Kitchen Grace (India) Private Limited v. 0




 


 


 







  

     
    



 

 
 !

"


 #$%$%&'#()$*#(+',-#(&(&./+'0 







  
 



 


 
 

  
 
























 !






"  


#



  
 

 





 

  
 
























 !






"  

  

$%&'
()'
* !+
),%'
-.%'!


%   
  /
0

"-''$
 %') %1 -
),%'
-.%'!


%   
  /

 





+11#2-&(*#+(%'3 ( +4#,**+*%)5 +4#,**+*6&728&9+$#-&($*##$%$%&'#( ( +,$#(%)5(',+(%-&( #3%&'+1%(#9$&( (%'&2*+(.+7 --%9%+1%:;%2+$&(7/(#,#'$  <  *(%(+.7  < $* #5(;+(07

<

#+(2#+('#2&;',#1-&($*#/+($0&&54#9$&(*+,9&.#5#-&(#$*# 9&;($ $& &//&,# $*# 9*#.# +'2 '&( +'0 /+($0 *+, 9&'$(&8#($#2 +'0 +8#(.#'$,.+2#%'$*##$%$%&' 
*#,+'9$%&'&-$*#&;($%,,&;3*$$&+9*#.#&-.+13+.+$%&'&-
 !

"


7$*#(+',-#(&(&./+'0=%$*  
 
 
 

7 $*# (+',-#(## &./+'07 ;'2#( #9$%&',>?

$& >?@ +'2 &$*#((#1#8+'$/(&8%,%&'&-$*#&./+'%#, 9$7 > >
*##+('#2&;',#1-&($*##$%$%&'#(,$+$#,$*+$$*#(+',-#(&( &./+'0 *+, 5##' 9+((0%'3 &' $*# 5;,%'#,, &- 2#,%3'%'37 2#8#1&/.#'$7 .+';-+9$;(#7 /(&9#,,%'37 +9:;%(%'37 5;0%'37 ,#11%'37 %./&($7 #A/&($7 ,$&9B%'372%,$(%5;$%'37+'2)&(2#+1%'3&$*#(=%,#%'+11B%'2,+'28+(%#$%#,&- B%$9*#' -;('%$;(# +'2 &$*#( -;('%$;(# +'2 $*#%( +99#,,&(%#,)9&./&'#'$, +'2 $*# (+',-#(## &./+'0 *+, 5##' 9+((0%'3 &' $*# 5;,%'#,, &- 2#,%3'%'37 2#8#1&/.#'$7 +,,#.5107 .+';-+9$;(#7 /(&9#,,%'37 +9:;%(%'37 




%',$+11%'37(#/+%(75;0%'37,#11%'37%./&($7#A/&($72%,$(%5;$%'37.+%'$+%'%'37 +-$#( ,+1#, ,#(8%9# +'2)&(  2#+1%'3 &$*#(=%,# %' +11 B%'2, +'2 8+(%#$%#, &- &2;1+( %$9*#'

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

$*#0+(#9+/%$+1%C%'3&'#+9*&$*#(,9&(#9&./#$#'90+'2(#,&;(9#,=*%9*%, #A/#9$#2 $& (#,;1$ %' ,$+5%1%$0 &- &/#(+$%&',7  9&,$ ,+8%'3, +'2 *%3*#( /(&-%$+5%1%$0 1#8#1, -&( $*# .+13+.+$#2 &./+'0 +'2 $*+$ $*# (+',-#(&( &./+'0%,+=*&110&='#2,;5,%2%+(0&-$*#(+',-#(##&./+'0+'2$*+$ $*# ,*+(#*&12#(, =&;12 9&',&1%2+$# $*#%( *&12%'3, +'2 1#8#(+3# $*# ,*+(# 8+1;#9&',#:;#'$$&*%3*#(/(&-%$+5%1%$0 @
#+('#2 &;',#1 -&( $*# #$%$%&'#( -;($*#( ,$+$#, $*+$ ,%'9# $*# #$%$%&'#(&./+'0%,+=*&110&='#2,;5,%2%+(0&-$*#(+',-#(##&./+'0 +'2 +11 $*# ,*+(#, &- $*# #$%$%&'#( &./+'0 +(# /(#,#'$10 *#12 50 $*# (+',-#(## &./+'07 "-''$
 %') %1 -
),%'
-.%'! +1&'3 =%$*%$,'&.%'##,+'2+-$#($*#9*#.

