← Library
Bombay High CourtCSD/1005/2016disposed off

Ufo Moviez India Ltd v. ---

2016-12-09Hon'Ble Shri Justice S.C. Gupte7 pages



 

 

  

     

       !"

#$% *+ ,$%+ -$#"

.# / ")

 # $%0     !"

# $%  ) ( 1+ $ 1+2 "

 )   $ 1 $% ' ( ) +  # "3 4'

 $ '%' 3  )   $% ' ( ) * 1 "

3 $  # "&&5')"65  &#$7'('$ ( $% ' ( ) * +  8 10     !"

# $% ) !  $% ##"

$:

'9'

"5)# ; 3'"#'7"

'!'

3*   '5!( #'7"

 '!'

3* 3#'39  '!'

3 "

 

"5 '!'

3 "

3

$7' ;  3'" '!'

 '#

(& ) '7 "# $53 #(

 $7' ;  3'" '!'

3* " )$!&"

)$#&$#"

3 :

' ( ) +  "7'

9 '

( # 9'( # 3 $%%')  "

"5:"65   ) $ "#<* 5$  =18* $"3 - =>*"#$5* 3 #',-*:!6"'? 2+1*""#"( #"* 3'" -@&&5')"

. 

 

    # "A ("4'

#! 3:

"4"5"'86 "A ("B$* 37$)"

(%$#

 $#"!C:& " C+  ) !6 #*        "&&5')"

. "6$7  "! 3 6. " $!&"

:!!$ (%$#'# )  

# "A ("'

( #:) 36.

"A ( " B $* 37$)"

( %$#

.*   

   %%'3"7'

3"

31#3 ) $6 #* $%# "A ("94"

''(#" $%

.*'

(:&&$# $%$!&"

.:!!$ (%$#'# )

 D'6'

(  # '

# % ## 3 $*       !

 E:'

."# $53 #($%

.*6 )$ 3  53 "

 ! #"53 "55* F$'

$$# $

"5  3 #'/F:#5" $"3*  "9"#* 3 #'/"( *:!6"'/2+*$ #'3".*

:"#.*>"

 "! %$#   &:#&$(  $% )$ ('3 #'

3* '% $:9  %'

* "&&#$7'

9* 4'

 $# 4'

 !$3'%')"

,(-*   &#$&$( 3 ) !  $% ##"

 6 $:

 '9'

"5)# ;  3'"#'7"

'!'

3* '5!(#'7"

'!'

3* 3#'39 '!'

3*



"5'!'

$7' ; 3'"'!'

 '## (& ) '7 ("# $53 #(,  G) ! H-   5 "( )5 "#3".(6 %$#   ("'3!

 E:'

."# $53 #($%

. $6  53"("%$# ("'3*" ') )$  ("'3   &5") *3".*3"

'! "%$# ("'3* $9  #4'

")$&.$% ) ! * " )$&. $%   D&5"

$#. 

 # E:'# 3 $ 6  (

 :

 )  1+1 $% ' ( ) * +  $# )$## (&$ 3'

9 &#$7'('$ ( $% ' ( ) * 1 "

  &# ()#'6 3 $#! $% #$D.* ("55 6  (

 6.

# 3$( 8& 3$( 8$:#' # $ ")$%  E:'

."# $53 #($% 

."

 '## (& ) '7 # 9'( # 3$#5"( < $4 "33# (( ( $# #$:9 !"'5 , $(  ("# $53 #( 4$(  !"'5 "33# (( ( "#  3:5. # 9'( # 3 4'

. $# 4'

  3 &$('

$#' ( %$# &:#&$( $%# ) '7'

9(:) ') (6. !"'5-*"33# (( 3 $ ")$%  E:'

"# $53 #($%

.*"

 '#5"( < $4 "33# (($# !"'5 "33# (( ("(& #  # )$#3($%

.$#  3 &$('

$#' ( 1 "

5 "( )5 "#3".(6 %$#   E:'

."# $53 #($% &&5')"

$ 6   53 "( "%$# ("'3* " ')  )$   ("'3 9* '

3')"

  3".*   3"

  &5")  "

'!  $% !

9 "( "%$# ("'3 6  &:65'( 3* (  )$&' ( $%   ) !  "

  (

# E:'# 3 $6 %:# '( 3&:#(:"

$ ) 1+1$% *+ ,I  ) J-$#)$## (&$ 3'

9&#$7'('$ ($%$!&"

*1"

$#! $% #$D. )"

 6  $6 "'

3 %#  $% )"#9  "

# 3 %%')  $% &&5')"

. "( "%$# ("'3 "

38$# "

  $%%')  $% '

( 37$)"

( 8(

"A ("B$* * #'

"5:'53'

9*1*"9'

3"("( # $"3* 5$#"

"'

* :!6"' ? 2 * '

4$ 5$)"5 4(&"& #( '  G #  # ((

$:# "5H'

 95'(5"

9:"9 "

#"

(5"

 # $%'

G"7("< 'H'

"#"

' 5"

9:"9 *6$ )'#):5"

:!6"' 2 :65')"

 $% $ ')  $%  9 $%   E:'

. "# $53 #( '

$7 #

";

'(3'(& ( 34'

  (

5'

3"&&#$7'

 %$#!$%"37 # '( !

