Executive Engineer Nandur Madhameshwar Canal Division Vaijapur v. Shama Ananda Gore And Others

-1IN THE NATIONAL LOK ADALAT PRESIDED OVER BY HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE V. K. JADHAV, HELD ON 14TH JULY, 2018, AT HIGH COURT LEGAL SERVICES SUB-COMMITTEE AT AURANGABAD 1080 REJECTED CASE NO. 1326 OF 2015 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISION VAIJAPUR BABAN BARKU SHINDE AND OTHRS Advocate for Petitioners : Mr. S.S. Thombre ....

1081 REJECTED CASE NO. 126 OF 2016 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, NADUR MADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISION, VAIJAPUR UNDER GMIDC, SHYAMSUNDAR SAHEBRAO SALUNE AND ANOTHER Advocate for Petitioners : Mr. S.S. Thombre 1082 REJECTED CASE NO. 129 OF 2016 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, NANDURMADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISION, VAIJAPUR UNDER GMIDC, AUR KACHARU BALWANTA THORAT AN OTHERS Advocate for Petitioners : Mr. S.S. Thombre ....

1083 REJECTED CASE NO. 177 OF 2016 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, NANDURMADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISION, VAIJAPUR UNDER THE GMIDC KARBHARI NATHU SHINDE DIEDTHR LRS GAYABAI BHAUSAHEB SHINDE AND OTHERS Advocate for Petitioners : Mr. S.S. Thombre .....

1084 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3515 OF 2016 THE EXE ENGINEER NANDUR MAHMESHWAR CANAL DIVISION VAIJAPUR THR GMIDC AURANGABAD TRIMBAK GOPINATH SHINDE DID THR HIS LRS GOKUL AND ANR

-2Advocate for Appellants : Mr. P.G. Rodge Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1085 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3516 OF 2016 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANUR MADHMESHWAR CANAL DIV. VAIJAPUR, AURANGABAD THR GMI SITARAM TOTARAM KUMAWAT Advocate for Appellants : Mr. P.G. Rodge Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare ...

1086 REJECTED CASE NO. 193 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C. DIVISION, VAIJAPUR SAHEBRAO GENU THORAT AND AR Advocate for Petitioner : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar 1087 REJECTED CASE NO. 194 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C. DIVISION, VAIJAPUR CHABU FAKIRA AND ANR Advocate for Petitioner : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar 1088 REJECTED CASE NO. 195 OF 2017 BHAGINATH PANDHARINATH SHIDE AND ORS Advocate for Petitioner : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar 1089 FIRST APPEAL NO. 248 OF 2017 WITH CA/8699/2016 IN FA/248/2017 THE EXE ENGINEER NANDUR MAHMESHWAR CANAL DIVISION VAIJAPUR THR GMIDC AURANGABAD TANHA SAMPAT SHINDE Advocate for Appellants : Mr. P.G. Rodge Advocate for applicants in C.A. : Mr. A.M. Hajare,

-31090 FIRST APPEAL NO. 5095 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, NADUR- MADHMESHWAR CANAL DIVISION VAIJAPUR (GODAVARI MAH DAULAT BHAGAJI GAIKWAD ANDORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. Vivek M. Lomte Advocate for Respondents : Mr. M.R. Malpani 1091 FIRST APPEAL NO. 32 OF 2018 SHRAVAN KARBHARI SHINDE AN ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar ...

1092 FIRST APPEAL NO. 192 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR BHASKAR DADA SHINDE AND OTERS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1093 FIRST APPEAL NO. 193 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR BALNATH KISAN BADAK AND OTERS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1094 FIRST APPEAL NO. 194 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR BALWANTA RAOJI THORAT AND THERS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1095 FIRST APPEAL NO. 195 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR

-4EKNATH CHAGAN SHINDE AND OHERS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1096 FIRST APPEAL NO. 196 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR SHEKNATH CHAGAN SHINDE ANDOTHERS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1097 FIRST APPEAL NO. 197 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR SHESHERAO RADHAJI SHINDE AD OTHERS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare ...