#5#%'3,+'9$%&'#27'&'#=,*+(#,+(# (#:;%(#2 $& 5# %,,;#2 $& $*# .#.5#(, &- $*# #$%$%&'#( &./+'0 50 $*# (+',-#(## &./+'0 +'2 $*#(# =&;12 5# '& (#&(3+'%C+$%&' &- $*# *+(# +/%$+1%'$*#(+',-#(##&./+'0+'2+1,&%'8%#=&-$*#4;23.#'$&-$*%, &;($ %' +*++.5+
'8#,$.#'$, %.%$#2 #(,;,

 %.%$#2 ! "  &./+'0+,#,7-%1%'3&-+,#/+(+$#&./+'0;..&',-&(%(#9$%&'+'2 &./+'09*#.##$%$%&'50"-''$
 %') %1 -
),%'
-.%'!7 $*#(+',-#(##&.

&-  
#+('#2 &;',#1 -&( $*# #$%$%&'#( -;($*#( ,$+$#, $*+$ $*# &+(2 &- %(#9$&(, &- $*# #$%$%&'#( &./+'0 *+8# +//(&8#2 $*# ,+%2 9*#.# &- 




.+13+.+$%&'+'250/+,,%'3&+(2 #,&1;$%&',=*%9*+(#+''#A#2$&$*# &./+'09*#.##$%$%&'

*##+('#2&;',#1-&($*##$%$%&'#(-;($*#(,$+$#,$*+$7#$%$%&'#( &./+'0 *+8# 9&./1%#2 =%$* +11 $*# 2%(#9$%&', /+,,#2 %' $*# &./+'0 ;..&',-&(%(#9$%&'+'2$*+$$*#&./+'09*#.##$%$%&'*+8#5##' -%1#2 %' 9&',&'+'9# =%$* $*# &(2#( /+,,#2 %' &./+'0 ;..&', -&( %(#9$%&' *# #+('#2 &;',#1 +//#+(%'3 &' 5#*+1- &- $*# #$%$%&'#(, *+8# ,$+$#2$*+$$*##$%$%&'#(&./+'0*+8#9&./1%#2=%$*+11(#:;%(#.#'$,+, /#( 2%(#9$%&', &- $*%, &;($ +'2 $*#0 *+8# -%1#2 '#9#,,+(0 +--%2+8%$ &- 9&./1%+'9# %' $*# &;($ &(#&8#(7 $*# #$%$%&'#( &./+'0 ;'2#($+B# $& 9&./10 =%$* +11 ,$+$;$&(0 (#:;%(#.#'$, %- +'07 +, (#:;%(#2 ;'2#( $*# &./+'%#,9$7 ? ) > +'2 (;1#, .+2# $*#(# ;'2#( =*%9*#8#( %, +//1%9+51#*#,+%2;'2#($+B%'3%,+99#/$#2 
*# --%9%+1%:;%2+$&(*+,-%1#2*%, (#/&($&' ,$2+0 &- #9#.5#(7 

%'&./+'09*#.##$%$%&',$+$%'3$*+$$*#+--+%(,&-$*##$%$%&'#( &./+'0*+,5##'9&'2;9$#2%'+/(&/#(.+''#(+'2$*+$ $*##$%$%&'#( &./+'0.+05#&(2#(#2$&5#2%,,&18#2 ?
*# #3%&'+1 %(#9$&( *+, -%1#2 +' --%2+8%$ &' @$* 2+0 &- +';+(07 

,$+$%'3$*#(#%'7,+8#+'2#A9#/$+,,$+$#2%'/+(+3(+/* 7%$+//#+(, 




$*+$$*#9*#.#%,'&$/(#4;2%9%+1$&$*#%'$#(#,$&-,*+(#*&12#(,+'2/;51%9
'/+(+3(+/* &-$*#,+%2--%2+8%$7$*# #3%&'+1%(#9$&(*+,,$+$#2$*+$<D
  

                              

 

     



      

!   

