Nivrutti Govinda Khotkar And ORS v. The State Of Maharashtra And ORS

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

BENCH AT AURANGABAD 923 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14528 OF 2017 IN FAST/37073/2017 WITH CA/14529/2017 IN FAST/37299/2017 EKNATH DONGAR PATIL 924 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14531 OF 2017 IN FAST/36987/2017 WITH CA/14532/2017 IN FAST/37297/2017 ASHOK POPAT KOLI THR POWER OF ATTORNEY HIRALAL M KOLI ...

925 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14533 OF 2017 IN FAST/36942/2017 WITH CA/14534/2017 IN FAST/37186/2017 WITH CA/14535/2017 IN FAST/37182/2017 GAJANAN SHAMRAO PATIL 926 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14536 OF 2017 IN FAST/37251/2017 WITH CA/14537/2017 IN FAST/37240/2017 WITH CA/14538/2017 IN FAST/37261/2017 WITH CA/14540/2017 IN FAST/37238/2017 SHANKAR NATTHU KOLI (DIED) VITTHAL (DIED) LRS DEVKABAI AND ORS 927 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14541 OF 2017 IN FAST/36918/2017 WITH CA/14542/2017 IN FAST/37150/2017 SITABAI ANANDA KOLI 1/16

928 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14546 OF 2017 IN FAST/36915/2017 WITH CA/14547/2017 IN FAST/37110/2017 BABAN PANDIT PATIL 929 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14548 OF 2017 IN FAST/36898/2017 WITH CA/14549/2017 IN FAST/37104/2017 MAHARU HIRAMAN KOLI 930 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14550 OF 2017 IN FAST/37089/2017 WITH CA/14552/2017 IN FAST/37331/2017 WITH CA/14553/2017 IN FAST/37329/2017 BHATU BHIKA PATIL 931 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14554 OF 2017 IN FAST/37263/2017 CHANDRAKANT TUMDU PATIL 932 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14555 OF 2017 IN FAST/38749/2017 HIMMAT CHINTAMAN PATIL 933 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14556 OF 2017 IN FAST/36893/2017 WITH CA/14557/2017 IN FAST/37112/2017 2/16

INDAL PUNJU BHIL 934 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14563 OF 2017 IN FAST/36994/2017 LUKA DHANA MAHAR (DIED) THR LRS RAMAN LUKA AHIRE 935 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14564 OF 2017 IN FAST/37141/2017 WITH CA/14565/2017 IN FAST/37301/2017 BUDHA RAMDAS KOLI AND ORS 936 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14566 OF 2017 IN FAST/36983/2017 WITH CA/14567/2017 IN FAST/37307/2017 SURASTABAI DASHRATH KOLI 937 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14568 OF 2017 IN FAST/36933/2017 BHIKAN PANDHARI BHIL 938 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14569 OF 2017 IN FAST/36880/2017 JIVAN EKNATH PATIL 3/16

939 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14570 OF 2017 IN FAST/36930/2017 AAYUB SHAHA HUSSEN FAKIRA 940 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14571 OF 2017 IN FAST/36726/2017 SUNIL DEVIDAS PATIL THE COLLECTOR, JALGAON AND ORS 941 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14572 OF 2017 IN FAST/36905/2017 KADU DATTU CHINCHOLE AND ORS THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER-1, UTPH, JALGAONAND ANR 942 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14573 OF 2017 IN FAST/36878/2017 DATTU ONKAR PATIL (DIED) THR LRS MANILAL AND ORS 943 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14574 OF 2017 IN FAST/37010/2017 LEELACHAND BHAGWAN PATIL 944 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14575 OF 2017 IN FAST/36985/2017 WITH CA/14576/2017 IN FAST/37292/2017 HIRALAL MAHASING KOLI 4/16

