← Library
Bombay High CourtFA/2855/2018disposed offdismissed for default

Ex. Engineer, Majalgaon Canal Div. No. 10, Parbhani Under Gmidc Aurangabad And ORS v. Hina Fatema Sayyad Azam

2018-07-14Shri Justice J P Devadhar11 pages

-1IN THE NATIONAL LOK ADALAT PRESIDED OVER BY HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE V. K. JADHAV, HELD ON 14TH JULY, 2018, AT HIGH COURT LEGAL SERVICES SUB-COMMITTEE AT AURANGABAD 1031 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2468 OF 2008 GMIDC, AURANGABAD THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MJALGOAN THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AD ORS 1032 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2472 OF 2008 GODAWARI MARATHWADA IRRIGAION DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION AURANGABAD THE STATE OF MAH AND ORS 1033 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2473 OF 2008 GMIDC, AURANGABAD THR EE MJALGOAN THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AD ORS 1034 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3034 OF 2008 GMIDC, AURANGABAD THR EE MJALGOAN THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AD ORS 1035 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3089 OF 2008 GODAWARI MARATHWADA IRRIGAION DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION AURANGABAD THE STATE OF MAH AND ORS 1036 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1527 OF 2010 WITH CA/9838/2007 IN FA/1527/2010 GODAWARI MARATHWADA IRRIGAION DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION AURANGABAD

-2THE STATE OF MAH AND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. B R Survase 1037 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2432 OF 2010 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER MAJLGAON CANAL DIVISION NO 10PARBHANI VISHNU MADHUKAR BALI AND OS 1038 FIRST APPEAL NO. 515 OF 2011 THE EXECUTIVE ENGNEER MAJAGAON CANAL DIVN NO 10 PARBHANI ATMARAM TULSHIRAM JAMDHADEAND ORS 1039 FIRST APPEAL NO. 518 OF 2011 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER MAJLGAON CANAL DIVISION NO 10 PARBHANI SURENDRAKUMAR SHANTARAM DAVE L.RS. MANGAL SURENDRAKUMAR DALVE AND ORS 1040 FIRST APPEAL NO. 548 OF 2011 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON CANAL DIVISION NO.10 PRAKASH BABAN KALE AND ORS 1041 FIRST APPEAL NO. 554 OF 2011 THE EXECUTIVE ENGNEER MAJAGAON CANAL DIVN NO 10 PARBHANI EKNATH YESHWANTA NIRWAL AND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. S.S. Thombre Advocate for Respondents : Mr. R P Surwase & G S Shelke AGP for respondent-State authority:Mr. B.V. Virdhe 1042 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3700 OF 2016 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, NIMNA UDHNA PROJECT, DIVISION SAILU, NOW MAJALGAON CANAL DIV

-3ASHAMATI VITHALRAO WARADE ND ORS Advocate for Appellant : Mr. B.R. Surwase Advocate for Respondents-claimants : V.D. Bhise 1043 FIRST APPEAL NO. 668 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS DATTATRAYA MANIKARAO KASHTE 1044 FIRST APPEAL NO. 727 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS TATERAO MANIKRAO KASHTE Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondent-claimant : Mr. M.P. Tripathi 1045 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2070 OF 2017 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAJALGON CANAL DIV. NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS SHIVAJI BHANUDAS PARDHI Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondents : Mr. V.D. Bhise 1046 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2204 OF 2017 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, NIMNA UDHANA PROJECT DIVISION, SAILU, THR EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PANDURANG BABURAO PARDHI AD ANR Advocate for Appellant : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. .....

