← Library
Bombay High CourtCSP/446/2015absolute

Vikram Seeds Private Limited Formerly Marathawada Engineers Private Limited v. 0

2015-08-28Hon'Ble Shri Justice S.C. Gupte9 pages

 



            

 

   

 !"

 

#

       $% !"

&







'('()*+',(*-' *)-**./)0    



            

 

   

% !"

 

#

       $1 !"  # 2 3





'('()*+',4)5 *)-**./)0    



            

 

   

1 !"

 

#

       $6 !" # 







'('()*+', ,(*5 *)-***', (*-'.*5./)0 

   



            

 

   

6 !"

 

#

        !"

 

    

   



'('()*+',7*', *)-**./)0',4)5 .*5./)0    



            

 

    "  !"

 

#

       ! !"  





'('()*+', *)-**./)0  



 



  

 

 

   

    

     !  

 

       

 



 

   

 



  

"    "  #$ %&'( ))  *'%+) ,(+)  -  +   

 . /01 -02,)'3 4*'%+),(+)  +   

 .5'2,) ))  *'%+),(+)+ +   

 .   -   "

 .  /,  ))  *'0 )  6   ')-'6)'+0  0(* 7 ,(+)  - 8  +   

 .      "

 . $ 9 6'0 ))  ,(+)+   

 . '8"

 .  885*,*() * 9-,,,(+:9-,,,; <5=4'*','('()*-()88'('()- *  '80(+:*   )-*(*()8(*4'* *  .>)',<(4(8(?7(5'* @  7/'< 

@1',77-'< !" @ !

*5*)57)-8*',/*'(-  :94'*,-4.:*',47*' '//-',4,.)5)*)0/*'0,-4)'*=*'5)0=*.)'-.5()', '('()- 

,-)4'()',7*'(--7,''./-('4,..8.'() )5 **).)'  :'A) & 

 

 

< ', (*-'

*)-**./)0)5 # 2 3



<',4)5

*)-**./)0)5# 





<','('()*+

,(*5 *)-** ./)0 * ', (*-' .*5 ./)0 )5   

       

     

< ', 7*',

*)-** ./)0 * ', 4)5 .*5 ./)0 A(',   

 

<', *)-*./)0*',-78'()./)0<7)5*4'()-$6!' $6 < 4'() !   ', ./)(- 4'< !6"  )5 ',* *8=)' /*=(-()-  ./)(-4' !$ $

, *)5 7)-8 * ', '('()*- -''- ',' ', (*-' *)-** ./)0'/*-)'(-()',:7-()--88'0/-,0:*(5<4*'((5-5-()4875() ,0:*(5+=*('8-5-4'')<4*8)5=':84*/-<=':8-<8A*-5- )54..*4(8-5- )5 ', 4)5 *)-** ./)0 (-()',:7-()-- )()*()< 88(5 -*=(4- )5 ()=-'.)' 4'(=('(- )5 ,(*5 *)-** ./)0(-)5()',:7-()--'*5()-5-)5()'()=-'.)'4'(=('(- )5',7*', *)-**./)0(-)5()',:7-()--485-'* *(478'7*8/*574)5()=-'.)'4'(=('(-)5 *)-*./)0'/*-)'(- )5()',:7-()---5-)5()=-'.)'4'(=('(- ,/*/-5./-(' -4,.  .8.'() )5 **).)' A(88 ,= ', :)(' - /* ', /()()',.).)'<','',.**A(8885'-0)*(-/*'()-)5 

.* /*'(478*80 ', :)('- ',' ', 4.:()5 /*'()- * :''* :7-()-- //*'7)('(- A() ' 4).(-  -48< ()'*'5 /*'()- )5 *574'()- () 4-'- )5 ',' ', .8.'() A785 ):8 /'(.7. 7'(8(B'()  7)5- ; -7*4- )5 ','',.8.'() A785 8- ):8', .*5 )'('0' *A .74,-'*A(',4)-8(5'5*-7*4-)5','',.8.'()A(88()'*'88 4'(=('(-.).)'7)4'()-',*:04,(=()*574'()()=*,54-'-)5 (./*=()4)'*8=*4-'-A,(4,A(888-85'5.()(-'*'(=4)=)()4)5 *'* ()'*)8 4)'*8- )5 ',' ', .8.'() )5 **).)' A785 ):8 8=*() ', 4/:(8('(-  4.:()5 )'('0 A,(4, A(88 88A //*'7)('(- * 7)5*'>() 7'7* C/)-() -'*'(- ' A(88 8- : 4)574(= ' ),)4 ', 4/:(8('0'44./'('()()',.*>'/84.*4'(=80

*)57)-8*','('()*-7*',*-''-','',*5(*4'*- ', '('()* ./)(- ,= //*=5 ', -(5 ./-(' 4,.  .8.'())5**).)':0/--()*5-87'()-A,(4,*))C5 '',*-/4'(=./)04,.'('()- "

