Rakesh Raghunath Pardeshi v. The Special Land Acquisition Officer,(L.S.K.) Buldhana And ANR

( 1 )

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD 902 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1588 OF 2024 RAJENDRA BHAGWAT JAISWAL AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1589 OF 2024 RAMCHANDRA FAKIRA KOLI FIRST APPEAL NO. 1592 OF 2024 VIJAY GANESH BASAIYE (TELI) FIRST APPEAL NO. 1590 OF 2024 VINODSING NAVALSING PATIL AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1591 OF 2024 VINOD BABURAO RODIYE 903 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6448 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17700/2024 VIJAY VINAYAK MAHAJAN FIRST APPEAL NO. 1533 OF 2024

( 2 ) KUSUM SHRIRAM JAISWAL AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6452 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17692/2024 KUSUM SHRIRAM JAISWAL AND ANR THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, (L.S.K.) BULDHANA FIRST APPEAL NO. 1531 OF 2024 VIJAY VINAYAK MAHAJAN AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1532 OF 2024 BHOJRAJ TOTARAM CHAVAN AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1529 OF 2024 FULCHAND GOBRA RATHOD AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6451 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17710/2024 BHOJRAJ TOTARAM CHAVAN CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6446 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17711/2024 FULCHAND GOBRA RATHOD AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1547 OF 2024

( 3 ) DATTU DHANU PATIL AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1535 OF 2024 SANJAY SHANKAR KAUSHLYA AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6454 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17729/2024 SANJAY SHANKAR KAUSHLYA AND ANR THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER,(L.S.K) BULDHANA AND ORS CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6470 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17733/2024 DATTU DHANU PATIL FIRST APPEAL NO. 1534 OF 2024 RATNAKAR RAJARAM CHAUDHARI AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6453 OF 2024 IN FA/1534/2024 RATNAKAR RAJARAM CHAUDHARI FIRST APPEAL NO. 1557 OF 2024 RAJENDRA BHOJRAJ CHAVAN AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6488 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17814/2024

( 4 ) RAJENDRA BHOJRAJ CHAVAN AND ANR 904 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6457 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17718/2024 ALKESH RAGHUNATH PARDESHI AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1536 OF 2024 ALKESH RAGHUNATH PARDESHI AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1539 OF 2024 MANGAN RAMESH PARDESHI AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6460 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17739/2024 MANGAN RAMESH PARDESHI AND ANR THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER,(L.S.K) BULDHANA AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1541 OF 2024 NALINI DEVIDAS CHUDHARI AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1540 OF 2024 GOKUL ONKAR CHAVAN AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6461 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17749/2024 GOKUL ONKAR CHAVAN

( 5 ) CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6462 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17750/2024 NALINI DEVIDAS CHUDHARI AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1542 OF 2024 PRATIBHA RAJENDRA CHAUDHARI AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1537 OF 2024 PAPILA RAMDAS PATIL AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6463 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17760/2024 PRATIBHA RAJENDRA CHAUDHARI CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6458 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17757/2024 PAPILA RAMDAS PATIL AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1543 OF 2024 PRAKASH VITTHAL MAHAJAN AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6466 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17773/2024 PRAKASH VITTHAL MAHAJAN AND ANR

( 6 ) FIRST APPEAL NO. 1548 OF 2024 RAKESH RAGHUNATH PARDESHI AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6474 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17779/2024 RAKESH RAGHUNATH PARDESHI 905 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6467 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17770/2024 PRALHAD SHYAMU MAHAJAN FIRST APPEAL NO. 1530 OF 2024 KAHNYALAL SUKHALAL JAISWAL AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6447 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17701/2024 KANHAIYALAL SUKHALAL JAISWAL THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, (L.S.K.) BULDHANA FIRST APPEAL NO. 1545 OF 2024 PUSHPBAI SURESH CHAUDHARI AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6468 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17763/2024 PUSHPBAI SURESH CHAUDHARI AND ANR

