← Library
Bombay High CourtCSP/472/2015absolute

Royal Deal Housing Private Limited v. 0

2015-10-30Hon'Ble Shri Justice S.C. Gupte6 pages



 

 

  

      

       

     

 

    !"#"#$%!&'"(!!)!&*!+$),-%.  

 

 

  

      

       

   / 

     !"#"#$%!&'"(! !012"#%*$),-%.     ! "#$$%&' ( )* * ! !  !

"#+,$-.        " ! -%$  -%/  

 ! "# $%&' (  )*

* ! !  ! "#+,$-. 

       "  

  01 

   2

  ( 34 (       2!5)  34  -22!+3$&(!-&#%* & -4!0((-(#'5 -4!0((-(6$7+8$9-"!3$&"(!!"#"#$%!&0 0(-(#'5&%0-&#3$& !*#$%-2#&!9"$&  :1,"!7  :"( 9"$5!&7

:

 !-&+!-&%!+$1%0!23$&"(!,-&"#!0$$54!9"$& (-09$)!5!3$&! "(! 9$1&" "$ $,,$0! "(! 9(!)! -%+ %$& -%. ,-&". (-0 9$%"&$8!&"!+ -%. -8!&)!%"0)-+!#%"(!!"#"#$%0  (!0-%9"#$%$3"(!$1&"#00$1*(""$-" 

 01 

   #   ( 3(

    #  !5)  37 1%+!& !9"#$%0 "$/-%+$"(!&&!2!8-%",&$8#0#$%$3"(!$),-%#!09"7   (! !-&%!+ $1%0!2 3$& "(! !"#"#$%!&0 0"-"!0 "(-" "(! &-%03!&$&' !)!&*!+ $),-%. (-05!!% 9-&&.#%*510#%!00$3 +!8!2$,)!%" $3 9$))!&9#-2 ,&$,!&"#!0 -%+ &!0#+!%"#-2 9$),2!;!0 #% -%+ 

-&$1%+ 1)5-#7 -(-&-0("&- -%+ "(! &-%03!&!!' !012"#%* $),-%. -%+ (-0 5!!% !%*-*!+ #% 510#%!00 $3 0,!9#3#9 +!8!2$,)!%" $3 9$))!&9#-2 ,&$,!&"#!0#%1)5-# (! ,&$,$0!+ 09(!)! $3 )-2*-)-"#$% <#22 (-8! "(! 5!%!3#" <(#9( <#22 &(5"( !65 (    "!! !5)   "!  " "3"5)(1    " ))7 0 ) 3(   ( 3 !  )3(  *) 05! !!( !(" 15)(

!5) !  ( !    (5( 8    (

3  !5)  3  "!) (  05! !!   0   " )

 9  !-&%!+ $1%0!2 3$& "(! !"#"#$%!&0 31&"(!& 0"-"!0 "(-" "(! $-&+ $3 #&!9"$&0 $3 "(! !"#"#$%!& $),-%#!0 (-8! -,,&$8!+ "(! 0-#+ 9(!)! $3 )-2*-)-"#$%-%+5.,-00#%*$-&+ !0$21"#$%0<(#9(-&!-%%!;!+"$"(! &!0,!9"#8!$),-%.9(!)!!"#"#$%0

 (!!-&%!+$1%0!23$&"(!!"#"#$%!&031&"(!&0"-"!0"(-"7!"#"#$%!& $),-%#!0 (-8! 9$),2#!+ <#"( -22 "(! +#&!9"#$%0 ,-00!+ #% "(! &!0,!9"#8! $),-%.1))$%03$&#&!9"#$%0-%+"(-""(!&!0,!9"#8!$),-%.9(!)! !"#"#$%0(-8!5!!%3#2!+#%9$%0$%-%9!<#"("(!$&+!&0,-00!+#%&!0,!9"#8! $),-%.1))$%03$&#&!9"#$%0 = (! !-&%!+ $1%0!2 -,,!-&#%* $% 5!(-23 $3 "(! !"#"#$%!&0 (-8! 0"-"!+"(-""(!!"#"#$%!&$),-%#!0(-8!9$),2#!+<#"(-22&!>1#&!)!%"0-0 ,!& +#&!9"#$%0 $3 "(#0 $1&" -%+ "(!. (-8! 3#2!+ %!9!00-&. -33#+-8#" $3 

