Vijay Arjun Shinde v. The State Of Maharashtra

1 1227-WP-8644-2020 & Ors

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD 1227 WRIT PETITION NO.8644 OF 2020 SANTOSH SHANKAR KUMBHARE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND OTHER 1228 WRIT PETITION NO.8645 OF 2020 KIRAN S/O SUDAM PAWAR THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA 1231 WRIT PETITION NO.8648 OF 2020 GOKUL BAPU AHIRE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA 1232 WRIT PETITION NO.8649 OF 2020 VIJAY ARJUN SHINDE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA 1235 WRIT PETITION NO.8652 OF 2020 SAGAR VILAS SHINDE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA 1236 WRIT PETITION NO.8653 OF 2020 SUNITA SURYAKANT GAIKAWAD 1238 WRIT PETITION NO.8655 OF 2020 SURYAJI ARJUN SHINDE 1240 WRIT PETITION NO.8657 OF 2020 PANDURANG ANANTA PAWAR

2 1227-WP-8644-2020 & Ors 1242 WRIT PETITION NO.8659 OF 2020 AJIT EKNATH DHUMAL 1243 WRIT PETITION NO.8660 OF 2020 ANIL SUDAM PAWAR THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA ND OTHERS 1245 WRIT PETITION NO.8662 OF 2020 SAMBHAJI RAGHUNATH GAIKWAD 1301 WRIT PETITION NO.8719 OF 2020 SHRIKANT KRISHNAJI SAWANT 1302 WRIT PETITION NO.8720 OF 2020 MONALI CHANDRAKANT WAGHMAR @ MONALI SHRIKANT NANAWARE 1304 WRIT PETITION NO.8722 OF 2020 VINAYAK SHANKAR JORKAR 1306 WRIT PETITION NO.8724 OF 2020 NANDKISHOR RAJARAM SANGURD 1307 WRIT PETITION NO.8725 OF 2020 DNYANESHWAR DASHRATH SHINDE

3 1227-WP-8644-2020 & Ors 1309 WRIT PETITION NO.8727 OF 2020 MANGALA NAGORAO PAWAR 1311 WRIT PETITION NO.8729 OF 2020 PARAG LAXMAN SHINDE 1313 WRIT PETITION NO.8731 OF 2020 DNYANESHWAR MAHADEO GAIKWAD 1375 WRIT PETITION NO.8793 OF 2020 MADHUKAR GAJANAN MAKU 1385 WRIT PETITION NO.8803 OF 2020 JITENDRA JAGANNATH MAKU 1454 WRIT PETITION NO.8872 OF 2020 RAJU HARISHCHANDRA MORE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER 1455 WRIT PETITION NO.8873 OF 2020 ROHIDAS LAXMAN GOYAJI THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER 1456 WRIT PETITION NO.8874 OF 2020 ARUN HARISHCHANDRA MORE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER 1457 WRIT PETITION NO.8875 OF 2020

4 1227-WP-8644-2020 & Ors NAVNATH YASHWANT KOLI THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER 1458 WRIT PETITION NO.8876 OF 2020 RAJESH CHANDRAKANT CHANDGANKAR THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER 1471 WRIT PETITION NO.8912 OF 2020 JIDNYASA W/O JALDEEP TANDE @ ROJANA D/O GOPICHAND MESTRI THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS.

1472 WRIT PETITION NO.8913 OF 2020 SAVITA W/O HARISHCHANDRA PTIL @ SAVITA D/O GOKUL ROGE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS.

1473 WRIT PETITION NO.8914 OF 2020 PARIKSHIT S/O HARIBHAU PEK THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS.

1474 WRIT PETITION NO.8915 OF 2020 GANESH S/O JANARDAN JAITU THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS.

1475 WRIT PETITION NO.8916 OF 2020 MADHURI W/O AJIT PATIL THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS.

1545 WRIT PETITION NO.8986 OF 2020 UMESH KISAN KOLI 1546 WRIT PETITION NO.8987 OF 2020

5 1227-WP-8644-2020 & Ors KARBHARI BARAKU KAKULTE 1547 WRIT PETITION NO.8988 OF 2020 AJAY KEDAR GARUD 1548 WRIT PETITION NO.8989 OF 2020 VILAS DASHRATH BACHHAV 1549 WRIT PETITION NO.8990 OF 2020 ANURADHA ASHOK SHINDE @ ANRADHA MAESH THOMBARE Mr. S. C. Yeramwar, Mr. Deepak Choudhari, Mr. S.S. Aradhye, Advocates for the respective petitioners in respective writ petitions. Mr. P. S. Patil, Mrs. M. A. Deshpande, Mr. K. N. Lokhande, Mr. K. B. Jadhavar, Mr. P. K.Lakhotiya, Mr. A. B. Chate, Addl. G.Ps./Asstt. G.Ps. for the respective Respondents-State in respective writ petitions. CORAM : S.V. GANGAPURWALA AND SHRIKANT D. KULKARNI, JJ.

DATE : 5th JANUARY, 2021 PER COURT :

1.

It is submitted that validation proceedings in respect of the tribe claim of petitioners are pending with the scrutiny committee, the same are not decided.

2.

Without issuing notice to the petitioners, the respondents have placed petitioners on the supernumerary post.

6 1227-WP-8644-2020 & Ors 3.

As the impugned action is without notice to the petitioners, we quash and set aside the impugned action.

4.

In case, respondents want to take action against the petitioners of placing the petitioners on supernumerary post or otherwise, then notice shall be issued to the petitioners giving opportunity to show cause. In that event, the petitioners can file reply and bring all the relevant facts to the notice of the respondent-committee.

5.

The Committee shall decide the validation proceedings expeditiously and preferably within a period of eight months from the date of appearance.

6.

The petitioners shall appear before the Committee on 8th February, 2021.

7.

Writ Petitions accordingly disposed of. No costs. [ SHRIKANT D. KULKARNI, J. ] [ S.V. GANGAPURWALA, J. ] mta