945 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14577 OF 2017 IN FAST/36980/2017 WITH CA/14578/2017 IN FAST/37309/2017 MADHUKAR ZUMBARLAL PATIL 946 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14581 OF 2017 IN FAST/37077/2017 WITH CA/14579/2017 IN FAST/37334/2017 WITH CA/14580/2017 IN FAST/37337/2017 SOMA LAKHA (LAXMAN) PATIL 947 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14582 OF 2017 IN FAST/37278/2017 PRAKASH RUPCHAND MALI THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER-1, UTPH, JALGAONAND ANR 948 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14583 OF 2017 IN FAST/37249/2017 EKNATH DONGAR PATIL 949 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14584 OF 2017 IN FAST/37282/2017 ATMARAM BHADU KOLI 950 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14585 OF 2017 IN FAST/36952/2017 WITH CA/14586/2017 IN FAST/37163/2017 WITH CA/14587/2017 IN FAST/37167/2017 WITH CA/14588/2017 IN FAST/37280/2017 SONUBAI BHIL AND ANR 5/16

951 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14589 OF 2017 IN FAST/36721/2017 WITH CA/14590/2017 IN FAST/37125/2017 WITH CA/14591/2017 IN FAST/37127/2017 BHATU BHIKA PATIL THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER (2) U.T.P.H., JLAGAON AND ANR 952 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14592 OF 2017 IN FAST/36908/2017 GOPICHAND UTTAM PATIL 953 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14593 OF 2017 IN FAST/36882/2017 GATALU NATTHU PATIL (DIED) THR LRS BAPURAO G PATIL 954 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14594 OF 2017 IN FAST/36889/2017 WITH CA/14595/2017 IN FAST/37147/2017 KESHAV SHALIK PATIL 955 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14596 OF 2017 IN FAST/37070/2017 WITH CA/14598/2017 IN FAST/37295/2017 ATMARAM MURLIDHAR PATIL 956 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14599 OF 2017 6/16

IN FAST/37095/2017 ZUMBARLAL BHAVARLAL JAIN THE COLLECTOR, JALGAON AND ORS 957 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14600 OF 2017 IN FAST/37008/2017 SATYWAN VASANT GAVANDE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANR 958 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14601 OF 2017 IN FAST/37014/2017 HIRAMAN NARYAN KUMAVAT (BELDAR) THE COLLECTOR, JALGAON AND ORS 959 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14602 OF 2017 IN FAST/37012/2017 RAMDAS RAVAJI GAVANDE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS 960 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14603 OF 2017 IN FAST/37006/2017 PUNDALIK RAOJI GAVANDE AND ORS THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS 961 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14604 OF 2017 IN FAST/37001/2017 DEVIDAS VITTHAL TONGALE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANR 962 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14605 OF 2017 IN FAST/36999/2017 BHIMRAO LAXMAN SAPKALE (DIED) THR LRS ASHABAI AND ORS THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER-2, UTPH, JALGAONAND ANR 7/16

963 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14606 OF 2017 IN FAST/37255/2017 DASHRATH BHAGWAT SALUNKHE AND ORS THE STATE, (THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, JALGAON AND ANR 964 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14607 OF 2017 IN FAST/37253/2017 KAILASH BABURAO KUMBHAR THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER-1, UTPH, JALGAONAND ANR 965 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14609 OF 2017 IN FAST/37122/2017 WITH CA/14608/2017 IN FAST/37305/2017 SHANKAR KALU SURYAWANSHI AND ORS THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANR 966 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14610 OF 2017 IN FAST/37242/2017 KALABAI MADHAVRAO JADHAV THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANR 967 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14611 OF 2017 IN FAST/37257/2017 CHAMPALAL BHAVARLAL JAIN THE COLLECTOR, JALGAON AND ORS 968 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14612 OF 2017 IN FAST/37020/2017 CHAMPALAL BHAVARLAL JAIN THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER-1, UTPH, JALGAONAND ANR 969 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14613 OF 2017 8/16

