'5 &(1%( ' &'+%(<1%&'+  (   *'4'<%*<2&'%&(1%(5&'%*&1%*&'5&(1%(2&'&+%(. (-(%&(+2#+%('&'2<,:&+%%+%*%%*.(+%&+&48&%*%* <'4(%=&'+&6':.%*%&%&'(+ *:6<'4(%=&'+(11-%4  

(,%*,%(&5'(1(42%*1*,--(+%:&('4(+':5'4 &+'%6&5%&6'.-(6&+&'+58'4&+'%1'%((.%-<:5&1-5&1. !0 &'1 55 %* (><&+&% +%%<%(. 1,-5&'1+ *6 :' <5&5542 ,-'. 1*,%&%&' +

 !"&+,4:+5<%&'%(,+-(.(+15<+DE2D:E '4D4E'4

/ !"&+,4:+5<%&'%(,+-(.(15<++DE'4D1E

* %&%&'( ,-'&+ % &5  1-.  %*&+ (4( '4 %* 1*, 4<5. <%*'%&1%4 :. %* ,-'. &+%((2 &* <(% D E2 ,:.2 8&%* %* 1'1('4<-(&'%'4'%%,-+2(%*-<(-+49<4&1%&'+%,-4<%. -.:52&'.2'%*+,8&%*&'3 4.+(,%*4%%*(4( !"

%&%&'(+(4&(1%4%&51(%&&41-.(4(5'8&%*1-.%* 1*,,5,%&'8&%*%*1'1('4&+%((,-'&+251%('&155.2 5'8&%* (, C &'44&%&'%-*.+&151-.+-(%*(56'%-(6&+&'+ %*,-'&+1%2!/"3) !08*&1*6(&+--5&1:5  !3

* %&%&'( ,-'&+ % -. 1+%+  + ! 2 )C 1* % %* &'5 &(1%(2 #+%(' &'2 <,:& '4 %* %&%&'(+ &' %* ,-'. 1*, %&%&' 

 !"%-.1+%++ ! 2 )C%%*&1&5&><&4%(2 &* <(%2,:.

+%+%:-&48&%*&'<(8=+(,%*4%%*(4( !$ &5&''4&++<'1%*4(8'<-(4(&+4&+-'+48&%*   

551'1('4(<5%(.<%*(&%&+%1%'1-.%*&+(4(5'8&%* 1*,4<5.<%*'%&1%4:.%*,-'.&+%((2 &*<(%D  E2,:.

D  <-%2 E