9$),2#-%9!#%"(!$1&"$&!$8!&7"(!!"#"#$%!&$),-%#!01%+!&"-?!"$ 9$),2. <#"( -22 0"-"1"$&. &!>1#&!)!%"0 #3 -%.7 -0 &!>1#&!+ 1%+!& "(! $),-%#!09"7 ='  -%+ &12!0 )-+! "(!&! 1%+!& <(#9(!8!& #0 -,,2#9-52!(!0-#+1%+!&"-?#%*#0-99!,"!+  (! !*#$%-2 #&!9"$& (-0 3#2!+ -% 33#+-8#" $% "( +-. $3 9"$5!&7 

0"-"#%*"(!&!#%70-8!-%+!;9!,"-00"-"!+#%,-&-*&-,(=7#"-,,!-&0 "(-""(!9(!)!#0%$",&!41+#9#-2"$"(!#%"!&!0"$30(-&!($2+!&0-%+,152#9 %,-&-*&-,(=$3"(!0-#+33#+-8#"7"(! !*#$%-2#&!9"$&(-00"-"!+"(-":@



 

     



    



  

    





 



  

               

         

 





  

    

 

     :9    !  0! *      '    (*    )

"  ! "" (#   ( 5!)        ! !50        !   05(  " )3 1  )) ) "0) * ! !" 7 "())7 !!5! ! 5 " 1 ))0 (!1 ( "" ("1 )19 %9 (!!-&%!+$1%0!23$& !*#$%-2#&!9"$&$%#%0"&19"#$%0$3& (-%+-%-1"(17 $#%"#&!9"$&!*-2#%"(!$33#9!$3"(! !*#$%-2 #&!9"$&7 #%#0"&. $3 $&,$&-"! 33-#&07 !0"!&% !*#$%7 1)5-# 0"-"!0 "(-" "(!. -&! 0-"#03#!+ <#"( "(! 1%+!&"-?#%*0 *#8!% 5. "(! !"#"#$%!&0(!-5$8!1%+!&"-?#%*0-&!-99!,"!+ 

$,9 &$) "(! )-"!&#-2 $% &!9$&+7 "(! 9(!)! -,,!-&0 "$ 5! 3-#& -%+ &!-0$%-52!-%+#0%$"8#$2-"#8!$3-%.,&$8#0#$%0$32-<-%+#0%$" 9$%"&-&."$,152#9,$2#9. $$9#%9! -22 "(! &!>1#0#"! 0"-"1"$&. 9$),2#-%9!0 (-8! 5!!% 3123#22!+7 $),-%. 9(!)! !"#"#$% $  $3 

 -&! )-+! -50$21"! #% "!&)0 $3 ,&-.!&0 92-10! A-B -%+ A9B -%+  $3 

 #0 )-+! -50$21"!#%"!&)0$3,&-.!&92-10!0A-B-%+A9B $+9(! !"#"#$%!& $),-%#!0 "$ 3#2! - 9$,. $3 "(#0 $&+!& -%+ "(! 9(!)!+12.-1"(!%"#9-"!+5."(!$),-%. !*#0"&-&7#*($1&" A B7$)5-.7<#"("(!9$%9!&%!+1,!&#%"!%+!%"$3"-),073$& "(!,1&,$0!$3-+41+#9-"#$%$30"-), +1". ,-.-52!7#3-%.7$%"(! 0-)!<#"(#%=+-.03&$)"(!+-"!$3"(! &+!& $-9(! !"#"#$%!&0 -&! +#&!9"!+ "$ 3#2! - 9!&"#3#!+ 9$,. $3 $&+!& -2$%* <#"( - 9$,. $3 "(! 9(!)! $3 )-2*-)-"#$% <#"( "(! 9$%9!&%!+

!*#0"&-&$3$),-%#!07!2!9"&$%#9-22.7-2$%*<#"( $&)@  #% -++#"#$% "$ ,(.0#9-2 9$,. -0 ,!& "(! &!2!8-%" ,&$8#0#$%0 $3 "(! $),-%#!09"7 =' <(#9(!8!&#0-,,2#9-52! $/9(!!"#"#$%!&$),-%#!0"$,-.9$0"0$3 0 7'@!-9("$"(!

!*#$%-2#&!9"$&7 !0"!&% !*#$%71)5-#$0""$5!,-#+<#"(#% 3$1&<!!?03&$)"(!+-"!$3"(! &+!& $&9 #2#%*-%+#001-%9!$3"(!+&-<%1,$&+!&#0+#0,!%0!+<#"( 

$'9229$%9!&%!+&!*12-"$&.-1"($&#"#!0"$-9"$%-9$,.$3"(#0$&+!& -2$%*<#"(9(!)!+12.-1"(!%"#9-"!+5."(!$),-%. !*#0"&-&7 #*($1&"A B7$)5-. A1,"!7 B

;

"  3 ! ( 5)(( ! 5("

""3  )! ( ( 9 )((03<8 1(#  9