IN FAST/36912/2017 WITH CA/14614/2017 IN FAST/37170/2017 WITH CA/14615/2017 IN FAST/37176/2017 UKHA YADAV AHIRE (DIED) THR LRS PRAKASH AND ORS 970 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14616 OF 2017 IN FAST/36886/2017 WITH CA/14617/2017 IN FAST/37156/2017 WITH CA/14618/2017 IN FAST/37159/2017 PANDIT KESHAV PATIL (DIED) THR LRS RATILAL AND ORS 971 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14619 OF 2017 IN FAST/36989/2017 WITH CA/14620/2017 IN FAST/37289/2017 MANGAL EKNATH KOLI 972 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14621 OF 2017 IN FAST/37143/2017 WITH CA/14622/2017 IN FAST/37303/2017 SUNDARBAI LUKA AHIRE (DIED) THR LRS RAMAN LUKA AHIRE 974 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14628 OF 2017 IN FAST/39341/2017 WITH CA/14629/2017 IN FAST/39345/2017 WITH CA/14630/2017 IN FAST/39343/2017 WITH CA/14631/2017 IN FAST/39348/2017 JAGDISH LAXMAN SALI THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER-2, UTPH, JALGAONAND ORS 975 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14632 OF 2017 IN FAST/36447/2017 9/16

SHANTARAM PANDURANG PATIL AND ORS THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER - 2 U.T.P.H, JALGAON AND ANR 976 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14633 OF 2017 IN FAST/38736/2017 DWARKABAI MAHARU PATIL 977 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14634 OF 2017 IN FAST/38745/2017 SHALIK SHANKAR PATIL AND ANR 978 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14635 OF 2017 IN FAST/38747/2017 DNYANESHWAR PANDIT PATIL 979 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14636 OF 2017 IN FAST/38741/2017 BHAGWAN GOKUL PATIL 980 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14637 OF 2017 IN FAST/38739/2017 ONKAR NATU PATIL (DIED) THR LRS SUNIL AND ORS 981 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14638 OF 2017 IN FAST/38743/2017 10/16

BHALERAO PANDHARINATH BHIL 982 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14664 OF 2017 IN FAST/39515/2017 WITH CA/14665/2017 IN FAST/39455/2017 WITH CA/14666/2017 IN FAST/39509/2017 WITH CA/14667/2017 IN FAST/39453/2017 WITH CA/14668/2017 IN FAST/39485/2017 WITH CA/14669/2017 IN FAST/39451/2017 WITH CA/14670/2017 IN FAST/39458/2017 WITH CA/14671/2017 IN FAST/39449/2017 WITH CA/14672/2017 IN FAST/39505/2017 WITH CA/14673/2017 IN FAST/39477/2017 NAMDEV KAUTIK RANE (DIED) THR LRS ANIL NAMDEV RANE THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER-1, UTPH, JALGAONAND ANR 983 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14674 OF 2017 IN FAST/39447/2017 DILIP PANDHARINATH CHAUDHARI AND ORS THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, UTPH-1, JALGAONAND ANR 984 CIVIL APPLICATION NO.

985 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14687 OF 2017 IN FAST/37720/2017 PRALHAD KARNA JOHARE AND ORS THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER-1, UTPH, JALGAONAND ANR 986 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14688 OF 2017 IN FAST/37706/2017 WITH CA/14689/2017 IN FAST/37708/2017 WITH CA/14690/2017 IN FAST/37710/2017 WITH CA/14691/2017 IN FAST/37703/2017 PRALHAD TOTARAM DESHMUKH THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER-1, UTPH, JALGAONAND ANR 987 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14692 OF 2017 IN FAST/37724/2017 WITH CA/14693/2017 IN FAST/37818/2017 WITH CA/14694/2017 IN FAST/37815/2017 DATTATRAY BALIRAM PATIL (DIED) THR LRS PUSHPABAI AND ORS THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER-1, UTPH, JALGAONAND ANR 988 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1212 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/33288/2015 BHAGWAN DEVIDAS NARWADE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS 989 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1219 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/35918/2015 KEDAR GANESHLAL TAPADIYA THR G.P.A. HODER JAINARAYAN BANSILAL RATHI THE THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS 990 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 1220 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/33298/2015 NILESHKUMAR BALAPRASAD RATHI 12/16

THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS 991 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 13446 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/36092/2015 JAINARAYAN BANSILAL RATHI AND ANR THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS 992 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14639 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/39408/2017 GOPAL MADHUKAR PATIL AND ORS THE STATE, SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, U.T.P.H (I) JALGAON AND ANR 993 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14642 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/39362/2017 WITH CA/14644/2017 IN XOBJST/39370/2017 WITH CA/14649/2017 IN XOBJST/39360/2017 WITH CA/14663/2017 IN XOBJST/39356/2017 JANABAI NATTHU KALE THR LRS SUKDEO AND ORS THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS 994 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14646 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/39368/2017 WITH CA/14648/2017 IN X-OBJST/39364/2017 WITH CA/14650/2017 IN X-OBJST/39366/2017 WITH CA/14651/2017 IN X-OBJST/39410/2017 WITH CA/14654/2017 IN X-OBJST/39403/2017 WITH CA/14656/2017 IN X-OBJST/39358/2017 WITH CA/14658/2017 IN X-OBJST/39412/2017 NANA RAJMAL PATIL SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, UTPH 1 JALGAON AND ANR 995 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14647 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/39398/2017 NIVRUTTI GOVINDA KHOTKAR AND ORS THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS 13/16

996 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14653 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/39395/2017 KEDAR GANESHLAL TAPADIYA THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS 997 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14655 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/39393/2017 GORJABAI ASHOK PATIL THR GPA HOLDER JAINARAYAN B RATHI THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS 998 CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 14657 OF 2017 IN X-OBJST/39372/2017 MANIK DEVIDAS NARODE AND ANR THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS ...

Advocate for the Applicants (except Sr. No.75) :Mr. Kale Ajeet B Mr.Ajeet B. Kale, Advocate for the applicants in all the applications, except Sr. No.975 Mr. Hemraj Kshirsagar, Advocate for the applicants in Civil Application No. 14632/2017 Mr. S. M. Ganachari, AGP for the respondent State in all the applications.

Mrs. Chatali Kutti, Mr. S. D. Dhongade and Mr. S. G. Bhalerao, Advocates for the Acquiring Body in respective applications.

CORAM

: K. L. WADANE, J.

DATE :

7th December, 2017 ORDER:

1.

Heard learned counsel for the respective parties. 2.

These are applications for condoation of delay of caused in filing the Appeals against the impugned judgment 14/16

and award.

3.

The learned counsel appearing for the applicants submits that the applicants are financially poor and they were unable to pursue the proceeding due to poverty. Learned counsel for the respondents opposed the applications on the ground that there is inordinate delay in filing the present appeals and it has not been explained satisfactorily. The delay caused in filing the appeals is not accidental and it is an intentional. In the alternate, the learned counsel submits that if the applicants succeed, they shall not be entitled for the amount of interest and/or other statutory benefits for the period for which the delay sought to be condoned.

4.

In view of the observations made by the Supreme Court in the case of Ramanlal Deochand Shah Vs. State of Maharashtra and another, reported in AIR 2013 SC 3452, the delay can be condoned on the condition that in case the appellants succeed in the first appeals, then they will not be entitled for the amount of interest on monetary benefits and/or other statutory benefits for the period of delay and it is accordingly condoned.

5.

Civil applications are accordingly disposed of. 6.

In first appeal, the learned counsel for the appellants submits that some the matters are likely to be 15/16

settled in Lok Adalat and therefore the same may be referred to Lok Adalat.

7.

In view of above, refer the above matters to the Lok Adalat, which is scheduled to be held on 9th December, 2017. (K. L. WADANE, J.) JPC 16/16