← Library
Bombay High CourtCSP/577/2015absolute

Shrem Aniruddha Power Pvt. Ltd. v. -

2015-10-23Hon'Ble Shri Justice S.C. Gupte8 pages



 

 

  

              

       

    #$% #&#'"&( #!#!)*'"+  

 

 

  

     ,         

      



     #$%  -!".#'"&( #!#!)*'"+  

 

 

  

     /         

   0   

      #$% % #.#'"&( #!#!)*'"+ 

 

 

 

  

     ,         

   1   

     #$% !2#%#'"&( #!#!)*'"+  

 

 

  

     ,         

      

       #$% #'"&(

!)*'"+     !"#$$%&' ( )* * ! !  ! "#+,$-.       " ! -%$  -%/  

 ! "# $%&' (  )*

* ! !  !"#+,$-. 

      "

   )    

   0

  #   1 !  ! 2 ( 

 

   #   "(  ! 2 (  

     # 

(  ! 2 ( 

   #  13  !

2 4  

     #  !  2  '33 .(!#% '# "4 # '5 &%%'% $6 '5 &%%'%7!8.9!-'

(!#% #& #:%!&3' $6#"&'# (!#

4 !"'3 # -!# # ')';'"%'8 (( - '3 <2 .'!#  =2* 8  =0#. -!6 #8  =

 '#. .!2"& 3(!#% *'# &!!65 -!# %'&-!) 6 (!# %  -!2# ! !**!&  %  -%  '". "!# '"+ *'#+ %'& -!"#!9 . '"+ '9 #) "&)'.

 "%   !"&   &'"- !" !( %  !2# & &!24% ! ' "

   )    

    0

    #   1 !  !

2(



  # "( 

! 2 (  

     #   

( ! 2 ( 

    #   13  ! 2 4   

      #  !  282".

# - !"&0/ !0/1'".!% ## 9'"*#!9 & !" !(% !)*'"

&-8 0 0   . !2"& 3 (!# % #& &'

& %' % #& #'"&( #!# !)*'"+8 %   -!". #'"&( #!# !)*'"+8 %  % #. #'"&( #!#!)*'"+'".% #'"&(

!)*'"+%'&6

"-'##+ "4!"% 62& "

&&!(!"&#2- !"'".% !2#%#'"&( #!#!)*'"+ & !)2 !  53! !!  % *#!*!& .&-% !()'34')' !"> 33%'9 % 6 "

( '&* #% !* " !"!(% )'"'4 "8%''33% !)*'"

& '#  2".

# &')  '"'4 " '".  43)( 5 (*3!  " 5   " *  ! (   !   ! ) 2 (      )   43)(

* ( !2  ! " ) 6! 5! (! " !  "!! 52 " 5     ) 53! !!3" !( )(" *  !(  !( 3!" 53

 5 ) 2  ) ( 2(   )  4 ))5) !  2"!) ( 53! !!!()(!2  !    ("

!   " )5!(   )  4 )) !3) " 2 !")( (3"  *

(!#(  !  *#  )( 7( 3 (  ) 3 ) 8   !3 "! (      )   4 )) !3)  !   " (3"   3) ) " 2))( 3) 2" ) "! 93 (  !5"

(352  !  !(  !  2: 

1  . !2"& 3 (!# % #& (2#% # &'

& %' %  !'#. !(  # -!#& !( % # !)*'"

& %'9  '**#!9 . %  &' . -%  !( )'34')' !"'".6+*'&& "4!'#.

&!32 !"&>% -%'# '""

?

.!% &* - 9 !)*'"+-%   !"&   .!2"& 3(!#% #&(2#% #&'

&%'8 # !)*'"

& %'9  -!)*3 . > % '33 %  . # - !"& *'&& . " %  # &* - 9 !)*'"+2))!"&(!# # - !"&'".%'% # &* - 9 !)*'"+-%    !"&%'9 6

"( 3 . "-!"&!"'"- > %% !#.

#&*'&& . "# &* - 9 !)*'"+2))!"&(!# # - !"& @   . !2"& 3 '** '# "4 !" 6 %'3( !( % #& %'9 &'

.%'% #!)*'"

&%'9 -!)*3 .> %'33# <2 # "&'& * # . # - !"& !( % & !2# '". % + %'9  ( 3 . "

- &&'#+ '(( .'9  !( -!)*3 '"-  "% !2#!# !9 #8% #!)*'"

&2".

#';

! -!)*3+ > % '33 &'2!#+ # <2 # "& ( '"+8 '& # <2 # . 2".

# % !)*'"

&-8 /@$ 0 '". #23 & )'.

 %  2".

