Bombay High CourtCSP/596/2016scheme sanctioned company

Reliance Telecom Limited v. -

2016-10-27Hon'Ble Shri Justice A. K. Menon11 pages

$! !" %&'(&&)&'(*%+,-&."

/" "

01 % &' (&&) -&+%, 2 " & 2 3 &' (*%+,-&."

1 %&'(&&)-'())%(%&

4+%-((5%+-&+%,+(+&6 4+%- 4-(+(+&6 &'+)),*-&+7,')'46),%6-)6+&),

446)')+% ,4*% '%.5%,4%6) 8,'''+9:8,'''; .67-& )&'&+&+%) ) ,'+,''&+9:%<8=*).)+%4+)-&).*),%& > = %%.

> $&'-&:). !"

> "

)6)%65%,4)&'*)&+, :8-&)',-(:)&'-5)& &**,&'-'(%6%)%?*)&?',-%&)7)&6%?7)(%&,(6+%&' &+&+%

' ,%-&+% &' 5)& +, ,5'& 5%6) -&+%, 2 " & 2 3 %6 &') )47%& *)7+,+%, &' (*%+, -&. "

. & &' -'( ))%(%& :&@%4+%-((5%+-&+%,+(+&6/A(B)A&' )%,)(*%?B0 %6 4+%- 4-( +(+&6 /A B ) A&' )%,)) (*%?B ) A&' &+&+%)(*%?B0%6&'+)),*-&+7,')'46),%6-)6+&),/A&'-'(B0

')%65%,4)&'&+&+%),&&,&'&&' )%,))(*%?+, %6+%&':5,+%,,&4-(,)7+-,.6&,)7+-,4%@+&'%C'5,&+7 )%745666,)7+-,%6**4+-&+%, ' )%,)(*%?+,%6. +%&':5,+%,,*)7+6+%&4-(,)7+-,.-7)+%(:+4%6+C6 4+%&4*'%?.+%-456+%:)6:%6.%&+%4%6+%&)%&+%44%6+,&%-,)7+-, %6 6& ,)7+-, 4% @+&' % C'5,&+7 )% 745 666 ,)7+-, %6 **4+-&+%, )%65%,4)&'&+&+%)5)&'),&&,&'&&')6+)-&), &'&+&+%)(*%?%6&' )%,)(*%?'7**)76&',+6-'( :?*,,+%)6,45&+%,.@'+-'@)%%C6&&'(*%?-'(&+&+%

)%6 5%,4 ) &' &+&+%) 5)&') ,&&, &'& &' &+&+%) (*%?+,@'44?@%6,5:,+6+)?&' )%,)(*%?%6%&+)D5+&? ,')-*+&4&'&+&+%)(*%?+,'46:?&' )%,)(*%?/$E E!F0 %6+&,@'44?@%6,5:,+6+)?.4+%-%-((%),&)5-&5)+(+&6/AB0 / "

!F0 ?&'*),%&-'(+&+,+%&%66&&)%,)&' 4-(%6)&<+% )(&'@'44?@%6,5:,+6+)?&+&,'46+%-(*%?%66,%&+%747%? (7(%&,,&,)4+:+4+&+,&%?-(*%?5&,+6&')5* *%&'-'( :-(+%-&+7.+%&)4+.+%)-%+&+%&'-&&'&&'(*%+,-&."

*)'+:+&,44&(%&,'),:?'46+%-(*%?&+&,,5:,+6+)?.%,'),&'

)%,)(*%?,'44:44&&6+%4+5)C-'%&''46+%+%&' &+&+%)(*%?

4,.&' )%,)(*%?+,%&)D5+)6&*?)*)7+6 )%?-%,+6)&+%&'))&' )%,)(*%?+,%&+,,5+%%?,'),) *?+%%?-%,+6)&+%.6+)-&4?)+%6+)-&4?.&+&')&'&+&+%)(*%?)+&, ,')'46), 5)&'). &' -'( 6, %& -& &' )+'&, %6 +%&),&, &' ((:), ) -)6+&), &' &+&+%) (*%? %6 6, %& +%747 )G )%+H&+% &' ') *+&4 &' )%,) (*%?

%,D5%&4? &' ,')'46),&' )%,)(*%?)%&4+<4?&:-&6:?&'-'( %7+@&'856(%&&'+,5)&+%'(:%7,&(%&,+(+&6),5, +(+&6/ !!"0"!

(*%?,,.+4+%(*%?5((%,)+)-&+%%6 (*%?-'(&+&+%:?&' )%,)(*%?@,6+,*%,6@+&'7+6)6) 6&6 &'6?55,&. !"*,,6+% $! !"