*%$#!$%&#$D.* %$#!$% ') *   D&5"

$#.

# E:'# 3 $6 %:# '( 3&:#(:"

 ) 1+1$%  ) $"))$!&"

') *6. #"#$%

'($:# '(3'(& ( 34'

 &&5')"

.:

3 # "< ( $C ' '((: $ ') )$ 9!

  E:'

.("# $53 #("(& # $#!$ , :5 >1$%$!&"

' (,$:# :5 (*++- '' '((:  D&5"

$#. 

 )$

"'

9 "55   &"# '):5"#( "( & #  ) 1+1$% *+ 0 

''' '((:  $#!$%#$D."(& # $#!$1>, :5 >1$%$!&"

' (,$:#

:5 (*++-"

'7 "37 # '(   $ ')  )$ 9!

9 "( & # $#!$1K, :5 >2$% ' (,$:# :5 (*++-  ("'3:

3 # "<'

9("# ")) & 3

 #"

A 79"*"'#!"

$%

.*"

3%"'5'

9'!*# "

A"."'<4"3*"

"9'

9 '# ) $# $%

.* "

3 %"'5'

'!*#F"&'59"#4"5* $'

"

"9'

9'# ) $#$%

.* 3 %"'5'

9 '!* # ! ."  * '# ) $# $%

.* "

%"'5'

9 '!* ( .

 3  $:;"* '# ) $# $%

.* "

%"'5'

9 ##"3"7"

*'# ) $#$%

.*"

3%"'5'

'!# ""A"F"

4"#*'# ) $#$%

.*"

3%"'5'

9'! #"#:

":5*'# ) $#$%

.("556   "'#!"

$%

  "%$# ("'3  $ 6   53 "

 ! #"53 "55* F$'

$$# $

"5  3 #'/F:#5" $"3*  "9"#*  3 #'/ "( * :!6"'/ 2+* $  

:"#.*>"

"!$#"

."3A$:#

$#"3A$:#

(  # $% >  "'#!"

"&&$'

3%$#  "%$# ("'3 $'((:   "37 # '( !

3( 3$:

') ($%   9# % ## 3 $"6$7  ("'3"'#!"

("55 "7  "55 &$4 #( "( & #   # ')5 ( $% (($)'"

. "

3 "5($ :

' ( ,$:# :5 (* ++ ,$# "

. # /

")

 # $%:&$  %% ) '7 (($%$!&"

*1-'

# 5"

 )$ 3:) $% 9,(-*'

)5:3'

9%$#3 )'3'

9&#$) 3:#"5E: ( ( !". "#'(  $# "

 "

. "3A$:#

 # $% $# "

. $  # !"

# '

)5:3'

"!

3!

  ) !  $# # ($5:

*'%"

.* &#$&$( 3"

  !

96. .& #($ ,(-"

$"() # "'

 3 )'('$ $%  ( ( $% 96." &$55 

K  E:$#:!%$#  "%$# ("'3!

 E:'

."# $53 #(("556 "( &# ()#'6 3:

3 # ) 1$% *1 +  7$ 96.&#$D.$#":

$#'( 3# &# (

'7 '

)"( $%6$3.)$#&$#"

6  & #!'

3* &#$7'3 3  " &#$D. '

  &# ()#'6 3 %$#!8 ":

$#'("

 3:5. ('9 36.  & #($

5 3 $"

37$ 9*'(%'5 34'

&&5')"

. "

 '

( # 3 %%')  "

 "5:"65   ) $ "#<* 5$ =18* $"3=>*"#$5* 3 #',-*:!6"'?2+1*""#"( #"*

5"

# *2K$:#(6 %$#   "%$# ("'3!

9"(# E:'# 3:

:5 > $%$!&"

' (,$:# :5 (*++  7"5: "

:!6 #$%  ("# ($% ")! !6 #("556 '

"))$#3"

)  4'

 6$$<(8# 9'( #$%

.$#3 &$('

$#' (# )$#3("

4 # 

#' ('

 6$$<(8# 9'( #83 &$('

$#' (# )$#3("# 3'(&:

3* "'#!"

   9 ("55 3 #!'

  7"5:  %$#   &:#&$(  $% "%$# ("'3!

3'(3 )'('$ '

6 "5%4$:536 %'

"5  "'#!"