# >% -% # & '**3 -'63 % &' .2".

#'; "4 &'-- * .   (( - '3  <2 .'!# %'& ( 3 . % & # *!# !" 0% .'+ !( -!6 #8   "!)*'"+-%   !"!&!,!( &' "4%'% '((' #& !( %  #'"&( #!# !)*'"

& %'9  6

" -!".2- . " ' *#!* # )'""

#'".%'% #'"&( #!#!)*'"

&)'+6 !#.

.!6 . &&!39 . 

,

4 !"'3  # -!# %'& ( 3 . '" (( .'9  !" 1% .'+ !( -!6 #8  &' "4% "8&'9 '". ?- *'&&'

. "*'#'4#'*%@8 '** '#& %'% -%  &"!*#

52. - '3!%  "

&!(&%'# %!3.

#&'".*263 - "*'#'4#'*%@!(% &' .(( .'9 8%

4 !"'3 # -!#%'&&'

.%'=A 

 

   ;<  

     

 

 

   



   !         " 

       " #             



       

 

 $

 %     "  

  ! " 



! $   "!   

 $

  

$&' ()

 

 *   " 



      



#  *

 "

   

"+

,+

"

 #   *

 "   -*    " 

   "    

    

  



  #   *

 "



 

   "  %:    !   5! *      ' ;<     (*    )  "  !"" (#    2

3  !"3!)!35 (    ((      " ) "  ""3  ( ( = $/#  !  2!

))!!!3"

""3  !4 "

 "!! 2 

"" 4   "

" )24   ) "5)""3  ( (!3"

!>&": $,:   !   5! *      ';5<     (*    )  "  ! "" (#    ( 3!)         ! !35          !   53(  " )2 4   )) ) "5) * ! !" 7"())7 !!3! ! 3 "

4 ))5 (!4 ( "" ("4  )4: $$:%  .!2"& 3(!#

4 !"'3 # -!#!" "&#2- !"&!(# %'".'"'2%28 ! " # -!# 4'3 "% !(( - !(%

4 !"'3  # -!#8  " &#+ !( !#*!#'

 ((' #&8

& #"

4 !"8 2)6'  &'

& %' % + '#  &' &( . > % %  2".

#'; "4& 4 9 " 6+ %  #&% '6!9 2".

#'; "4&'# '-- * . $+: #!) %  )'

# '3 !" # -!#.8 %  -%  '** '#& ! 6  (' # '". '&!"'63 '". &"!9 !3' 9 !('"+*#!9 & !"&!(3'>'". &"! -!"#'#+!*263 -*!3 -+ $-: "-  '33 %  # <2 &  &'2!#+ -!)*3 '"- & %'9  6

" (23( 33 .8 !)*'"+ -%   !" !&  ! , !(   '#  )'.

'6&!32  " #)&!(*#'+ #&-3'2& B'C8B6C'".B.C'"., !(  &)'.

'6&!32  " #)&!(*#'+ #-3'2& &B'C'".B-C $/:% # !)*'"

& ! ( 3  ' -!*+ !( % & !#.

# '". % -% .23+'2% " -'

.6+% !)*'"+

4 &#'#8 4%!2#  

B C8!)6'+8> %% -!"- #"

.2* # "

".

"!(')*&8(!# % *2#*!& !('.52. -' !"!(&')* .2+ *'+'63 8 ('"+8!"% &') > % "@.'+&(#!)% .'

!(%  #.

# $&:% #& '#  . # - . ! ( 3  ' - # ( . -!*+ !( !#.

# '3!"4 > % ' -!*+ !( %  -%  !( )'34')' !" > % %  -!"- #"

.

4 &#'#!(!)*'"

&8 -#!" -'33+8'3!"4> % !#)A, " '..  !" ! *%+& -'3 -!*+ '& * # %  # 9'" *#!9 & !"& !( % !)*'"

&-8 /@$ 0>% -% # &'**3 -'63  $':% #!)*'"

&!*'+-!&&!( & 8$A '-%!%

4 !"'3  # -!#8

& #"

4 !"8 2)6'  '". % # " % !)*'"+-%   !"!&!,!( !*'+-!&& !( & 8$A!%  (( - '3 <2 .'!#8 4%!2#8!)6'+!& !6 *' .> % "(!2#>

;&(#!)% .'

!(%  #.

# $?: 3 "4'". &&2'"- !(% .#'>"2*!#.

# &. &* "& .> % $@:33-!"- #"

.# 423'!#+'2%!# &!'-!"'-!*+!(% &!#.

# '3!"4> %-% .23+'2% " -'

.6+% !)*'"+

4 &#'#8  4%!2#B C8!)6'+ B2* 8 C

1  "  2  ! ( 3)(( ! 3("

""2  )! ( ( : )((52A 6 4(# :