1098 FIRST APPEAL NO. 198 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR GANGADHAR RAOJI THORAT ANDANR Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1099 FIRST APPEAL NO. 199 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR VASTHALABAI NIVRRUTTI THORT AND OTHERS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1100 FIRST APPEAL NO. 200 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR DADA LAXMAN BANGAL AND OTHRS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar

-5Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1101 FIRST APPEAL NO. 202 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR BHIVSON JANARDHAN SHINDE AD OTHERS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1102 FIRST APPEAL NO. 779 OF 2018 KAKASAHEB UTTAM SHINDE ANDORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1103 FIRST APPEAL NO. 780 OF 2018 ASHRU SURYANBHAN BANGAL AN ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal. 1104 FIRST APPEAL NO. 781 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C. DIVISION, VAIJAPUR MOGAL DHONDIRAM DIED THR HS LRS JIJABAI MOGAL THORATAND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.S. Shejwal.

1105 FIRST APPEAL NO. 782 OF 2018 ASHOK BALA SHINDE AND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare 1106 FIRST APPEAL NO. 783 OF 2018

-6ANANDA MANAJI THORAT AND AR Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal 1107 FIRST APPEAL NO. 784 OF 2018 RATAN DAMU SHINDE SINCE DEEASED THR HIS LRS WASTCHALABAI RATAN SHINDE AND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare ...

1108 FIRST APPEAL NO. 785 OF 2018 LAXMIBAI RAMAJI SALVE AND RS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A.M. Hajare and Mr.A.S.Shejwal 1109 FIRST APPEAL NO. 786 OF 2018 PARWATIBAI CHANGDEO SHINDEAND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal 1110 FIRST APPEAL NO. 787 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C. DIVISION, VAIJAPUR VIKRAM BHIKA AND ANR Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal 1111 FIRST APPEAL NO. 788 OF 2018

-7VASANT PANDURANG SHINDE AN ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal and Mr.A.M.Hajare 1112 FIRST APPEAL NO. 789 OF 2018 PARIGHABAI GANGADHAR SHIND AND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal and Mr.A.M.Hajare 1113 FIRST APPEAL NO. 790 OF 2018 BHAUSAHEB WAMAN SHINDE SINE DECEASED THR HIS LRS GAYABAI AND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal 1114 FIRST APPEAL NO. 791 OF 2018 SUKHADEO GANGADHAR THORAT ND ANR Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal ( V.K. JADHAV, J. ) ( LOK ADA, J. ) 1115 FIRST APPEAL NO. 792 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C. DIVISION, VAIJAPUR PANDURANG GANPAT DIED THR IS LRS ASHABAI BAURAO THORAT AND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal ...

1116 FIRST APPEAL NO. 793 OF 2018

-8GIRJINATH BHAURAO SHINDE ND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal ...

1117 FIRST APPEAL NO. 794 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C. DIVISION, VAIJAPUR GIRJINATH MOGAL AND ANR Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar Advocate for Respondents : Mr. A. S. Shejwal 1118 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21504 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR TUKARAM MALHARI THORAT ANDOTHERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1119 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21507 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR LAXMAN RAOJI THORAT AND OTERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1120 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21510 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR PUNDLIK BALANATH SHINDE AN OTHERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1121 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21530 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR

-9RAHUNATH TUKARAM SHINDE AN OTHERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1122 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21533 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR VASANT PANDURANG SHINDE AN OTHERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1123 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21536 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR MOGAL SANTUJI THORAT SINCEDIED THROUGH LRS GAYABAI AND OTHERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1124 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21539 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR BHIKA MATHAJI GHER SINCE DED THROUGH LRS SARUBAI ANDOTHERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1125 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21542 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR DATTU ANANDA BANGAL AND OTERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1126 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21545 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR POPAT BABURAO SHINDE AND OHERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre

-101127 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21593 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR SHAMA ANANDA GORE AND OTHES Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1128 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21607 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR LAXMAN RAMJI MOKALE AND OTERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1129 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21610 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR RAGHUNATH DAGADU NILE Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1130 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21613 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR BHAUSAHEB DAMU SHINDE AND THERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1131 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 21617 OF 2014 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER NANDUR ADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISIONVAIJAPUR BHIMRAO PANDURANG SHINDE DED THROUGH LRS LUKHA AND OTHERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1132 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 16080 OF 2015