$%'5 "

"%%'3"7'

5 (( ( 7 3".(6 %$#   3"

%'D 3 %$#   $53'

9 $%   !

3 3$ # &$# '( $:#   3'# ) # 9"#3'

 '((: $% ') ("

 "37 # '( !

"7 6 3:5.)$!&5' 3 4'

  "'#!"

$# &$# '($:#  # (:5 $%  "%$# ("'3!

94'

13".($%  )$ )5:('$ $% 9*"

 ("'3# &$# ("556 7 #'%' 3 6.'(%%'3"7'

1  )$ 3 $53'

9 $%   !

9 $%    ):# 3 # 3'

$#( $% &&5')"

.* %$#   &:#&$(  $% )$ ('3 #'

3* '% $:9  %'

"&&#$7'

9* 4'

 $# 4'

 !$3'%')"

,(-*   &#$&$( 3 ) !  $% ##"

 6  $:

 '9'

"5 )# ;  3'" #'7"

 '!'

3*  

'5!(#'7"

'!'

3*3#'39 '!'



"5'!'

3*"

$7' ; 3'"'!'

 '## (& ) '7 ("# $53 #(,  G) ! H- '( 3'(& ( 3 4'

 '

 7' 4 $%   "7 #!

 !"3  '

 &"#"9#"& 2K $% "%%'3"7'

 '

 (:&&$# . :!!$ ( %$# '# )  "



&&5')"

.:

3 # "< ( $'((: '

3'7'3:"5 ') $%   "#'

  6. # 3 $(  8'# !"'5 $ "55  ):# 3 # 3'

$#( "

:

3 # "< ( $ &:65'(   ("!  '

 $  '((:  ") $% " 3"'5. 4(&"& # 7'; #  # (( $:# "5H* '

  95'( 5"

9:"9  "

#"

(5"

 # $% '

G"7("< 'H* '

 "#"

' 5"

9:"9  "7'

9 )'#):5"

 '

 :!6"'   :

3 # "<'

9'(")) & 3 2 )$ 3$53'

( ):# 3# 3'

$#($% &&5')"

.* %$#   &:#&$(  $% )$ ('3 #'

3* '% $:9  %'

"&&#$7'

9* 4'

 $# 4'

 !$3'%')"

,(-*   &#$&$( 3 ) !  $% ##"

6 $:

'9'

"5)# ; 3'"#'7"

'!'

3

'5!( #'7"

 '!'

3 "

3 3#'39  '!'

3 "

 

"5 '!'

3*

 $7' ;  3'" '!'

3 '( 3'(& ( 3 4'

 '

 7' 4 $%   "7 #!

!"3 '

&"#"9#"&2+$%  "%%'3"7'

'

(:&&$# $% .:!!$ (%$# '# )  "

. :

3 # "< ( $ '((:  '

3'7'3:"5

') $%   "#'

  6. # 3$( 8'#!"'5 $"55 :

( ):# 3 # 3'

$#( "7'

9 $:

( 3'

9 6"5"

)  $% ( *8/  "

3 "6$7  3:

3 # "< ( $&:65'(  ("! '

$ '((:  ")$%"3"'5. 4(&"& #7'; #  # (( $:# "5H* '

  95'( 5"

9:"9  "

#"

(5"

 # $% '

G"7("< 'H* '

 "#"

' 5"

9:"9  "7'

9 )'#):5"

 '

 :!6"'   :

3 # "<'

9'(")) & 3 :#(:"

 5":( "

35":( $%  ) ! $%##"

  "3A:(

8 # 3:) * '% "

. $%   ):#'

' (# !':! ))$:

#"

(% #  ,'

)5:3'

( ):#'

' ( &# !':! &:#(:"

"!"59"!"

- ("55 6  %% ) 3 "( "

 '

9#"5 &"#   ) !  '

( 5% '

"))$#3"

) 4'

 &#$7'('$ ($% ) *"

31$% ' ( ) * +  "

'%' 3 ( )   $% ' ( ) * 1 $% &&5')"

.*   ("'3 # 3:)    ):#'

' (# !':! 3$ ( 7$57  '

 # 3'!'

:

 $% 5'"6'5'

. '

 # (& )  $% :

&"'3 ("#  )"&'

"5 $# &".!

$"

.("# $53 #$%&"'3/:&("# )"&'

"5 &&5')"

:

3 # "< ( $&"(("& )'"5 ($5:

%$#  &#$&$( 3# 3:)

D 

")$&.$%(& )'"5# ($5:

.) !  3'

7' 4$% "6$7 &#$) 3:# &# ()#'6 3:

3 #( ) ,-$% *+ 3 ) "

3$  #"&&5')"65 &#$7'('$ ($% *1 )$ %'#!'

9# 3:) $% ):#'

' (# !':!'(3'(& ( 34'

 ,:& -    

     

  

  

 

     



     !" #