, *)5 7)-8 * ', '('()*- 7*',* -''- ','< '('()* ./)(-,=4./8(5A(',88',5(*4'()-/--5()',*-/4'(=./)0 7..)-*(*4'()-)5','',*-/4'(=./)04,.'('()-,=:) (85 () 4)-))4 A(', ', *5*- /--5 () *-/4'(= ./)0 7..)- * (*4'()- 

,*)57)-8//*()):,8','('()*-,=-''5','', '('()*./)(-,= 4./8(5 A(', 88*?7(*.)'-- /*5(*4'()-  ',(- 7*')5',0,=(85)4--*0(5=('4./8()4()',7*' *=*< ','('()*./)(-7)5*'>'4./80A(',88-''7'*0*?7(*.)'-()0< -*?7(*57)5*',./)(-4'<!6"

+  !$ )5 *78- .5 ',* 7)5* A,(4,=*(-//8(4:8 ,-(57)5*'>()(-44/'5 %

, (4(8 (?7(5'* ,- (85 ,(- */*' ) ! ', 50  77-'<  !" () ./)04,.'('() -

)5

% !"-''()','',(*-',

*)-** ./)(- ,= :) 4)574'5 ()  /*/* .))* )5 ',' ',

*)-**./)(-.0:*5*5':5(--8=5

,()8(*4'*,-(85)(5=(')"',5077-'< !"-''() ',*()<-=)5C4/'--''5()/**/, <('//*-','',4,.(-)' /*975(4(8 ' ', ()'*-'  -,*,85*- )5 /7:8(4  ) /**/,   ', -(5 (5=('<',()8(*4'*,--''5','@D  

    



    

   

 

             



  



    



  

    !

 " # 



                   



  

    



  !

 !$%    

          

      

      

 

 !     "

# " 

       

    $    

  

      !         

   

         

 

  

     :;      #     "    34

  



 '"          *  

   8" 88#    

 8"  <!+   

 .  8  8"   $    .     $       . $   

#  8"  8 =    * - ', :-*='() () /**/, 2:3  ', (5=('  ()8 (*4'* (- 4)4*)5< ', *)5 7)-8 * ', '('()* ./)(- -7:.('','','('()*./)(-*:7)5'4./80A(',88//8(4:8 /*=(-()-)4. C4')588'C(--7-*(-()7'',4,.A(88 :.')5)-A*5()44*5)4A(',8A !

, *)5 7)-8 * ()8 (*4'* ) ()-'*74'()-  *   ,)5)7',7<()'(*4'*8()',(4',()8(*4'*< ()(-'*0  */*' (*-< #-'*) ()< 7.:( -''- ',' ',0 * -'(-(5 A(', ', 7)5*'>()- (=) :0 ', '('()*- , := 7)5*'>()-*44/'5  

!!

*.',.'*(8)*4*5<',4,.//*-':(*)5*-):8)5 (-)'=(8'(=)0/*=(-()-8A)5(-)'4)'**0'/7:8(4/8(40 !

()4 88 ', *?7(-(' -''7'*0 4./8()4- ,= :) 78(885< ./)0 4,. '('() -

 )5

%   !" * .5 :-87' () '*.-  /*0*- 487- 23<2:3 )5 253 )5

1 ' "    !" * .5 :-87' () '*.-/*0*487--23)5243 !$ , '('()* ./)(- ' (8  4/0  ',(- *5* )5 ', 4,. 5780 7',)'(4'5:0',./)0(-'**< (,7*'2  3<.:0<A(',', 4)4*)57/*()')5)''./-<*',/7*/-5975(4'()-'./ 57'0/0:8<()0<)',-.A(',() 50-*.',5'',*5*  !

,'('()*-*5(*4'5'(84*'((54/0*5*8)A(',4/0  ', 4,.  .8.'() )5 **).)'- A(', ', 4)4*)5 (-'**./)(-<84'*)(4880<8)A(', *. D1()55('() ' /,0-(48 4/0 - /* ', *8=)' /*=(-()-  ', ./)(- 4'< !6"

+ !$A,(4,=*(-//8(4:8  !"

, '('()* ./)(- ' /0 4-'-  - ! < +D 4, ' ', ()8 (*4'*<#-'*)()<7.:()5','('()*()',./)04,. '('() -

 )5

%   !" ' /0 4-'-  - ! < +D 4, ' ', (4(8(?7(5'*< (,7*'<.:0 -'':/(5A(',()7*A>- *.',5'',*5*  

!

(8())5(--7)4',5*A)7/*5*(-5(-/)-5A(',  !% 884)4*)5*78'*07',*('(-'4')4/0',(-*5*8)A(', 4,. 5780 7',)'(4'5 :0 ', ./)0 (-'**< (, 7*' 2   3< .:0 2  7/'< 3