Bombay High CourtCSP/629/2015scheme sanctioned company

Splendid Agro Investments Pvt. Ltd. v. -

2015-12-11Hon'Ble Shri Justice K.R. Shriram11 pages

! !"#$% & !$' $(#')$"$"*+(#,

! !"#$% &/"#0$(#')$"$"*+(#,

! !"#$% &&!$0$(#')$"$"*+(#,

! !"#$% &$(#')$"*+(#,

!" # $%%&'( )

*+ +!"!

# $,-%./

# !" .&% .&0

!" # $ %&'( )

*+ +!"!

!" # $,-%./

* !

2!"

" 3 )

#) " 3 )

!) " 3 4!

" 3 )

(220)"$&($!#3 $ (4'&&(&!%5 (4'&&(&6"708"/( )"$ & ! !"#$' $#4(#!9:*($!#3&!%5$#'($!)"$ & 3!"#(2!$/ "$ $ (*(;(# &(7 & ))!/!(2!<:!0( "$ =9 &$!$(*7 =

&/*5$7

($0($#0":#'2)"$ &+($ !'""54/ "$&('/"*5)"$ & /":$ " "++"' & /&* (#0 #"$ (#, +($ , &(' /"# $"8$ 0 (#, (8$*# '*(0!# & ! !"#' & '(#/ !"# ") & ":$ !' '":3& " ( #

* !

2!"

" 3)

#) " 3 )

!) " 3 4!

" 37:#0$/ !"#' - "->(#0" &$$28(# +$"8!'!"#'") &"*+(#!'/ 7 -

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

& ($#0 ":#'2 )"$ & ! !"#$' ):$ &$ ' ( ' &( ! !"#$ "*+(#!' &(8 /"*+2!0 @! & (22 & 0!$/ !"#' +(''0 !# & $'+/ !8 "*+(#, :**"#' )"$ !$/ !"#' (#0 &( & $'+/ !8 "*+(#, /&* ! !"#' &(8 5# )!20 !# /"#'"#(#/ @! & & "$0$'+(''0!#$'+/ !8"*+(#,:**"#')"$!$/ !"#' &($#0":#'2(++($!#3"#5&(2)") & ! !"#$'&(8' ( 0 &( & ! !"#$"*+(#!'&(8/"*+2!0@! &(22$<:!$*# '('

+$ 0!$/ !"#' ") &!' ":$ (#0 &, &(8 )!20 #/''($, ())!0(8! ") /"*+2!(#/!# &":$ "$"8$7 & ! !"#$"*+(#!':#0$ (; "/"*+2,@! &(22' ( : "$,$<:!$*# '!)(#,7('$<:!$0:#0$ & "*+(#!'/ 7 % -(#0$:2'*(0 &$:#0$@&!/&8$ !'(++2!/(52&'(!0:#0$ (;!#3!'(//+ 0 . & ))!/!(2 !<:!0( "$ &(' )!20 &!' $+"$ "# & 0(, ") "8*5$7

!#"*+(#,/&* ! !"#"' "- ")

' ( !#3 &( &())(!$'") &$(#')$"$"*+(#!'&('5#/"#0:/ 0!#(+$"+$ *(##$ (#0 &( & $(#')$"$ "*+(#!' *(, 5 "$0$0 " 5 0!''"280 1 & 3!"#(2 !$/ "$ &(' )!20(# ))!0(8! "# > & 0(, ")"8*5$7

' ( !#3 &$!#7 '(8 (#0 ?/+ (' ' ( 0 !# +($(3$(+& 7 ! (++($' &( & /&* !' #" +$4:0!/!(2 " & !# $' ") '&($&"20$' (#0 +:52!/ # +($(3$(+& ") & '(!0 ))!0(8! 7 &

3!"#(2!$/ "$&('' ( 0 &( =A

D(E

" #

" $

& ' " #

# % " #

%( D5E$

% ) " * "

" +,--

--./" 0-1( " "

/ " #

/" " % % #

/" " # %

-- 3

,- $ !

% "

% 45 $ " 6

$ 6

8 7 "

$ 6 " 9 6 " " %

$ 6 "

")($(' &"5'$8( !"#!#+($(3$(+&D(E") &))!0(8! ") 3!"#(2 !$/ "$ !' /"#/$#07 & ! !"#$ "*+(#, &$":3& ! ' /":#'2 ':5*! 0 &( !#(00! !"# " &/"*+2!(#/")//":# !#3 (#0($0F

>7 &$(#')$"*+(#,'&(22+(''':/&(//":# !#3# $!'@&!/& ($ #/''($, !# /"##/ !"# @! & & /&* " /"*+2, @! & " &$ (++2!/(52//":# !#3 (#0($0':/&('A /

")($(' &"5'$8( !"#!#+($(3$(+&D5E") &))!0(8! ") 3!"#(2 !$/ "$ !' /"#/$#07 & ! "#$ "*+(#, &$":3& ! ' /":#'2 ':5*! 0 &( &<:! ,&($'&205, & !$' $(#')$"$"*+(#, (#0&!$0 $(#')$"$"*+(#,!# & $(#')$ "*+(#,@!22' (#0 /(#/220(#0/"#'<:# 2, &$@!225($0:/ !"#")+(!0A:+<:! , &($(+! (2") &$(#')$"*+(#,#/7 &($#0":#'2 )"$ & ! "#$"*+(#!'+$(,')"$ &(*#0*# " &/&* 5,(00!#3/2(:' -.") &/&*(':#0$= -. & !$' $(#')$"$ "*+(#, (#0 & &!$0 $(#')$"$ "*+(#, &"20' .7 (#0 <:! , &($' ") ' %A (/& $'+/ !82,!# &&($(+! (2") &$(#')$"*+(#,:$':(# " &!'/&*")*(23(*( !"#7 &!#8' *# ") & !$' $(#')$"$ "*+(#, (#0 & &!