-11EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, NANDURMADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISION, VAIJAPUR UNDER GMIDC, AUR GORAKH RAOSAHEB SHINDE ANDOTHERS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1133 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 193 OF 2016 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C.DIVISION, VAIJAPUR DAGADU BHAVRAO BANGAL AND THERS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V. R. Sonwalkar 1134 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 771 OF 2016 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, NADUR MADHAMESHWAR CANAL DIVISION, VAIJAPUR UNDER THE GM ANKUSH TUKARAM MAGAR AND AR Advocate for Appellants : Mr. S. S. Thombre 1135 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 1586 OF 2016 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C. DIVISION, VAIJAPUR SHANKAR MURLIDHAR ABHANGI ND OTHERS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V. R. Sonwalkar 1136 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 1592 OF 2016 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, N..C. DIVISION VAIJAPUR LAXMAN ANANDA GORE AND OTHRS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V. R. Sonwalkar 1137 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 12757 OF 2016 JAGDISH SHIVLAL CHAVAN ANDORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V. R. Sonwalkar

-121138 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 12772 OF 2016 PUNJA RAOJI THORAT SINCE DCEASED THR HIS LRS RAMRAO PUNJAJI THORAT AND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V. R. Sonwalkar 1139 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 12781 OF 2016 MANIK SAVALIRAM SHINDE AND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. V. R. Sonwalkar AGP for Respondent-State authorities: Mr. A.M. Phule, Advocate for respondents-claimants: Mr. A.M. Hajare, A.S. Shejwal, Mr. M.R. Malpani ....

(60)

O R D E R

1.

Mr. Pandit Rohidas Sirsath, Executive Engineer, Nandur Madhmeshwar Irrigation Division, Vaijapur, Sandipan Suryakant Sanap, Sub Divisional Officer, Vaijapur and Mr. Jagannath S. Dange, Sectional Engineer, are present before the panel. Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar, Mr. P.G. Rodge, Mr. S.S. Thombre and Mr. V.M. Lomte learned counsel appearing for the appellant-acquiring body, Mr. A.M. Hajare, Mr. A.S. Shejwal and Mr. M.R. Malpani, learned counsel for respondents-original claimants and Mr. A.M. Phule, learned A.G.P. for the respondent-State authorities are also present. 2.

Mr. Pandit Rohidas Sirsath, Executive Engineer, Nandur Madhmeshwar Irrigation Division, Vaijapur, has placed on record a

-13communication dated 10.07.2018 issued by him to the Government Pleaders' office, High Court, Bench at Aurangabad. The said communication is taken on record and marked "X" for identification. 3.

Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar, Mr. P.G. Rodge, Mr. S.S. Thombre and Mr. V.M. Lomte, learned counsel appearing for the appellantacquiring body, on instructions from the aforesaid officers, who are present before the panel submit that the rate awarded by the impugned judgment and award passed by the reference court is less than four times of the rate awarded by the S.L.A.O. In view of above, Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar, Mr. P.G. Rodge, Mr. S.S. Thombre and Mr. V.M. Lomte, learned counsel appearing for appellant-acquiring body, on instructions from the officers, who are present before the panel and in tune with the Government Resolution dated 03.11.2016 and the subsequent corrigendum dated 23.02.2017 seek leave to withdraw these first appeals.

4.

Since the acquiring body has taken decision to settle the dispute finally, which squarely falls in the category of Government Resolution dated 03.11.2016 and the subsequent corrigendum dated 23.02.2017, leave granted. All first appeals/rejected cases are disposed of as withdrawn. Court fees be refunded as per Rules. Pending civil applications, if any, are also disposed of. Statutory

-14benefits be extended in accordance with law. 5.

In terms of the letter dated 10.7.2018, in some of the matters, the appellant acquiring body has deposited the amount as per the award passed by the reference court and in case if the amount as per the award passed by the reference court is not deposited before this Court or in the executing court, it is agreed that the same would be deposited within six months from today. The amount if paid in excess be refunded to the acquiring body.

(K.C.Sant) (V.B. Mantri) ( V. K. Jadhav, J.) Advocate D.J.(Retd.) Head of the Panel Member Member Date: 14.07.2018 Place: Aurangabad rrd/