Atlas Fine Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. v. -




 


 


 







  

    
    



    




   ! !"#$% &$'#()$"$"*+'#, 



 


 


 







  

    
    



    

-


   ! !"#$% &$'#()$"*+'#, 




  
 



 



  


  
 
























 !



"  


#



  
 

 



  



  
 
























 !









" 

  

$%"
& '
(')%"
*+$'
%)$'!

$   
  ,
-

)"
)'.
*+$'
%)$'!


$   
  ,  '../)"$&'$!#0 $ '1(&&'&!%2 '1(&&'&3"4/5"6' )"$ & ! !"#$( $(7'( &!!%2$#('$!)"$ 0!"#'.!$6 "$ $ '*'8'# &'4 ))!6!'.!9:!/' "$  ;:+ 4  ; &+ *2$4 ; 
'$/'$#/":#(.)"$ &+'$ !(""216 "$ &'(6"*2)"$ & 6":$  " "++"( & 6&* '#/ #"$ '#, +'$ , &'( 6"# $"5$ / '#, '5$*# (*'/!# & ! !"#( 
& ('#6 !"# ") & ":$  !( (":0&  " '" 

  

$%"
& '
(')%"
*+$'
%)$'!


   
  ,
-

)"
)'.
*+$'
%)$'!


$   
  ,4:#/$6 !"#(

 "

<'#/" &$$.5'# +$"5!(!"#") &"*+'#!(6 4 


&'$#/":#(.)"$ & ! !"#$(( ' ( &'  &$'#()$"$ "*+'#,&'(2#6'$$,!#0"# &2:(!#(('(*'#:)'6 :$$(4+$"/:6$(4 )"$*:.' "$(4 $('$6&$(4 *!=$(4 $)!#$(4 +$"6(("$(4 $+$"6(("$(4 




$+'68$(4'((*2.$(4=+"$ $(4!*+"$ $(42:,$(4(..$('#//'.$(!# '.. ,+( ") 2'(!6 .*# (4 (,# & !6 '#/ #' :$'. "$0'#!6 '#/ !#"$0'#!6 6&*!6'.(4 + $"6&*!6'.(4 )!# 6&*!6'.(4 6&*!6'. 6"*+":#/(4 ).""$!#0 6&*!6'.(4 '$!# &*!6'.(  6 '#/ $'#()$ "*+'#, &'( 2# 6'$$,!#0"# &2:(!#((")'#/!*+"$ '.. ,+(")0""/(*$6&'#/!('#/ ($5!6( *'#:)'6 :$$(4 +$"/:6$(4 )"$*:.' "$(4 $('$6&$(4 *!=$(4 $)!#$(4 +$"6(("$(4 $+$"6(("$(4 $+'68$(4 '((*2.$(4 =+"$ $(4 !*+"$ $(4 2:,$(4 (..$( '#/ /'.$( !# '.. ,+( ") 2'(!6 .*# (4 (,# & !6'#/#' :$'."$0'#!6'#/!#"$0'#!66&*!6'.(4+ $"6&*!6'.(4)!# 6&*!6'.(46&*!6'.6"*+":#/(4).""$!#06&*!6'.(4'$!#&*!6'.( 6 &+$"+"(/(6&*")*'.0'*' !"#7!..&'5 &2#)! '(+$ & "+!#!"

# ") & *'#'0*# 4 &'  2" & & "*+'#!( '$ :#/$ ('* '#'0*#  '#/ !  7":./ 2 '/5'# '0":( " 6"*2!# & '6 !5! ( '#/ "+$' !"#( !# ' (!#0. "*+'#, '#/ & '*'.0'*' !"# 7!.. #'2. & $'#()$"*+'#, "6"#(".!/'  &2:(!#((('#/.'/ "(,#$0!(!# "+$' !"#'#/6$' '( $"#0$)!#'#6!'2'(7&!6&7":./2'/5'# '0":( " 6"*2!# & '6 !5! ( '#/ "+$' !"#( ") 2" & 6"*+'#!( !# " ' (!#0. "*+'#,)"$(,#$0!( !6.!#8'0('(2" & &"*+'#!('$#0'0/!# & ('* ,+")2:(!#(('6 !5! ('#/ &:( &$7!..22#)! ")6"*2!#/ )!#'#6!'$(":$6(4 &!(7!..2$).6 /!# &+$")! '2!.! ,") &$'#()$ "*+'#,'#/ &'  &'*'.0'*' /"*+'#,7!..!**#(.,2#)! )$"* (5$'. 2'68#/ +$"6((( (:6& '( (:++., 6&'!# '#/ ."0!( !6( '.!0#*# 4 2#)!