1047 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2207 OF 2017 WITH FA/2208/2017 WITH FA/2209/2017 EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAJALGON CANAL DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS

-4SARJERAO BHAGWAN PARDHI AND ANR Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondent No.1 : Mr. V.D. Bhise 1048 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2898 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS GHYANSHYAM NARAYANRAO SONNKAR AND ANR Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondents : Mr. Vijay Jogdand patil 1049 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3193 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS SITARAM NARAYANRAO SONNEKA AND ORS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondents : Mr. V.D. Bhise 1050 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3718 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS NANDKISHORE PUSARAM PARTAN Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondents : Mr. V.D. Bhise 1051 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3719 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS BALKISHAN PUSARAM PARTANI ND ORS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. 1052 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3720 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10,

-5PARBHANI AND ORS KEDARNATH MOTILAL LOYA ANDANR Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondents : Mr. R.P. Survase 1053 FIRST APPEAL NO. 3721 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS URMILA PRADIPKUMAR DAGA AN ORS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondents : Mr. V.D. Bhise 1054 FIRST APPEAL NO. 5096 OF 2017 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS SUNIL ANANTRAO KULKARNI Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondents : Mr. V.D. Bhise 1055 FIRST APPEAL NO. 358 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM DIVISION NO.10,PARBHANI AND ORS DATTATRYA VISHAMBHAR KULKANI Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondents : Mr. V.D. Bhise and Mr. M.M. Patil Beedkar 1056 FIRST APPEAL NO. 359 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS SHARDABAI GANPATRAO BHOSAL Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondents : Mr. V.D. Bhise and Mr. M.M. Patil Beedkar

-61057 FIRST APPEAL NO. 360 OF 2018 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS PRABHAKAR ASHROBA NIRWAL Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. Advocate for Respondents : Mr. V.D. Bhise and Mr. M.M. Patil Beedkar 1058 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 5465 OF 2016 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO.10, PARBHANI AND ORS VARAD SANJAY NAIK U/G OF HS FATHER SANJAY VYANKATESHNAIK Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. 1059 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 9282 OF 2016 WITH CA/6278/2016 IN FAST/9282/2016 WITH CAST/10514/2018 IN FAST/9282/2016 WITH CAST/10516/2018 IN FAST/9282/2016 THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, MAALGAON DAM, DIVISION NO. 10, PARBHANI AND ORS SADASHIV BALIRAM GUNJKAR AD ANR Advocate for Appellants : Mr. Patil Ruturaj C. 1060 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 10895 OF 2017 EX.

ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIVISION NO.10 PARBHANIUNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND NAMDAR KHAN HUSSAIN KHAN AD ANR Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase Advocate for Respondents : Mr. V.D. Bhise 1061 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 11001 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIVISION NO.10 PARBHANIUNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND AFSAR KHAN HUSSAIN KHAN Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R.

-71062 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 11007 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIVISION NO.10 PARBHANIUNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND ANKUSH GANPATRO HOGE AND OS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase 1063 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 11013 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIVISION NO.10 PARBHANIUNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND JAYANT KISHANRAO DIGRASKARAND ANR Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase 1064 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 11020 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIVISION NO.10 PARBHANIUNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND PRAVIN VITTHALRAO AGLAWE Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase Advocate for Respondents :Mr. V.D. Bhise 1065 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 23420 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIV. NO. 10, PARBHANI UNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND OR GUNAJI VISHWANATH RASVE AN ORS Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase 1066 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 23534 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIV. NO. 10, PARBHANI UNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND OR MUTAHIR ALI KHAN MOHJAN AL KHAN Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase

-81067 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 23537 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIV. NO. 10, PARBHANI UNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND OR RAHAMAT ALI KHAN AJIJ ALI HAN Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase 1068 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 23541 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIV. NO. 10, PARBHANI UNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND OR TADVI SIKANDAR ALI KHAN AJJ ALI KHAN Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase 1069 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 23547 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIV. NO. 10, PARBHANI UNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND OR HINA FATEMA SAYYAD AZAM Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase 1070 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 23552 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIV. NO. 10, PARBHANI UNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND OR GULAM ALI KHAN S/O AJIJ AL KHAN Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase 1071 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 23562 OF 2017 EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIV. NO. 10, PARBHANI UNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND OR MINAJ KHATUN D/O AFZAL ALIKHAN AND ANR Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase 1072 FIRST APPEAL (STAMP) NO. 23566 OF 2017

