Bombay High CourtCSD/633/2016absolute

Allied Blenders And Distillers Pvt. Ltd. v. -

2016-07-22Hon'Ble Shri Justice B.P. Colabawalla4 pages

!"

# $% ' ( ) * $% +, "

- $ # # . /"

&#$/'('$ ( $% $!&"

' () * 0 !"

#$% ) (+ $+1$% $!&"

' ( ) * +, "

- $ # # . /"

&#$/'('$ ($% ' () * 0 !"

# $% ) ! $% !".2"!"

* 4 4 9 *")$!&"

4'

)$#&$#"

9 - # ' ( ) * +, "/'

2 '

( 9 # 2'( # - $%%') "

+17 "!'

9 "!8 #(* "!'

$"-* 6!8"'7 1

9

1 9:&&.')"

4

".. -6!!$ (%$#'# ) %$# "#'

2 # "; ("'<8<( "; ("= $*-/$)"

%$# &&.')"

$#"!> $."8"5".."* "

> -6.4*

"&&.')"

4 "8$/ "! - 84 " 6!!$ ( %$# '# ) # "; ("'

( #6) -84<( "; ("= $*-/$)"

%$# &&.')"

4* -"

#--"4$%6 * $%# ".".*6 $#'? - #($ &&.')"

4*'

(6&&$# 6!!$ (%$#'# ) "

@'8'

# '

# % ## - $*

>7 )$ / 2 "

- $.-'

2 !

2 $% A6'

4 "# $.- #( $% &&.')"

4 %$# &6#&$( $% )$ ('- #'

2 "

-* '% $62 %'

* "&&#$/'

2* 5'

$# 5'

$6 !$-'%')"

B(9 &#$&$( - ) ! $% !".2"!"

* 4 5'

4'(-'(& ( - '

/' 5 $% )$ (

2'/ 84 ".. %$6# A6'

4 "# $.- #($% &&.')"

4* 5') "# "

@ - "(

$ %%'-"/'

$%6!!$ (%$#'# ) )$ / 2"

-$.-'

2 !

# % # ) ("# $.- #($% &&.')"

4 %$# &6#&$( $% )$ ('- #'

2 "

-* '% $62 %'

* "&&#$/'

2* 5'

$# 5'

$6 !$-'%')"

B(9 &#$&$( - ) ! $% !".2"!"

* 4 5'

4'(-'(& ( - /' 5$% )$ (

2'/ 84 8$ # % # ) ("# $.- #($% &&.')"

4* 5') "# "

@ - "(

$ %%'-"/'

$%6!!$ (%$#'# ) )$ / 2 "

- $.-'

2 $% !

2 $% )6# - # -'

$#( $% &&.')"

4 %$# &6#&$( $% )$ ('- #'

2 "

-* '% $62 %'

* "&&#$/'

2* 5'

$# 5'

$6 !$-'%')"

B(9 &#$&$( - ) ! $% !".2"!"

* 4 5'

4'(-'(& ( -5'

/' 5$% "/ #!

(!"- '

&"#"2#"&C$% 6!!$ ( %$# '# ) "

"

6 - # "D ( $ '((6 '

-'/'-6".

') $%-"

$% "#'

4) ! 84 2'( # -$( $"..'

( )6# - # -'

$#("

-".($ $&68.'( ("! '

5$.$)". 5( &"& #(/'?E # # (($6# ".F*'

2.'(."

26"2 "

#"

(."

# $%'

E"/("D 'F*'

"#"

'."

26"2 *8$ "/'

2)'#)6."

6!8"' ("'- - # "D'

2'(")) & - 1 )$ / 2"

-$.-'

2 $% !

2 $%

( )6# - # -'

$#( $% &&.')"

4 %$# &6#&$( $% )$ ('- #'

2 "

-* '% $62 %'

* "&&#$/'

2* 5'

$# 5'

$6 !$-'%')"

B(9 &#$&$( - ) ! $% !".2"!"

* 4 5'

4'(-'(& ( -5'

1 /' 5$% "/ #!

(!"- '

&"#"2#"&+$% 6!!$ ( %$# '# ) "

"

6 - # "D ( $ '((6 '

-'/'-6".

') $%-"

$% "#'

4) ! 84 2'( # -$( $"..'

(

( )6# - # -'

$#("

-".($ $&68.'( ("! '

5$.$)". 5( &"& #(/'?E # # (($6# ".F*'

2.'(."

26"2 "

#"

(."

# $%'

E"/("D 'F*'

"#"

'."

26"2 *8$ "/'

2)'#)6."

6!8"' ("'- - # "D'

2'(")) & - B G*9 ) # '%4 "

'( #- #6&.$"- -'(" #6 "

-)$## ) )$&4$%$#'2'

". ('2 -$#- # &.$"- -84>"

D"#"5- *

$2#"& #