')%65%,4)&'&+&+%)5)&'),&&,&'&.&+&+%)(*%? ',-(*4+6@+&'44&'6+)-&+%,*,,6+%&'(*%?5((%,)+)-&+% %6&'&&'(*%?-'(&+&+%',:%+46+%-%,%%-@+&'&')6) *,,6+%(*%?5((%,)+)-&+% $

')%65%,4**)+%%:'4&'&+&+%)',,&&6&'&&' &+&+%)(*%?',-(*4+6@+&'44)D5+)(%&,,*)6+)-&+%,&'+,5)& %6 +& ', +46 %-,,)? +67+&, -(*4+%- +% &' 5)& )7). &' &+&+%)(*%?5%6)&<,&-(*4?@+&'44,&&5&)?)D5+)(%&,.+%?., )D5+)65%6)&'(*%+,-&."

9 !"2%654,(6&')5%6)@'+-'7) )**4+-:4 ',+65%6)&<+%+,--*&6

'+%4+)-&)',+46%+67+&%2)66?-&:). !".+%&) 4+.,&&+%.,7%6C-*&,,&&6+%*))*'/+0&/7+0.+&**),--)6+% &+%4+)-&).&'&&'-'(+,%&*)856+-+4&&'+%&),&,')'46), %6*5:4+- %*))*'&',+6+67+&.&'+%4+)-&)',,&&6&'&>G

!"!# $ %#

%&'# () * (+) # , -..

!"# /0( (*1 2) (+)

# 1#3 #

!"# / ) ( 5# 6

7 8

!" # 9 8 5#6

1 9,:

; 9 9 , ;

: , 9 - , )<+ 1; 1 # (+)2 , 9 (+= , > 0 ?

)@ 9 1 9

, 4A@<A@ # ( @ 9

" 1 , 2) (+) , ) ?

(+)

3@- 0 @#;5A;0;(? 1?*4;) B)* C 0@- 0 0@-;A @ ;<)<?2 (< +* (+) .--B)6-B(. @-3 , , 8 D @ 9

, ,. .

!" # 9 -

(C +C (+) 1 1 -.:.

% ),*%, & :7 :,)7&+%, &' +%4 +)-&). &' &+&+%) (*%? ', +46 +&, +67+& +% )*4? 6&6 "$&' -&:). !" 64+% @+&' &' :,)7&+%,(6:?&'+%4+)-&)> "!

,),&':,)7&+%+%*))*'/+0&'+67+&+%4+)-&) +, -%-)%6. &' &+&+%) (*%? ', ,5:(+&&6 &'& +& @+44 -(*4? @+&' 44 **4+-:4*)7+,+%,%-( C-&%644&C+,,5,)+,+%5&&'-'( @+44:(&%6%,@)6+%--)6%-@+&'4@ ""

,),&':,)7&+%+%*))*'/++0&'+67+&+%4+)-&) +, -%-)%6. -(*4+%& )))6 & +% &' *))*' 5%6) ))%- *)&+%, & -'())%(%&:&@%+,&('?( 4)7+-,+(+&6/A B0%6 4+%- ((5%+-&+%, +(+&6 /A(B0 8,&'% +' 5)& /+% )4&+% & 0:?+&,)6)6&62!&'*&(:). !"%6(:? +'5)&/+%)4&+%& (0 :? +&, )6) 6&6 $&' -&:). !" ', ,%-&+%6 &' -'( ))%(%& ,&'-(*4+%&6,%&*)&+%&&'*),%&,-'())%(%&. &'C*4%&+%*)7+66:?&'&+&+%)(*%?+,5%6&:,&+,-&)?

, ) , &' :,)7&+% +% *))*' /+++0 &' +67+& +%4 +)-&) +, -%-)%6. &' &+&+%) (*%? ', ,5:(+&&6 &'& &)+4 -5)& *)-6+%,@+44:6%66:?&'&+&+%)(*%?+%--)6%-@+&'4@ , &' ,+6 *)-6+%, 6 %& *)&+% & &' *),%& -'( ))%(%&. &' C*4%&+%*)7+66:?&'&+&+%)(*%?+,5%6&:,&+,-&)? "2 , ) , &' :,)7&+% +% *))*' /+70 &' +67+& +%4 +)-&) +, -%-)%6. &' &+&+%) (*%? ,&&, &'& , *) -45, "

2 &' -'(.&'-'(+,-%6+&+%45*%:&+%+%**)74&'*)&(%&

4-((5%+-&+%, ' &+&+%) (*%? ,'44 :&+% ,5-' **)74, :) +7+%-&&&'-'( ',+6C*4%&+%*)7+66:?&'&+&+%)(*%? +,5%6&:,&+,-&)?

"3 ,),&':,)7&+%+%*))*'/70&'+67+&+%4+)-&) +,-%-)%6. /+0 %),*-&&':,)7&+%*)&+%+%&%%,5:(+,,+%6+7+,+%+%%-+4, +,-%-)%6.&+&+%)(*%?',7+6+&,4&&)6&6 &'*&(:). !" *)7+66-)&++6-*?&'6+7+,+%4+%%-+4,+&,()65,+%,,%6 &'(+%+%5,+%,,,%2",&)-'. !"&&'+-+%4+)-&)

',+6C*4%&+%+,5%6&:,&+,-&)? /++0%),*-&&':,)7&+%*)&+%+%&**4+-:+4+&?-&+%"E!&' (*%+,-&. !"2+,-%-)%6.&'&+&+%)(*%?',,5:(+&&6&'&&'

*),%&-'(+,+465%6),-&+%,2 "&2 3&'(*%+,-&."