)$"* &!#6$'(/(6'.")"+$' !"#(4('5!#0!#5'$!":()!

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

, " ):.., .5$'0 ( $"#0 '(( (4 6'+'2!.! (4 =+$!#64 =+$ !( '#/ !#)$'( $:6 :$ ") 2" & & 6"*+'#!( '#/ &'  & *$0/ # ! , 7!.. '.(" &'5 (:))!6!#  ):#/( $9:!$/ )"$ * !#0 ! ( ."#0 $* 6'+! '. #/( '( +$"5!// )"$ !# & (6&* '#/ &'  & 6&* ") '*'.0'*' !"#7!..$(:. !#6"( ('5!#0)"$2" & &6"*+'#!('( &,'$ 6'+! '.!>!#0 "# '6& " &$( 6"$ 6"*+ #6, '#/ $(":$6( 7&!6& '$ =+6 / " $(:.  !# ( '2!.! , ") "+$' !"#(4 6"(  ('5!#0( '#/ &!0&$ +$")! '2!.! , .5.( )"$ & *'.0'*' / "*+'#,4 &:( !  7!.. !**#(., 2#)!  &(&'$&"./$(")2" & &6"*+'#!

<
'$#/ ":#(. )"$ &  ! "#$( ):$ &$ ( ' ( &'  & "'$/ ") !$6 "$( ") &  ! "#$ "*+'#!( &'5 '++$"5/ & ('!/ 6&* ") *'.0'*' !"#'#/2,+'((!#0"'$/ (".: !"#(7&!6&'$'##=/ " & $(+6 !5"*+'#,6&* ! "#( 
&'$#/":#(.)"$ & ! "#$():$ &$( ' ( &' 4 ! "#$ "*+'#!( &'5 6"*+.!/ 7! & '.. & /!$6 !"#( +'((/ !# & $(+6 !5 "*+'#,:**"#()"$!$6 !"#('#/ &'  &$(+6 !5"*+'#,6&*  ! "#(&'52#)!./!#6"#("#'#67! & &"$/$(+'((/!#$(+6 !5 "*+'#,:**"#()"$!$6 !"#( ?
& '$#/ ":#(. '++'$!#0 "# 2&'.) ") &  ! "#$( &'5 ( ' / &'  & ! "#$"*+'#!(&'56"*+.!/7! &'..$9:!$*# ('( +$ /!$6 !"#( ") &!( ":$  '#/ &, &'5 )!./ #6(('$, '))!/'5!  ") 6"*+.!'

#6!# &":$ "$"5$4 & ! "#$"*+'#!(:#/$ '8 " 6"*+., 7! & '.. ( ' : "$, $9:!$*# ( !) '#,4 '( $9:!$/ :#/$ & "*+'#!(6 4 ?%  '#/ $:.( *'/ &$ :#/$ 7&!6&5$ !( '++.!6'2.&('!/:#/$ '8!#0!('66+ / @
& ))!6!'!9:!/' "$&'()!./&!($+"$ "##//',") + *2$4 !#"*+'#,6&* ! "#"")( ' !#0 &'  &'))'!$(") &$'#()$"$"*+'#,&'(2#6"#/:6 /!#'+$"+$*'##$'#/ &'  &$'#()$"$"*+'#!(*',2"$/$/ "2/!((".