( 7 ) FIRST APPEAL NO. 1544 OF 2024 PRALHAD SHYAMU MAHAJAN AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1552 OF 2024 MOHANSING GOTUSING NAIK AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6480 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17794/2024 MOHANSING GOTUSING NAIK AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1553 OF 2024 PRAVIN GOPAL CHAUDHARI AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1554 OF 2024 PRAKASH SHANKAR CHAVAN AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6483 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17802/2024 PRAKASH SHANKAR CHAVAN CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6481 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17803/2024 PRAVIN GOPAL CHAUDHARI AND ANR

( 8 ) FIRST APPEAL NO. 1556 OF 2024 KISHOR JAGNNATH TURRE AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6486 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17813/2024 KISHOR JAGNNATH TURRE 906 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6479 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17784/2024 EKNATH RATAN PAWAR AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1551 OF 2024 EKNATH RATAN PAWAR AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1550 OF 2024 GOPAL ONKAR CHAVAN AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6478 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17787/2024 GOPAL ONKAR CHAVAN AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1549 OF 2024 ASHOK JAGANNATH TURRE AND ANR

( 9 ) CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6477 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17791/2024 ASHOK JAGANNATH TURRE AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1559 OF 2024 BABULAL MANNU KHATIK AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1560 OF 2024 SUMALA RAMESHCHANDR JAISWAL AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6493 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17822/2024 BABULAL MANNU KHATIK CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6494 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17824/2024 SUMALA RAMESHCHANDR JAISWAL AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1564 OF 2024 MANOJ SHANKAR KAUSHYALE AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6501 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17834/2024 MANOJ SHANKAR KAUSHYALE

( 10 ) FIRST APPEAL NO. 1601 OF 2024 UMRAO KESHAO PATIL AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6731 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17932/2024 UMRAO KESHAO PATIL DIED THR. LRS BHARATSING U. PATIL AND ORS FIRST APPEAL NO. 1600 OF 2024 VASANT BABURAO PATIL AND ANR X-OBJECTION NO. 163 OF 2024 IN FA/1600/2024 VASANT BABURAO PATIL THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THROUGH DISTRICT COLLECTOR BULDHANA AND ORS CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 9275 OF 2024 IN X-OBJ/163/2024 VASANT BABURAO PATIL THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THROUGH DISTRICT COLLECTOR BULDHANA AND ORS 907 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6504 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17840/2024 VIJAYKUMAR MOTILAL KHIWASARA AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1538 OF 2024 MOHANISH NARENDRA PATIL AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6459 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17720/2024 MOHANISH NARENDRA PATIL AND ANR

( 11 ) FIRST APPEAL NO. 1561 OF 2024 ARUN SHANKAR CHAVAN AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6495 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17827/2024 ARUN SHANKAR CHAVAN FIRST APPEAL NO. 1563 OF 2024 RAJKUMAR MOTILAL KHIWASARA AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6500 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17835/2024 RAJKUMAR MOTILAL KHIWASARA AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1566 OF 2024 VIJAYKUMAR MOTILAL KHIWASARA AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1595 OF 2024 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (M.I.W.) JALGAON.

RAMDAS UKHA PATIL AND ORS CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6720 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17907/2024 RAMDAS UKHA PATIL THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THROUGH DISTRICT COLLECTOR BULDHANA AND ORS

( 12 ) FIRST APPEAL NO. 1603 OF 2024 SUNIL VASANT PATIL AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6734 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17956/2024 SUNIL VASANT PATIL AND ANR 908 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 9282 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17858/2024 ONKAR TOTARAM CHAVAN FIRST APPEAL NO. 1555 OF 2024 MADHUKAR RAJARAM CHAUDHARI AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6485 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17809/2024 MADHUKAR RAJARAM CHAUDHARI FIRST APPEAL NO. 1568 OF 2024 NARAYAN BABURAO CHAUDHARI AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6512 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17844/2024 NARAYAN BABURAO CHAUDHARI

( 13 ) FIRST APPEAL NO. 1570 OF 2024 DEVENDRA SURESH PARDESHI AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6517 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17848/2024 DEVENDRA SURESH PARDESHI FIRST APPEAL NO. 1571 OF 2024 SUBHASH BABURAO PATIL AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1572 OF 2024 RAJESH SURESH PARDESHI AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6518 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17853/2024 SUBHASH BABURAO PATIL AND ANR CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6521 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17855/2024 RAJESH SURESH PARDESHI FIRST APPEAL NO. 1573 OF 2024

( 14 ) ONKAR TOTARAM CHAVAN AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1598 OF 2024 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (M.I.W.) JALGAON.