& +, 5)&') ,5:(+&&6 &'& , &' &)%,) 5%6)&<+% +, :+% -&6 , % +%&)4*)&&'-'(59,2 "&2 3&'(*%+,-&."

.,-&+% "E!&'(*%+,-&. !"2+,%&**4+-:4 '),+6,*-&',4, :% -%,+6)6 :? &' 4'+ +' 5)& +% +&, 856(%& +% %,?,&(, +(+&6/(*%?&+&+%"3! !!20@')+%@'+4-%,+6)+%&'*)7+,+%, ,-&+% 2/"0/0&'(*%+,-&."

/@'+-'+,,+(+4)&,-&+%"E! &'(*%+,-&. !"20+&'46&'&,-&+% 2/"0/0@,%&**4+-:4, &'6())@,:+%-&659,2 "&2 3&'(*%+,-&."

' ,( @, 4, -%,+6)6 :? &' =)%&< +' 5)& +% +&, 6-+,+% % > %+&6*+)+&,+(+&6/(*%?&+&+% "$! !"30@')+%+&.+%&)4+. '46&'&*)7+,+%,,-&+% 2(*%+,-&."

),-&+%"E!&' (*%+,-&. !"2@546%&:**4+-:4,&'&)%,)&'5%6)&<+%+, *5),5%& & -'( )(6 59, 2 " & 2 3 &' (*%+, -&. "

' C*4%&+%*)7+66:?&'&+&+%)(*%?+,5%6&:,&+,-&)? /+++0% ),*-& :,)7&+% *)&+%+% & &)%,) 4+-%,, %4? 5& E 4+-%,,+,-%-)%6.&'&+&+%)(*%?',,5:(+&&6&'&45," "2 &'-'(6+%, 4-(%6)&<+% ',(',&:)6@+&'-'654 "&' -'(@'+-',*-++-44? 4+,&,&' 4+-%,, &:6()6+%&&'

)%,)(*%?

')(+%+%24+-%,,@546-%&+%5&)(*)&&' !

(+%+%5,+%,,&'&+&+%)(*%?

',+6C*4%&+%+,5%6& :,&+,-&)?

/+70%),*-&:,)7&+%*)&+%+%&%%G5)%+,'+%56+&6+%%-+4, &' )%,)(*%?,%2"

!"+,-%,+6)6.&'&+&+%)(*%? ,5:(+&,&'&-*?&'56+&6%%54--5%&,&' )%,)(*%? ',:%%%C6,%%C5)I2J&&'+67+&6&6"$&'-&:) !"+46 :?&'&+&+%)(*%?

',+6C*4%&+%+,5%6&:,&+,-&)? "

, ) , &' :,)7&+% +% *))*' /7+0 &' +67+& +%4 +)-&)+,-%-)%6.&+&+%)(*%?,'44-(*4?@+&'&'6+)-&+%,+,,56:? &' +(+&6%6 &+%4&-< C-'%%6++(+&67+6&'+)),*-&+7 4&&),6&6 E&'54?. !"

)(&'(&)+4%)-)6.&'-'(**),&:+)%6),%:4%6 +,%&7+4&+7%?*)7+,+%,4@%6+,%&-%&))?&*5:4+-*4+-? "$ +%-44&')D5+,+&,&&5&)?-(*4+%-,'7:%54+446.&'(*%? -'(&+&+%+,(6:,45&+%&)(,*)?)-45,,/0%6/-0 "E

' &+&+%) (*%? & +4 -*? &'+, )6) %6 &' -'( 654? 5&'%&+-&6 :? &' (*%? +,&)). +' 5)& / 0. (:?. @+&' &' -%-)%65*)+%&%6%&&(*,.)&'*5)*,6856+-&+%,&(*65&? *?:4.+%?.%&',(@+&'+%!6?,)(&'6&&'+,)6) "

'&+&+%)+,6+)-&6&+4-)&++6-*?)6)4%@+&'-*? &'-'(@+&'&'-%-)%6+,&))(*%+,.4-&)%+-44?.4%@+&' )( G E +% 66+&+% & *'?,+-4 -*? , *) &' )47%& *)7+,+%, &' (*%+,-&."

9 !"2@'+-'7)+,**4+-:4 !

'&+&+%)(*%?&*?-,&,, "!.!!!9G&&'+%4+)-&). #,&)% +%. 5(:+ ,&& : *+6@+&'+%5) @<, )( &'6& &'+, )6) "

+4+%%6+,,5%-&'6)@%5*)6)+,6+,*%,6@+&'

44-%-)%6)54&)?5&')+&+,&-&%-*?&'+,)6)4%@+&' -'(654?5&'%&+-&6:?&'(*%?+,&)). +'5)&/ 0.(:?

/ = %% 0

-)&+?&'&&'+,)6)5*466+,&)5%6-))-&-*?)++%4 ,+%6)6) *466:?>'%<) @6.&%)*')