A
& 0!"#'.!$6 "$&'()!./'#))!/'5! "#A &/',")+ *2$4 ( ' !#0 &$!#4('5'#/=6+ '(( ' /!#+'$'0$'+&?4! '++'$( &'  &6&*!(#" +$1:/!6!'. " &!# $( ")(&'$&"./$('#/+:2.!6
#+'$'0$'+&?") &('!/))!/'5! 4 & 0!"#'.!$6 "$&'(( ' / &' ;B



 

   /0
  


     

 

 

 

   



   !         " 

       "
 #             



       

 

 $

 %     "    

  $

    

    ! 

" 



!$   "!  



 $

  $&'

()


 

 *   " 



       



#  *

 "

   

"+

,+

"

 #   *

 "   -*    " 

   "    

    

  



  #   *

 "

 

 

   "
  1
"




2  

  

/0





* 
!  

  


   
  ,

3
 
3 
32 




 



  

3  
"

  
4
#

$   
  ,
 

3
3  



- 
 
 ,






  
-


" 
 ,
-



2
3  
"

  
3

"5
 1



 1
"




2  

  
/20





* 
!  

  


% 
3 



   
  
32 


   
  
 
23 

 ,
-


2
  

  
$6

 

6
3
  
3


" 
-
2

 
 - 

  
-

-1
1
&'$#/":#(.)"$ 0!"#'.!$6 "$"#!#( $:6 !"#(")$ &'#/'#': &:4 "!# !$6 "$0'.!# &"))!6") & 0!"#'. !$6 "$4 !#!( $, ") "$+"$'  ))'!$(4 ( $# 0!"#4 :*2'! ( ' ( &'  &, '$ (' !()!/ 7! & & :#/$ '8!#0( 0!5# 2, &  ! !"#$(&'2"5:#/$ '8!#0('$'66+ /
 1
$"* & *' $!'. "# $6"$/4 & 6&* '++'$( " 2 )'!$ '#/ $'("#'2.'#/!(#" 5!".' !5")'#,+$"5!(!"#(").'7'#/!(#"  6"# $'$, "+:2.!6+".!6,
 1
!#6 '.. & $9:!(!  ( ' : "$, 6"*+.!'#6( &'5 2# ):.)!../4 "*+'#, 6&*  ! !"# "  ")  '$ *'/ '2(".:  !# $*( ") +$',$( 6.':( C'D4 C2D '#/ C/D '#/  ")  !( *'/ '2(".: !# $*(")+$',$6.':((C'D'#/C6D
#1
&  ! !"#$ "*+'#!( " )!. ' 6"+, ") &!( "$/$ '#/ & 6&*/:.,': &# !6' /2, &"*+'#, 0!( $'$4!0&":$  




C D4"*2',47! & &6"#6$#/:+$!# #/# ") '*+(4)"$ &+:$+"(")'/1:/!6' !"#")( '*+ /: , +','2.4!)'#,4"# & ('*7! &!#?/',()$"* &/' ") & $/$
1
&  ! !"#$( '$ /!$6 / " )!. ' 6$ !)!/ 6"+, ") "$/$ '."#0 7! & ' 6"+, ") & 6&* ") *'.0'*' !"# 7! & & 6"#6$#/

0!( $'$")"*+'#!(4.6 $"#!6'..,4'."#07! & "$*
BA !# '//! !"# " +&,(!6'. 6"+, '( +$ & $.5'#  +$"5!(!"#( ") & "*+'#!(6 4 ?% 7&!6&5$!('++.!6'2.
1
& ! !"#$"*+'#!( "+',6"( (") (4%B'6& " &

0!"#'. !$6 "$4 ( $# 0!"#4 :*2'! '#/ &  ! !"#$ !# & "*+'#, 6&*  ! !"# "  ")  " +', 6"( ( ")

(4%B " & ))!6!'.!9:!/' "$4!0&":$ 4"*2',"(  " 2+'!/7! &!#)":$78()$"* &/' ") & $/$
71
!.!#0'#/!((:'#6") &/$'7#:+"$/$!(/!(+#(/7! &
81
..6"#6$#/$0:.' "$,': &"$! !( "'6 "#'6"+,") &!("$/$ '."#07! &6&*/:.,': &# !6' /2, &"*+'#, 0!( $'$4 !0&":$ C D4"*2',
C:+ 4 D