-9EX. ENGINEER, MAJALGAON CAAL DIV. NO. 10, PARBHANI UNDER GMIDC AURANGABAD AND OR KHATIJABEE D/O MUKHTAR ALIKHAN U/G REAL MOTHER MANJUM JAHAN W/O MUKHTAR ALI KHAN Advocate for Appellants : Mr. B.R. Surwase 907 (SB) FIRST APPEAL NO. 1321 OF 2016 EX. ENGINEER, NIMNA DUDHNA PROJECT, DIVISIN SAILU AND ORS VITTHAL TUKARAM KHOSE AND ANOTHER .....

Advocate for the appellants: Mr. Shyam C. Arora Advocate for respondent-claimants: Mr. V.D. Bhise AGP for Respondent-State authorities in all matters: Mr. B.V. Virdhe (45)

O R D E R

1.

Mr. Bharat Ramkisan Singade, Executive Engineer, Majalgaon Canal Division No.10, Parbhani is present before the panel. Mr. B.R. Survase, Mr. Ruturaj C. Patil, Mr. S.S. Thombre and Mr. S.C. Arora, learned counsel appearing for the appellant-acquiring body, Mr. V.D. Bhise, Mr. M.M. Patil Beedkar, Mr. R.P. Survase and Mr. N.K. Tungar, learned counsel for respondents-original claimants and Mr. B.V. Virdhe, learned A.G.P. for the respondent-State authorities are also present.

2.

Mr. B.R. Survase, Mr. Ruturaj C. Patil, Mr. S.S. Thombre and Mr. S.C. Arora, learned counsel appearing for the appellant-acquiring

-10body, in respective appeals, on instructions from the aforesaid officer, who is present before the panel, submit that the rate awarded by the impugned judgment and award passed by the reference court is less than four times of the rate awarded by the S.L.A.O. In view of above, Mr. B.R. Survase, Mr. Ruturaj C. Patil, Mr. S.S. Thombre and Mr. S.C. Arora, learned counsel appearing for appellant-acquiring body, on instructions from the officer, who is present before the panel and in tune with the Government Resolution dated 03.11.2016 and the subsequent corrigendum dated 23.02.2017 seek leave to withdraw these first appeals.

3.

In terms of the award passed by the reference court, the acquiring body has deposited the compensation as awarded at the enhanced rate by the reference court. The acquiring body has also taken decision to settle the dispute finally, which squarely falls in the category of Government Resolution dated 03.11.2016 and the subsequent corrigendum dated 23.02.2017.

4.

n view of above, leave granted. All first appeals are disposed of as withdrawn. Court fees be refunded as per Rules. Pending civil applications, if any, are also disposed of. Statutory benefits be extended in accordance with law.

-115.

Mr. B.R. Survase, Mr. Ruturaj C. Patil, Mr. S.S. Thombre and Mr. S.C. Arora, learned counsel for the appellant-acquiring body, on instructions, submit that the amount at the enhanced rate as awarded by the reference court, if any, will be deposited within six months from today. The amount if paid in excess be refunded to the acquiring body.

6.

In so far the first appeal No. 668 of 2017 is concerned, learned counsel appearing for the respondents-claimants submits that during pendency of the said first appeal, the respondent-original claimant died and his legal representatives are yet to be taken on record. However, since entire group arising out of the same project is disposed of in terms of the settlement, as aforesaid, the respondents-claimants in the said appeal are at liberty to file civil application for bringing legal representatives on record even in the disposed of appeal.

(K.C.Sant) (V.B. Mantri) ( V. K. Jadhav, J.) Advocate D.J.(Retd.) Head of the Panel Member Member Date: 14.07.2018 Place: Aurangabad vsm/