← Library
Bombay High CourtITXA/748/2020disposed off

Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax 19 Mumbai v. Jitendra Jugraj Bokadia

2022-03-29Hon'Ble Shri Justice K.R. Shriram,Hon'Ble Shri Justice N. R. Borkar20 pages

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2211 OF 2019 JAYVEER STEEL INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.892 OF 2020 RAKESH RASIKLAL PATEL INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.353 OF 2020 VISHAL DHANDHIA HUF AVK 1/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.636 OF 2022 RIGHT IMPEX INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.747 OF 2020 AJIT METAL SYNDICATE INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.736 OF 2020 ALLWYN METALS AVK 2/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.734 OF 2020 AJIT METAL SYNDICATE INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.731 OF 2020 ALLWYN METALS INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.724 OF 2020 ALLWYN METALS AVK 3/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.3199 OF 2018 ALPESH DEVICHAND MEHTA INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.86 OF 2019 ALPESH DEVALCHAND MEHTA INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.1148 OF 2019 ALPESH DEVALCHAND MEHTA AVK 4/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2629 OF 2019 RAJENDRA MADHANI INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.3293 OF 2019 VINIT RAMNIKLAL DEHIA INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.746 OF 2020 JAYVEER STEEL AVK 5/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.917 OF 2020 JAYVEER STEEL INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.1514 OF 2019 RISHAB STEEL HOUSE INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2798 OF 2019 MANGILAL K. DOSHI AVK 6/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.1166 OF 2020 SHANTILAL BACHRAJ CHANDAN INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2740 OF 2019 MOTILAL P. JAIN INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2741 OF 2019 ALLOYAAGE PRODUCT AVK 7/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.186 OF 2020 NAGINBHAI KHIMJI CHOUDHARY INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2799 OF 2019 SUPER TECH INDUSTRIES INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.700 OF 2020 NAGINBHAI KHIMJI CHOUDHARY AVK 8/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.992 OF 2020 CHANDAN DHINGADMAL JAIN INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.229 OF 2020 SOHANLAL BOHRA INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2795 OF 2019 MANOJKUMAR PARASMAL CHANDAN AVK 9/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2900 OF 2019 NAVDEEP METALS INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2792 OF 2019 VIJAY METAL CORPORATION INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2789 OF 2019 KIRTI MURLIDHAR MUNI AVK 10/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.2943 OF 2019 SOLHANLAL BOHRA INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.99 OF 2020 KIRTI MURLIDHAR MUNI INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.3103 OF 2019 BHAIRAV TUBE (INDIA) AVK 11/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.634 OF 2020 23 MUMBAI RAJU KISHINCHAND MAHTANI INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.3102 OF 2019 23 MUMBAI RAJU KISHINCHAND MAHTANI INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.1036 OF 2021 23 MUMBAI RAJU KISHINCHAND MAHTANI AVK 12/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.637 OF 2020 SAMARTHMAL H HSHA JAIN INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.108 OF 2020 HARESH JAYANTILAL PAREKH INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.105 OF 2020 CHUNILAL R SHAH AVK 13/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.1354 OF 2020 SUPREME STEEL IMPEX INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.3283 OF 2019 NILESH S DOSHI INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.748 OF 2020 JITENDRA JUGRAJ BOKADIA AVK 14/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.1189 OF 2020 BHURARAM VIRDAJI CHOUDHARY INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.3296 OF 2019 ARVIND MANRUPCHAND SHAH INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.3310 OF 2019 BHURARAM VIRDAJI CHOUDHARY AVK 15/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.3134 OF 2019 V/S.

JITENDRA JUGRAJ BOKADIA INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.909 OF 2020 V/S.

JITENDRA JUGRAJ BOKADIA INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.134 OF 2021 23 MUMBAI V/S.

CHETAN P. CHITALIA AVK 16/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.3301 OF 2019 23 MUMBAI V/S.

CHETAN P. CHITALIA INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.924 OF 2020 V/S.

VIRMABHAI A PATEL INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.749 OF 2020 V/S.

MUKESH C SANGHVI AVK 17/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.854 OF 2022 V/S.

RACHNA CARD COLLECTION INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.184 OF 2020 V/S.

ISHRARAM G CHOUDHARY INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.874 OF 2019 V/S.

BABULAL U MUNOT AVK 18/20

INCOME TAX APPEAL NO.1160 OF 2019 V/S.

WAMAN HARI PETHE JEWELLERS Mr.Sham Walve, Advocate for the Appellant in all Appeals. Ms.Radha Halbe a/w. Mr.Devendra Jain, Advocate for the Respondent in ITXA-2741-2019.

Ms.Hetal Laghave a/w. Ms.Rutuja N. Pawar, Advocate for Respondent in ITXA-2795-2019 and ITXA-1514-2019. Mr.Ankit Rajput a/w. R. Bhatt, Advocate for Respondent in ITXA720-2020 AND ITXA-747-2020. Mr.B.V.Jhaveri, Advocate for Respondent in ITXA-1160-2019. Mr.Jitendra Singh a/w. Ms.Neha Paranjpe and Mr.Om Kandalkar, Advocate for Respondent in ITXA-134-2021 and ITXA 3301-2019.

CORAM

: K. R. SHRIRAM & N. R. BORKAR, JJ.

DATE : 29th MARCH 2022 P.C. :

Mr.Walve states that substantial questions of law proposed in these appeals are squarely covered by the orders passed by this AVK 19/20

Court in the cases of The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax17 vs. M/s. Mohommad Haji Adam & Co. 1 and Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Central-4 vs. M/s. Paramshakti Distributors Pvt. Ltd.

2, and therefore the appeals could be disposed.

Accordingly, all appeals disposed.

(N. R. BORKAR, J.) (K. R. SHRIRAM, J.) ARTI VILAS KHATATE by ARTI VILAS KHATATE Date: 2022.03.30 19:15:03 +0530 Income Tax Appeal No. 1004 of 2016 & Connected Appeals dated 11th February 2019 Income Tax Appeal No.413 of 2017, dated 15th July 2017 AVK 20/20