   

      "        # 

               

  



   

       

 

   

     


&-+(+,$*#&5,#(8+$%&'%'/+(+3(+/* &-$*#--%2+8%$&- #3%&'+1 %(#9$&( %, 9&'9#('#27 $*# #+('#2 &;',#1 -&( $*# #$%$%&'#( &./+'0 ,;5.%$$*+$$*##$%$%&'#(&./+'0+(#5&;'2$&9&./10=%$*+11+//1%9+51# /(&8%,%&',&-
'9&.#+A9$+'2+11$+A%,,;#,+(%,%'3&;$&-$*#9*#.# =%115#.#$+'2+',=#(#2%'+99&(2+'9#=%$*1+=

*##+('#2&;',#1-&( #3%&'+1%(#9$&(&'%',$(;9$%&',&-( *+'2+'+;$*;7 &%'$%(#9$&(#3+1%'$*#&--%9#&-$*# #3%&'+1%(#9$&(7 %'%,$(0&-&(/&(+$#--+%(,7 #,$#(' #3%&'7;.5+%,$+$#,$*+$$*#0+(# ,+$%,-%#2 =%$* $*# ;'2#($+B%'3 3%8#' 50 $*# #$%$%&'#( *# +5&8# ;'2#($+B%'3,%,+99#/$#2



(&. $*# .+$#(%+1 &' (#9&(27 $*# 9*#.# +//#+(, $& 5# -+%( +'2 (#+,&'+51#+'2%,'&$8%&1+$%8#&-+'0/(&8%,%&',&-1+=+'2%,'&$9&'$(+(0$& /;51%9/&1%90 




>
%'9#+11 $*# (#:;%,%$# ,$+$;$&(0 9&./1%+'9#, *+8# 5##' -;1-%11#27 $*# &./+'09*#.##$%$%&'%,.+2#+5,&1;$#%'$#(.,&-/(+0#(,91+;,#!+"$& !2"

@
*# #$%$%&'#( &./+'0 $& -%1#+ 9&/0&- $*%, &(2#( +'2 $*# 9*#.# 2;10+;$*#'$%9+$#250$*#&./+'0 #3%,$(+(7%3*&;($! "7&.5+07 =%$* $*# 9&'9#('#2 ;/#(%'$#'2#'$ &- $+./,7 -&( $*# /;(/&,# &- +24;2%9+$%&'&-,$+./2;$0/+0+51#7%-+'07&'$*#,+.#=%$*%' 2+0,-(&. $*#2+$#&-$*# (2#(


*##$%$%&'#(,+(#2%(#9$#2$&-%1#+9#($%-%#29&/0&-&(2#(+1&'3=%$*+ 9&/0 &- $*# 9*#.# &- .+13+.+$%&' =%$* $*# 9&'9#('#2 #3%,$(+( &- &./+'%#,7#1#9$(&'%9+1107+1&'3=%$* &(.
D%'+22%$%&'$&/*0,%9+1 9&/0 +, /#( $*# (#1#8+'$ /(&8%,%&', &- $*# &./+'%#, 9$7 ? ) > =*%9*#8#(%,+//1%9+51#

*# #$%$%&'#( &./+'0 $& /+0 9&,$, &- , 7)D #+9* $& $*#

#3%&'+1%(#9$&(7 #,$#(' #3%&'7;.5+%+'2$*# --%9%+1%:;%2+$&(7%3* &;($7 &.5+0 &,$ $& 5# /+%2 =%$*%' -&;( =##B, -(&. $*# 2+$# &- $*# (2#(

%1%'3+'2%,,;+'9#&-$*#2(+=';/&(2#(%,2%,/#',#2=%$* 





11 9&'9#('#2 (#3;1+$&(0 +;$*&(%$%#, $& +9$ &' + 9&/0 &- $*%, &(2#( +1&'3 =%$* 9*#.# 2;10 +;$*#'$%9+$#2 50 $*# &./+'0 #3%,$(+(7 %3* &;($! "7&.5+0 !  *(%(+.7 " ')%2%'

 /


1 
3



3
 



/

  
 
  4

5
6/
7
"

 8
(0
"

    4