← Library
Bombay High CourtCSP/8/2016scheme sanctioned company

Ashok Piramal Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. v. -

2016-04-22Hon'Ble Shri Justice B.P. Colabawalla7 pages



 

 

  

            

   

   

          !"#"#$%!&'&(%)*!&$&$+,(%- (%.   /        

         

         !"#"#$%!&'&(%)*!&$&$+,(%- (%.           

    /    

         !"#"#$%!&'&(%)*!&$&$+,(%- (%.           

        

       !"#"#$%!&'&(%)*!&$&$+,(%- (%.           

    

  

        !"#"#$%!&'&(%)*!&$&$+,(%- (%. 

  0        

       

       !"#"#$%!&'&(%)*!&!!$+,(%- %"1!+(""!&$*"1!$+,(%#!)2"3/  4$*/ 56  % "1! +(""!& $*  !2"#$%) 0/ "$ 0/7 $* "1! $+,(%#!) 2"3 /   (%. $"1!& &!8!9(%" ,&$9#)#$%) $* $+,(%#!) 2"3 06  %"1!+(""!&$*21!+!$*+(8:(+("#$% $* )1$;#&(+(8%"!&,&#)!)&#9("!#+#"!. 4<=$&<"1!&(%)*!&$&$+,(%-=5 (%. &#.:!,$#%" !(&%#%: &#9("! #+#"!. 4<=$&<"1!&(%)*!&$&$+,(%-=5 (%. &$+>!88 $$8) 4%.#(5 &#9("! #+#"!. 4<=$&<"1!&(%)*!&$&$+,(%-0=5 (%. &$))&$(.) 1$,,!&"(#%+!%" &#9("! #+#"!. 4<= $& <"1! &(%)*!&$& $+,(%-7=5 (%. $&(&?!! $2@8.()   A   &#9("! #+#"!. 4<= $& <"1! &(%)*!&$& $+,(%- =5 >#"1  @"$ $+,$%!%") &#9("! #+#"!. 4"1!&(%)*!&!!$+,(%-5 (%. "1!#&&!),!2"#9!)1(&!1$8.!&)  

 !"#$  !#$% &  (?!)11(1#'B (?!)11(1A$ 3.9$2("!)*$&"1!!"#"#$%!&  &  #%$. 1(&+( **#2#(8 #C@#.("$& ,&!)!%" #% $+,(%- 21!+! !"#"#$%$ "$$*   

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

%")&#9("!#+#"!.(%."1!#&&!),!2"#9!)1(&!1$8.!&)   !(&%!. .9$2("! *$& "1! !"#"#$%!&) )"("!) "1(" "1! !"#"#$%!& $+,(%- )1$; #&(+(8 %"!&,&#)!) &#9("! #+#"!. 1(9! B!!% #%2$&,$&("!. *$& 2(&&-#%: $% "1! B@)#%!)) $* ,&$9#.#%: )@,,$&" )!&9#2!) #% "1! *#!8. $* (22$@%"#%:3 8!:(8 +(&"!%3 2$%)@8"(%2- )!&9#2!)3#%*$&+("#$%"!21%$8$:-3@)#%!)),&$2!))3$@")$@&2#%:A ,&$9#.#%: ())#)"(%2! #% B(2; $**#2! $,!&("#$% (%. "1! !"#"#$%!& $+,(%- &#.:!,$#%" !(&%#%: &#9("! #+#"!. 1(9! B!!% #%2$&,$&("!. *$& 2(&&-#%: $% "1! B@)#%!)) "$ B@#8.3 2$%)"&@2"3 .!9!8$,3,8(-)21$$83B$(&.#%:1$@)!3"!(21#%:28())!)*$&,&#+(&-3 )!2$%.(&-3 1#:1!& !.@2("#$% #%28@.#%: :&(.@("! ' ,$)" :&(.@("! 2$@&)!) #% +(%(:!+!%" (%. "!21%#2(8 *#!8.) (%. "1! !"#"#$%!& $+,(%- &$+>!

88 $$8) 4%.#(5 &#9("! #+#"!. 1(9! B!!% #%2$&,$&("!. *$& 2(&&-#%: $% "1! B@)#%!)) "$ +(%@*(2"@&!3 *(B&#2("!3 ,&$2!))3 ,&$.@2!3 *#%#)13 ())!+B8! B@-3 )!883 #+,$&"3 !F,$&"(%..!(8#%3#%28@.#%:.#)"&#B@"#$%$*(88"-,!)$*!%:#%!!&#%: "$$8)32@""#%:"$$8)32(8#B&("#$%!C@#,+!%"3+!()@&#%:#%)"&@+!

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

2"#$%),())!. #% $+,(%- @++$%) *$& #&!2"#$%) (%. "1(" "1! $+,(%- 21!+! !"#"#$%) 1(9! B!!% *#8!. #% 2$%)$%(%2! >#"1 "1! $&.!&) ,())!.#%&!),!2"#9!@++$%)*$&#&!

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

2"$& 1() *#8!. (% **#.(9#" $% /"1 (&213  )"("#%: "1!&!#%3 )(9! (%. !F2!," () )"("!. #% ,(&(:&(,1 3 #" (,,!(&) "1(" "1! )21!+! #) %$" ,&!?@.#2#(8 "$ "1! #%"!&!)" $* )1(&!1$8.!&)(%.,@B8#2  %,(&(:&(,1$*"1!)(#.(**#.(9#"#"#))"("!.



                                  

     

 

               

 ! 

          

                      

 ) *(& () "1! $B)!&9("#$%) #% ,(&(:&(,1  $* "1! (**#.(9#" $* "1!

!:#$%(8 #&!2"$& #) 2$%2!&%!.3 "1! ,!"#"#$%!&) "1&$@:1 "1!#& 2$@%)!8)@B+#")"1(""1!,!"#"#$%!&)(&!B$@%."$2$+,8->#"1(88 (,,8#2(B8!,&$9#)#$%)$*%2$+!(F2"3(%.(88"(F#))@!)(&#)#%: $@" $* 21!+! $* (+(8:(+("#$% >#88 B! +!" (%. (%)>!&!. #% (22$&.(%2!>#"18(> 

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

!:#$%(8 #&!2"$&3 !)"!&% !:#$%3@+B(#(%."1!!"#"#$%!&#% $+,(%-21!+!!"#"#$%$ "$$*"$,(-$)"$* )  3'H !(21 "$ "1! **#2#(8 #C@#.("$&3 #:1 $@&"3 $+B(-  $)")"$B!,(#.>#"1#%*$@&>!!;)*&$+"1!.("!$*"1!$&.!& 

 #8#%:(%.#))@(%2!$*"1!.&(>%@,$&.!&#).#),!%)!.>#"1   882$%2!&%!.&!:@8("$&-(@"1$&#"#!)"$(2"$%(2$,-$*"1#)$&.!& (8$%:>#"121!+!.@8-(@"1!%"#2("!.B-"1!$+,(%- !:#)"&(&3 #:1$@&"4  53$+B(-    4  $8(B(>(88(3 5  " 2!&"#*-"1(""1#) &.!&@,8$(.!.#)("&@!(%.2$&&!2"2$,-$*$&#:#%(8 )#:%!.$&.!& 

,8$(.!.B-EH1(%;(&(>.!3"!%$:&(,1!&