VISHWANATH GANU PATIL AND ORS CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6723 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17892/2024 VISHWANATH GANU PATIL THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THROUGH DISTRICT COLLECTOR BULDHANA AND ORS FIRST APPEAL NO. 1599 OF 2024 TAPI PATBANDHARE VIKAS KHORE MAHAMANDAL, JALGAON THROUGH THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, L.P.V., JALGAON SHRIRAM TUKARAM MAHAJAN AND ORS CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 6725 OF 2024 IN X-OBJST/17917/2024 SHRIRAM TUKARAM MAHAJAN DIED THR LRS REKHA SHRIRAM MAHAJAN AND ORS THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THROUGH DISTRICT COLLECTOR BULDHANA AND ORS 909 X-OBJECTION NO. 134 OF 2024 IN FA/1567/2024 SUNIL BHAGAWN PATIL AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1546 OF 2024 RAJANI CHUDAMAN PATIL AND ANR X-OBJECTION NO. 132 OF 2024 IN FA/1546/2024 RAJANI CHUDAMAN PATIL AND ANR THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER,(L.S.K) BULDHANA AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1562 OF 2024

( 15 ) SANDIP GOPAL CHAUDHARI X-OBJECTION NO. 133 OF 2024 IN FA/1562/2024 SANDIP GOPAL CHAUDHARI FIRST APPEAL NO. 1567 OF 2024 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, (M.I.W.), JALGAON, TQ. AND DIST, JALGAON. SUNIL BHAGAWN PATIL AND ANR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1593 OF 2024 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, (M.I.W.) JALGAON BHASKAR PRALHAD PATIL AND ORS X-OBJECTION NO. 137 OF 2024 IN FA/1593/2024 BHASKAR PRALHAD PATIL AND ANR THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA THROUGH DISTRICT COLLECTOR BULDHANA AND ORS Mr.A.B. Kale, Advocate for the appellants.

Mr.V.V. Tarde and Ms. Manjusha S. Jagtap-Ware, Advocates for the Acquiring Body in the respective matters.

Mr.K.S. Patil, Mr. K.B. Jadhavar, Mr. P.D. Patil, Mr. V.S. Badakh, Mr. R.K. Ingole, Mr. K.S. Patil, Mr. K.B. Jadhavar, Mr. P.D. Patil, AGPs for the respondent-State and its authorities in the respective matters.

CORAM

: KISHORE C. SANT, J.

DATE : 18.10.2024 PC :- 01.

All these matters are arising out of acquisition proceedings

( 16 ) bearing No. LAQ/SR-No.47/04 acquired by S.L.A.O., Minor Irrigation Scheme Sur, Tal.. Jamner, Dist. Jalgaon. The parties have produced on record copy of order passed in Lokadalat dated 14.12.2019 in First Appeal No. 3614 of 2019 along with other connected appeals arising out of the same acquisition proceedings, wherein the appellant-acquiring body has accepted the award. The claimants have also accepted the award. All the parties have accepted the rate given by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Jalgaon in LAR No. 323 of 2008. Cross-objections filed by the claimants have been disposed off. The order passed in First Appeal No.3614 of 2019 and connected matters in Lokadalat dated 14.12.2019 is taken on record and marked "X". Copy of judgment passed by the Reference Court dated 29.04.2015 is also taken on record and marked "X-1".

02.

In view of above, the acquiring body does not wish to proceed with the appeals. Even original claimants also do not wish to continue with the cross-objections.

03.

Therefore, all these appeals and cross-objections stand disposed off. Pending civil applications also stand disposed off.

( 17 ) 04.

The parties shall be entitled to get refund of Court Fees as per rules.

05.

Decree be drawn in terms of order passed in First Appeal No. 3614 of 2019 with connected matters in Lokadalat on 14.12.2019. [KISHORE C. SANT, J.] snk/2024/oct24/fa1588.24