$0 $(#')$"$ "*+(#, !# & $(#')$ "*+(#,'&(22' (#0/(#/220&/(#/22( !"#(#0$0:/ !"#") & '&($/(+! (2(//":# ('()"$'(!0'&(225))/ 0('(#!# 3$(2+($ ") &!'/&*! '2)(' &'(*0"'#" !#8"28! &$0!*!#: !"

2!(5!2! , !# $'+/ ") :#+(!0 '&($ /(+! (2 "$ +(,*# " (#, '&($&"20$ ") (#, +(!0 :+ '&($ /(+! (2 (#0 & "$0$ ") & ":$ '(#/ !"#!#3 &/&*'&(2250*0 "5(#"$0$:#0$/ !"#

") & / /"#)!$*!#3 & /(+! (2 $0:/ !"#H (8 " (*#0 3$(# 0 "5/($$!0": @! &!# @"@;')$"* &0( ") &"$0$

")($(' &"5'$8( !"#!#+($(3$(+&D/E") &))!0(8! ") 3!"#(2 !$/ "$ !' /"#/$#07 & ($#0 ":#'2 )"$ & ! !"#$ "*+(#!'':5*! &( & ! !"#$"*+(#!'($5":#0 "/"*+2, @! & (22 (++2!/(52 +$"8!'!"#' ") #/"* (? / (#0 (22 (? !'':' ($!'!#3": ") &/&*@!225* (#0(#'@$0!#(//"$0(#/@! & 2(@

& ($#0 ":#'2 )"$ 3!"#(2 !$/ "$ "# !#' $:/ !"#' ") $ &(#0(#( : &:7 "!# !$/ "$ 3(2 !# & "))!/ ") & 3!"#(2 !$/ "$7!#!' $,")"$+"$( ))(!$'7 ' $# 3!"#7:*5(!' ( ' &( &,($'( !')!0@! & &:#0$ (;!#3'3!8#5, & ! !"#$' &(5"8:#0$ (;!#3'($(//+ 0

- $"* & *( $!(2 "# $/"$07 & /&* (++($' " 5 )(!$ (#0 $('"#(52 (#0 !' #" 8!"2( !8 ") (#, +$"8!'!"#' ") 2(@ (#0 !' #" /"# $($, "+:52!/+"2!/,

> !#/ (22 & $<:!'! ' ( : "$, /"*+2!(#/' &(8 5# ):2)!2207 "*+(#,/&* ! !"#"' "- ")

($*(0(5'"2:

!# $*' ") +$(,$' /2(:' D(E7 D5E (#0 D0E (#0 - ")

!' *(0 (5'"2: !# $*'")+$(,$/2(:''D(E(#0D0E

& ! !"#$"*+(#!' ")!2(/"+,") &!'"$0$(#0 &/&* 0:2, (: &# !/( 0 5, & "*+(#, 3!' $($7 !3& ":$ D E7 "*5(,7@! & &/"#/$#0:+$!# #0# ") (*+'7)"$ &+:$+"' ")(04:0!/( !"#")' (*+0: ,+(,(527 !)(#,7 "# &'(*@! &!# 0(,')$"* &0( ") & $0$

& ! !"#$'($0!$/ 0 ")!2(/$ !)!0/"+,")"$0$(2"#3@! &( /"+,") &/&*")*(23(*( !"#0:2,(*#00@! & &/"#/$#0

3!' $($ ") "*+(#!'7 2/ $"#!/(22,7 (2"#3 @! & "$* A 1 !# (00! !"# " +&,'!/(2 /"+, (' +$ & $28(# +$"8!'!"#' ") & "*+(#!'/ 7 % -@&!/&8$!'(++2!/(52

. & ! !"#$ "*+(#!' " +(, /"' ' ") ' 7%A (/& " &

3!"#(2 !$/ "$7 ' $# 3!"#7 :*5(! (#0 & ! !"#$ !# & "*+(#, /&* ! !"# "' " - ")

" +(, /"' ' ")

' 7%A " & ))!/!(2!<:!0( "$7!3&":$ 7"*5(,"' "5 +(!0@! &!#)":$@;')$"* &0( ") & $0$

1 !2!#3(#0!'':(#/") &0$(@#:+"$0$!'0!'+#'0@! &

22/"#/$#0$3:2( "$,(: &"$! !' "(/ "#(/"+,") &!'"$0$(2"#3 @! &*#00/&*0:2,(: &# !/( 05, &"*+(#, 3!' $($7 !3&":$ D E7"*5(, D9 &$!$(*7 E /$ !), &( &!' $0$:+2"(00!'( $:(#0/"$$/ /"+,")"$!3!#(2 '!3#0"$0$

+2"(005,=&(#;($(@07 #"3$(+&$